Murray Hill Market makes the best authentic Italian food just like my Nonna's kitchen! Everything on the menu is perfectly seasoned to excite your taste buds and give you the comfort of eating savory homemade cuisine. It has become my new favorite place to pick up a light fare or to enjoy an amazing meal in a relaxing setting. Don't miss this unique culinary experience. Mangiamo! read more

What a gem. We had a chicken parm sandwich and a meatball parm sandwich. They were outstanding. My wife had the chicken parm and I the meatball parm, the sauce was delicious. The called the sauce Grandma T's sauce. The guys were so kind. The vibe of the deli was like my neighborhood spot. If I lived close to Little Italy of Cleveland, I'd be there at least 2 times a week. Great job guys. I'm sorry I forgot got your names. read more

Very nice neighborhood market and sandwich shop. Lots of selections. All fresh made. Service was a bit slow the day I went but not excessively so. One of the few places I've seen a porchetta sandwich. It was juicy and porky. read more

See all

Not only is the food consistently delicious, but the staff clearly take pride in their work and in assuring a good customer experience - when a recent delivery service order arrived with missing items, the MHM team reached out to me via the delivery service before I had even realized items were missing, and arranged to have the missing items sent via another courier. We love Murray Hill Market! read more

Sandwiches are delicious , market has a very good selection of wine and groceries . It also has an outdoor dining area . If I lived in the area I'd use the store regularly read more

Exceptional food and service! My husband and I were immediately greeted with kindness and warmth. We were given samples of the menu, which aided us in making our selections. We got Italian Deluxe and Chicken Parmesan subs; pasta, and zucchini pancakes for later. Absolutely delish and we will absolutely be back! read more

Quaint market with a lot of imported foods. The deli counter had good sandwiches and side salads. Nice little sidewalk tables. Service was a little slow but everything was hand made. read more

Cute nice store. A assortment of basic foods and household goods. The prepared goods are great. I love their meatball sandwich.

Darn good sandwiches at darn good prices! It's actually a convenient store, but you can also get hot food there. Heads up, it's an old building that's tiny inside, so not great for people in wheelchairs. read more

See all

A perfect gem of a spot! Classic but updated neighborhood grocery ... We stopped in for sandwiches and sodas. The people who work there were SO friendly and welcoming! We had a prime rib sandwich with melted provolone and peppers, and the Italian BLT (pancetta, brie, arugula, tomato, & balsamic vinaigrette; pictured here, forgot to take pic before I started!). Absolutely delicious. Not huge but just the right size. When you're finished eating, there are all kinds of interesting groceries, produce, wines, pastries, locally sourced items, and more. Definitely will be back, worth heading up the side street off Little Italy's main drag. Don't miss it! read more

Murray Hill Market - Italian BLT - Grocery Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

We just stopped in to kill some time, met the owner Michelle and she is an amazing, energetic and generous person. Enjoyed talking with her. It definitely be a stop whenever in the area. The meats and cheese are so tasty! She gave a sample of the zucchini pancakes - wow!! Sooo Good! read more

I was in the area and never been to Murray Market before so for dinner one night, I got the Italian Sub Deluxe ($12.95) after asking what their most popular meat sandwich was. It was ready in about five minutes and was a super yummy, authentically Italian sandwich with a generous amount of cheese and meats. I had forgotten that I don't like pancetta so I had to take those slices out, which is unfortunate because pancetta was like half of the meat. The best part was the bread the sandwich was in! I should have bought a bag of those to bring home. As for the store itself, it is old and worn and the prices of items are high. Some have price tags on them and others don't. You may be in for a surprise when you go to the checkout! This is a good place for locals to stop in and get an item or two. It's kind of like the quick stop shop or bodega of Little Italy. read more

See all

Italian sandwich and roast beef were excellent! The sauce on the eggplant parm was great. Just wish the eggplant was sliced a little thinner and the skin was peeled but over all a great experience. read more

Very cool little family-run market, artisan Italian foods and curated goods. Friendly, quaint atmosphere in a super cute Italian neighborhood. read more

Stopped in for lunch while getting familiar with Cleveland. This Italian market won't let you down! Delicious and made fresh the Italian way! read more

See all

Food is always so fresh and delicious. Service is polite and amazing! Ambiance as usual makes me feel like im in italy. read more

Murray Hill Market - Italian Sub Deluxe Pellegrino water - Grocery Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

My wife and I had an amazing time there. The food was very good, loved the zucchini pancakes and sandwiches, and the owner, Michele, was very engaging. She makes you feel like you're family. read more

For me this place brings to the table something amazing also known as their eggplant Parm sandwich. I'm always very picky when it comes to red sauce, but this place delivers...the service is really fast and efficient even at the times They are really busy. I saw there is seating there, but I usually take, my food to go. I've tried a few things from there, but hands-down I always order the eggplant, Parm sandwich, and it never disappoints. They also carry a great selection of ice cream and ices. read more

Murray Hill Market - Grocery Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

Found out about this place from my Italian plumber who said this was the best Italian food in Little Italy- so i knew I HAD to try! Cute shop in Little Italy that doubles as a small grocery store + restaurant. Limited seating. They some a couple tables outside and I believe one table on the inside if you want to eat-in. They also have bottles of wine you can order when you eat inside. Murray Hill has a mix of cold and hot foods, but i've only tried the hot foods so far. The fresh salmon sandwich, the Eggplant parmigiana sandwich and the Italian Sub deluxe. Wow- I mean they were all so delicious and packed with flavor. Tasted homemade, too. Not over-processed like I feel some american-italian tends to be. think my favorite was the eggplant based on how cheesy it was, but close second was the italian sub. read more

Murray Hill Market - Eggplant Parmesan Sandwich - Grocery Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

Porchetta was out. Settled for a dry and cold meatball sub. I don't think it was intended to be that way. Had a Turkish soup that was mostly just brown flavored water. Perhaps the lentils were still at the bottom of the serving container behind the counter. Overall it's a cozy place. Maybe too cozy, it was very slow in there and so was the food prep. There must've been a very important customer amongst us because she sucked up all the staff attention. Food - mediocre at best. Wine selection - decent. 6:10 for the first visit. read more

One of my favorite community hole-in-the-wall places to stop for lunch. Murray Hill Market is a small grocery store x sandwich shop crossover. They have a good selection of sandwich options ranging from classic (chicken parm) to inventive (Asian Philly roast beef sandwich). There's something on the menu for everyone! The sandwiches are freshly made and affordable. Definitely recommend if you're in the Little Italy area and want something quick to grab for lunch. read more

Murray Hill Market - Asian Philly Roast Beef Sandwich - Grocery Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

This is a great place the service is amazing and the food is just as good. Just ask for a sample they will provide one for you.

Murray Hill Market is located on the corner of Paul Ave and Murray hill Market. There is free 15 minute street parking off of Paul Ave if you just want to pop in to pick up some delicious food items at the deli. My husband and I came by here on a Tuesday afternoon around 2:10 pm. We were greeted by a friendly employee behind the counter. We had just had lunch down the street and some at Mama Santa's and walked up here to check out this market. I thought it would be nice to pick up some sandwiches for some lunch tomorrow when we visit Cuyahoga Valley National Park. We ended up purchasing the following (and consuming the next day): Combo Salad, $10.95 prior to tax- This combo salad comes with your choice of 3 salads in the displace case. I decided to order this salad because I thought it was a good deal at the price point. For this salad combo, I ended up picking pasta salad, chimichurri chicken, cous cous salad. I had asked if the chimichurri was part of the combo salad choices and another employee told me it can be (lol). I had asked him if it was spicy. He told me it isn't but did ask if I wanted to try it. I am glad he let me try it because I really liked it and did not find it to be spicy. I have a low tolerance for spicy foods. Often times when others have told me they don't think something is spicy, I find it to be (lol). The portion of this salad combo was huge and perfect at sharing with my husband. I liked the pasta salad and also the cous cous salad. I also liked that the pasta salad did have green leafys in it, which was nice to round out the selection I picked. Would definitely order this combo set again. Turkey Breast Rotisserie Roasted Sandwich, $9.95 prior to tax- After my husband ordered this sandwich, one of the employees began slicing the turkey and then putting together the sandwich. It was quite tasty the next day but I was surprised how small it was. It is a good thing I ordered the combo salad so that we would both have enough to eat. But the turkey sandwich itself was tasty with the pepper jack cheese and the cranberry mayo. ---------------------------- (Total= $20.90 after tax) Service was very friendly. We felt so welcomed. This market also sells a limited section of gourmet items (sauces, cheeses, jams/ spreads, jarred olives, breads, etc). There is also some seating inside upstairs and also some seating outside as well. If I lived in this area, I would come back. read more

See all

Good market in Little Italy. It feels like a classic deli and market. Murray Hill Market is located in the historic Italian neighborhood. Convenient for getting sandwiches or carryout. They have some indoor seating. A lot of items are packed into here. It basically is a deli with a market. The counter has freshly made salads and sandwiches. A lot are classic Italian flavors. There's a few newer kinds of styles. A good one is the hummus vegetable wrap, which had a lot stuffed into it. It has lots of hummus and vegetables like spinach and tomatoes among others. This is about $9 for a pretty good size, and comes with a side of chips or pretzels. If you're looking for some authentic items, you can find them here. Lots of classic herbs and spices. There's also great local choices of wines, and they have many frozen desserts like sorbets. read more

Murray Hill Market - Hummus Vegetable Wrap - Grocery Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

The Murray Hill Market is a visit to the past albeit slightly gentrified. My kids and I got sandwiches and some other bites and sat at the old butcher block table. The staff was very courteous, almost doting, yet competent and professional. I miss these kinds of places. My son gave the chicken parm sandwich ten out of ten. read more

This is a small Italian grocery in the middle of Little Italy of Cleveland's Eastside. There were several home-cooked Italian dinners that were prepared and ready to be warmed up on demand plus a sandwich and salad bar with soups I enjoyed one of the chopped Italian salad which were very large in portion and freshly made to my order the prices are reasonable and the grocery has a little bit of everything in case you need a quick convenient pick up before dinner. The service was very friendly and several people behind the counter for a rush hours like a lunch which I was a little white four but still had a personal touch and people ready and willing to help go the extra mile for that Italian dressing or something special you want left out or included in your order read more

See all

Amazing Italian sandwiches. We ordered Italian Deluxe, Classic Italian, Chicken Parm, Eggplant Parm, and Breakfast Sandwich--all super delicious. You can taste the freshness in ingredients and the perfect amount of crunchiness in their bread. The shop is SO CUTE with grocery items, deli, and wines to choose from. Few out door seatings out front and in the back. The back patio is accessed thru side of the market. Plenty of free hour & permit parking around. Murray Hill Market is an absolute gem in Little Italy! read more

Murray Hill Market - Italian Sub Deluxe - peppers, italian meats, basil, & fresh mozz - Grocery Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

Excellent food, I frequently stop here when I'm in Cleveland. Good variety of tasty sandwiches. Also very interesting drink selection

This place is an ethnic Italian neighborhood mini mart that makes delicious soups, sandwiches and entrees. The people are SUPER NICE and gear to please. Street parking usually easy to find. read more

First time visiting Murray Hill Market due to the reviews and it fell extremely short. Not the best service and food. The eggplant parm was very soggy, cold, and bordering bland. My sandwich was quite small and disappointing for its price. The lady at the counter was a snob and there was a younger lady taking orders that wasn't any more pleasant. No surprise the place was empty. I regret not picking another place. I'm sure the pizzeria down the block served something much better. Will never go there again. read more

Murray Hill Market - Our Signature Eggplant Parmesan Sandwich - Grocery Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

Delicious sandwiches with high quality ingredients and creative premade salads. Counter service within a little market. There are a few seats available to eat in. We chose to carry out. read more

This place used to have the best freaking sandwiches ever!! I think they changed staff sometime last year because the same sandwich I always get was never made correctly by the new staff, which sucked. Still, the meat and cheese selections are vast and they're amazing quality. The basil on the sandwiches are always fresh too. I miss the twink that used to make my sandwiches all the time early last year (heartbreak emoji) read more

A hidden gem in Cleveland's Little Italy. Away from the main drag, and parking is still difficult as it usually is down there, Murray Hill Market is the typical corner deli and store taken up the 10th power. Best eggplant parmigiana around, excellent options for sandwiches, great customer service, and an opportunity to walk upstairs to a quiet table. Took my dad there on my birthday and an employee (maybe the owner?) took us upstairs for fresh cavatelli and bread. She opened up a bottle of wine, took care of us, and gave us free Pizzelles on the way out. The best place in Little Italy. Easily. read more

Updating to five stars because I've tried probably 25 different items from here and I've never once had anything bad. The vast majority of their hot and cold items are actually fantastic- this is a serious gem in Little Italy. You must try the incredibly moist meatloaf and the juicy salmon! read more

See all

What a cute place! Walking in, we didn't really know what to expect. It's a very small market and deli, but they have some unique offerings that you may not find in a regular grocery store. My husband and son both ordered sandwiches and were very happy with their selections. A turkey sandwich with cheese and a cranberry mayonnaise, which my husband enjoyed and then an Italian sandwich for my son. They both said the bread was the best part although everything was fresh and put together well. Worth a trip if you are in the area. I'm sure it's a favorite for the locals. We were visiting Case Western University and this place came recommended by a faculty member. You may not find it otherwise. read more

We were in the area and looking for lunch but didn't want a full sit down Little Italy meal and found this place on Yelp. It's a little grocery and the sandwiches and salad was so freakin good. I had the eggplant Parm sandwich and my wife had the roasted turkey (roasted on site!) and they were both amazing. Starts with the crusty bread and the eggplant was sliced super thin and the rolled up with the perfect amount of sauce. We are in and they took great care of us, bringing the food to one of the little tables upstairs, including a huge chopped Italian salad with fresh cut meats and lots of veggies. This place is a gem! read more

Murray Hill Market - MHM's Signature Fried Eggplant Cutlet - Grocery Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

Nestled in Little Italy, this gem provided a robust and delish ribeye sandwich, fit for a king. Delightful market with some legit selections. read more

A pleasant surprise and a hidden gem I never knew existed. Was at UHHS and went on Yelp to find a place to check out before heading home. Murray Hill was a top recommendation and it's evident why. Part deli part convenience store but the deli is where it's at! Everything is homemade and they get their wonderful baguette from somewhere nearby. Sandwiches are not huge but who cares as the meats and cheeses and salads are all restaurant quality. Their salmon is insanely good and fresh whole salmon they bake in house skin on. It's cooked medium with slight pink, super juicy and the way I love it. You can get the salmon as a salad or on baguette. Yum! For the salad they make a tarragon and a balsamic dressing. I added Gorgonzola based on their recommendation and it was excellent. Had to get some tuna salad to go--so good! If you're in the area debating where to grab lunch amongst the many restaurants--put Murray Hill at the top of your list. read more

Murray Hill Market - Zucchini pancakes with homemade marinara - Grocery Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

See all

-pricey but good, the granita is really good and can be purchased even on days Mount Granita is closed -mozzarella was only okay and not worth the price, could las for store bought read more

Effin perfect! Great little general store with yum food. We will be back to sit on the patio which I cannot figure out where they might be hiding. Really reminds me of an NYC upscale Italian general stet and deli. Think bodega with better everything! Go! Damn good looking staff too! read more