Mr Kisco Seafood is a staple in town! Such a wonderful place to get fresh fish, seafood, sushi, and other ingredients. All the employees are such friendly faces and help make the buying process smooth. There are several parking spots to the side of the building, making it easy to pop in and out. I have never had to wait longer than a minute or two to pay for my items. Sushi is a must here! It's so tasty and fresh and easily the best sushi in town. This is a quick go-to for dinner and I highly recommend it! read more

Mt Kisco Seafood - Seafood Markets Near Me - Mount Kisco, New York

See all

Most of the time, they sold me rotten and expensive seafood. One time an employee was very anger because I bought what he thought was too much seafood. I had to deal with the problem for many years because they were the only seafood business closest to my home. I used many fresh lemon juice and water to rid of the bad smell. read more

Great selection. Only the freshest and best fish & seafood. Very attentive service and willing to fillet and trim per your request. Fully cooked food as well as raw. Ambiance great for a fish market. Prices are appropriate for what you are getting. read more

The very freshest and best seafood around. The knowledge and service are outstanding. The ambience of the store goes back in time to great fish markets. I love Mt. Kisco Seafood and wouldn't go anywhere else. Seafood is my favorite food and I can see the best quality exists here. read more

Great seafood, great service We bought sushi rolls, oysters, salmon, halibut, crabcakes, produce, and pantry items for dinner tonight. The seafood was excellent and the service exceptional. We dined well tonight. read more

The best fresh seafood that I've ever had. We got clams. Scallops, peeled, shrimp, halibut, and salmon. The meal was miraculous. read more

Delicious! This Mount Kisco institution serves such fresh salmon, baked clams, and even delicious, seared, creative sushi. You know when you open a cut of salmon and it doesn't have a single fishy smell? You wouldn't even know it's fish. That's what they sell here. When you're hankering for that weekend, treat-yourself-to-not-supermarket seafood, or simply want easy-peasy and good sushi, come here. 5 stars!!! read more

Bought 150 little neck clams and they were very fresh. A little pricey but tasted good

Mt. KISCO SEAFOOD, They have a great selection of fresh seafood that comes in daily. The prices are a little high but the quality is really worth it. You won't go wrong buying your seafood at this place. read more

Everything, this business is for real! Food is fresh staff are friendly and the ambience is real!

We've been coming here for decades for the best fresh seafood and service. Yesterday I branched out and bought steaks. Wow! The ribeye was the best I've had at home or at a restaurant in ages. So glad for local businesses with high quality goods. read more

What a gem. This little shop is nestled on Lexington Avenue, and it almost feels like it belongs in a river town, because it is so authentic as far as fish shop goes. The attention was personalized, the service was phenomenal, and the quality of the fish? The best I've seen lately. I picked up a pound of lemon sole (my FAVORITE) and some branzino fillets. I cannot wait to cook them up. What I found particularly unique about Mt. Kisco Seafood was that it is also part grocery store, with beautiful, farm-fresh produce, prepared sauces, and other fish-friendly accoutrements -- think marinades, sushi-rolling tools, panko, etc. They even have a sushi chef on-site. For just under $40, I picked up enough fish to feed my husband and me for two meals, and I'm already eager to return. read more

One of the only places I've never been disappointed in when buying seafood. I've gotten a culinary education just by talking to these guys over the years. They have been my go to for major holiday orders (though get them in early) for the better part of a decade. I appreciate all of the Covid precautions they've taken over the past year. It hasn't been easy on any small business but their efforts haven't gone unnoticed! read more

COVID has struck again. Years ago I bought shrimp to make for a cocktail party and to my disgust got home and opened the bag and the smell was all it took to see the lack of regard for good tasting food they chose their profit over my meal. No different now with their bench / table outside did you call in an order? We prefer you don't check it's better for your bottom line! At least when you walked through the store you could see what you were paying for. Ask for a steak (pre COVID they worked a quality butcher into the program. Ask for a steak now? Here it is , looks big, PRE PACKAGED! Had zero distinction. When I asked how much, dude asked "does it weigh"? Not enjoyable tasteless , chewy, wont go back! Oh yeah the tomato salad another sounded good but inedible! Pandemic sucks but I see business as usual. read more

Don't buy the frozen lobster tails! I bought two big ones yesterday and one was rotten. Normally I would let it go, but I bought six large ones back at Easter and three were brown/rotten inside. I gave them a 2nd chance in part because supply chains are stressed right now, but they should know they should change their supplier. Rotten seafood at that consistency suggests something is wrong. I tried to call several times to alert them discreetly, but the phone is always busy. Otherwise this place is very good. read more

There are some nice items here, but the quality is inconsistent. During one visit we paid $60 for crab that was so fishy we threw it away.

First time. Must be a popular place. Ordered fish last week. Still had to wait on an hour line along with those who had not ordered ahead. Whole Foods next year. read more

I went here because I was in town and I saw the good reviews on Yelp so I figured I might as well stop by since I'm a big lover of sushi. Don't expect cheap though. immediately, when I walked in the front door, there was a big variety of fresh sushi with two sushi chefs making a bunch more. I also heard some customers making requests which is pretty cool but I didn't feel the need to do that because they already had some pretty good-looking rolls laying out. The salmon was very fresh and I for sure will go back there to get that again. I also really loved the salmon cream cheese that they had in a container in back in the fridge. it was like $7 for a small container but they packed it very tightly and there was a ton of salmon in it, so to me, totally worth it. they also sold some fresh bread by the cashier counter, so I bought two rolls to dip into the cream cheese, but the rolls werent something out of this world, so feel free to get your bread at the local supermarket if need be. they had a ton of fresh fish you could buy as well. they also had some fresh tomatoes that looked really good and were nice and firm. to me, that was great, because my local supermarket always seems to have mushy tomatoes. Anyway, solid establishment. Good service. Will come back. read more

They are really difficult to deal with - you can't ever se what you are buying and if you bring it home and aren't happy with it you can't return it or complain about it either apparently . read more

Two words - Tuna Carpaccio. SOOOO amazingly good.

The bottom line is: this is a great store. The people who work are are very friendly and the seafood is top quality. They also have amazing bread, and a very good selection of high quality vegetables, groceries, etc. They even have some prepared food and meats. This is a great place to come if you are cooking dinner for 2 or 40. They also have catering, which is quite good. I can't recommend Mt. Kisco Seafood highly enough. read more

I have been a customer for well over 15 years and have NEVER had bad service or fish that was anything but excellent!!! Recommendations on what fish is best have always been on point and the guys are always ready with suggestions on how to prepare the fish if you are unsure. Their soups are equally amazing. read more

This is a great seafood shop! We drive over the TZ Bridge happily knowing we will get fresh amazing fish. Our favorites are the stone crabs! Yum! Nice people and good service. read more

Attended the American Gold Cup at North Salem Hose Farm and had a Lobster Roll $23 with a bag Potato Chips and a side of Corn & Bean Saladin the side. The roll was toasted and the Lobster fresh and delicious! Only problem for me was it was Cash only! With modern technology why don't they join the other food trucks and allow for credit card chargers. I am not going to an ATM that they had stationed nearby because i do not trust these pop-up ATMs. read more

Horrible experience. I ordered shrimp for shrimp cocktails for Easter Sunder dinner. I said I wanted large shrimp thinking that "large" really was large. They were cooked and deveined, as I ordered, but $57 bought me quite small shrimp, unattractive to use. Unfortunately I didn't discover this mistake until nearly the time they closed, so had to run to my local market to buy larger ones. The man I spoke to on the phone was unpleasant and defensive. A very overpriced, hurried place that doesn't take the time to listen to what a customer wants. "THIS is the way WE do shrimp cocktail" he said angrily. Their prices are outrageous. read more

If you don't mind spending the big bucks, this is the place for fish. They will poach, grill, bake, or fry, anything you buy. If you're cooking yourself they will tell you exactly how to cook your fish. They make their halibut cakes and crab cakes in the store. They have fresh lobster meat and if they're out of it they'll make some asap. read more

I have been going to Mt. Kisco Seafood for 40 years. All the fish is always perfect and fresh. The help is outstanding and know their business. I have not taken advantage of the butcher and Japanese foods offered there. read more

The sushi was surprisingly disappointing ! The rice was NOT sushi rice, it tasted like over cooked white rice. The fish was very fresh but had a few flavors like onion and something I could not place. If I go back it won't be for sushi. read more

Super fresh seafood and friendly, helpful staff. Be warned, the weekends can get BUSY, but they're very efficient and keep the line moving. The scallops are perfectly cleaned without the least bit of grit. They're sweet and delicious. The lobsters are feisty and you can tell they're fresh, unlike at some grocery store fish counters. The other seafood looks delicious and they have a broad selection. When you walk in, there are people making the fresh sushi and there's a small produce section as well as a meat counter. They have fresh bread that looks like it would be great for sopping up all that fishy goodness you'll be making. I know they also allow phone ahead orders, but I've had zero issues getting what I've come for. I live in Peekskill and will drive the 30+ minutes for fish just because I know it's super good quality. It can get a bit pricey depending on what you buy, but you also can rest easy that no dyes or other artificial items have been added to your fish! read more

This is the best fish market I've ever experienced. The fish and shell fish are fresh and fabulous and varied. The prepared platters like tuna carpaccio are crowd pleasers, and the people are the best! And now the produce is fresh, local and at times includes some hard to find items- like fiddleheads. I love this place and after 16 years of being a frequent customer hope it continues to thrive. read more

Fantastically friendly staff, knowledgeable, always well stocked, and incredibly fresh.

Best place to buy FRESH sea food.Great service, and now they are selling sushi that is freshly made every day and has the same goos quality as their fish. tuna carpaccio is amazing too! read more

Fresh Fresh Fresh!!!....that's what you get!!...always can count on a warm welcome and a smile :) Just a great place to shop for a delicious meal...Well done, Guys! read more

The best customer service I've seen in years. Fresh, tasty seafood. I live about 45 min. away and will always the make drive when I need seafood. I ordered lobster today to pick up Friday and they are going to prepare it for me ready to eat when I pick it up. I'm glad because I have the slightest clue on how to kill a live lobster. I'm glad I tried this place with many thanks to the reviews on Yelp. read more

Top notch seafood! If your a seafood lover and only like the best quality you definetly need to check this place out. You surely pay for the quality but its consistent and beats any place else I've tried to buy seafood. They also have good breads, spreads, seasoning, and the employees who are more than happy to help. read more

I've been a customer for at least 25 years. I've never been disappointed. Their seafood is fresh and delicious. Their catering is the best and is extremely reasonable. The staff is great and Brian and Joe Fish, the owner are tops. Don't miss their meat counter for awesome steaks. Visit once and you are a customer for life. read more

Thank you for making my first seafood cooking attempt so easy and successful. I brought in my Cioppino recipe and was advised on what and how much to buy, everything was cleaned and preped for me, and you even had beautiful crusty bread to go with it. The Cioppino was a delicious hit. Thank you for making it so easy for me. read more

Wow. The seafood is great from here, I truly mean that. However, the price of the fresh/frozen seafood is outrageously over priced!!!!! $32.99 was the price of their frozen Alaskan king crab legs. Now I know their legs are just shy of 1lb each, but I know general prices in Manhattan and Westchester for AKC in this weight range and this is INSANE!!! In Manhattan (I won't leave name of company bc I'm not "peddeling" promotion of another company, just showing the reality of this huge flaw MKS has) at extremely REPUTABLE places in the 40s on the East Side the price of AKC in the SAME weight range is $20-25 a lb. In Westchester there are more reputable places in the $20-25 per lb range with the SAME weight range of 1lb per leg!!!! I like MKS but do NOT want to feel as if I'm being robbed when I go to settle the bill!!! I was turned off with the price gouging of their other seafoods but shocked & appalled at this final straw!!! I will not be returning to MKS and I live here in Mt Kisco. I have been going there for many years but this is the straw that broke the camels back!!! I will be going to a much more reasonable priced seafood store in Elmsford!!!! read more

Just letting you know that I have been a customer of yours for years and just happen to notice today a sign in your window in which I was offended. It says "Immigrants and refugees are welcome". What does that even mean? What kind of point are you trying to make? Actually, You don't have to answer any of those questions because as of today I will never be stepping foot in your store again. You just lost me as a customer and I have been spending several thousand dollars a year purchasing your products. I highly doubt that the Immigrants and refugees will be keeping your business alive at your prices.... Shame on you for making your business political..... GO TRUMP!!!! read more

When I'm looking for fresh oysters, clams, baby octopus, etc I always head here. Great selection. Don't see it in the case? Ask and they may have it in the back. read more