Oh my god. What can I saw. I had breakfast from here. I had the Ackee and saltfish. Whoever the hell is the cook, they made this food with love. The saltfish was really clean, and the boiled banana, yam and dumpling was cooked cooked to perfection with the right amount of seasoning. I also had the porridge. Someone put their foot in it. Smooth texture with absolutely no lumps. Another dish made with love from the heart. I hope that same love is the same love they cook lunch and dinner with because I'll definitely be back! read more

Nicky's Jamaican Cuisine - Ackee and Saltfish - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Not sure why I gave them 3 stars 2 years go. I have never set foot in the place, merely order Oxtail from them through uber eats. One of my homies put me on to their oxtail dinner. Somebody in that kitchen knows how to prepare and cook some oxtail. They simply fall off the bone, like you can suck with no teeth. I will be posting a pic next time. The 4 stars is simple because of the oxtail dinner. read more

On Sunday November 2nd, 2025 was the best tasting oxtail from Nicky's restaurant since her father left. It was so soft and tender, the meat was falling off the bone. Not to mention the aromatic flavors and the right amount of spices used to enhance the meal. Everton i hope you are well compensated especially after this one! Should taste like this all the time read more

This is my 3rd time going to this restaurant. Today I ordered the stew chicken which was very well seasoned and delicious. I love the fact they have Gungo rice and peas, like my family makes. Many Jamaica restaurants have a well-deserved reputation of "poor customer service". I was very happy to say not this one. The two previous times I've been there, the staff was courteous, very knowledgeable, and attentive. Today was different. I felt rushed, no may I help you, she was short with me, kind of rude, and I felt as if I was intruding on her time. After I ordered, I noticed she was on her personal phone talking. Nothing wrong with passing the time away, catching up with phone calls. However, the customers should never feel like they're bothering you. I support young black youths earning a living, she just needs someone to speak with her about being on the phone. Her name was on my receipt. However, I'm not gonna put her name out on this forum. If the manager is reading this, She was the cashier working 9/12/20. At 6:30. My receipt number was 115. read more

Nicky's Jamaican Cuisine - Stewed Chicken with gungo Rice and Peas - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've lived in this area for years. I loved the curry goat. I went in this store to order food. The young lady in the store was assisting someone else. I waited, then she proceeded to answer the phone. One I work in the hospitality field, you place the person on hold & take care of the person in front of you. I asked if they had fish she said no. So now I'm frustrated I see the people in the back I yell exacuse me excuse me can come take my order or you don't want a customer. A guy comes & tells me don't worry about her, what do I want...She rung me up. But let me you guys something when people don't want to serve you leave. My food ended up being nasty the meat was slimy & yeah it wasn't worth the $13 for a small. Curry Goat!! read more

Nicky's Jamaican Cuisine - Curry goat looks yummy but it ain't. - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I did good with my ubereats order today. After disappointing oxtail orders in recent weeks, I decided to change restaurants. The rice was nice, fluffy, and NOT dry, making it ok without drowning it in gravy (although, I'm never against extra gravy, and you shouldn't be!). There was salad and plantain, and all in nice portions. I would definitely order again. Maybe not be lazy and actually go over there myself. I approve. Side note: sorry about my photo. I had already ripped into it, but it was that good. read more

Nicky's Jamaican Cuisine - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ordered oxtail meal with white rice. Meal came with plantains and vegetables. Oxtails were delicious. Tender and flavorful just like I like it. Tasted like some home cooked Jamaican food. Customer service could use some help but the food tasted so good I sort of forgave the lack of customer interaction. 4 stars would be 5 once the customer service gets better here. read more

Great food and a great variety of dishes. The oxtail is awesome succulent and tasty. The curry goat and jerk chicken are spicy and leaves me wanting more. My mouth's watering as I write. Food highly recommended read more

I've been a customer of Nicky Jamaican restaurant for over 5 years but got the last couple of months they have been messing up with food that they serve to send in Uber eats .for the last 5 orders placed it's been burnt dried out fried chicken or other stale and not edible foods.i kept tell myself that it was the last time but still kept order.made a recent purchase only for them to collect the money and not send the items on top of that spoke to a male there don't know it's it's the boss or manager he was very rude in say saying that I might got the order n was lying.please be aware when purchasing food from them because they have made it an habit to sell stale food read more

Unfortunately, the customer service here is one the worst experiences I've had. I ordered through a food app and saw a high rating so thought this should go smoothly. I was sadly mistaken. I had a group order and a whole person's order was not delivered. I did my part and called the delivery man right away and he said that's what they gave him then I tried to call the Restuarant but of course their phone is disconnected. So I told the food delivery company and they refunded my money but it's the food I needed at that instant. Then this is where I lost it...the employee from the establishment calls me to tell me the Uber delivery driver has it and was supposed to come back and get it. That is not a customer issue nor my problem and out of my control. I reordered the food because the group was looking forward to eating what they ordered and the audacity of this female employee to call me "the customer" to tell me it's not their problem. Nor did she apologize. Gross. I will let friends know inot to order or go here. It's a false rating. read more

One of my favorites. The menu can vary depending on availability of ingredients. Their business is mostly take-out, but they have some tables and we eat in and take out. My Jamaican friends say the food reminds them of back home. Run by nice people well like by the community. Some dishes can be spicy, some are mild, as is typical of Jamaican cuisine, but something for everybody. Highly recommended, ooh oxtail, chicken, goat,ackees, and porridge. read more

See all

I was on my way home and the smell alone from across the street brought me in. I ordered the goat and oxtail stew. Tastes fresh, flavorful and authentic. Very friendly, kind staff. read more

Nicky's Jamaican Cuisine - Goat stew and Rice and Peas - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

It's expensive and can't feed you full. Not even asking me what sauce do I like The waitress was watching the TV all the way Won't be here again read more

I read some of the review to do restaurant. Someone said, "this restaurant by far is the BEST Jamaican restaurant in Canarsie... period" ! LIES! That person must of work for that establishment. Or maybe had the BEST Green stuff ever before going there... (If you know what I mean) LoL I came there with a cousin mate from, yard. ( Jamaican ) The customer service there. Was hella rude and poor customer service all in all. That we stand there and look at her and then we walked right out door. SmH Don't get me wrong the food is good. But, it don't match the service. That I may paid a dish for. I would rather go somewhere else. They should be careful who they do that too. They don't know who can give them a bad rating or worst. Bad attitude or bad service at a restaurant , give bad taste in my mouth. I would rather go to, Haitian restaurant. Then to go there again. SmH LoL read more

The liver and banana is excellent! The woman who is always at the front is the best. She is very professional and friendly.

Don't let these other reviews steer you away, I travel 19 miles to get this food. This food is never hit or miss it's ALWAYS a hit. It taste like authentic Jamaican food and it always taste the same. Every time I go the staff is nice to me and I've been a customer since 2011. So don't cheat yourself treat yourself to some good food. Sorry I didn't post a picture but the food is always gone shortly after I get home lol. read more

This was one of my favorite restaurants for Carribean food, especially Jerk Chicken, their taste is above the rest. What has completely turned me off from ever going back to their establishment is customer service. It was never great to begin with, but these last couple of times the young lady behind the counter was just plain rude and treats customers like they are begging for the food they are paying for. There is no eye contact when you're ordering, if you have a question or are unsure of your order then they make eye contact but with disgust and impatience. This reflects horribly on management or the owner I would imagine. If this is something that you can handle and are okay with than you will get a good plate of food, but me personally I pass. I don't want to feel like I'm begging or inconveniencing a business by placing an order. read more

I've been meaning to do a review on this restaurant for months now. I must admit that sometimes my view of this restaurant changes BUT I WILL SAY THIS!!!!! This restaurant by FAR is the BEST Jamaican restaurant in Canarsie... period. This is based on flavor, food consistency, and freshness. I've literally been going to this restaurant since I was in high school and they've always had the best food. Anytime I want Jamaican food this restaurant will ALWAYS be my first choice. Anything after that, is a second resort if nicki's is closed. I have ordered in person and through UberEats, the food is always good! My favorite dishes are the stew chicken and stew fish. For breakfast they have great cornmeal porridge and ackee and salt fish. If you order any of those you'll be good! Before I go, I must address the customer service. To me it's not that bad ... lol. Idk if I'm impartial because I love the food so much. Or maybe because I'm accustomed to it when ordering from a Jamaican restaurant ( I'm full blood Jamaican myself). But to me, they kind of remind me of my aunts lol. They may come off a little cold, but if you go in knowing what you want, say good evening or good morning, and stay off of your phone when you order you'll be good. Lol enjoy! read more

See all

Ackee snd salt fish was amazing, they make you feel very welcome when entering the store. The food is pricey but it is worth it. I had liver there one time and it was also good read more

Nicky's Jamaican Cuisine - Kinda pricey .. $9.00 something got this. But still good - Caribbean Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have been to this restaurant for a quick meal before going to a prior function. I tried the oxtails along with a few other dishes. Was not disappointed. Seasoned well and everyone enjoyed the dishes that they ordered. Will definately be back whenever I am in Brooklyn. Keep doing what you are doing. Blessings always!! read more

Pleasant experience food comes promptly hot and fresh. The food is always good no complaints this way. Cabbage nicely steamed oxtails very tender. Time too eat. Thanks read more

Ive lived in the area for years and I used to only get the Stewed Snapper maybe 5 years ago which was always delicious. More recently, I visited there for lunch and ordered an oxtail with white rice and a sauce of Mac and cheese and plantains. So I walk in and there's a guy at the counter and he doesn't say hello or hi or how may I help you or ANYTHING ! And I'm like okkkkk, so I just say my order.. and the guy doesn't even respond to me. He literally doesn't even say "ok or no problem or coming right up". He doesn't acknowledge me at all. After I say my order, he simply gets up and goes to the back. Why do they have to play into the stereotype of rude Jamaicans????? You wanna know why??? Because the food is fuckin bomb that's why. They clearly earned that right.My oxtail was so good and tender and they gave me MAD GRAVY without me having to beg for extra gravy. Now the Mac and cheese was wack AF but I salvaged it with the oxtail gravy. So yes, even tho the employee was rude as a muthafucka, I'll still be going back. read more

best overall Jamaican food in Canarsie and also one of the premier in Brooklyn. Their stew chicken is too die for as well as the stew peas with pigtails. Hospitality is great and very scenic atmosphere makes you feel like your on vacation in Jamaica. 5 out of 5 read more

This review is not about the food . Someone needs to fire that older lady . Her attitude is beyond disgusting for no reason . I thought it was just me until i read the reviews here . I prefer the younger cashier she makes you feel welcomed . Sb: the food is good read more

Based on two orders via UberEats & 1 in-person. This restaurant charges extra for steamed vegetables but you actually get a salad. Don't list what you don't have... Also, the food is subpar and the young lady in the front has a nasty attitude. read more

So I decided to write this review in hopes that management will do something about their staff. I walked into this restaurant and was ignored for about 1 minute by both the cashier and the cook. They better both stood there did not make any eye contact nor did they say good afternoon. Finally the cashier reluctantly asked how can I help you. I decided to leave at that point because they were acting as though they were doing me a favor. Just a reminder, your business is supported by the customer so with that in mind being polite and welcoming should be the standard. I will never go to this establishment again. read more

I just had to write a review. The customer service in this place is at an all time LOW! Ever since the first time I came there to buy food i was hit with the typical "i hate my job" attitude that is no stranger to a jamaican restaurant and its sad! The worst part is even when you're a regular known for supporting the restaurant's business you still get treated like a piece of crap. I try not to give attitude or say anything being that they are preparing my food, but while i was standing in the shop today i overheard other people complaining, and quarreling about how DISGUSTINGLY RUDE AND UNWELCOMING THE OLDER LADY AT THE CASHIER IS and then i thought to myself "omg so I'm NOT the only one that sees it" !!! SHE IS FULL OF ATTITUDE FOR NO REASON! Im so used to my fellow jamaican people looking annoyed as they take your order but even they smile and say "have a nice day". She is the WORST. S.B this post has nothing to do with their food, i love it. read more

Umm hot greasy mess. Super fatty meat (like they didn't trim the meat at all) and the lady must've gave me the oils from the top of the settled gravy b/c I got grease not gravy. $10 in the garbage. So sad right now :( read more

Brown stew fish made fresh to order the and oxtail on point!! The wait is a little long but the food is worth the wait.

Good food. My only complaint is that I cannot understand why they keep putting rice and peas with the curry goat. I always ask for white rice. I get home and it's rice and peas. Please stop doing that. Besides that good food. My boyfriend always gets the oxtail. read more

Coming home from Coney Island family was starving checked this place out because of the yelp reviews the food was awesome and cheap lol

The customers service in this restaurant is poor. The way the older lady at the front speak to customers is very unprofessional. She needs some classes in professionalism!!!! Its so hard to support your own people read more