Delivery was faster than they said it would be. Got a regular with green peppers and pepperoni. Also got a Sicilian, which is a thick crust square delight. Both were cooked perfectly with just the right amount of cheese and there was no skimpin on the toppings. It was fast and friendly and yummy too. read more

Monte Cello's Pizza - Sicilian, thick crust - Pizza Near Me - Wexford, Pennsylvania

See all

Thank you so much to the Monte Cellos in Wexford... everyone loved today's catering! The food was delicious and conveniently packed, reasonably priced! It was a hectic day for us and everything was perfect. Would recommend them with no hesitation. We loved it! read more

Monte Cello's Pizza - Catering - Pizza Near Me - Wexford, Pennsylvania

I've eaten at the Downtown Monte Cello's on many occasions. Like the Downtown location, the Wexford Monte Cello's is a simple, solid three-star performer. I stopped in here recently with some friends and co-workers after a morning's hiking. I don't remember what the others ordered, but my 1/2 Italian hoagie and my cup of wedding soup were both very good. Believe me, I love a good soup and 1/2 sandwich combo. So Monte Cello's won't set the world on fire. That's okay--it doesn't need to. It's good basic food that really fills the bill. read more

Ordered two pasta dinners tonight. The eggplant was so burnt my wife had to throw it all away. I had the stuffed banana pepper pasta and the sausage was so over done I couldn't even cut it with a knife. Both soups spilled all over the pizza box they were in on the way home because the kids were not put on properly. This is just another example of a restaurant that isn't able to adapt to carry out only. If you are just going to sell people food that can't be eaten so you can stay open shame on you. Keep selling people food that all ends up in the trash and you'll be a vacant building soon. read more

This was possibly the most infuriating experience I've ever had. My co-worker and I work just down the street from Monte Cello's in Wexford. We decided to order delivery for lunch. The delivery took 45 minutes (not the delivery guy's fault) they were super busy. We ordered the 8 cut pizza, thinking he and I would each have 2 or 3 slices and save the rest for lunch tomorrow. So when we got the pizza it was cut into 4 slices instead of 8. We thought they sent us the 4 cut instead by accident. My co-worker called the restaurant and the lady on the phone said that's their regular 8 cut but they only cut it in 4 by accident. So we cut the pizza ourselves. And each slice was so tiny. There's pictures below for reference. The lady on the phone said that's their standard 8 cut. So my coworker and I paid $19.45 for the pizza. Then tipped $4.55. So we spent $24 on this tiny pizza and the lady on the phone said we were harassing her and then hung up when my coworker said that this ridiculously overpriced for the tiny size of it. It was more a personal sized pizza rather than an 8 cut pizza. And I have super small hands, like Donald Trump size hands. This isn't the first time I've had a bad experience with Monte Cello's but never this bad. This was the final straw. Never ordering from from Monte Cello's again. Don't waste your money ordering from here. read more

See all

Monte Cellos has been a staple for my family for more than 20 years. The recent renovations to the dining room give the restaurant a much warmer and more cozy feel. The service is always friendly and the food is always fresh. Must Try: Steak Onion Ranch Pizza, Any Calzone, The Pittsburgh Chicken Salad, the Fried Zucchini and their Chicago Style Pie. Awesome place. read more

Food was very good. Service was horrible. I My server only had one table to serve,and I had to hunt him down to ask for to go cartons and order dessert. Never check on us once. read more

I've only ever eaten at this Monte Cellos but I'm a huge fan of their Chicago style. With extra tomatoes it's even better! I hardly ever drive out here and there's usually nothing but chains in the area so this is definitely a better option than most things in this area. read more

Went here for lunch and ordered a pizza. Wasn't great, and wasn't even cooked all the way through. Almost nothing else on the menu looked edible, and the buffet looked terrible. Would not repeat this. read more

Monte Cello's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wexford, Pennsylvania

See all

This is a Friday night staple in my family. I was raised in Wexford, so I've been ordering from Monte Cello's for as long as I can remember. The cheese sticks are among my all time favorite (my wife & I used to rate who had the area's best fried cheese). I've never in all my years strayed from ordering either a calzone or the pizza. It's always good. I know they have meals and salad there but that to me is like Norm walking in to Cheers and trying the merlot. Is it the best pizza ever...no. But it is good, the service has always been great, even delivery. Also, they offer wheat crust, which while I know doesn't make pizza healthy, it does make it ever so slightly less bad, which not all pizza restaurants offer. read more

Very good food. Wait not very long. Waiter seem a less enthusiastic. Overall good

Have ordered take out two times from this location. Both times the orders were wrong. The first time one of our ordered items was a regular steak salad - they gave us a steak Caesar salad. We live 10-12 minutes away so it wasn't worth calling, my husband just added tomatoes and other items from home. Wasn't in a hurry to order again but here we are months later and we thought we'd try. Only ordered one pizza and a few appetizers. They package everything in brown cardboard containers so you can't check your order before you leave. Everything is taped shut. My husband asked if everything was in the bag. Girl says yes and walks away. So after unpacking the bag we are missing an item. A 9.50$ item. We call and she says 'we have a credit book, we'll write your name in it and next time you come in we'll credit your order' what?? Seriously? You screw up so much you have to have a 'credit book'?? Nah, doesn't sit with me - so my husband is on his way back to get our money back for the missing item. Why would I go back for a third time when it's going to be wrong again?? Ugh. Skip this place for take out for sure. Can't say how dining in is, haven't eaten in there for many years. read more

Well we were hungry , thats all. I think this pizza would be tasty for kids. The taste is not high quality for a foodie . The Sicilian crust tasted like stale bread. It looked like the pizza crust you buy sealed on grocers shelves The thin crust was better but pretty low quality. It isn't a hand tossed pizza . We did like the toppings and gave the crust to the dogs .toppings were generous and visible, unlike large plain ,........ The sauce is kind of jar tasting, certainly not homeade like mama Lucias . It looks like ragu. It's a bit sweet and thickened looking. I will say this. Wexford is a family place, not upscale or childfree. I think that's why the food is lower quality. We wouldn't order their pizza again but may try the eggplant parm or something else , but my expectations are low. This isn't lawrenceville or penn avenue read more

I live in California but if I could come to Pittsburgh more often to visit more often I would because this is my favorite place ever. I've been eating here since I was a kid and even used to work here when I moved out to Wexford for a year. Never disappoints! Also get a large pep with an Italian hoagie and a side of buffalo wings! Very family friendly and best pizza ever! read more

They have incredibly friendly, professional service & treat you like a customer! Plus the food is fantastic!!

I place a catering order at the Wexford PA location one week before my event for 12 hoagies and then added a large potato salad, one day before the event. I ordered chicken parm, meatball and Italian hoagies. They were delicious. Your Italian tomato sauce is just excellent. Everyone at my event loved the hoagies. The potato salad was also fabulous. Service in ordering was excellent. Delivery was on time and the hoagies came warm. And also I have to say that the price for everything was very, very reasonable. I could not have asked for anything better. Thank you for helping me and for your delicious food. Linda A Wexford, PA read more

Will never go to this location again on a game day for high school (Or any other time) They are incapable of managing a large crowd. There were 15 people waiting inside the front door. I was told it would be a 30 min wait. After 20 minutes I asked "how much longer". The 16 yr old hostess said it would be about 30-40 minutes. I explained that I already waited 20 minutes and now my wait time actually got longer. How is that possible ? She said nobody has left the restaurant yet. I walked into the dining room area and I realized why the wait time wasn't improving At least 5 tables were filled with patrons drinking coffee and Pepsi. Their kids were coloring and all their dirty dishes were piled in the center of the table. They didn't want to leave yet for the 7:00 football game because it was raining. It was only 6:00 and had they were going to squat at these tables for another 20-30 minutes. The place is not managed but instead is being operated by 16-18 yr old kids. I'm done with Monte Cellos. Sir Pizza has much better service and better pizza! read more

So disappointing. We have been faithful customers to Monte Cellos in Wexford for over 15 years. But this new menu is terrible. There were 4 of us tonight at dinner, not one of us liked our meals. Nothing had any flavor. From the cheaper blend of house salad to the chicken parmigiana, pizza, spaghetti and meatballs, nothing tasted good. Go back to your original recipes and quit trying to save money. You will lose more money if you don't go back to your original recipes. read more

First off I have to say I would Never go or recommend this place to anyone. The girl in the front was very rude and disrespectful she had a real attitude for no reason and bad customer service. The food was not the best especially for what I paid would not be returning really bad experience especially it being my first time going there. I would give it zero stars if I could. read more

18:19 the Monte Cello parking Lot was full so we assumed that it is a good sign. My wife and I walked in and five people in the receiving area did not even acknowledge us. We were the only ones at that point in time. The awkwardness was heightened when no one paid attention as I was looking for someone to seat us. We finally decided to leave when I asked why it seemed that they were complacent. I could not believe it when one of the gentlemen said it's been slow time if the night. Mind you, a full parking lot tables seem very occupied from the window. I am speculating the we are not welcome and they prefer a certain genotype of customer. We went off to Bistro 9101 which we will review later. Aviva has better service and great pizza and alike. read more

A staple to the North Hills area, Monte Cellos has been dedicated to their customers for many years, I can remember how much of a treat going here was as a kid. The recent renovations of the facility have kept it current with the change occurring in Wexford. Excellent lunch buffet for under $10. Best traditional pizza in the Wexford area, if you are looking for a specialty pizza you won't find another pizza comparable to the buffalo chicken pizza. Excellent portions of quality food, I have never seen anything come out of that kitchen that didn't make me salivate. My personal recommendations would extend to the fried zucchini and pepperoni rolls. There is nothing like them. Nice, quiet bar to watch the games at and the bartenders are always friendly. Plenty of parking, easy to find. read more

'Scuse me. Excuse me. This place is the staple of Wexford life. You either have it delivered to your door or you come here, you get a crappy iceberg lettuce salad and then you gorge yourself with their perfect pizza. If you're me then Dad orders a beer or two and Mom drives home. You chortle in the backseat with your sister. End of story. read more

We moved to Pittsburgh 2 years ago...we discovered their pizza 6 weeks ago, we are moving in 3 weeks and truly wish we would have found this place sooner! Pizza is the best! Service is good. Enjoy read more

I'll keep this review short and sweet. I ordered the "Chicago Style" deep dish with pepperoni: my go-to pie. Yah, I know I'm super original. I've eaten pizza in Chicago several times in my life and not once has it sucked. In this regard, my pizza was very Un-Chicago Style. Let me put it this way: I go back for seconds with average pizza. I paid $18 for this pie and I kinda just wanna throw the rest away. And then give it the finger. read more

One of my favorite local pizza places, Monte Cello's is a 'staple of Wexford life' as the previous reviewer said. The food isn't 'outstanding, omg best pizza ever' but it'll get the job done and is tasty. I'd normally give it 4-stars, but the service is sometimes lacking and could use a little boost in customer service training. read more

I like their bacon pizza, stuffed shells, and wedding soup. But the item that I really loved was their Garlic Bread. Their pizza crust is also very soft. (A good thing) But, their sauce was a little thin, but some folks prefer it that way! This restaurant all depends on people's point of views and opinions. I liked my pizza but my dad didn't! They have an interesting variety of desserts. Featuring the "Connley Cookie" and ho ho cake. Mmm... read more

After waiting 40 minutes we were served a burnt pizza. Really? The bartender must not have noticed it was burnt! We asked for another one and waited another 25 minutes. Not even a complimentary drink?? Really? Wont' be going back.. sorry... we were regulars before this incident. read more

I can't comment on food. We didn't stay because one of our party couldn't navigate the stairs, which was the only access to the seating. The hostess offered to bring out a ramp from somewhere to place over the stairs, but our friend was embarrassed by the makeshift fuss this would cause so we left. If you have mobility issues, I suggest you find a restaurant willing to accommodate that by design. read more

Sooooooo good! We get the margarita and steak and ranch pizzas, excellent!!!!! I wish they delivered but worth the drive!!!!

This is a pizza place, first and foremost. But one would expect everything Italian to be good here. Personally we like their pizza. Nothing super specific, just regular old pizza. The ingredients are always fresh and I love the crust. It's crispy on the outside and soft inside. On a whim we got the cannolis, bad idea lol. There inside of the cannoli was fresh but the taste of the entire thing? Well. I'll just put it this way, those store bought cannolis with the pre-made shells and filling are like 50x better than these cannolis at Monte cellos. Sorry guys but you missed the mark! read more

Really good food but avoid this place AT ALL COSTS on Friday nights during the school year. We were quite disappointed to see the children from the nearby North Allegheny high school treat fellow patrons and the wait staff so disrespectfully. I'm sure that my wife and I spent more than two tables full of these kids. I can't see how this works for Monte Cellos. It definitely didn't provide a good experience for us and will not be good for you either. Friday night = No Monte Cellos. read more

Besides great food, the staff are just awesome! We came on a Friday night with a large group and they took great care of us. Check out the spinach and feta pizza. Friends who moved to Virginia make it a point to stop in and get some whenever they're in town and our teenagers go nuts over the Conley Cookie. read more

This is your average pizza joint. Food pizza always busy.....but I have no idea why people are coming back. The service is so bad. I was sitting there for fifteen minutes before any employee asked if I were dining in. Then they forgot my order then had to retake my order..... 20 minutes later. Then as we though the place couldn't get any worse, they have us the wrong bill! Just go to some other place! Yes, it is pizza but even better pizza can be found at whole foods! read more

Had dinner tonight, must of had a lapse in judgement and ordered ravioli stuffed with crab, what was I thinking this is a pizza joint. They must have worked relentlessly to screw up their recipe on this one, this is so bad take if off the menu. If you know food this place is not for you in fairness to monte cellos they offered to take it off the bill but I told them not to do so. The cost was fourteen dollars not nearly enough to make something worthwhile ( what was I thinking) Finale thoughts if must go here keep it basic pizza, hoagies and salads read more

This is one of my favorite local pizza places. The buffalo chicken pizza is the best buffalo chicken pizza I have ever had. Everything about it is perfect, the cheese, sauce, chicken and crust are perfect. Their homemade ranch just adds to this as well. Make sure to order a peanut butter Conley cookie before you leave as well, it is such a delicious dessert read more

Best pizza I know about. All food is just delicous.

Great food and great atmosphere for a family. Very good value! read more

Love their pizza, and try the Joe's pizza for a real treat. Was here on a Saturday night with my family. 3 tables of mostly male football sized teenagers started getting rowdy and loud, with no regard for the other patrons in the restaurant. There was no manager in sight, and all of the wait staff, in their early twenties, just put down food and then hung out in the hall and texted when they were not working. I was also disappointed that the wait staff puts their thumb in your plate to carry it, instead of using a tray, or properly carrying it from the bottom. I'll be back, but only for takeout. read more

The parents love them some buffets so they booked an appointment with "the kids" for this specific Monte Cello's. Not any Monte Cello's, and not the one closest to the ol' homestead: in their opinions it had to be this one. I had called the day before to verify that they indeed do have a pizza buffet (yes), the hours (11-2), and the price ($7.99 per person). This matched the parents' information so off we went, arriving at 1pm. The parents are slow, methodical buffet eaters, so they wound up with a superior experience to the other half of "the kids" and myself, who shamelessly gobble our food and then (gasp) stop when we are full, even if we haven't tried everything. Why this didn't work out well for myself or the other half is that the buffet was poorly stocked when we got there. I understand it was 1pm, but they had a full hour to go and other buffet diners, so they should have hustled a little bit more. Other half took just about all the salad that was left. There were dregs of Italian wedding soup, which greatly distressed the parents who are obsessive followers of Italian wedding soup. There was cheese, pepperoni, buffalo chicken, and Sicialian pizza with canned tomatoes, a few pieces of each. I tried to pace myself, hoping things would get better. I started with salad and 2 small slices. Round 2 was the same (thankfully they refilled the salad). The pizza tasted better than expected but was extremely greasy. The first new pizza appeared around 1:30 and had veggies and sausage. I ate some of there and stopped, however heretical that was. The other half kept going. It was only the intrepid parents that got to partake of the fresh pot of Italian wedding soup that appeared at 1:45pm and some of the new pizzas that were set out just after. I sat on my hands and resisted it. So who's fault was it? Theirs or mine? read more

The food is just so unstable. Sometime great... Sometime not so great... I highly recommend driving 10min up to the Cranberry Monte Cello, you will find it's a completely different experience. read more