Me & my family loved the pizza especially the Big Eighter!…read more It was perfect! We were met with great service & a friendly smile! The cleanest restaurant in Decatur!!

Cool building in downtown Decatur. Service at the window and they bring out the food. Loved that…read morethey had cold beers. The lunch combo was 2 slices, fries, and a drink. The fries were the bomb. They had course salt and pepper seasoning that had tons of flavor. Now for the pizza, serviceable but nothing memorable. I want more flavor in the sauce or something.

Looked for a place that was open late on a Friday night, and 1860 hit the spot. Erica greeted us…read morewarmly and the menu looked extensive. We stuck with pizza and shared a half hula girl and half sausage mushroom and onion. Crust was firm and how I like it. The spicy hula girl was so flavorful - I don't usually do pineapple on pizza but with the pulled pork and spicy sauces it worked perfectly! The whole little Main Street area of Bridgeport looked like something we would want to explore another time. So glad we found these guys. TVs for football, a well stocked bar, and great pizza! High schoolers showed us as we were leaving but they were polite and not rowdy - ha!

Not sure if this is the old 1860 as the new name is 1860 Slice House. Obviously, you can order by…read morethe slice or whole pizzas. We tried take out with a 18" Meat Lovers pizza and what a sight to see. Large, thick pepperoni, Canadian bacon, beef, bacon and quarter size balls of Italian sausage on a nicely sauced pizza crust. While not my favorite crust, I had to take into account we drove for 45 minutes after picking it up. The only negative (which I love) is trying to fold a slice and take a bite is tough because the three balls of sausage rolled right off the slice. Fixed it by breaking them up so they wouldn't roll! Great taste. Sauce and cheese were just right and the bottom crust was very nice, held together under the weight of the toppings but still gave a soft mouth feel. Loved the pizza! Mozzarella sticks appeared be freshly made: great breading and soft, warm cheese. Excellent side dish. Service was right on, it was ready we when showed up three minutes early, greets warmly and checked out within four minutes. Dining area was clean, TVs not too loud and lighting wasn't too bright. We will go back after I finish off the leftovers. Best pizza in town for sure.

Love this place! The food is always excellent. We usually come here with friends and they are…read morealways able to accommodate the larger parties.

Food was absolutely amazing... Service was very good too. We will definitely be back. The chicken…read morespecial and it did not disappoint....

I have mixed feelings about my meal here. They are new owners and they have scaled back the menu…read more I was told my pizza would be ready in 45 minutes and it took a lot longer because the first pizza fell apart, new cook. When I got it home it looked very different but did taste good. Seems like they need to keep working at it. I will try them again.

This place is off the beaten path for most but is a local favorite. The pizza is always good,wings…read moreare plump and have a good flavor. When we have had pasta, it's been good when you go with the basics (chicken parmigiana, lasagna, fettuccine, etc.). The plate my daughter had was stuffed shrimp and she did not really care for much of it. The rest was great! They feature karaoke on Thursday's which is a lot fun. They do have a bar side and restaurant side. If not busy or wild, they will allow the older kids on the bar side. The staff is wonderful. Now for the not so good. The place is in dire need of a facelift. I don't know when the last time the walls had seen a good coat of paint. The floors I am certain get swept and mopped everyday but with how old they are, you can't tell. The bathroom - there is only one. There are others are not working. If they could take care of aesthetics, this place would get more than 3 stars from me.

Quick stop on our way passing through. When we got there we weren't sure if it was open because no…read morecars were outside but it seems like everyone started showing up as soon as we sat down. Definitely has a homecooked taste which I love. Family vibes for sure. We ordered the lasagna, Alfredo, and shrimp scampi. All were delicious.

Not a bad local Italian joint. Not a great local Italian joint…read more The XL pizza might be the best value deal in this town, and it's HUGE! Not the best pizza in the world, and they are skimpy on toppings... but it's HUGE! It feeds a lot! Take it home, pile on your own toppings, throw it in the oven for 10 minutes, and you've got an absolute Winner! Everything, including the take out boxes and menu's are Lisanti. What that means is they serve the same stuff almost everyone else does. Nobody's "nonna" is in the back hand rolling the pasta... but there are 2 other places within a short driving distance, that use the same ingredients that blow this place away... However, quick and easy counts for something on a Tuesday night! The calzone was desperately undercooked. My air fryer couldn't save it. My oven couldn't save it. We ate LOTS OF RAW DOUGH... ugh. The pasta was horribly overdone. Pro tip: If you are going to pre-cook the pasta, don't cook it all the way, then cook it again... or you get: OVERDONE PASTA! Blech. The Philly cheesesteak was one of the best we have ever had. It was slice, not chopped, and full of cheese and veggies! Highly recommend! 3 STARS because I'll be back for that Philly!

I went there today to get a pizza for me and my family. I walked in and the man said "what do you…read morewant." I said I'll take the extremost and before I could say anything else he turned around and slammed the pizza on the counter and said "cash or card." I was livid leaving there and I got home and got a regular pepperoni so I paid a dollar extra for the wrong pizza and nothing else. Im not happy with the costumer service and not going back anytime soon.

Went to this location for a Saturday Football Day hot and ready (anything) pizza. Arrived to a…read morelobby packed with football fans and no hot and ready pizzas. Swing and a miss Little Cesar's. Went to the competition and had a custom ordered 2 medium sized pizzas in 11 minutes.

Everything was great here. Not just pizza place they had cat fish, chicken strips etc. the pasta…read moredish my wife had was delicious. My friend had the cat fish and they were nice size pieces and very tasty. His wife had a salad & lasagna and really liked it. I had.....chicken strips... don't judge me. Loved them. My wife had the chicken Alfredo. You should give this place a try. You won't be let down.

This is a very popular local place with quick delivery which earns it some high ratings…read more We stopped in after reading the YELP reviews, but there was only 1 table which was taken. There's a hallway to another room, which could have been another business, but no one was in there... and the hallway was kinda blocked by stacks of boxes. I can not tell if it was additional seating or not, but it was very uninviting. While not necessarily rude, the lady at the counter was not welcoming, and appeared to be in a huge rush. The kitchen seemed to be in a state of chaos with several people screaming at each other. As it was us and one other couple, there must have been tons of call-in orders or something... but we seemed more like we were in the way, rather than they appreciated our business. The philly steak grinder, unseasoned with a 1/2 melted piece of provolone thrown over the top (see pic), which would rate a 2. The kids garlic butter spaghetti, was super garlicky... not my preference, but not a big deal. The pizza wasn't cooked through, and was soggy and greasy with no color on the crust at all... 2 stars. There's nothing to say about the Caesar, and the Tiramisu is the same Lisanti frozen product you can get at every Italian joint in the county. There's nothing here that warrants the return drive. 2 STARS

This has always been our go to pizza shop you can get 1 slice or a whole pizza. Calzones yummy all…read morethe pastas are a go to also

Great East Coast attitude! They are quite authentic and so delicious! Great atmosphere, feels like…read moreI'm in New York! Love!

The pizza was delicious. The uncle Monty was a for sure try if you like variety on the pizza. Best…read morepart was the friendly owners. Johnathan was great with helping us with everything.

The small was not 10". It was 6". The price for that pizza was ridiculous. The large was fine but…read moreboth were Just not to our taste.

OK, the pizza here is excellent. My wife likes pizza but can't have the marinara, so she gets it…read morewith olive oil. Anyway we got an mushroom and onion pizza with extra cheese and it was DELICIOUS. The young girl who answered the phone and who was at the counter was very friendly. So, the pizza was made exactly as we ordered and as stated earlier DELICIOUS.

I love this place is is clean good food and gets food out fast good ranch and good ham rolls…read more I is good