Ordered a pint of strawberry and one of chocolate ice cream and a chocolate Smith Island Cake. I…read morewas disappointed in the ice cream; tasted like chalk. The cake was okay, but wouldn't order again. To each their own, not for my taste.

I had a great experience with Smith Island, baking! I recently ordered my mother a birthday cake…read morefrom here, the lemon cream flavor. It was delivered by goodly, as we live in Massachusetts. The cake arrived in great condition and I received notifications throughout. Good belly was also wonderful in responding to different questions along the way. Smith Island was also great as when I gave them a call over the phone, they were very friendly and happy to assist me. Overall, I'm very happy with this company and would order from them again! I also meant to add that the cake was very tasty. The flavor was great and it was very pretty as well.

This is a walk up, order, wait and eat outside or take it to go kind of place. I was surprised at…read moreeverything they had on the menu. Crab cakes, pizza, burgers, hot dogs, subs, salads, pretzels and of course ice cream. Something for everyone. Just remember that you will be sitting outside at picnic tables under cute thatched umbrellas but they also have a shady pavilion type area. Not only do they have food but they have golf cart rentals and bikes too. One stop shopping. Customer service was very friendly. I ordered the soft serve. Even though they have 24 flavors I got chocolate. So basic. But it was sooooo good and hit the spot after a day of walking around. The flavors range from coconut, peanut butter, blueberry, watermelon, amaretto, strawberry and lemon. My chocolate was devoured before it had a chance to melt. I love soft serve!!! Definitely recommend for ice cream.

We couldn't make it past the front gate because their political flags and posters were so…read moreoffensive. Tackiest welcome to this sinking island. And of course the wait staff seemed blatantly annoyed by island visitors that we quickly opted for another, less caustic atmosphere.

This is a neat little stop on Tangier Island. It's 50's style ice cream parlor. The ice cream is…read moreyummy, but you're missing out if you don't ask for the Spanky's Ice Cream Sandwich! It is soft serve ice cream sandwiches between two homemade chocolate chip cookies! I can't even begin to tell you how amazing it was! And huge! I could've split it with my husband if I would've realized! My lack of 5-stars is because the people behind the counter (both times we went) were extremely unfriendly. Like they won't smile back at you when you smile and thank them. We found this somewhat common on the island, but I'm not a fan.

Atmosphere is quaint. Service was poor and food was ok. Better ice cream at Four Brothers.read more

The cake is what they're known for on this island. While the number of layers varies, I ended up…read morewith an eight layer German chocolate cake. It was absurdly decadent. I was surprised at the number of flavors, but of course there's no reason you can't use this basic style of cake with any number of ingredients. This place notably offered a gluten-free slice for a bit more, and cold beverages. Signage on the outside seemed to indicate the building might be for sale. There are a few places to get a cake on this island, but on my visit I felt this the right choice.

I came straight to Smith Island Bakery to try their delicious cakes and they did not disappoint!…read moreThey have a variety of flavors but be sure to go early as they will sell out later in the day.

Since we visited Chincoteague during a shoulder season, not everything in town was open. Island…read moreCreamery saved the day with ridiculously delicious ice cream. If you love coffee and chocolate, get the Java Jolt - the coffee ice cream was rich, the chocolate covered espresso beans were delicious, and the brownie chunks were fudgy . If you want something a little fruitier, the Cherry Vanilla is so good. Lots and lots of black cherries. The Pineapple Upside Down was a little bit of a bummer - it was super sweet. We were hoping for a strong pineapple flavor but it mostly tasted of sugar. Still nice but I wouldn't get it again.

I forgot to write down the flavours I got but I combined a chocolate peanut butter ice cream and…read moreanother ice cream (I think the snickers one?) for my shake and it was delicious. I would recommend this place and be down to visit again. Most my friends got ice cream in waffle cones and they looked very good (and had large servings!)

BYOC is a great stop on the island. Who knew there were so many combinations of cookies, ice cream…read moreand toppings. Well worth the wait.

My daughter and I went to visit my husband at Wallops Island. We went over to Chincoteague to get…read morea sweet treat and decided to try BYOC. By first glance, it's a small food truck, which seems to be the thing here for quite a few places to eat. They set out tables and chairs with umbrellas, thank you for that! The menu was laid out well and made ordering simple. You choose your cookie, your ice cream and your toppings. I am so glad they had a gluten-free cookie, and I was surprised with how good it was! You don't need to order more than one scoop of ice cream, the scoops are generous and the cookies are huge! I definitely recommend this place if you're looking for dessert. This was one place that didn't disappoint me on the island

Was wandering in eastern shore this place looked good. Again late for lunch. Probably near 3 pm…read more Large portions for The bowls. Delightful array of fresh n flavorful ingredients. Nice n refreshing on a warm day.

We both had the special vegetarian panini with a side salad. The picture shows the second half of…read morethe sandwich! Very good! It's nice when a panini is moist, yet crunchy on the outside but not dried out. Lots of flavor. I would try to add a few slices of avocado to make it even better. Luckily yelp helped us find this place before driving in. Street parking was all taken at 1p on Friday afternoon so a loop around the block produced opportunities. The people were friendly and helpful.

Best baked desserts in the area all homemade and handmade taste with such a delicate look ! I have…read morehad almost everything that doesn't have chocolate in it (I don't eat chocolate) Im a sucker for gooey bars but the lemon raspberry cake was a slice of heaven it was like eating clouds of deliciousness !

This place shares space with what seems to be a separate business; of the two, this is the larger…read moreone. They offer pies and ice cream in a relatively high-end atmosphere. After some perusal, I elected a chocolate mousse slice. It was a resplendent work, with strong chocolate but a mix of flavors including a surprise hit of caramel at the bottom. The ice cream is locally made but I certainly did not have room to try it. There seem to be several local businesses under this general ownership, which gives one a good reason to pull over while traveling through the region.

My experience was unbelievably bad The ice cream was frozen…read moreto the point where I couldn't even eat it let alone it wasn't prepared as I requested at the end. The young lady offered me the opportunity to Which I thought was special. I won't be going back for sure.

Sweet potato biscuits are back on the Shore! If you remember Friendly's biscuits you'll enjoy…read morethese. And the scones are excellent !

I excellent tart cherry pie. Quiches are very good too! Their pie crusts are the best!…read more Didn't like theirs sweet potato biscuits otherwise I would have given them 5 stars.