A nice option in Ann Arbor for those who just want a slice or two versus a whole pizza. Many options to choose from, with standard styles such as pepperoni to the more unique like buffalo chicken and even French fry toppings. Their $2 Tuesdays are the best opportunity for having their food cheap. But because it's so popular, you might find yourselves waiting in a line that goes outside the building. Not just during lunch but even during dinner time. read more

I love me some NY Pizza Depot and I usually stick with a cheese slice and order on a regular basis. Yes, I've been to Joes but I feel that the flavor of the cheese is better and the price is better as well. The place is inviting and the staff is friendly but parking can be a challenge. if you're looking for a decent slice in A2 for a good price, give them a try! read more

New York Pizza Depot - cheese slice fresh out of the oven - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

Mediocre. $30 plus for four slices of mediocre pizza, a coke, and a piece of cake. The pizza was excessively greasy and tasted as if it had been sitting around for too long. The cake was delicious. Maybe would have been better fresher. Overall , it served its purpose- a quick bite to eat before heading home after a comedy show. read more

See all

Been a customer since '96. Back for a game weekend and reliving good memories, but it was short lived. I had an unpleasant encounter with one of the employees here, an older man with close-cut hair. When I went to pick up my food, he questioned whether I had ordered two slices. I told him I only had one in my hand, and my roommate clarified that the second slice was mine. Despite this, the employee refused to hand me my slice unless I admitted to ordering two. Auto D-bag alert and it got worse. When I asked him not to make things difficult and just give me my food, he escalated the situation by telling me to "step into the kitchen if I wanted a fight." He also made a racist remark, asking me, "Why can't I speak English clearly?" The cashier at the register, who was also Asian, immediately apologized for his words--which makes me think this behavior is not unusual for him. Based on how openly he acted, I suspect he might even be the owner. Either way, this kind of treatment is unacceptable and makes me feel this establishment needs to hide this dude in a dark closet or off the floor completely read more

New York Pizza Depot - The racist dude - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

See all

They started to add on additional hidden fees when paying with a credit card. I was charged $7.26 for three slices of pizza for their $2 Tuesday deal. That's a 21% upcharge. It appears they've also covered the "No Tip" option on their card reader, so you have to hit "Custom Tip" and manually enter $0. Not worth going anymore, just on principle. Edited to add response from owner: "the 21% fee is tax credit card fee box that you asked 0.50 c if you pay cash for 3 slice is $ 6.18 even $ 7.26 is a good deal for 3 slices, so you will get from us: 0 star as a costumer". Real classy joint... Maybe that's why the Brighton location closed so quickly? I've encountered the rude owner in-person before, like one of the other reviewers here (the photos of the guy with short hair). He really is a piece of work and has no business being behind the counter and interacting with patrons. Go to Joe's instead. read more

Wow I made a mistake! I only had their pizza to go and never dined in. What a world of difference! The pizza was fresh out of the oven, the crust was crispy. I loved the buffalo pizza roll with a crispy bottom. The service was great. The place is huge with chill vibes on the Sunday we went. It feels just like New York! read more

New York Pizza Depot - Buffalo Pizza roll - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

See all

They do GOOOD food here! Ordered lasagna, chicken alfredo, antipasto salad and garlic knots for a coworker to celebrate his 25th work-aversary and couldn't be happier. Took a chance as we have never ordered from here before but glad I did! DELICIOUS! read more

$2 pizza slice Tuesdays at NYPD might just be the best deal in town! The deal runs all day until 10pm and it's valid on all slices except for the deep dish. They usually have a pretty big selection to choose from but going through the line can be stressful as often times they'll be rotating through options so quickly that they might have a whole different variety when you get to the front. The line stays pretty consistent throughout the day but I've come to find that the best time is either right when they open or during late afternoon. They have a good amount of seating both inside and out. The people working are always really nice with a funny, almost NYC style attitude. It really feels like a taste (no pun intended) of home. The pizza isn't the absolute best I've ever had and Joe's is undoubtedly better in the area, but it checks a box and again, $2 slices simply cannot be beat especially considering Joe's is like $4 for a simple cheese. My favorite slices are the barbecue chicken and the pesto chicken, but again they have a ton of options. Will absolutely be back! read more

New York Pizza Depot - Greek slice and penne slice - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

See all

NYPD is our go-to pizza spot in A2. The dine in area is large enough for groups- and it's decorated like we are in NYC. We order up a freshly made pie on the spot, it is served up delicious & cooked to perfection. My favorite is the white sauce pizza, while my son opts for the yummy Chi town pizza. My man loves the pepperoni roll. We can't wait for our next slice! read more

See all

Best New York Style Slice in town. Ive been coming here for 10 years, its great stuff,

Super reliable slices place with unbelievable variety and a great vibe. Came here the night before a football game and it was packed and super fun. incredibly efficient service as well. Pizza tastes great. Open late. Seriously, how can you not like this place. read more

Love the $2 pizza Tuesdays. The variety is always great and rotating. The line is long at times but goes quick.

Working at the hospital night shift, NYPD stays open and delivers late which is nice for us night shifters! Usually get pizza or a calzone when we order. Food is average. But the cheese bread and ranch are really good!! My big complaint is that they always put multiple calzones into one box, which makes it hard to store when you order out with multiple coworkers. I have been inside NYPD and it's a small pizza shop but cute. Perfect for drunken college students late at night to come in after the bars and get pizza by the slice! read more

New York Pizza Depot - Spinach Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

New York Pizza Depot was one of the only places open late after an evening of enjoying some local watering holes, so I tried to order through their website while in town over the summer. It was not working at all, so I ended up ordering through Uber Eats to have it delivered to our hotel. The delivery time came and went so I called the restaurant and was told it would be there shortly. Nate and I hung out in the lobby so I was able to grab it from the delivery person as soon as they arrived. We ordered a 12" supreme pizza, with pepperoni, sausage, onions, mushrooms, peppers, and ham. It was not the most visually appealing pizza and seemed like it was missing a lot of sauce - plus the sausage was sliced smoked sausage, which was a little weird, and most of the peppers and onions were basically raw. Fortunately we were pretty hungry and the pizza was decent for late night, after the bar food. I don't think I'd try ordering again late on a Friday night, but I might stop in for a slice at lunch. read more

New York Pizza Depot - Supreme pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

Pretty average quality/taste but good for that late night quick bite. They offer a variety of specialty flavors, different style pizzas (classic, Chicago style, Detroit style) and other menu items. You can order whole pies or order by the slice. We tried the White Pizza and Mixed Mushroom Pizza. read more

New York Pizza Depot - White pizza andmushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

This place is awesome. When in Ann Arbor go try this place. We always stop here when in town . This is my favorite New York Style Pizza place. Value (A+) $11.50 for two big slices and an order of garlic knots. It's so good and well worth it. Not too expensive Service (A) Excellent for a campus town. They quickly reheat the slices you want and call out your order. If the slices are not ready they are super friendly and let you know how long. Remember it's a campus pizza place. Quality (A+) The slices are sooo good here. My favorite NY pizza place. They usually have a number of slices ready to go and a great selection. They have perfected the art of campus town pizza slices. The pizza is a greasy unhealthy indulgence at its finest. Now I remember why I weighed so much when living in Ann Arbor. If your in town or a local go and try this place. You won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Horrible service...left my pizza in the microwave for 20 minutes. And then they dropped my pizza on the floor and made me wait.

New York Pizza Depot was my preferred pizza-by-the-slice joint while I was an out-of-city student at UMich, and it continues to be one of my favorite spots to swing by as a townie walking around downtown. The variety (Chicago-style, Detroit-style, mac and cheese, BBQ chicken, etc) has always been fun and the pizza staples (pepperoni, veggie, etc) are very good. The late-night hours are also a plus. While I haven't checked lately, I recall them doing all-day Tuesday $2 slice deals. A steal for great pizza! read more

See all

For years I have been saying this is the best pizza in state of Michigan. However, it has been a while since I had it. Picked up a pie (1/2 cheese, 1/2 pepperoni) last night. Something has definitely changed because it was blah. Definitely undercooked, but even after heating a bit more it was no better than average. Also ridiculously priced. $30 because have to order through Slice. Which again would not have minded if it tasted like used to. Disappointing for sure. read more

New York Pizza Depot - Simple 1/2 cheese and 1/2 pepperoni. Their specialty slices are fantastic also. - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

See all

I went during lunch hours when the pizza came out fresh, it was pretty good! It's a pretty reliable pizza joint in Ann Arbor with lots of sitting room. The service is also quick. read more

New York Pizza Depot - White Pizza Caprese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

What does the school up north have what OSU doesn't have, real New York pizza served like a real NY pizzeria. As a pizza snob, I am always searching for good pizza. Although not Totonno level but still pretty good for the mid- west. read more

Beyond good. Ziti and chicken parm stuffed into homemade pizza crust. Ridiculous. Anyone who gave this less than 5 stars does not understand or appreciate New York pizza--and that's not ok. My son's deep dish chicken pizza was also a standout. Great prices. Great service. Family owned...straight from Italy to NYC to---Ann Arbor. read more

Rude beyond belief. I waited for over 20 minutes for a salad that looked like a chipmunk could put together, it was simply pathetic. Btw the "making" of the salad consisted of a styrofoam box with dirty lettuce and a little itty bitty PATHETIC sauce packet. It was also $9 and omg I could make for under $5. The man behind counter couldn't make eye contact nor could he even give me one second of his time. When I finally was able to get his attention and ask for a refund, he dismissed me and was very rude. All this for a salad that looked like my 5 year old cousin could make. read more

Whats crazy is this pizza place should be the best rated in all of the A2 area, but they're all over the map the last number of years in every category: Friendliness, selection available ability to do heat up the Chicago style pizza all the way thru even when asked to make sure Actually pretty simple when you think about it bcs they already conquered the hardest part- amazing pizza, both NY thin crust style as well as Chicago deep dish. C'mon NYPD - you can do this! read more

Do you know how you can tell if a New York style slice shop is truly great? Order the cheese slice and don't put anything on it. No shaky cheese, no garlic powder, no dried herbs, no pepper flakes. Just taste the basics. On their own. Unembellished. In doing so, there is no place for imperfections to hide. Bland crust? Flavorless cheese? Meek sauce? They will stand out like a sore thumb. Typically, I wouldn't advise doing this in Ann Arbor. We're far enough away from New York, that it's unreasonable to expect a close facsimile of the style. Pizza here is typically thicker, cheesier, and embellished with more toppings. But since I've never been to NYPD before, I wanted to see how it stacked up to the new shop in town that just opened its first location outside NYC. As expected, the cheese slice was uninspiring. The flavors in the dough were underdeveloped, and the dough itself was undercooked, producing a gum line between the bottom crust and the layer of sauce. There was too much sauce and too much cheese. Plus parts of the bottom crust were woefully undercooked, despite going in the oven for a reheat. On the up side, NYPD does have a grandma pie, which looks tastier. Since it has the sauce on top, it shouldn't suffer from the gumminess problem. And the sauce has a little bit more love put into it. Plus this pizzeria has beer on tap. So I'm looking forward to return for a grandma slice with a pint, and hoping to produce a tastier outcome. Also, kudos for the integrity of reheating all the slices to crisp up their bottoms. Despite its flaws, the cheese slice did have a crisp undercarriage. It's also worth noting that most people seem to come to NYPD for their more topping heavy slices, which are surely tastier than the one I tried. But I was playing strict rules New York style pizza slice evaluations. Rules are rules. Still, I'm cautiously optimistic that on a return trip, NYPD will earn that fourth star. read more

New York Pizza Depot - One cheese slice. - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

See all

Came in with the husband after a date at the spa, wanted to grab some quick pizza to take home to eat with a new movie, the staff was arguing and the manager was shouting across the store hostilely, was just really rude. I've been coming here for 20 years, since before they moved. My husband and have both lived in NY, my husband is from the Bronx, and though the food is good - the service is seriously lacking. Every new patron that came in was shouted at. Update: we were charged $46 for a two topping 18", a slice of German chocolate cake and 5 garlic knots. Upon seeing an actual menu I see we were overcharged 16$ What the fuck. read more

New York Pizza Depot - Manager is moooooooooooody - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

My favorite oizza place is one the downslope. Can someone please save it !? Went with a friend only to find a paltry Selection at dinner time. I mean like 4-5 pizzas I don't like much and only one deep dish. read more

I don't care what anyone else says. I love going here grabbing a slice and a drink. Eating it there. Leaving and feeling satisfied yet not weighted down. The owner is a nice guy. It's a good place. This and Joe's should be on your list. Sometimes I'm in the mood for crispy crust (NYPD) or chewy Neapolitan style Joe's. read more

Amazing pizza, with some qualifications. Delivery can be spotty. Once received a cold pizza 2 hours later that had flipped over. Also service can occasionally be staggeringly rude - like when I tried to help the cashier ring up Tommy York and was rewarded by the owner taking out whatever was bothering him that day on me. They're open late which is great - though it can mean putting up with a bunch of drunk students who just left Scorekeepers after the bar closes at 2AM. For picking up a couple of slices during the day it's great. Lots of delicious options. And the service is usually great. Just don't be shocked if you get your head bitten off before you bite into you pizza. If you frequent this place it will probably happen. TLDR - great slices during the day. Maybe steer clear of delivery and late night stops. read more

Chicago Slices $4.25 look great but the bite's soft and dough tough, not your Pizza Uno or Gino East's buttery crisp crumbly crust. Pie lacked sauce, and the spicy chicken was a Bell pepper overload with little chicken, though the spinach and cheese filling was tasty. Deschutes IPA on tap, a/c, booth, it was time to energize the legs for more fair action. Plastic forks and cups, paper plate service, filler and rest, just Alright. read more

New York Pizza Depot - Spicy Chicken Chicago style $4.25 - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

The pizza is really good and so is the sauce. They don't go too heavy on the sauce either and it's NOT a greasy pizza. Which is so refreshing cuz it's light on your stomach! The bottom of the box wasn't greasy at all after drive home with it either. They're open everyday and they're open really late which is convenient. The cheese is great and it's just a good spot. The only reason for 4 and not 5 stars is that it's pretty expensive. read more

New York Pizza Depot - 14" medium cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

I ordered late late night leaving a 7v7 tournament last weekend in Ann Arbor Michigan . The pizza was good

Got NYPD delivery during my recent return visit to Ann Arbor. As far as I'm considered they have the best pizza in town. The pizza and garlic knots are still really good. If you're in a hotel and don't have a lot of storage or whatever consider the personal pizza and garlic knots combo as it'll fill you up but won't saddle you with a bunch of leftovers. read more

This spot is pretty much a staple here. Cheap New York style slices and open hella late. I always think this spot every time were in Ann Arbor for drinks and bar hopping. I had the Tomato and Feta slice, my hubby did the pepperoni slice and Ricotta white slice. We both totally smashed our slices. Wutcha expect when your coming from a wedding with an open bar. After drinking food is always necessary. The place is what it is. No frills, bunch of booth seating, cafeteria style ordering and self serve soda fountain. You come, you pick out what your want, you pay, eat and dip. It's that simple. I always leave pretty satisfied. Thank you so much for reading my review. I hope this helps with your decision making experience. Enjoy your awesome yelptastic day! read more

See all

NYPD is an average pizza spot. They offer unique pizza creations and flavors which stand out. This is one of the few real late night food spots in Ann Arbor which makes it convenient. I thought the chicken bacon ranch pizza was okay but not my favorite and definitely not traditional New York Style but the crust was tasty and well seasoned. I also thought the Alfredo pasta was pretty good but the garlic knots were not my favorite. I do not recommend the cinnamon knots. Eating the cinnamon knots was a challenge in itself and felt as if my friends and I were partaking in the cinnamon challenge as there was so much cinnamon on the knots and it was just a vessel for eating a spoonful of cinnamon. read more

New York Pizza Depot - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan

See all

White sauce pizza is amazing! Affordable and convenient for in the run, do recommend White sauce pizza is amazing! Affordable and convenient for in the run, do recommend read more

We got to try four different slices of pizza from nypd_ann_arbor.We have the white pizza, plain cheese, the mixed mushroom white pizza, or the sundried feta white cheese pizza. I've always been a fan of white pizza, so that's a win for me. Would've liked to try the deep dish but the veggie deep dish wasn't available so I'll have to check back again. But super good pizza if you're ever in the Ann Arbor area. read more

See all

Something quick? Pizza by the slice is probably the best bet here. It's going to be a gamble on the available ready selection but if you have 15-20 mins you can grab a hot pizza or calzone. Ended up here because of its proximity to my hotel. Wanted to grab something for an evening snack but didn't want a sit down experience. Ordered a calzone which was cheesy, hot and dusted with garlic seasoning. read more

Not bad, it's just the definition of eating food when your really hungry. It's not top tier food but it's like decent food. It's solid.

The pizza itself was pretty tasty, although it was cold. Customer service, however, was terrible. When I arrived to pick up our order, I asked to please see the pricing detail since it seemed we were being charged more than the prices listed on their website. The person at the register was very rude, told me the prices online would be different than if I called in the order, and told me to take it up with the owner. When I reviewed the receipt, not only were the prices higher than the website, but we were charged more for toppings on the right half of the pizza than the same topping on the left?!? I followed up with an email, to which I received no response. We will not be planning to return. read more

New York Pizza Depot - Website listed $1.00 per topping - Pizza Near Me - Ann Arbor, Michigan