Very well made pizza that tastes just like something you would get in New York! I would recommend just a plain cheese pizza. It really doesn't need anything else! read more

Good place with good food. I wouldn't say the flavor is exactly what pizza tastes like in NY (needs more sauce and the crust felt too thin and didn't taste the same but it's probably the difference in water used) but it's probably the best pizza I've had in all of Memphis and the surrounding areas. My husband and I grabbed a couple of plain slices, a buffalo chicken slice (the buffalo sauce was too runny but not bad taste wise) and some knots for the toad and were overall happy with the quality and service. This place has a couple of tables to sit down and eat at just like at a typical NY pizza joint. Next time, I'll be trying the chicken roll and seeing if it's similar to the ones in Brooklyn. If you're looking for a traditional NY type place, this will be your best bet but the taste of the crust is completely different than back home, just keep that in mind. Still good though. read more

New York Style Pizzeria - Plain sliced and buffalo chicken slice in the back. - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

See all

Highly recommend. Flavor was all there. Chewy, crisp crust. Well cooked...and BONUS it reheats excellently especially if you have a stone/steel. Tried the garlic knots cause they looked good, but wasn't an OMG got to have again. The restaurant is a standard pizza place. Limited tables and mostly quiet. They took our order and gave us exactly what we asked for. This will be one of my go-tos going forward. I'd take it over local Germantown places like Little Italy, Rock N Dough read more

New York Style Pizzeria - Large Pepperoni to-go - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

The calzone or supreme roll was amazing. The pizza looked like Milanos which I really love but I was turned off by the sliced pizza just sitting out on the counter with no protection from flies or temperature. All food has to be within certain temperature ranges at all times and you cannot simply cook something and leave it on the counter waiting to sell it. Anyway that's my opinion. Milanos does have a refrigerated display case to sell their slices out of. I didn't want a whole pizza, and for these reasons I decided on the calzone. They did make it fresh and it was good. The meat toppings were just the standard pre cooked stuff bought from whatever vendor they are using. All in all it tased perfect and it was hot and steaming. I loved it. read more

New York Style Pizzeria - Supreme roll. Excellent - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

The pizza is so delicious! Pizzas were Piping hot and full of flavor! We will definitely return! Salads were cold and crisp! read more

New York Style Pizzeria - Large cheese! Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

See all

Awesome pizza!! Great sauce- perfect crust- this pizza is 10 out of 10. Will be ordering again.

We were pleasantly surprised by this small pizza place easily overlooked. Their sauce is not sweet, not too rich, not too chunky, but just right. Their crust is not too thick, nor too thin, but again, just right. And their gluten free crust option was great for a family member. A definite place to go to. Don't take a large crowd though...only some small tables in a slim atmosphere. The service...it may have been a difficult day for the gentleman who served us a few times, since we ate in. We all have hard, miserable days...take out solves that! read more

We just went in to pick up a cheese pizza! Simple and delicious! Excellent dough! Real stretchy cheese! Kind employees! Simple, clean, quiet environment. Just right! Do note that some items are not available after 4 on the weekend! The note is on the menu! read more

See all

Definitely found a new favorite pizza place. Everything about their pizzas is great. The size, the toppings, the crust, ALL OF IT!! I ordered 2 large pizzas, one supreme and one chicken bacon ranch not realizing the large wasn't the normal large you get from all other pizza places. When my daughter walked in with the boxes I realized then we should have gotten medium at best. Only order the large if you are feeding a team of kids seriously, best pizza anywhere near the area hands down. read more

Pizza is good. We have ordered a few different kinds and haven't been disappointed. Service was good and wait time wasn't bad.

I came here after a long day of driving and was starving so me and my family decided to go here. The inside was nice and there was a lot of New York looking pictures and the people were nice and made my food fast , we ordered 3 large pizzas and ate all them, yummy yum yum read more

Normally I am extremely impressed with the pizza here. But this time I got a takeout pepperoni pizza and it did not live up to the expectations I have of this restaurant. I live 5 minutes away so it isn't like this pizza is hours old, this is nowhere near what this restaurant usually provides. read more

New York Style Pizzeria - Floppy pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

Good pizza and salads. Family owned and operated and proud of their restaurant. Glad they are here!! read more

Love love love this place and everyone there!!! Love the pizza, knots, garlic bread with cheese and lunch special!!!!

We stopped in New York Style Pizzeria for dinner and got the pepperoni pizza. Pizza was great, and we're excited to try something different next time we go! read more

New York Style Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

The food was amazing. I got a calzone, and it was perfect. My wife and son got a Hawaiian pizza, and it is also amazing. The ambiance is as typical, hole-in-the-wall NY Pizzeria: small and homey. 6 tables total. Most people seem to order take-out, so seating was easily available. read more

The pizza is classic and delicious. It has the perfect type of cheese that brings a savory taste to the dough which leans more toward a yeast like flavor. The cheese to sauce ratio is exactly what I want and the crust has that delicious garlic butter finish. I also think the price point os more that fair! read more

NY Pizza snob here. This pizza is absolutely delicious. The crust is a perfect combination. Of crunchy and chewy.

Closest thing to NY pizza. Owner from Long Island like us so he knows the deal. Had the meatball,onion,and banana pepper pizza and it was on point. Chatted with the owner afterwards and enjoyed the conversation. read more

Not a bad pizza place if you have a burning desire for New York style pies. My wife from Queens, NYC was pleased with the quality and thought it was pretty close to her hometown flavor. I'd recommend checking it out if you wanted NYC style pizza. The only downside was the price. The cost was a little steep just for pizza, but you'll get pretty big pies overall. We'll keep this place on our list especially when we want a familiar taste from the Big Apple. read more

New York Style Pizzeria - Medium Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

See all

I mean, this pizza wasn't bad. I don't know that I would say it's amazing either. It was what you may get if you go to any run of the mill ny style pizza place. The employees weren't the warmest folks. However a young lady came in as I was leaving that looked like she worked there and was super nice. If you want a pizza that isn't your normal boring chain pizza place, this isn't your worst option. I would suggest giving it a try. read more

Pizza pizza pizza - so good! I really felt this small place made it with care and love! I had doubts too- but place smelled clean... I saw the owner/pizza chef wash his hands frequently- made me feel safe!!! Also oregano on the table!! A good sign. Pizza was good! Well balanced, cooked through, dry toppings, good dough, nice sauce! Exceeded expectations! read more

New York Style Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

See all

My review is strictly experience and not on the food (because I didn't get any). On a craving for pizza I always drive by this spot and decided last night to stop in. Plenty of staff who were super nice but when it came time to order they had no pie!! I asked how long it would take to get a few slices of cheese and they told me they would have to make a new pie which would be about 20-30 minutes. With my stomach rumbling and my two kids I knew we couldn't wait that long and simple declined and left. One of the great reasons I love New York style shops is because you can pop in and three minutes later you got a slice (pizza on demand basically) and last night I was disappointed. I will at some point have to stop in and give it a try but it took six months of me driving by to stop once it might be another six months. read more

Finally , a good pizza joint in Memphis! We got the Italian Eggplant pizza. It had thin, crispy slices of eggplant parm, dollops of ricotta and mozzarella. Delicious! The crust is thin and light and did not overwhelm the flavors. Normally, I don't care for ricotta on pizza but, it paired so well with the crispy eggplant! I now consider this pie a favorite! We ordered a medium and it was huge! Also, we ordered a calzone with sausage, peppers, onions and mushrooms. It too was delicious! The fillings were very fresh and light. The outside had the perfect amount of char. Their marinara is light and fresh. The calzone also had ricotta which, was nice but; next time I would order it without. The owner was friendly and very efficient. We can't wait to go back and try their pastas and Chicken Marsala. read more

This place has the BEST New York style pizza I have ever had outside of New York. The owner moved down from there several years ago and brought the secrets of excellent pizza with him. My family gets a large cheese and calzones to split at least once a week. So tasty, filling, and works just as well leftover! If you're in the Memphis area, you HAVE to try this pizza. read more

New York Style Pizzeria - Cheese pizza pie - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

Best pizza in the area! The owners are so kind and have great customer service!! We love New York Style Pizzeria!!

Great pizza! Seems to be a lot of loyal customers. The staff knew the customers and were friendly!

Food is excellent. Great pizza's but they also have great entrees. Chicken and Vegetables are a delicious option. Owner work as a teenager on Long Island at an Italian restaurant. read more

This is legit New York pizza. I'm from NJ, and moved to Los Angeles where you can't find a decent NY slice literally anywhere in Southern California (I've been looking for years to no avail). I visited Memphis for Thanksgiving, and found this hidden gem on yelp. When I looked at the photos I could tell right away by the pizza and interior of the restaurant that it was from the northeast. I tasted the pizza, and lo and behold it was genuine NY style pizza. In fact, this was the best pizza I had since eating at Joe's pizza in NYC last year (this is not an understatement). If you're looking for New York flavor and style, then look no further. This restaurant is authentic. read more

Delicious, authentic, and a real gem. The place may not be fancy, but the food is great. Salad are big, pizza is made with care and love. Stromboli and pepperoni rolls are superb. We feel like we are back in the NorthEast. But with Southern hospitality. read more

Best pizza in Collierville!! The crust is what makes the pizza so good. I'm a pepperoni man so that's what I usually get. Looking forward to trying some of the other dinners. read more

Great place. Great pizza. They have a lunch special. Huge pieces of pizza. Ask them to make it well done. Great taste. Very similar to actual NY pizza. Will definitely be back. read more

Pizza was delicious on a gluten-free crust. Calzone was tasty as well! Staff was really nice and helpful! Very clean establishment. Toppings generous as well. Highly recommended! read more

Small family owned business. Great food at a reasonable price. Have to admit, we like the pizza so much that's all we have tried.

This is not NY style pizza. Soggy crust, bland toppings, mediocre product at best..... this is more akin to sabore's mall pizza.

The name says it all, it is New York Pizza for sure. The pizza was thin with just the right proportions of cheese, sauce, and dough. We had half cheese and half pepperoni. I love to add a lot of Parmesan but I tried with and without. The ingredients were top quality and resulted in the perfect pizza texture and flavor. The Parmesan seemed higher quality than most other places although I won't claim to be an expert Parmesan taster. I prefer chewy crust so the crust was a bit too crunchy for my taste but it was spot on identical to several places in Manhattan. I won't deduct points for my personal preference. Of course the pizza gave a NY style flop if you didn't fold it but who doesn't fold their NY style pizza? I am pretty sure folding is in the rule book. One last comment, someone gave this place 1 star after ordering pasta. It's a free country but I wouldn't got into a French restaurant and order a hamburger. It's a pizza place. Mr. 1 star, you should go back and try the pizza and give these folks have a proper rating. It's a pizza place. As for getting your order wrong, that can happen also, you need to cut the ma and pa joints a bit of slack, it's a tough business. That would be a 1 star deduction at most where I yelp from. Untangle your panties. read more

Wow, really amazing pizza, you definitely need to try the cheese pizza "AMAZING" I'm definitely returning. The owner has been Making pizza's for 28 years in New York so it's definitely the real deal read more

See all

I got a cheese pizza with some alfredo and marina dipping sauce. The pizza was AMAZING! So were both of the sauces. (The alfredo was amazing as well) I will be back! read more

New York Style Pizzeria - Cheese pizza with marina and alfredo dipping sauce - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee

Great Pizza , and food ! Employees fantastic! They need to deliver to Germantown! Please ! Thanks for Listening. Sincerely, Paula Bucy

I have been here twice now and the pizza is amazing. If you live in/near memphis and want true New York style pizza, this place is a must. The Greek salad is awesome as well, and the owner and staff are very friendly. FYI-portions are huge, a small pizza has 8 slices read more

New York Style Pizzeria - Small Mushroom Pizza (8 slices) - Pizza Near Me - Collierville, Tennessee