Crap! Got a meatball hoagie and onion rings I asked if the meatballs were home made she said th e y were yea they were 3 of them on on 8" bun 85% breading,Disgusting!! Onion rings well they use the skin mainly what I got ! Don't know why everywhere seems to be crap anymore! Sheets hoagie better and cheaper plus add cheese . read more

New Sheffield Cafe - Meatball hoagie n onion rings 5 onion skin rings I think was $8. - American Near Me - Aliquippa, Pennsylvania

See all

My sister lives in the area and suggested we have breakfast at this newly opened restaurant. It was a great idea. They currently have three different rooms for dining, as well as an outside deck under construction. The menu has about eight different omelets, eight breakfast combos, wraps, sandwiches, pancakes and waffles. I opted for the veggie cheese omelet with hash browns and rye toast. My sister had a sausage and cheese omelet with potatoes. Both items were delicious and plentiful. Service was great from Patrice. read more

See all

Good food quality, friendly service, and comfortable seating created a pleasant visit, with minor delays being the only issues preventing an otherwise excellent and satisfying meal tonight for our group. read more

My husband and I waited 20 minutes and no one ever came to our table. Two servers looked at us, but never came over. Will not be going back. Very poor service. read more

This was so delicious and amazing. The tea was delicious as well. Highly recommend this place Had their steak salad that was awesome. read more

New Sheffield Cafe - 12 Wingers , AMAZING and crisp to perfection - American Near Me - Aliquippa, Pennsylvania

What a delicious array of food items are available in this charming bar/restaurant! I enjoyed a humongous Reuben that was scrumptious! Our wonderful waitress was personable and made sure my coffee cup was never empty. This restaurant has a pleasant atmosphere created by pleasant employees and customers. read more

I have been eating at the New Sheffield Cafe my whole entire life! It is in a new location on Brodhead Road. I probably have only gotten three or four things until my last time there...wanted to venture out. The new location has a great size bar upstairs, and one downstairs too, as well as two rooms of low tables and some high tops table in the bar area. The last time there my husband and I both got a cup of clam chowder soup that was pretty good and shared a basket of friend shrimp, fries, and cole slaw. The shrimp were great as well as their fries. We normally get the steak salad or steak bowl...both always wonderful with sweet and sour dressing...a must read more

New Sheffield Cafe - a man sitting at a table with a drink - American Near Me - Aliquippa, Pennsylvania

See all

The breakfast was delicious and hot and the service was excellent. I would definitely come back here to eat.

My boyfriend and I 10/10 recommend this place!! We got beer battered fish and hot pepper wings and they were amazing also great customer service!! read more

Food is amazing!! I worked here for just a few months and i fell in love with the staff and the people. Id recommend this place to everyone.

I really enjoyed my steak salad from New Sheffield cafe. I do wish I got a large instead of a regular, however it is nice they offer two different sized! The steak was perfectly cooked and a good variety of veggies was in the bowl. Can't wait to go back soon read more

Saw this place on DoorDash so decided to give it a try. Food came fast and for delivery it was really good. Well packaged also. Huge portions here. I got a large steak salad but should have gotten a small. Steak was great. Real pieces of steak...not nasty steakums. Cubed cheese was a nice option. Ranch tasted homemade. My son got a custom burger with fries. He said it was good. The fries are those crispy seasoned kind. Also got a buffalo chicken wrap but saving that for lunch tomorrow. It does look and smell delicious though. Will definitely order from here again to try more items. Glad I took the chance on this place. read more

New Sheffield Cafe - Steak Salad - American Near Me - Aliquippa, Pennsylvania

Ordered a chicken tender salad this evening. Very disappointed. 3 olives, 8 pieces of cheese and chicken that would feed a child.

Just had the #6 Triple. 3 eggs, hash browns or home fries, toast and meat. $11.19. It was really good. Over easy eggs cooked perfectly. I requested crispy bacon and that's what I got. Texas toast toasted perfectly. I could eat this every day if my cardiologist would let me! Lots of crispy hash browns. Very good breakfast. They were busy so my meal took a while but it was worth the wait. I eat there all the time and I've never been disappointed. read more

This place is pretty cool. Best Onion Rings I think I've ever had. Please take that Buffalo chicken dip off your menu. I'm not even sure how one makes Buffalo chicken that is both bland and bad. It's like the easiest dish to make. I was pretty sad about it. Those onion rings were fire though. Definitely get those if you come here. read more

The food is always good here. The daily specials are great and the prices are very reasonable considering the size of the portions. The wait staff are friendly and the place is clean. Great for take out or sit down. The meatloaf is excellent - it's my favorite! read more

Hello I ordered shrimp salad ($20) and received a steak salad When I called I was told by Brittany that I could bring the salad back ( this was my lunch from work) I asked for a door dash or refund and was told no they can't and won't do that. i have a picture of my receipt and the food I received. I then asked for a manager and was told Brett would not be in until this evening . Very poor customer service! I will never order from here again. I guess my money and time are not important. What happened to integrity and standing behind your service ? read more

New Sheffield Cafe - Receipt from my shrimp salad - American Near Me - Aliquippa, Pennsylvania

See all

The service is absolutely fantastic. Buckshot and the crew are the best. Highly recommend the New Sheffield Cafe

Beer Batter Fish Platter was delicious. Steve is fantastic, even remembered my cocktail and haven't had him as a server for a while. Steve always gives the best service!! read more

New location update decor same good food. I had a wrap and it was to the edge of the wrap and sampled somebody's lemon cello pancakes very light and Delish. New location. Best of luck. read more

New Sheffield Cafe - American Near Me - Aliquippa, Pennsylvania

Stopped in for breakfast today and had the most wonderful server ever. My coffee cup was never empty and her suggestion for a speciality breakfast from the chef was ou of this world. A must stoo place to eat. We will definitely be back. read more

I come here very often for the salads which are great. However I placed an order for take out on a Friday evening. Boneless Buffalo and bbq wings with ranch. I get home to open a box of wings with no sauce and SOUR CREAM. I had just worked a 12hr shift and was starving. When I called back they told me the kitchen was closed. read more

Omg there Rueben sandwiches are the best hands down. Got the banana pepper rings with it instead of fries. Omg those are really good to. Something different I've never seen anywhere. read more

Great food and Beverage. Clean. Great Staff. Wonderful Specials. Always adding something new and unique.

Worst Fettuccini Alfredo I have ever eaten! It was so bland that I actually had to add salt for some kind of flavour. The only positive was that the staff were friendly and efficient. However, if you want Italian food stick with an Italian restaurant! read more

Local bar; nothing fancy. A server came over and took our drink order then told us she didn't know if she would be our server or not. Strange way to start out. Wasn't very busy at all and they seemed to have too many employees that didn't know what to do with themselves. I had the mahi mahi which turned out to be dry & no flavor. Hubby had beef tips over noodles w/ gravy. He said it was ok. We took some home since there was quite a bit; so I ate them the next day. Personally, I thought they weren't very good. Had a Long Island Ice Tea which was the drink special - good & strong. read more

New Sheffield Cafe - Beef tips over noodles - American Near Me - Aliquippa, Pennsylvania

See all

There are signs on doors about rising food costs. We get that but please charge for real food costs! Steak sandwich added tomato which was 1 slice of tomato literally 99 cents! Lettuce addition again a few pieces again was 99 cents! Shame on you! Again extra dressing costs outrageous $1.39 for what cost you maybe 25 cents and that's generous on cost. Steak salad all iceberg lettuce! Food good but don't ask for any extras to enjoy the way you like! Don't need to so over charge for the minor extras! Just not right! read more

STEAK SALADS!!! Since the Hilltop in Rochester closed, we have been searching for a decent steak salad all over the Pittsburgh area. Found it. Awesome. The steak tips were perfectly seasoned and fork tender. The option to choose cubes of cheese instead of shredded sealed the deal. I bet there was a pound of cubed mozzarella on each salad. Real eggs, black olives and whole pepperoncini peppers put it over the top. The sweet and sour dressing wasn't homemade, but I'll take Marzettis any day. As for the rest of the menu, the steak tips over noodles looked good, but I probably won't order anything else here. read more

New Sheffield Cafe has the best steak salads I ever had in my life time. I came back home for the holidays. You already know I had to stop by and order it. The service was amazing and the place is clean. read more

See all

Linda's SERVICE was the BEST. Great tasting (very large) Vege Omelet. Hash browns too thin and greasy tasting. Biscuits & Gravy I did not like the (thin) sausage gravy‐ made with pizza sausage bits and could not taste the biscuits. Easy over eggs perfectly cooked. We WILL eat there again for breakfast but will have to try something else on the menu. Evening meals have always been great. read more

Nice place, good food, great service, but the seats in the downstairs restaurant and bar are the worst I've ever sat in. I've talk to many people about the new location and they all said the same thing about the horrible chairs. They are cheap aluminum chairs that make your butt hurt and your legs go numb after a half an hour or so, just makes you want to leave. I would rather be somewhere comfortable when hanging out with friends! read more

$19 for 6 wings and fries just to have the wings covered in chemicals from melted styrofoam. The price doesn't seem to fit the demographics but I guess it works for them. read more

New Sheffield Cafe - Wings hold the styrofoam - American Near Me - Aliquippa, Pennsylvania

Michelle was our waitress she was nice everyone enjoyed their food as for me the famous for there steak and chicken salads and the potatoes skins and the long island ice tea was slammin. My son had the shrimp basket my husband had the wings and myself I had the usual. read more

See all

Salads good (steak and chicken) but service horrible before covid and after .. They can never seem to make my wings right I have to bring them back every time.. wings (whole) that big should be left down longer I think they don't have the fryer space and get slammed with orders so my extra 10 mins is costing time and money.. they rather get the complaint than miss another order ‍ read more

Been here for brunch with a great friend a few times, rather excellent breakfast line-up . Well if you're looking for something to eat and you're out that way ; check it out ! read more

See all

Rather quaint venue . Could actually give them 5 stars as they have just kept growing and improving ( of course ) since first visited. Not a smoking joint, a shady place ( NO ! ) . Nice venue for friends hang out . Now actually not bad for a relaxed family get together . read more

The food is mediocre at best. They don't tell you but they charge way too much if you ask for an extra condiment. Not somewhere I'd return to. read more

I am very disappointed in the service of this establishment. My family and I have frequented this places numerous times as we live in the neighborhood. I think Covid has really put a strain on them. Last time we tried to dine in, myself, husband and 2 year old were thankfully told before ordering that the wait for food was over 1.5hrs because of take out orders. I am so thankful the waiter realized we had a toddler with us and was honest about the wait, we happily left. Tonight we tried to have dinner there again, I ordered a grilled cheese, my mother a salad, my husband fish nuggets and my toddler a side of Mac n cheese. It took almost 1.5 hours to get our food. After waiting an hour I asked the waitress how much longer and was told "it will be a few more minutes, we are backed up with to go orders" when the food finally arrived it was cold, it was cold and my sons side of Mac was burnt he could barely chew it. I returned my grilled cheese asking for a warm sandwich after waiting as long as I had I refused to eat a room temp grilled cheese. Which the bartender gave me attitude for mentioning, but was made another sandwich which took another 20 minutes and the rest of my party was finished with their meals. I understand the strain and stress an increase in take out orders can have, but it sure did not feel as if the dine in customers were a priority. The waitress tried to help by taking my Fountain soda off the bill, which I didn't ask for anything to be removed. So I appreciate the thought. But really ?big whoop one fountain soda isn't gonna make up for terrible service. I was never a big fan of this place prior to this, but my husband likes it so we would frequent, I can assure you now I will not be returning. Maybe a takeout order if I'm in a bind as they seem be get the better service. Very disappointed and unsatisfied customer. read more

My family and I used to love their food, especially their salads. However, when we went for take out 2 weeks ago, things were different. First off, as a tip: if you are going to sit near the bar, bring your ID. Even if you're getting pop or water, you will now be carded. I understand that they were busted for serving an underage person, but it makes it a little inconvenient if you just wanted to have a nonalcoholic beverage. Anyway, when we got the food and went home, the steak salad, which is usually amazing, was tough and had no flavor and the fries were cold. read more

Absolutely teriffic food. Best burgers around, and CHEAP too! Free popcorn while you wait, which is a nice touch. Wait staff very friendly and also with a little sharpness, perfect example of local personality..and it's brilliant! Steak salad is fresh, tasty, and huge! Wedding soup is terriffic. Chicken strips are absolutely perfect. There's a full bar. My local favorite. read more