We stayed right before Memorial Day and loved our stay. We had looked at multiple hotels and this…read morewas our first time to the area, I'm glad we went with this one. We actually were more pleasantly surprised with the room and stay than we expected. They worked with us on a late check in, the room and bathroom were great, everything was clean, walking distance to shops and restaurants, walking across the street and you're on the beach. We did use the beach chairs and umbrella one afternoon, those did have some mold or mold stains on there and umbrella was bent..but could still use them. I think they are due for cleaning after the winter, or maybe replacement. The sister property has the pool and we spent some time on the hammock and lounge chairs. They had some shade, which was great bc it was needed for someone fair skinned in our party. We tried swimming but it was just a tad too chilly to swim yet for me. One night there wasn't enough parking but we parked on the grass across the street and were told by security that it was fine. A con I'd say is when you hang the privacy placard on the door, the housekeepers still come into your room, and leave a tip envelope.. that irritated me that they disregarded the privacy placard. But hopefully management will see this and pass on the message so that won't happen to you. Hope that gives you an idea of what to expect. Overall would definitely recommend this hotel to others :)

I have stayed in various motels along South Emerson Street since the 2000s. This Inn is very…read moreutilitarian with small, but efficient and clean rooms at a good value. Odd house/motel directly behind my bathroom window, but the Inn has plenty of cameras and locks to allow key-only guest entrance to the room areas/porches and courtyards/pool. The pool was in the adjacent sister resort, but went there once since the beach is very close, as is the town. The staff were courteous, but don't understand other Yelp reviews raving about how great the service was. NO free upgrade or anything else, just nice people/employees- what it should be. I intend to go back- maybe in peak season.

Like others have mentioned, Marram is a minimalist but very nice resort. You are paying for the…read moreprime beachfront access in Montauk. The resort is also walkable to many cafes, restaurants, and shops. Once we got to Marram (we took a cab from the LIRR to the resort), we did not have to do any additional driving while we were there. The rooms are on the smaller side, but comfortable. The bed linens are like you are sleeping on a cloud. You can control the air conditioning to your liking. The room has very little in the way of amenities - free water, sparkling water, popcorn, hairnets, and makeup remover. No bath robe or slippers, so be sure to bring your own. The pool is very small but it does go up to 8 feet, which is nice. The cafe/restaurant on the premises is awesome. We loved all of the baked goods including the ham and cheese miso scone, the croissants, and the cookies. This area of the beach was quiet during the week. Fun place to sun bathe, watch the surfers, and really relax. While we were at Marram, I also took advantage of one of their free meditation sessions. If you're there while Raymond is doing the meditation, definitely check it out! It was a very relaxing way to kick off our stay. The walls are hilariously thin, but nothing that we weren't able to sleep through. Our room faced the courtyard and I was worried that it would be too loud at night, but it seems like they're serious about enforcing the quiet hours, which is nice. If you're looking for a chill, close to everything, walk onto the beach resort, this is the place for you!

My wife and I Just had an amazing and relaxing experience for five nights at Marram in Montauk…read more Quite possibly one of the best hotel experiences ever. If you're looking for five star accommodations, this is not it. No room service, no concierge and very little available as far as food and beverage service. This place has been remodeled into a serene, minimalist getaway with very few distractions from the outside world. No TV's in the rooms and no complimentary newspaper; both of which make this the perfect escape. Get a room with a view of the ocean and you'll enjoy the scenery and the sounds. Unplug and enjoy the quiet environment. Read a book. Don't laugh, but the soap and shampoo make you smell like vacation. Take advantage of the heated pool and beach chairs and walk into town for meals and cocktails. Everything in Montauk is only a few minutes away by car. I would suggest trying to plan your stay in the slower part of the season to avoid the influx of the Instagram influenced city folk. As I mentioned, the food and beverage were the only areas that could use some help. It's daylight by 5am but the restaurant doesn't open until 8am, so you'll have to hike into town for coffee. Or sleep late. Coffee was great though. Breakfast was also minimalist but really amazing; simple food done well. 4-5 savory selections and a great assortment of pastries. The lunch / dinner service was puzzling so we avoided it (literally a protein with sides for $45 and the menu was not published). Cocktails were on point; pricey, but you're in the Hamptons so it's expected that every cocktail is $20. It would have been cool if they had some "pool food" or "beach food." I don't do the Yelp thing often but figured I would share my thoughts for posterity. I'm on the fence about going back to Marram. On one hand, we already have our room picked out for the next visit. On the other hand I don't think I can ever recreate such an amazing and relaxing vacation. We'll see.

I spent a weekend here with my two dogs this summer. Overall, I had a nice time, but there were a…read morefew areas that could be improved. Starting with the room, the size was good, but it could have been cleaner. I noticed some dust and dirt in the corners, and the room felt like it could use an update. The coffee machine looked older and wasn't very clean, the refrigerator wasn't working properly, and there wasn't an ice machine nearby--you have to call the front desk for ice. At night, the room wasn't very soundproof. You can hear footsteps from the room above, along with other noises, so if you're a light sleeper, it's something to keep in mind. On the weekend, the hotel was lively because of a wedding and the nightclub. There was music until around midnight, and when guests left, the noise from the cars made it difficult to get a full night's sleep. The food and drinks were very good, although they were on the expensive side. I was happy with the quality of the dining experience. Most of the staff were fine, though I noticed a few employees who seemed less welcoming. Thankfully, everyone I interacted with was polite. The overall atmosphere was the highlight of my stay. The property has a beautiful, relaxing vibe with a classy crowd, and I especially loved the morning yoga classes. I spent about $5,000 for a two-night stay, so I expected a more luxurious room experience. Mine was one of the more affordable room categories, and it didn't feel especially upscale for the price. Next time, I would probably visit for the food, drinks, beach, or spa day pass instead of staying overnight. If you're looking for a lively resort with plenty of events and activities, this is a great choice. If you're looking for a very quiet hotel, you may want to consider other options.

Extremely disappointing experience at Gurney's Montauk. Neither my room nor my daughter's room had…read morehot water for nearly three hours. After several calls, we were repeatedly told to wait another 20-30 minutes, but the issue was never resolved before dinner. I had to wash my hair in my daughter's sink, and my daughter missed our family dinner because she couldn't shower after spending the day at the beach. We also received conflicting explanations about whether someone entered my room despite the "Do Not Disturb" sign. The air conditioner was extremely loud, the room phone didn't work, and no manager was available when we needed assistance. We ultimately left one day early because we no longer felt comfortable staying. Despite repeated calls and promised follow-up, management refused to refund the unused night. For a hotel at this price point and with this reputation, we expected far better service, communication, and accountability.

Split verdict on an 18 hour stay. We were there for a wedding. The space is beautiful. The views…read morefrom the ocean view rooms were amazing. Our room was small but nicely furnished. The bathroom layout was nice. The room wasn't as clean as it could have been and there was graffiti scratched into the sliding glass door. The patio was lovely. The major detraction was that our room was noisy. Even during the day you could hear voices and footsteps from adjacent rooms. This continued overnight, keeping my wife awake. I would definitely give this place another try. I would suggest an upper floor room or a cottage.

Stopped here for breakfast with friends. Stunningly awful. After being seated in the main dining…read moreroom, no one greeted us for 15 minutes. On a Sunday morning during the month of July, even with a relatively quiet dining room, the service was terrible. We had to run down a server just for water and coffee. The coffee, if you can call it that, is watered down and tasteless. We asked for cream and sugar, none came, so we had to go get it ourselves from the kitchen. Bizarre. The banana bread, which is $16, is literally one slice with fresh bananas. OK, so I am fine with paying higher prices for the location, but $16 for one slice of banana bread? Give me a break. Turkey sausage patties are literally 1 mm thick. The avocado toast, which was a very light spread of avocado on toasted bread, was extremely spicy. Totally fine with tortilla chips for a dinner, but certainly not for a breakfast entrée. The smoked salmon came with cucumbers, which had a very weird medicinal taste. The only person happy with their breakfast had ordered the scrambled eggs. Tough to mess that up. One of our party asked for an over easy egg on the side, and they wouldn't do it. Asked for a fruit basket, but it never came. Service and quality of food were both extremely disappointing. The only redeeming quality is the location. Don't come here and spare yourself to disappointment.

We had the most amazing stay at Hero Beach Club! This is our second time staying here and we will…read moredefinitely be coming back! From the moment we arrived, the experience was a 10/10! The location is perfect -- steps from the beach and close to everything (very walkable). The whole staff is amazing! Sophie, Troy and Alex went above and beyond to make us feel welcome and taken care of.Whether it was helping with local recommendations, making sure we had everything we needed, or just being friendly faces throughout our trip -- they truly made the difference! The rooms are always super clean and we love all the amenities the hotel offers like the pool, beach service (food+drinks), fire pit s'more's and sauna! Highly recommend!

The Motel is very nicely renovated. Pool is in a nice location with plenty of sun…read more A lot of unused spaces- the lawn and basement massage rooms.trying to be a resort, but at end of the day, really just a motel. A bit of a hike from a central beach and village area- compared to other hotels further east. Was clean- rooms had a lot of wasted space given that they were small to begin with. Front desk and breakfast varied with the person at the front - some very nice, some not so. A bit pricey, but it is Montauk. Stayed in September 2025- looked into staying this September but prices had gone way up for available rooms.

My friends and I chose this hotel for our Montauk girls' trip, and I would stay here again in a…read moreheartbeat. The location was perfect;just a short walk to both the beach and the shops, which made it easy to enjoy everything Montauk has to offer. The staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming throughout our stay. The pool and bar had great vibes and energy, and we spent a lot of our time relaxing by the pool. Our room was beautiful, simple, and very clean;exactly what we needed for a beach getaway. The location was truly everything, and having decent parking was an added bonus.

Super cute and clean hotel really close to the beach and the town, everything is walkable…read more I love the pool vibe, it's chill. The staff was really good! Very helpful and kind. Highly recommend this place!

We had an absolute amazing time and experience here on this awesome property…read more Built in 1983 and refreshed... has everything you need, especially for Montauk, which is truly more motel and ridiculously overpriced for the tiniest and not nice looking places. With that said, very different experience here. It's tranquil (except for the families that stay here... little rug rats throughout, and boy are they bratty. (Welcome to the new generations). Bedroom upstairs and bathroom. Full Kitchen and living area on first floor. All clean. Nothing "gorgeous" but very respectable (again, in context for where we are). Beautiful pool and deck areas. Gorgeous walkway to the beach. All private. Complimentary chair, umbrella, and towel service. Beach and water, is what you come here for! We'd come back, for sure. In our 50s and we've been around the world (mostly), and appreciate how this is only 2 hrs from home. It's like another state or beyond. Love it! Make sure you eat at Surfside, about a mile down the road. Good dinner, great views.

The location and the grounds are nice. I've been staying there for years and I'll never go again…read more The price is astronomical. There's huge variability from unit to unit as far as finishing and comfort of beds and furniture when I went the week of Fourth of July this year my unit had ant infestation in the kitchen that persisted for five days the entire time I was there. The only thing that was offered to me was a one bedroom unit that wouldn't fit my children. I asked to be compensated for something I got no return calls from my request in writing. The customer service is lackluster at best. There is no value given to the spending exorbitant fees to stay at their location.

One of the worst dining experiences I have ever had…read more My partner became ill and was unable to join me for dinner. We called the restaurant to either move our reservation to another day or cancel it, and were told that only the manager could assist us. However, we were told the manager was unavailable because he was busy speaking with regulars at a table. I asked if we could simply be placed on hold until he was available so we could find a solution. We were told no. Instead, the employee said they would "leave a note" and that someone would call us back if they were able to help. Meanwhile, we were told that if the reservation was canceled, we would be charged a $135 cancellation fee -- despite the fact that we were actively trying to work with the restaurant to either reschedule or resolve the situation. The experience became even more unacceptable when the employee eventually hung up on us and then stopped answering our calls. The restaurant only answered after American Express contacted them on our behalf. To be clear, I have no issue with a restaurant having a cancellation policy. What I have an issue with is the way this situation was handled: being told the manager was "too busy" to speak with us, being refused the simple courtesy of being placed on hold, having our calls screened, and ultimately being hung up on. That is an embarrassing level of customer service for an establishment of this caliber. I genuinely hope someone in management -- above the person working the restaurant that evening -- takes this seriously and addresses this behavior. A cancellation policy is one thing; treating a customer with this level of disrespect is another.

We recently had dinner at 1770 House and really enjoyed the beautiful outdoor garden setting, it…read moremade for a lovely evening catching up with friends. The service was excellent and the ambiance is definitely the highlight. As for the food, it was good but didn't quite live up to our expectations. A few of our dishes arrived overcooked and only lukewarm, which was a bit disappointing. That said, we still had a nice experience overall. I wouldn't hesitate to come back, especially to enjoy the beautiful garden atmosphere. Overall, a nice spot for a relaxed night out.

I can't afford this place during peak season but Montauk Blue is my off-season pick year after…read moreyear. It's walkable to everything in town, and the majority of rooms open right out to the water with incredible beach views. The rooms themselves are clean and updated but small. The pool is indoors here which also makes this a perfect off season pick - we came in May when it was still a bit cool out, but the pool being indoors meant it was still a great pool day. Included in your stay is beach chair and umbrella service, but it was too chilly out for us to take advantage of that. We did enjoy sitting out on the lounge chairs on the beachfront deck they have here. The rooms we stayed in did have pretty big cracks under the doors which felt a little sketchy, and my mom's shower wasn't working properly. They would have moved us but we were already settled in when we noticed. Overall, great location, beachfront, amenities abound. Pros outweigh the cons for me.

The location was prime for walking to shopping and restaurants. And the beach front rooms are…read morewonderful - the view is spectacular. Beach is so clean. The staff of the hotel were so accommodating, especially Jim the grounds manager. Highly recommend!

Very nice and clean hotel in Montauk. Came here for a little honeymoon with my wife. Clean,…read morecomfortable bed, beautiful pool right outside your room, and near everything in town. Came In September, and had a great time. The weather wasn't the best so we didn't get to use the pool even though it is heated. Staff was very welcoming and would def stay here again. Price wasn't too steep and the room was nice. If you're looking for something big, this place isn't it though. Very small straight to the point room with a nice small balcony in the back. We stayed for 2 days and were always on the go so it was perfect for us. We just came to shower and freshen up but dies its purpose. It's one block away from the beach and located right in town near everything pretty much. I would def stay here again if we came back and highly recommend this hotel if you're looking for a room that's not over priced like a lot of other places on Montauk. The rooms can use a lil renovations but that's every hotel on Montauk unless your staying some where fancy. Overall had a good time and highly recommend this hotel. Parking easily accessible right in front of hotel. 8/10

Close to ocean and shops. Affordable and comfortable room. Helpful staff. Perfect stayread more