Wow Nicky's truly is undefeated. About an hour after my flight landed I knew I at least wanted a sandwich, and boy was I impressed! Besides the food being incredible, it was competitively priced with other chain sandwich stores. I would highly recommend Nicky's, unless you're not a birds fan (Philadelphia Eagles). read more

Some of the best subs in town. They have a lot of other good food as well. Owner is super chill and nice. My only request- please get a toaster for the subs. Game changer. read more

Found my new Sunday ritual at Nicky's Undefeated. If you're looking for a solid sandwich spot, this is it. Beef Cheesesteak (10/10): The undisputed star. Perfectly seasoned, juicy, and easily the best thing on the menu. Don't skip this. Italian Sub: This one was just okay for me. A decent sandwich, but it couldn't compete with the cheesesteak. The vibe is great and the service is quick. It's officially in my weekly rotation! read more

I'll start by saying the vibe is good, and my cheesesteak was also good... but I was expecting more. I wanted a 5 star cheesesteak sandwich, but today's did not deliver. I ordered the classic 12" steak with sautéed onions and got white American cheese on their suggestion. It may have been this cheese selection that didn't hit quite right... I know I typically have provolone... also the bread, while fresh enough, wasn't warm or toasted, and was a bit too thick for my personal preference, there was just more bread than needed. The meat was good. The way too creamy cheese quickly dished through the soft bread making this a super messy sandwich. Overall, I'm not mad about it, but I think next time I'll make some different decisions. Also the 12" sun is huge and loaded with steak. You can definitely share, which is good, because my sandwich, a soft drink, and a tip was over $27... a bit pricey for a quick lunch. Please don't let me discourage you. Order your sandwich your way. I'll ask next time if they can toast the bread, they have multiple options for cheeses, and a decent sized menu board I never even took a look at... so I'll be back and will update accordingly. read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Bar - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

See all

Wow!!! My cheesesteak was gigantic and it tasted good!!! Because of the name, I had to try this place out. True to the name, I could barely finish my meal. Nice place, check it out for yourself. read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

See all

Nicky's Undefeated Let's start w some background- I grew up outside of Philly, so I have had a couple cheesesteaks and hoagies. Walking in - even without the Super Bowl winning Eagles flags, Flyers and Sixers gear it has the feel of a hometown / mom and pop cheesesteak joint. You can see the flattop / grill wit onions and steaks being grilled, the "back" of the house. Back home typically no chairs / booths, get your food and get out. Nicky's has tables and booths so it has a come in and soak up some Philly. The small bar / counter is a good idea allows for quick seat. Menu is spot on - allows you to order how you want, but also provides some great "suggestions" and yes if you just don't know - order Founders special. We ordered a small Italian hoagie and small cheesesteak fries (old bay seasoning). Knocked both out of the park. The rolls nice crunch on the outside, soft inside. The steak high quality no gristle, onions grilled not killed. The cooper sharp creamy melted - not so much that the steaks and onions are lost. The hoagie, a solid Italian - decent deli meat, Shredded lettuce, tomato and onions. Plenty of salt pepper and oregano. Next time I'll get heavy oil and vinegar- I like that bite. We will definitely be back, Nicky's makes me feel like being back home. Go Birds ! read more

See all

I definitely got everything I ordered... I ordered the whole beef cheesesteak with extra provolone and extra American white cheddar sauce and some old beef fries with some cheese sauce dip. I think that's called Cooper or something... I also ordered a drink and made it like a combo or whatever. The cheese steak was very good, very meaty, and honestly, I think I didn't need the extra cheese. Next time I go, and there will be a next time, I'm going to get it regular style with just provolone and no cheese sauce. I am a little disappointed that I do not offer mushrooms or bell peppers. However, the hoagie bun was really good. The meat was really good. The portioning was really good, and... It was just really good. My dad got the turkey and ham hoagie with lettuce, onions, and American cheese. I traded him a little bit of my sandwich for a little bit of his sandwich. It was fantastic. Way better than most sandwich shops. It didn't seem like it had much on it, but it was Both filling and very flavorful. You could taste the meat. You could taste the cheese you could taste the lettuce, taste the onion you could taste everything nothing was overwhelming. Nothing was overpowering. It was just a fantastic hoagie. My sister got the Philly cheesesteak salad, and it came with a modest amount of meat on it, so if you're going to order the salad, I would recommend ordering extra meat on that one. Today happened to be a taste of Tucker, and there were vendors all over the place, selling food and crafts, and there was live music outside, but it still wasn't hard to get a parking spot fairly close to the business. On a regular day it actually would be about the same. Maybe a little better as we might have been able to get parking along the side of the street on Main Street. Do I recommend this place? Oh yes. As of right now, this place will now be my favorite Philly cheesesteak place. I've been to others around Atlanta and I've never really found one that I actually liked much. The fact that Nikki's offers the cheese was option or the provolone option or the American cheese or sauce option... Or a combination of all three or just two or whatever you want? That's something that says Nikki's apart from other places a lot of Philly cheesesteak places will only let you get it a certain way because that's how they believe a cheesesteak should be made Nicky's offers all the options. The only thing they're leaving out is the mushrooms and the bell peppers, but I'm OK with that part being left out as long as I can get my cheeses! You want a really great Philly cheesesteak? Check out Nicky's Undefeated. read more

See all

Great cheesesteaks and beer in a clean atmosphere. It's self service, so you order at the register and seat yourself, and I don't know if they intend to hire a bartender because there has never been one there the times I've gone. The fries are terrible though, so maybe try the white bean salad, which is tasty. read more

First time I ate a Philly steak sandwich here it was outstanding! Great beef ...great flavor. The holy grail for sandwiches unless you are vegetarian or vegan. Why only 3 stars you ask? Because today I tried it again. The beef was tough and I had to throw away half of it. So will I try it again ? Yes and the 3rd time will hopefully break the tie for the good guys. read more

Huge sandwiches, 1 full is for two people. I had the philly and it was very good. The flavored soda as well was good. The kid at the counter was very honest when I asked about a menu item. The vibes were good, very relaxed and lots of families. I'll definitely be coming back to try their chili dog. read more

I love this place, and come here often. Best cheese steak outside of the SE Pennsylvania area, and would give most of them a run for their money. I recommend the Founders Special, and a cold beer (or something tamer) and enjoy the ride. Great service, alway a line if you order walk up, and full of Philly ambiance. Love the addition of other PA beers besides Yuengling, although I would never stray from America's oldest brewery. read more

See all

Cool Philly style restaurant. The place is a full of Philly memorabilia pretty cool atmosphere. They had a lot of food options but I ordered a pizza slice which was just perfect. I'll def be going back for a Philly cheese steak read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Sausage Pizza - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

See all

10/10!!! Pleasantly surprised!!! Meat was seasoned so well and the fries was good too!! I usually go to Freds but looks like I have found an alternative read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

It was a bit of a drive for us to check out Nicky's undefeated the other weekend but I am happy we did. The steak sandwich is for side one of the best I have had in or outside of Philly. read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

See all

Ok this is one of those spots that's right on the borderline Yes it is good food, yes it has a great feel, yes the service is good but the prices just seemed about 20 bucks over and the sandwiches just needed a lil more seasoning to really hit !!! I had a great cheesesteak and my wife had an ok deli sandwich (both sandwiches were half sandwiches) also had some good mozzarella squares and a nice beer but it just seemed like it got up to $65 + bucks tooo quick ???? My wife and I said we would both go back but we would split a full su.e sandwich which would bring our costs down about $10-12 bucks and then this may not seem too pricey ?????? So that's my thought go with a friend or partner and order one large sandwich I strongly recommend the cheesesteak it will fill yall up !!! Get a lil salt or see if they can jazz up the seasonings just a smidge and this is golden !!! read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Chips were cool as well - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

This place was a Yelp find for me and I brought a friend as well. The smell of the bread was great lol. I ordered my friend the Chicken Philly egg rolls and The Bean salad on the salad was a really tangy and fresh. I got the Founders Special which was a Philly with white American cheese sauce with the hot pepper. It was pretty decent. My only issue was with the young Asian guy who was working the counter. I was having card issues and they rang my order in without me paying for it yet. While I was talking to the bank. He comes up to me and says my manager said if you take off some items, your meal would be cheaper if you can't pay that price or if you have insufficient funds. I thought that was rude and they also brought my food out and all the while it was getting cold. I felt judged in that moment and had to endure a cold Philly. The whole thing probably took about 5 min to do but no employee should've been doing that. And they didn't want to make me a fresh one. But instead warm up the old one. So not the best customer service. However I did tell the owner Walt how good the bean salad was. Wish I had a better experience after spending 100 dollars. read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Menu - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

See all

The name Nicky's Undefeated really lives up to their name because I've tried my good share of cheesesteak and I gotta give them 1st place. The price, quantity and quality were just right & the meatball soup was spicy but not overly spicy which really made my experience so much better. Everyone here just has a great attitude. 10/10 I can't wait to show my friends and family this place! read more

See all

Very nice place. My server was very polite and the place was welcoming and clean. I ordered a Philly with American cheese. It was delicious. I would have liked peppers and more seasoning on the meat but the sandwich was good. I will definitely come back for another. The bread was fresh which is important and the sandwich wasn't greasy which is crucial to me. I love a Philly loaded with peppers and onions. (I love cherry peppers for some extra heat too) Another plus was the sweet tea. I love gold peak sweet tea. read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Philly. Large - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

My friend and I were looking for a low-key place to grab drinks and food on a Saturday afternoon. Nicky's Undefeated was the perfect place! They have something for everyone, including people like me who are dairy free. Violet was an excellent server/bartender. She was very sweet & friendly. We were greeted with a delicious scoop of complementary water ice. I ordered the buffalo chicken Philly with vegan cheese and a side of fries. I didn't love the cheese, but that's on me - not Nicky's. Our food was delivered smoking hot!! That's always a plus for me. My Kentucky mules were delicious. If you like a sweeter alcoholic drink, try the Lemonara. We swapped the vodka for tequila and... Chef's kiss! The restaurant was very cute! The decor is Philly inspired. There was a steady flow of customers, but it never felt over crowded or uncomfortable. Needless to say, we will be back! read more

Nicky's Undefeated - 6-inch Buffalo chicken Philly with onions on a seeded bun with vegan cheese, a side of fries and a Kentucky mule - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

See all

On main street, with street parking Indoor large seating area with benches or stand alone tables Order at counter, get a number, food will be delivered at your table. Big menu with traditional hoagies and sub or fried chix style hoagies The portions are big and price reasonable Friendly and knowledgeable staff read more

See all

Watch repeats of the Eagles 2025 Super Bowl victory as you stuff yourself with a generous servings of cheesesteak and bay fries. Very northeast cheesesteak joiny feel to the place. No one will go away hungry. read more

Parking is a bit tight in front of the store but if you go around the block to the back, there might be more parking spots. Their cheesesteak is solid! Fresh hot melted cheese on proper cooked beef and good bread. Simply tasty. I do wish they have mushroom as an optional topping but that doesn't affect the quality of the cheesesteak. They have a window for togo order if you don't want to dine in. You can also just walk in and place the order for to go. The restaurant is nice and clean. The staffs are friendly and helpful. I will try the ice cream the next time i stop by. Definitely should give it a try if you're in the area! read more

See all

I have been looking forward to trying Nicky's Undefeated for awhile now. I had a rough day at work, didn't feel like cooking, so I picked up hubby and we moseyed along in traffic and headed downtown (Tucker) to try the Philly/Jersey sandwiches. I ordered the beef cheesesteak "Wit" (with onions) and provolone with the seeded bun, plus fry combo and added cherry peppers and banana peppers. Hubby ordered the Italian hoagie (Philly Way) on a regular bun, plus pasta salad combo. Both sandwiches were stacked with meat! I wished there were a bit more onions in my cheese steak, but I'm not complaining because of the amount of meat - it was a perfect ratio of bread:meat (tipping heavier to the meat side just as it should). I really enjoyed that the meat wasn't chopped too much so you got nice big chunks which kept it from getting over cooked and dried out like many places do. I'm going to try the Cooper cheese sauce next time instead of provolone. I had eaten half my sandwich before I even noticed I didn't get the seeded bun like I ordered. I was enjoying it too much to realize. Once I did,though, I was disappointed because I can just imagine how that would have nudged the sandwich even higher on my taste scale. Oh well, just means I have to go back sooner so I can try it. {I'll make sure I get the right bread BEFORE I start to devour it, though.} Hubby really enjoyed his Italian hoagie, he loved the seasoning/oil/vinegar they used as part of the "Philly Way." He said the dressing was better than [the chain Jersey sandwich place] - Shocking!!! {he loves that other place}. He also raced about the pasta salad which was well seasoned and dressed. He thoroughly enjoyed being able to order a side other than a bag of chips. For dessert we opted for peach ice cream (for me) and lemon water ice (for hubby) - hubby definitely made the better choice! We had never heard of water ice before - it is a creamy refreshing not too sweet delight. So how long will it be before we return? Knowing us and our enjoyment of great "sand-ditches" - and knowing how bad I really wanted to try that seeded bun - it won't be very long at all. Edit: I'm thinking I got sliced jalapenos, not the cherry peppers I ordered...another thing to check next time. read more

See all

We were very happy to see this new addition to the Tucker culinary landscape. As we walked in, the space is impressive--clean, spacious, and not crowded. There are large TVs and get this--a bar--a full bar! But I digress... We ordered cheesesteaks, of course. I got the Founder's sandwich and my wife got something that was basically just beef and cheese on bread. We were both pleased with what we got. Lots of meat on a nice roll. It needed more cheese, but I'm not going to hold this against them, yet. Staff was very friendly, considering we walked in with less than 30 min to closing. But they took our order at the counter, and they served us with a smile. Next time we'll do our best to arrive early. Holler if you're coming with. read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Needs more cheese! - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

Active casual sports bar type restaurant. I ordered a half of a Philly cheesesteak, fries and a drink that cost $20. It wasn't worth that at all. It should really cost about half but I'm assuming it's a small local business. My food was pretty bland so I probably wouldn't come again but the owner was super nice! read more

Great sandwiches! Everything I've had here has been great but the founder's special cheesesteak is in the top 3 steaks in the ATL for my money. A must visit! read more

Had a great first visit here - the cheesesteaks were outstanding! Rib-eye with cooper cheese & grilled onions on seeded roll ....buffalo chicken cheesesteak was also solid. Fries were hot & well-seasoned. Very friendly service & food came out quick. Had some ice cream & a tiramisu for dessert. Great beer & cocktail selection. Lots of TVs on the wall to watch sports. We will definitely be back! Great addition to Main Street Tucker. read more

Wow!! This place has the best Philly Cheesesteak and other Philly favorites! The owner delivered some of the orders and made small talk to just about everyone there. I could hear some patrons saying they were from Philly. They have table seating and a bar to sit and order. I will definitely be back! read more

See all

Tasty. Miss the peppers and onions. If you're looking for Philly style, I think this is the closest you'll get in Atlanta. Service was decent and the ambience is Sports Bar. read more

I've only had the Italian the "Philly Philly Way." It's a very, very good sandwich. Bonus points for the Cooper cheese. The menu could use a little help to make it more user friendly. Stop by during college ball season as they've got some of the biggest TVs w the game on. read more

you'll not be disappointed. Today we ordered the whole Philly Sub. it was enough for me and my wife. top quality and swift on line pick order. read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Half Philly Sub. This is my pepper. Really spices it up. - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

Went in for the first time last week. Will absolutely be going back. First and foremost, the staff were all awesome from the cashier to the co-owner. Food was delicious, portions were much larger than I had expected. Prices feel slightly high looking at the menu but it's plenty of food for the money. The pretzel bites were awesome, my wife got the Impossible cheese steak and I got the buffalo chicken, both great. She also got a side of the Old Bay fries which were solid as well. The place was decently busy when we went in and even through the traffic, everything was very clean. read more

Very good lunch here today. We preferred the cheese steak over the Italian hoagie. We'll return & likely try the cheese steak egg rolls. Staff were all very nice. Wish we lived closer but it's prob best we don't for our waistlines ;-) read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Philly cheese steak & fries - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

This place really is undefeated with size, quality, taste. They hit every mark. I've been to almost every other philly spot in the ATL area and this one is not only better than the Atlanta spots but I would put it in any contention with the entire North East. Highly recommend it. read more

Nicky's Undefeated - Philly with old bay fries and wiz on the side. - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

Nikki's Undefeated? More like Nikki's Unbothered--because they clearly don't care about customer service. Walked in to pure chaos--the owner, Walt, yelling about his favorite team like it was his personal clubhouse. We had to shout just to place an order. I got a chicken cheesesteak and fries, my friend got a regular one. Easy, right? Nope. People who ordered after us got their food first. After 25 minutes, I asked what was up. Walt said our ticket didn't print. Michael, the other owner, said the chicken "just takes longer." So which one is it? Because those two lies didn't even try to match and they were standing next to each other. When the food finally showed up? Cold fries. Missing fries. No apology. Just blank stares. Then, when we asked for a to-go box, we got hit with "Boxes are only for cheesesteaks"--even though we just watched someone get one for their cheesesteak. The math ain't mathing. Bland food. Excuses on top of excuses. No customer service. If I wanted rules, I'd go to court--not pay $15 for a mid cheesesteak. Never again. Cant help to think some racism was involved can't prove it but no other Black people came in after me. Makes sense now. read more

Nicky's Undefeated - I put my own mustard on there. It looks dry you say. It was. even with cheese. No flavor, no taste.. Bread was even terrible. Look at it. - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Tucker, Georgia

This was our first time eating here and we are so happy we tried it. The food was fresh and delicious. We definitely plan on returning the next time we're in this area. Cece took our order and she provided such a pleasant experience. She had knowledge of the food and was able to offer suggestions based on our taste buds. Kirsten provided excellent customer service as well. Both ladies made us feel welcome and in good hands. read more

I love their Italian grinder! The bean salad is a winner. The menu is worth returning to try the variety. Large space to eat in and choices of beer to enjoy with meal. A winner! read more

We go to Nicky's Undefeated often, and we always enjoy the delicious Philly style food. My husband is from Philly, and the food is very authentic, especially the cheesesteaks. I love the egg roll style cheesesteaks...just the right amount for me! The owners and the staff couldn't be better. A GREAT addition to Tucker. Mary read more

I went here on 8/19/2024 for the first time. I got some chicken wings 6 for $12.00 I wanted lemon pepper flavor they had Garlic Parm instead they are delicious! The cheesesteak is really different from others I tried before the copper cheddar is creamy in delicious and you taste it the whole time you eat this sandwich. I also got a lemon water ice delicious. read more

See all

Well, I will say Tucker can add another great resteraunt to the city. I had a 6 inch Philly. That sandwitch was nice and flavorful and cheesy. I especially loved the bean salad. The bean salad had a nice vinegarette taste,with just the right amount of onion added in. The service was a little slow,around 25 minutes. However, the quality of the food and tastes was exceptional. I will certainly be back again and advise you do the same. read more

See all