We love John at Vails Gate Tire and Auto. They never do more work than needed and are fair with…read moretheir prices. John treats you like family. I was also very happy to see that when driving my car out they had put a seat protector so that nothing got on the seat. That's how it should be!

My guy took his car for a low tire. Turns out they said there was a nail in the tire. Turns out…read morethere was a nail in that tire 5 x . Then he got a new tire. turns out there was a nail in the other tire, four d got a new tire. Took my car for a yearly inspection. I needed was 4 new tires. No, just No

Best garage in New Windsor. Honest, & processional. They may not get you in right away- but that's…read morebecause they're popular and usually have a lot of work to do.

3/30/2026: Your hours say 8am-6pm but when I pull up, your sign is closed and the door is locked…read more However, there's a nerdy white male in the garage bay pretending to work. I gesture if he's closed and doesn't even acknowledge me. So that's when I take my business elsewhere. It seems that they only service vehicles that they want to service. Go to Route 94 Auto down the road instead. This is not the first time that you've been nasty to me because I don't look like your usual customer. A word advice, business is all relationships. So fix your ATTITUDE.

Don't be fooled by this being a repair center attached to a gas station. This is the best auto…read morerepair I have been to in the area. I went here on a Saturday around 11am (they close at 230p) and I was desperate for front brake pads. Instead of acting rude and unprofessional, like they did at Levines garage in vails gate when I called there, they (Carmine and Carmine) were very polite and professional and squeezed me in to get my brakes fixed. They ordered the parts and by 2pm I was on the road and my brakes are now better than ever and at a good price. This is where I will get my car fixed from now on and will never ever go to Levines garage again

From the owner: All mechanical repairs (no body work) We do everything and…read morewill match or beat any price Semi SYNTHETIC oil/filter change only 39.99

They did a fantastic job on my SUV! I had a dent in my passenger side door and scratches. It looks…read morebrand new and they cleaned the inside from all the shavings after fixing the door!!! Everyone was very polite and explained everything they had to do! I would highly recommend them! They do great work! Nancy

Service , quality & value is outstanding !!! They strive for perfection!! From start to finish was…read morea pleasure !!!

Just wanted to take a minute to thank Jimmy's Auto Care out of Newburgh, NY, for helping us through…read morea sticky situation. As we traveled back from PA to RI, our car lost its brakes. Luckily we were able to get off the highway and to safety. We called Jimmy's and they were able to take our car in immediately. Not only was it ready the next morning, he stayed and fixed the car before closing, knowing we'd need it to travel home in the morning. Top notch customer service, fair pricing and just a really awesome experience. We made it home safely and couldn't be more grateful for the people of Newburgh, NY! ‍

What comes to mind about Jimmy's Auto Care is friendliness, reliability, and most importantly,…read morehonesty. I will never visit another car repair facility as long as I am alive.

I have known sahr for 20 years now, back when he was fixing cars in driveways. He went to school…read morefor it and we both worked for toyota ar some point. I can honestly say he knows his stuff and now is teaching a younger generation a trade that is so important. I trust sahr and his team with my vehicles. Pas is a place where you can trust your getting a honest diagnosis and a trusted repair. All the employees are so nice and pleasant. From the receptionist to the mechanics you are treated as more than a customer, but like family. A nice clean enjoyable waiting room if you are waiting for your car and a dunking donuts across the street, its located in a great easy location. Whether its a normal repair, tires or if you are looking to add performance parts this is the place to go.

This shop is amazing. The staff is so courteous to everyone who comes in and welcomes them as a…read morecustomer.

This shop is either crooked or very incompetent. I was looking for a new mechanic for my vehicles…read morebecause my old mechanic retired. I live nearby and gave Star Quality a try. I took my car in because it was leaking oil and antifreeze. Most local mechanics I've used don't charge diagnostic fees as long as you're paying them to do the repairs. Star charged me a $120 diagnostic fee. If you're charging me $120 to tell me what's wrong, you better be right about the problem. I paid $1,312 for them to replace the valve cover and coolant housing. I got the car back and the oil leak was even worse. I brought my car back. They charged me a second $120 diagnostic fee, even though I already paid it the first time and they failed to correct the problem. I paid an additional $1,907 for them to replace the oil housing. This included a lot of the same labor that was done during the first service. That would've saved me an extra $120 diagnostic fee and several hours of work if they did the job correctly the first time. The service tech even admitted that the second mechanic paid more attention than the first mechanic. I got the car home and it's still leaking oil all over my driveway. I paid them $3200+ and the problem still isn't fixed. I'm not bringing it back to pay another $120 diagnostic fee and more labor charges. It should've been fixed right the first two times. I'll be finding another mechanic for my vehicles.

My wife and I have been using star quality for years and are very pleased with its work. So, I was…read morevery surprised so see the negative reviews. Happy to say that has not been our experience.