This is a beautiful hotel. Well run. Overall. !!! Cozy lobby. Great restaurant ! montes !!! I have stayed here many times The pool in the summer is well run. The view is amazing !!! read more

Can definitely recommend unit 427. Great 2-bedroom, both with en-suite bathrooms. Efficient kitchen with new water filter. Comfortable sitting area. Used the gym daily and excellent food at Monte's just off the lobby. We'll be back. read more

I stayed in a spacious, nicely furnished studio overlooking the pool area. The hilltop location has beautiful views. The outdoor pool was nice and warm, and the hotel provides transportation to the beach. If you arrive by train they can send a car to pick you up. Monte's, the hotel's restaurant is also very good. Everyone there was very polite and helpful, and I look forward to returning. read more

Everything at the manor was terrific! The room, the services, the pool and staff, extraordinary! Monte's restaurant left a bit to be desired. Oh, well! There's plenty of dining options in Montauk. read more

Just spent 4 nights at the Manor. Had a wonderful experience. They couldn't be more helpful and accommodating!

This is a beautiful, historic hotel on a tall hill overlooking Montauk and the water. Pool, hot tub, tennis, beautiful lobby. The restaurant opens and closes often. The only downside is Melky. She has to go. read more

Our weekend stay was lovely. The unit we were in had a Murphy bed in the living room that was so well camouflaged as a wall unit that we didn't realize until housekeeping came to set it up for us. We also had a loft upstairs with two Queen beds and a full bathroom. There was also a bathroom downstairs. The kitchen was a decent size though we didn't cook since we ate at Monte's for almost all our meals. They cleaned and made the beds while we were out. One of us used the hot tub in the lower level. The staff was friendly. The lobby is beautiful. I just wish the parking lot was closer. The one by the main entrance is usually full so you have to park at the lower one which isn't far away but when it freezing and windy, it sure feels far. read more

See all

Stayed for our anniversary, room was comfortable, nicely decorated, clean and quiet. Indoor pool was plus! Staff was excellent read more

See all

Upon arrival you are met with threatening signs limiting your parking in the front area to 15 minutes, no valet. If the line to check in has more than one person, it will take you longer than 15 minutes. Upon check in, a plastic bag with 3 room remotes is thrust at you and your credit card is charged a deposit. You are expected to carry the remotes to your room and return them to the front desk when you check out. Not exactly "deluxe service". They also charge you for your room keys. The one main elevator is small and slow. It is often crowded. No attendant to help you with your bags. Some rickety luggage carts are available. My impression of the lobby is that it is old and dingy. Couches look worn. Miss Havisham would feel right at home. The room. If you are lucky to get a room facing east, the view is great. Very little privacy with respect to the other room balconies. So say hi to your neighbor. The room is also worn, chips in all the cabinets, furniture and chairs. There was a Keurig. On the second day we asked for some more coffee pods and were told "no". That was déclassé. The balcony chairs had green mold, the balcony small side table had burn marks. Our room didn't have a real closet. It was a small pocket closet. The other "Duplex" room. This room looked like it was decorated by Tony Hawk. Skateboard decks on the walls. No view. Not a real two bedroom, it has a loft, so I hope you like stairs. No privacy. No usb charging outlets in the rooms. Overall this is not a luxury hotel. And don't forget to return your remotes to the front desk on check out or else! read more

See all

My hubby and I had a wonderful stay for 2 nights. My husband uses a scooter. Most of the hotels are not wheelchair friendly in Montauk. . Montauk manor was great! We stayed in a one bedroom unit that has a roll in shower. (There were no bars for the toilette which was difficult for us) They do have a shower chair but it was very small. There was a ramp out to a large balcony overlooking the pool. The indoor pool and hot tub were really lovely for our use. They have an ada pool lift which is one of the reasons that brought us here. It worked!! The weather was not great but sitting by the cozy fire in the evening was wonderful. We had a great dinner at the restaurant by the fire. The grounds are beautiful and the place is spotless! The biggest praise goes to the entire staff. I've never felt so welcoming in any hotel. Unfortunately I would have given 5 stars but the lack of bars in the toilette and the shuttle to town not being accessible I had to take a star away. read more

Montauk Manor - Resorts Near Me - Montauk, New York

Such a great hotel. So refreshing to go somewhere out of the norm. The room was great,better than I expected and better than the online photos! The only issue we had was that we could not get any ti's to work. There was no signal. Went to the front desk and the guy tried to help,but to no avail. That was super disappointing since my daughter and I were trying to have e a movie night for her birthday. Pool area and hot tub were super clean and enjoyable! Would definitely come back. read more

See all

I really love Montauk manor. It's beautiful, charming, comfortable, and Monte's is so delicious... great location Cons: odd that you don't need a key card to get into the hotel at night - anyone can enter. The "lifeguard" is always in the hot tub or pool which makes it uncomfortable for guests to enjoy. Rooms are a bit dated and the shower water doesn't stay hot read more

My elderly parents had made a reservation on 1/16 for 1/28th. They called on 1/26 to cancel as the area where they live was completely iced in and state of emergency. They were not given a refund of credit because they signed a "no refund policy". My parents were told that the $100 change free would be waived if they rescheduled. In the meantime my father fell on ice and is injured- there is no way to reschedule in the near future. Good sense is that this resort would refund the money paid up front. read more

The Montauk Manor is a classy historic hotel closely located to the LIRR Montauk stop. DAHIANA made sure to make us feel welcomed. I planned a trip for my mom's birthday and Mother's Day weekend. Montauk Manor was the perfect place. She really enjoyed herself. The grounds were beautiful, the Manor was charming, and the trees were in full bloom. I appreciated that after we had to comment on a situation with our room, it was quickly and swiftly resolved. I enjoyed the shuttle service because it was a nice treat to not have to call an Uber or Lyft. We were able to use the shuttle to go into town and the train station. Montauk gives relaxation vibes for sure. I could see us returning over and over just to unwind. Thanks for a great stay! read more

See all

A historical hotel with breathtaking views of the ocean. The entrance has grand ceilings with large wooden walls and pillars. The entrance lobby is warm with large fireplaces and stunning windows. The rooms are decorated with bright colors and comfortable beds and furniture. The lower level of the hotel has a large swimming pool and hot tub. We had an amazing experience at the hotel. The staff were friendly and welcoming. read more

See all

Absolutely Terrible Customer Service - Avoid This Hotel I rarely take the time to write reviews, but the experience I had with this hotel was so disappointing that I feel obligated to warn others. I want to preface that our stay is schedule for March 2026 and this is from my phone call with the general manager. I spoke with the general manager with a request regarding a reservation issue, and instead of receiving basic courtesy or professionalism, I was met with rudeness, impatience, and an unbelievably nasty attitude. The general manager spoke to me in a condescending and dismissive tone from the very start of the conversation. Rather than trying to help or even listen, she was argumentative, uninterested, and clearly irritated that I had called at all. At no point did she make any effort to be understanding or solution-oriented. It honestly felt like I was inconveniencing her just by calling. Customer service in the hospitality industry should be about making guests feel valued and respected. This general manager completely failed at that. I have never been spoken to so rudely by someone in a professional position. Because of how poorly I was treated, I would never consider staying here and would strongly recommend that others look elsewhere. There are plenty of hotels that actually care about their guests. This is not one of them. If this is how the general manager treats potential customers, I can only imagine how guests are treated once they arrive. Save yourself the frustration and book somewhere else. read more

Super nice and quiet winter weekend getaway. It was freezing outside but we had a nice warm room with a view, beautiful indoor pool with a hot tub and sauna. Was also nice to have a restaurant & bar in the lobby !!! They also have a shuttle read more

Montauk Manor - Resorts Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

The pool and hot tub were so nice. The room and everything were well maintained, even though the TV is a bit old but who goes there to watch TV anyway. Sunset right outside the hotel is perfect and Montes is delicious (must make reservation for dinner though). read more

Hats off! Montauk Manor has to be the happening and most exquisite hotel in Montauk. It's like a mini mansion with an indoor pool, gym, restaurant, bar and the most beautiful interior decoration. And how convenient it's about 5 minutes away from Montauk train station. It's really mesmerizing and carries a sharp personality. My friend and I was passing through so we decided to stop in at the bar for drinks and appetizers. I ended up having an Aperol and tiramisu. A bit pricey, but the atmosphere was refreshing and accommodating. We were told this place get seriously busy during the summer months and holiday season during the winter months. It's very classic and warm hearted. read more

See all

We recently stayed at the Montauk Manor for four nights, and it was an incredibly lovely experience. The Manor mixes old-world charm with modern convenience. It is impeccably clean and well-staffed, and located in a beautifully bucolic location a few minutes from downtown Montauk, as well as the lighthouse and the national parks. Our room was a one-bedroom with two full bathrooms, and that extra bathroom made a great deal of difference. Every window offered a breathtaking view of the bay, and the sunset from our room was postcard-perfect! The room was well-stocked with dishes and silverware, and the Keurig coffeemaker with coffee pods was a lifesaver. Above all, I must single out Patty, whom I initially spoke to on the phone when making the reservation. She was absolutely delightful to deal with when calling, and she made sure we got the best possible room at the best rate. She made the entire process so easy and pleasant. And meeting Patty in person was even better! She greeted us upon our late-night arrival with a heartwarming smile and deep, genuine kindness. Our check-in was a breeze, thanks to her, and throughout our stay she was so happy and eager to help with anything we needed. Patty is such a sweet and lovely person who never failed to speak to us with sincere friendliness and care, and she is a great credit to the Montauk Manor. I very much look forward to seeing her when we return. She is a true ray of sunshine who brought much joy to us during our stay! Also highly worthy of mention is Michelle. She is another gem of a person, whose kindness and willingness to help were well-evidenced in every interaction. She patiently talked to us about places to go and things to see in the local area, and she offered much-need and very detailed recommendations on restaurants. Michelle's advice and expertise were invaluable to us on our trip (especially since it was off-season, which to me was even lovelier), and we are grateful that she was there for us. Diana was also extremely kind and helpful, offering assistance whenever she was available, and giving us counsel on where to go and what to see. We look forward to her warm and welcoming smile when we come back. And last but surely not least, we were fortunate enough to have very pleasant interactions with Tom, who was always extremely friendly, very gracious, and infectiously joyous. It was a wonderful boost to our day to run into him in the halls of the Manor! We loved our stay at Montauk Manor, and we plan on making a return trip very soon! Thank you to all involved for making this an unforgettable experience read more

Montauk Manor is beautiful! We were there right after Christmas so the feeling was even more elegant. The staff were spectacular and the accommodations were just perfect! read more

See all

The manor is beautiful we were there off season and not for a day but everything was as described .

I along with my wife, daughter and her fiancé were planning their wedding out in Montauk. We needed to find a place to act as out center of operation for the destination wedding. We visited the Montauk Manor and we were hooked. The property, the views, the feel of the property, the pools, and the rooms. It truly was the perfect destination location. Now, I need to make my daughter's dream come true. This is where Donna Marcotrigiano comes into the picture. Donna is part of the Montauk Manor Conference Sales department. She was absolutely the most amazing partner that I could have ever asked for in pulling together this event. She worked tirelessly and seamlessly with me to bring a high percentage of our quests with over 50 rooms booked. She helped me navigate and secure over 10 2-bedroom rooms, a honeymoon suite for my daughter, and much much more. Donna is without a doubt a major reason why our wedding weekend was a resounding success! Thank you for your amazing efforts. Thank you to the Montauk Manor, and much thanks to Donna for making it happen. I highly recommend you work with Donna for any future group plans. read more

Always the best at Montauk Manor! We stayed many times and this year August and again in Sept! The best in everything from service to staff no complaints read more

Best hotel in montauk. Donna was great help and she made our wedding amazing - she was super communicative throughout the whole wedding planning process read more

Montauk Manor - Best hotel in Montauk. 2 Pools, 3 tennis courts and a great shuttle. Donna booked our whole wedding and it was incredible. - Resorts Near Me - Montauk, New York

Wonderful experience from start to finish. The staff were kind and very helpful. Best views in Montauk. Will definitely be back.

Good value. Beautiful grounds. Immaculately clean. Staff is very nice. Far away from everything but vans take you where you need to go which is a plus. If you want a quiet retreat that is the place. Bonus having an indoor pool if it is cold and rainy. read more

The hotel is in a great location and has beautiful grounds however it is a little tired and understaffed. We had a hard time getting a cold drink at the pool. Service at the restaurant was extremely slow. read more

Always the BEST experience. The staff is courteous, friendly and attentive. Love the Lobby and the fireplace to sip your wine and read or play games. The Units are kept immaculate! LOVE Montauk Manor! read more

We had a wonderful experience staying at the Manor for the first time. We had a studio and it was perfect for a couple. The interior was decorated nicely for Christmas and the dinner at Montes at the Manor was delicious. Staff was very friendly and helpful. read more

Fabulous stay. Clean rooms. Lovely staff. Delicious food. Been here twice and both times were wonderful!

Yet another trip to the Montauk Manor and it did not disappoint. Unit 414 is our go to unit. Breakfast and Montes both days, Dinner at Monte's one night. Spent a rainy day sitting by the fire playing games in the lobby. Then a nice swim in the indoor pool and a sauna. Exactly the retreat we needed! read more

Place was very relaxing and met my needs. Having a studio was perfect as having a small kitchen was very helpful. Location made for easy access to town, where there are many restaurants and shops. My family loved the pool and spa hot tub, especially my grandson. read more

I'm a homeowner at the Manor. The Jacuzzi has been inoperable for most of the last 5 years!! So what the F is going on? P.S. I've heard it all!!!! read more

I stayed here for a business meeting and the staff was extremely friendly and very helpful with accommodating our group. The rooms were excellent, clean and provided unbelievable views. If you ever venture out to Montauk, I highly recommend staying here. You won't be dissappointed. read more

See all

Grounds are beautiful. Staff were pleasant. Room was very clean and housekeeping staff very professional when asked to clean my room after I leave for the day. Montes' restaurant very cozy and perfect for breakfast without leaving the establishment. Would definitely stay again when in Montauk. read more

See all

Very happy with the room. Patrick took us to the beach via the courtesy shuttle. He was very friendly and funny. The servers at Monte's restaurants were very accommodating. The Ron itself was spacious and nicely decorated. Parking was easy and the pool was nice and warm. Overall very pleased and looking forward to returning next summer. The EV charger was a plus too! read more

Nice spacious suite on 3rd floor. Two full bathrooms, balcony, living room and two flatscreen TVs. Fully equipped kitchen. Overall, a pretty nice experience. Many of the staff appeared disengaged or even hostile. Check in was abrupt which I found peculiar. Not sure I'd come back since there are a couple more luxurious oceanfront resorts that don't require a shuttle ride to the beach. Oh, also if you think you've lucked out with a water facing unit think again. The LIRR terminates about a mile away from these units and the noise of diesel locomotives starting around 730p extends for at least 90 minutes making your beautiful sunset view a horrid juxtaposition of heavy industrial sounds and a beautiful ocean view. read more

For a 5 star hotel I found there to be very little help, assistance. Every time I asked for information or some help regarding specific information no one knew what was going on! For the price you charge and the number of people in our party who booked a room with your establishment,we definitely should have received some assistance. When asking for "concierge" service? "We don't have that here.... Really a 5 star hotel without a concierge. No bell hops?we lugged a HELL of a lot of luggage by ourselves. I guess we should be grateful you had luggage carts for us to borrow. The hominess of the room and the availability of the kitchenette proved to be the only reasons for the 2 stars I will leave you with. read more

We absolutely loved Montauk Manor. The grounds are spectacular and very clean as well as our room. Staff were all very pleasant and helpful. We ate breakfast in Monte's and it was great. They redid indoor pool and locker rooms and they were beautifully done. I would highly recommend staying here and I will definitely be back. read more

See all