If you recall my review of the ice cream shop down the road. This place was number two and also remains a place we visit when nearby. Consistently good homemade ice cream. Any line goes fast. Enjoy! read more

Creamy, fresh ice cream. Patient staff. I got peanut butter chocolate and cookie dough together in a waffle cone. My brother opted for a fresh homemade waffle cone and said it was delicious!! Planning to come back and try that asap. Thank you :) read more

Nauset Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

The place is good and has good ice cream expect the fact that when the ice cream was melting I had to run back in to get a spoon and cup just to stop the melting. So thanks for that read more

Nauset Ice Cream - Store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

Always great service to go along this great homemade ice cream. Ample parking. Scoop sizes always generous. The cranberry Ice cream is one of their best. read more

Generous portions and quick service despite the long lines! I tried the black raspberry chip frozen yogurt and it was good. Lots of groups stay to eat out at the tables so it can get crowded, but very low key and fun spot! Would recommend to swing by if in the mood for ice cream after perusing the iconic Nauset lighthouse! read more

Our go to ice cream when in Eastham. We are ginger ice fans and not many places offer it. The mint chip is not fluorescent green which is a plus in my book! This year the sorbet was also popular with our group. Great service as well. read more

When my family is on vacation on cape cod nauset ice cream is part of the experience. Great flavors with outstanding service from friendly people make the experience truly memorable. Most cape dining experiences leave you cringing on the value and cost. Nauset is down home old school great value ice cream. Many homemade flavors with different options for all tastes. All within the confines of your wallet. Great value for the money. Give it a try. You won't be disappointed! read more

Nauset Ice Cream - Chocolate peanut butter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

Ice cream itself is nothing to call home about, but they have a lot of flavors and are definitely not shy with their mix ins. Coffee Oreo is super packed with cookies, as are all their choc chip flavors, and the coconut almond chip is lowkey more nuts and chocolate than ice cream but I'm not complaining. The portions are large and definitely worth the price. A kiddie can have two flavors and is comparable in size to a Ben & Jerry's small? Maybe? For 2/3 the price. They also have lids for cups, which is so appreciated!! read more

Nauset Ice Cream - Kiddie (mint chip / coffee Oreo) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

4 different ice creams ordered and 5 different opinions when we were done. First thing we noticed is the line. It was an early evening on July 2nd and the line was "out the door". Of course, we had to check it out. After waiting a short time, we were able to enter and place our orders. The wait staff was very pleasant and easy going. Our choices for size were kiddie, small and regular. Like most places, the kiddie is a small, a small is a large and a regular is an xl. We all had ice cream in a cup with a spoon and went outside to enjoy it. There are 4 tables with 4-5 chairs to sit and enjoy after ordering, which was very nice! I had the coffee heath bar, which was good but not the best I have had. It is hard not to love ice cream but for some reason the taste was not overwhelming. The Peanut butter Oreo and Cookie Dough were reported to be excellent! Finally, the mint chocolate chip was not a big hit. It did not have enough chocolate chips and the color was not green (not saying it has to be green because I have seen it before) but it was not very tasty, too! I gave 4 stars for the two complaints Plenty of parking Price was fair Service was excellent with a smile Line did not take too long read more

See all

Pineapple orange ice cream was amazing! The line moves quickly and efficiently when store is crowded. It is also open later than most other ice cream shops around. I rarely eat ice cream but Nauset Ice Cream does it right! read more

Great experience ice cream was very good also the workers were pretty good at there jobs

One of my fav places on the cape for ice cream. I always go for black raspberry chip. The chips are the perfect size so you get a few in every bite. Creamy creamy ice cream. read more

Excellent homemade ice cream and great service from happy and helpful teens (where did you find them?).

Nauset Ice Cream is a creamery that opened in Eastham, Massachusetts in 1998. It was founded by Joanne Cremins. The ice cream is made fresh on a daily basis. They have over 30 different flavors to choose from on any given day. In addition to their regular selection of ice cream, Nauset Ice Cream also offers frozen drinks, ice cream sodas, frozen yogurt, sorbet and sugar free/low fat ice cream flavors. My wife, son and I visited Nauset Ice Cream last week while we were on a week-long family vacation in Cape Cod. We visited in the early evening hours for an after dinner treat. They place was hopping; a small line was out the door and there were several customers eating outside. After scanning the menu, my wife decided on a cup of Caramel Sea Salt with Heath Bar chunks. She was very happy with her decision. I ordered my favorite: Mint Chip. Although most creameries serve Mint Chip ice cream that is green, Nauset Ice Cream serves there's the traditional way: white. That's right, green mint chip ice cream is dyed that way with food coloring. For this alone, Nauset Ice Cream already earned several bonus points with me. My wife and I both agreed that they have some of the best ice cream we ever had! We'll definitely be back when we make future trips to Cape Cod. read more

See all

Really great ice cream! Locally owned. Young staff is attentive and quick. . Highly recommend.

This is our favorite Cape ice cream - highlights include: creative and delicious flavors (my favorites are cranberry and a lemon ice cream), great service, and most of all high quality ice cream. I look forward to returning every year. read more

Always a must visit for some of the best on the cape! There were some new flavors this year too!

Best ice cream down Cape. Diverse menu. Staff are helpful and pleasant, always dealing with long lines efficiently and effectively. Tastes are provided, and even with smallest cup, staff will combine 2 flavors. Store is small but L-shape of cases enables customers to see all the flavors, and there's seating for about 15-20 people right outside the shop. I always go for the chocolate and coffee flavors, and am never disappointed ... they're glorious! read more

We love great ice cream and whenever we travel we are always in search of the local stores that might make the " best" ice cream in a particular neighborhood. When we were in Cape Cod, we heard about Nauset Ice Cream and word was that their homemade ice cream was spectacular! We made a date to visit their store and sampled five different flavors . Our favorite was Ginger Ice Cream! It was indeed spectacular. We also loved their purple cow and their coffee ice cream as well as their pistachio and coffee flavors. I'm only sorry we couldn't figure out how to keep their ice cream frozen for our 7 hour ride hone! read more

Nauset Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

See all

Very friendly staff and the flavors were terrific. Complex, flavor full perfect balance of creamy and good consistency. Very nice to our kids as well. read more

I will go back and test more flavors this week, have spent a week so far on the Cape and this was the creamiest ice cream so far! And I have been testing LOL. Worth your while to checkout. Generous single and nice staff. Tables outside. Two big thumbs up! read more

Nauset Ice Cream - Reese's peanut butter cup, OMG - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

In a tired looking strip mall on the northbound side of Rt. 6, there is a wonderful little ice cream shop. Nauset Ice Cream is staffed by cheerful young workers that work hard, but do so efficiently with good cheer and smiles. The ice cream is as good as anyone could want. So good. I would NOT order anything larger than a medium. Wait until you get a look at what they serve for a small. Even the kiddy cones were generously sized. I happen to be an insatiable Maple Walnut aficionado and theirs did not disappoint. Creamy base with maple swirls and chunks of walnut. Not pieces, chunks. Tasty-Wasty! read more

Nauset Ice Cream - This pic was taken at dinner time, a good time to go. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Eastham, Massachusetts

The hot fudge is brown glue. Likely corn syrup. Why people bother to sell this garbage when they have a great product to begin with is beyond me. Also, it reeks of cheapness to not offer almonds, chopped, roasted, and salted. I would suggest 99.99% of businesses on Outer Cape Cod are in it to scrape your wallet and bitch about you on your way out. The character of those in service is pitiful. They can't even pay the locals a decent wage they have to import the help from Eastern Europe how's that for hypocrisy- one star for this place not importing their help. read more

I thought this place was overrated. I got a peach ice cream that was practically flavorless. Millions of peaches... but somehow none of them made it to my ice cream. read more

Homemade. Plenty of staff and fantastic ice cream. Coffee Heath and Coffee Oreo the best!! And dog friendly outside. Dog pup cups a dollar inside!!! read more

A-MAZING! The texture is so light and creamy, not hard packed or gummy. My husband and I had to go back a second day as it was SO good! Best Run Raisin and Pistachio flavors we've ever had. Also loved a coconut almond chip flavor. Staff was excellent! We love this place! read more

Good ice cream, and friendly service. A few tables to eat outside. Plenty of flavors to choose from.

Typical long line during the summer but the ice cream was good! I had a coffee frappe which was less thick than I had envisioned it to be but it was tasty nonetheless. I would recommend you be really clear about what toppings you want on your order if the place is busy though, my Dad ordered a fudge sundae one night when it was PACKED and he ended up getting ice cream with whipped cream on top. No fudge, no cherry, no other toppings! My dad only asked for no walnuts. read more

What a great sweet fix after a day strolling the Cape on a beautiful summer day. There's an array of flavs available and don't be afraid to ask for samples. Some unique flavs include ginger, purple cow, rum raisin, and etc., but of course they also have the standard ones like chocolate, oreo, mint, coffee and vanilla. Then toppings are also available to add. Like any ice cream shop, seating is not available indoors, but there are a few tables and chairs out front. Remember to bring cash, they don't take credit cards. read more

Some of the best ice cream you can eat. I had the mint chocolate chip, my favorite flavor. "Perfect" Smooth, creamy, no iceyness, clean finish. All signs of great ice cream. My wife had rum raisin- she enjoyed it! And the portions are very good, medium is two large scoops! We will be back very soon! Great team of servers. Likely 14% butterfat and 60% overrun. I sold ice cream for fifteen years, I know good ice cream read more

See all

What a nice find! The ice cream here is premium tasting. I'm a connoisseur of coffee ice cream, and so many places and manufacturers have been "going cheap" on coffee ice cream for years now. It's been all but impossible to find one that's truly five starts anywhere. I have only found two places that fit his description and who had what I would describe as "Excellent" five star coffee ice cream, and this place is the second one! My wife loved her almond ice cream even better than the place at home in Everett, who is also pretty good! Very good process for ordering with social distancing and required masks. The servings are very generous, pricing is fair, and everything is tasty and store is kept very clean. Nice job, folks! read more

I put together a never tried two scoop combo peppermint and ginger ice cream. It's great!

Delicious ice cream!! They had coconut fudge chip--my favorite. And such big scoops! Friendly service too.

Smooth ice cream and great flavors like Rum Raisin and Ginger. Seating outside and dog friendly. Great place to stop if your driving up the Cape. read more

They made a mistake and did ,after a complaint, acknowledge it and offer to make me whole. I'm glad because they have great ice cream and I would have missed going back read more

Delicious homemade ice cream and huge portions. Always a wonderful treat. Love Nauset!!

Walked up at 9:55 before it closed and they wouldn't let us in to buy ice cream. Rude!!! You never shut the door on a customer if you aren't closed yet! read more

A lot of flavors and toppings, close by, low wait time, good ice cream, small store so the line stretches out the doors!

Love, love, love their ice cream! More flavor and less sugar than other brands. Always greeted with a smile and helpful server! You may have to wait in line, but don't fret, it moves fast. read more

This ice cream is the best! It's so flavorful and creamy. It's jam packed full of "stuff" - nuts, chips - whatever it may be. They have plenty of flavors to choose from. I got a small because the cup looked small but it was a lot of ice cream. It's so rich that you don't need much! Had toffee chip today and it was yummy! Cash or check only! read more