Yes Yes Yes, we love and can't say enough good things about this place. If you haven't taken the…read moreshort drive out to Cato and had this Pizza well you're definitely missing out. The first time I stopped here was on a Fluke, I was looking for a quick bite while working and all it took Was one time and I was hooked. I've gone several times now and I've never been disappointed,We've tried Cheese, pepperoni, chicken wing and Garlic pizza and all have been great. We've also had their wings they make them fresh and crispy. Large pepperoni and 20 wings $32.00 I've had the same in Mattydale for close to $47.00... Staff is super friendly, Food is great and the price are very fair. Take the drive you won't be disappointed...

I decided on a small cheese pizza and chargrilled wings with their "Jenny" sauce on the side. The…read morepizza was very good, there was a good amount of cheese and the sauce was tasty. I don't care for a thick crust (and this wasn't thick at all), but it was so thin that I actually wished it had a little more dough. It was very nicely cooked and I did enjoy it. The wings were chargrilled perfectly, and were very juicy inside. The Jenny sauce was okay, I found it was a bit lacking in flavor, for my taste. I'd definitely get the wings again and try a different sauce. It was very busy and the service was great. I'm looking forward to my next visit and trying one of their specialty pizzas!

Needed a quick slice so stopped here. Inside of this place isn't very appealing. The pizza though…read moreis really good. The plain cheese was great. No flop and cooked to perfection. Nice sauce and cheese ratio. The Sicilian was average but not bad. It looks burnt in the picture but I like it that way. They had tons of flavors of pizza ready for their lunch rush. If you are in the area, try this place.

The pizza showed up looking like it needed another ten minutes in the oven and a rescue team…read more Undercooked dough, undercooked toppings, and enough piled on to sink a canoe. I literally had to scrape it out of the box, put it on my pizza stone, and finish cooking it myself -- as I live 40 minutes away. When I reached out, the owner admitted the regular cook wasn't there. Instead of stepping in or making it right, he offered to remake it with the same cook and tossed out a 10% off next time like that would fix anything. In the end, it was a $56 dinner I had to throw out, and the lack of customer care was louder than anything else. Their actions make it obvious they care more about their own convenience than their customers. The response on their Facebook confirms their lack of professionalism and customer service. Follow up: the missing four slices the owner is referring to are on the pan I used to cook the pizza. Which ended in up in the garbage as the cheese didn't melt.

We had a very delicious Italian Wedding Soup. It was a…read morecrowd favorite. Coffee. Grilled Cheese with lettuce and tomato. Side of chips. meatloaf and mashed potatoes with gravy

Great restaurant Good food. Wide selection…read more We are fortunate that it is here in Elbridge .

Got there and were told it was a 30-40 minute wait. After exactly 30 minutes our table was ready…read more The place is not too dimly lit -it's just perfect for a romantic dinner. Our waitress was okay. Now the dinner. We ordered the beet salad which is one of our favorites. It did not disappoint -note that it's seasonal though. For the entrees, we got the chicken parmigiana pasta and the shrimp bolognese pasta. I was debating between that and the shrimp fra diavolo but the latter was out so my choice was decided XD . Our meal, overall, was delicious! For those interested, they have a special three course menu until the 14th of March, 2026, and it is 25$ per person.

Ordered the Apizza pizza, meatball appetizer and broccoli pizza. Don't get the pizza with broccoli…read moreit was bitter. The apizza was very good 7/10 one bite everybody knows the rules. The meatballs were ok. They seemed a little burnt and had hard crust on it. Don't get it can't say I didn't warn you.

Was driving through town recently and wanted a quick late afternoon snack…read more This place was exactly what I hoped it would be. The guy working the counter was friendly and welcoming. He still had a few slices left from lunch, so I grabbed one of those. It was excellent New York style thin crust. Perfect for an afternoon snack. Bathroom was clean, parking was easy, food was good, and the pizza chef was a cool dude. There's a few booths for seating indoors and, at least in the summer, two tables outside. I'll gladly stop here next time I'm in town and need a bite.

Great pizza , their "weird" sauce is really good. Always positive and friendly, definitely…read morerecommend trying a slice

Yummy food, great service. The garlic cheese pizza is soo good and the wings are always excellent…read more If you don't love fried food, you'll absolutely love the ice cream options!

Great little mom & pop eatery in Red Creek, NY. They have ice cream in the summer and pizza/food…read moremenu year round. I was pleasantly surprised by how good the food was on my first visit. So good, we went back the next night too. Fried zucchini was good, wings was good and my bf loved the Chicken cordon bleu. Check them out!

First time coming in & had a good experience. Place was clean & staff was welcoming. Place was a…read morelittle quiet, could've used some music or sports in the background. Beers were good but nothing out of this world special. Food was the same, only two options pizza and pretzel. Food was delivered hot and fast, again service was good. Overall good experience but expected a little better from a brewery.

I have driven by this place hundreds of times and made it a point to come tonight. Soooo glad I…read moredid! What a gem! This is a local craft brewery that offers a few food items and has local musicians play a couple times a week. Both indoor and outdoor seating and even a playground for the kiddos if you have them along with you. My boyfriend tried a flight of 6 different beers and enjoyed them all. Went back though and got their Blood Orange kolsch which is one we've tried before and is amazing. A LOT of orange flavor. They also make their own wood fired pizzas. We ordered a pepperoni pizza. My boyfriend also ordered the Bavarian Beast Soft Pretzel with what looked like a stone ground mustard. Super soft and huge!! Three of us were eating in it and we are still bringing some of that home! They also offered a salad. Honestly, that was AMAZING. It's made with butter and oak leaf lettuce, broccoli micro greens, grape tomatoes, sliced mushrooms, pepper dews, provolone and Parmesan cheese with their house Italian dressing on the side. Soooo good! They also had cheese curds, kettle corn, a variety of munchies and they offered canned craft ciders, spritzers, etc... They had a big crowd here tonight for the music. A local duo who was playing all 90's music. They were very good. Overall a great first experience! I am looking forward to coming again and I haven't even left yet!!

People working are sketchy the food is terrible the place is sketchy. Ordered shrimp basket and got…read morelike 3 shrimp

Great stop, good pizza AND ice creme! 10 miles from home, stop every time we go through Port Byron…read moreNy

Great prices, great service, & great food were all available at this adorable water-side dining…read more The pizza was good but the salad was amazing. The staff knew we had tickets to the boat on the lake and made sure we were done on time. They also told us we could take our leftovers onto the boat (which was true!) so we didn't have to rush.

This was our first time at Gilda's and we agreed we would return. I got there early to snag a…read moretable, they only take reservations for five or more. I got a table quickly without any waiting, which was surprising with how busy the town was. The place was cozy it's not huge inside but they did have a few seating outside which was nice for a hot day like today. We all ordered sangrias, they were great(no spirits here). We all shared small plates and ordered our own pizzas. The fries and calamari were seasoned and cooked perfectly. I loved the different sauces that came with them. I would get these again. My friends enjoyed the gnocchi, it took awhile for it to come out(waitress said they were training), we were not in any rush it was our girls night. They enjoyed it. Two of us ordered Sam's Favorite and one Blueberry. My friend split a slice of her sister's blueberry pizza with me, it was different but not in a bad way. We thought it was good. The different flavors complement each other. I enjoyed the Sam's Favorite, loved the kick of heat from the fresno peppers. We were full but made a little room for dessert lol, all three order the pot de crème. I will never turn down chocolate lol, it was delicious. Overall the food was good and friendly service, I can see this as date night spot for my husband and I. I enjoy a place like this because the menu is not overwhelming.