This was my first time trying these donuts! They were recommended to me by my aunt. I got a box of six and they didn't disappoint. All of the flavors were nice and moist on the inside and the toppings were delicious. By the time I got there at 1pm, most donuts were sold out (popular spot) but they had a good selection to work with! My favorite was the glazed donut. It was so soft and pillowy. It melted in my mouth! I would definitely want to come back and grab a different dozen of donuts. The staff was super friendly and the place is just super cute and cozy! I would definitely come back to try more and would recommend for others to try. read more

See all

They continue to push out such great weekly options! Even with the steep price, I still go back a couple times a year. It's special enough to indulge now and again. The service is always quick and helpful, and the place is really cute inside. If you're in a "treat yo self" mood, def stop by and make sure to try the specials! read more

See all

The donuts a amazing tasting and amazing to look at. They have so many kinds from Oreo cookies s'mores fruity pebbles glaze jelly and so on. The service was very helpful with letting me know all the different types of donuts they have. The ambiance is cute small a take out spot for on the go eating. In the heart of Bayshore Main Street a good treat to make you happy. read more

See all

Let me start by saying that wherever I travel, I normally try a doughnut . So I've had doughnuts basically all over the world, and in the United States. The doughnuts here were the best I have had in YEARS! Not only are they large, the dough is slightly dense, but yet airy. The frosting was perfect not overboard. I tried the Cannoli doughnut and I have to say even the cannoli cream in the center and the little cannoli place on top was delicious. 10+ Next time in Long Island, I plan on going and picking up a few more to try . They truly hit the spot and I look forward to having them with a hot cup of coffee. The inside is absolutely so inviting, bright, and has this 80s 90s kind of vibe . I had no problem with the service either, the ladies were very nice and explained that they were other shops throughout Long Island. Love, love love this place ... read more

See all

As soon as you walk in, your sweet tooth is now aware that you're in an awesome place I like all the colors and the flavors and how everything looks fresh. read more

North Fork Doughnut - Natural goodness - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

We stopped in for a quick treat on a Friday evening. It's a beautiful little spot, colorful and very clean. The people were very attentive, greeted us and helped us immediately. We got a churro latte, a churro donut and a small coffee. The Donut was delicious, soft airy and perfect amount of cinnamon sugar. The latte wasn't as good, and the small coffee was a bit watered down. All in all they are a Donut company, at which they absolutely excel! read more

See all

Service was very quick, the young lady working was really nice. I got the Rice Krispie donut and it was fantastic. The donut was well balanced, it was a plain donut on the bottom so that it would not be too sweet with the cream / topping which was well done. Definitely a special treat because oh my calories ! But so worth it... The place is so stinking cute; love the decor. We planned on sitting outside to eat our donuts since there weren't any chairs inside. All but one set of chairs / tables were locked up with chains and the cushions were so gross so we just ate in the car. read more

North Fork Doughnut - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

They sell big, unique donuts. Prices are a little high. Employees were friendly. I love the decorations on the walls. It's a cute place to grab a coffee and a donut. It's take out only- seating is not available. Currently, on Wednesdays they have buy one get one mini donuts. read more

This was my first time actually visiting the shop, but my second time enjoying their doughnuts. My first impression walking in was, "This is cool." The whole pink doughnut shop with an '80s vibe was on point--cassette tapes, a Walkman on the wall, and that nostalgic MTV candy-store energy. The design was clean, fun, and full of personality. It's takeout only, so there's no seating, but the atmosphere still makes an impression. I ordered the Caramel Crumb Cake, Jelly, and Chocolate Cake doughnuts. The Caramel Crumb Cake was absolutely delicious--soft, flaky, and the caramel drizzle took it to another level. It honestly tasted like a decadent cinnamon bun in doughnut form. Definitely a spot worth checking out if you appreciate great doughnuts and a fun throwback vibe. My only complaint is I seemed to remember the Doughnuts being bigger the last time I came. Service wasn't terrible but dude was a little sterile. But the Doughnuts definitely made up for the experience. I came in curious. I left loyal. This place understands the assignment. I'll definitely come back. read more

See all

I was blown away by the selection of donut flavors. There is literally a donut for everyone here. Prices are reasonable for gourmet donuts I ordered 4 donuts caramel crumble, cookies and cream, Boston cream, tres leche , cannoli and a latte. The ambiance was welcoming and nostalgic with some old school feel to it. My favorite was the tres leche: there was a nice surprise of more milk in the top of the donuts, this was a plus for me cause I like my tres leches with extra sauce. The close second was the cannoli donut. read more

See all

Unable to rate the donuts considering it's 6:21pm Friday night and the place is closed read more

North Fork Doughnut - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I get donuts from here all the time. They're always fresh and delicious. Keep up the good work, NoFoDoCo!

This was my go to donut place since a long time ago... HUGE DENSE AND FLUFFY DONUTS... unfortunately... the donuts have gone down in quality in both size and density. I have a comparison picture and it's ridiculous. I'm truly sadden, for $18 for 4 donuts, you'd expect them to look the way they usually did in the past huge and 6 people could eat those 4 donuts to looking exactly like and tasting like Dunkin' Donuts... truly a downturn for the place. Best thing I could do is give the feedback for you to improve and go back to the original. read more

The donuts here are different and creative and a great dessert. Small restaurant mostly for take out. I bought 4 donuts today its was $17.00. Staff are friendly and helpful. They have Cute pink boxes for its packaging. read more

See all

Kalie was a sweetheart and made us happy customers with great service and delicious doughnuts. read more

North Fork Doughnut - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Very good donuts with many varieties of flavors and is very involved with the community visiting camp for a chance to get your donut sold in stores the service is very quick and good the building has cool donut themed signs and designs read more

I've been in the Bay Shore area recently for work, and I read online that there is a donut place here called NoFoDoCo that's supposed to be pretty good. I love donuts and wanted to try it out so I hit it up on two separate occassions over the past few weeks. I called beforehand to ask about pricing and the lady who answered the phone seemed pretty nice. The place itself is pretty small, but the decor and interior seem clean, modern, and well lit. I came in the afternoon, and it was entertaining to look at the donut lineup when I got there, as they all looked really good. I ended up trying a regular chocolate frosted donut ($4.50 total) on one occassion, and a glazed donut ($4.35) on another occassion. Please note that the price is slightly lower if you pay with cash, and the lady gave me back three quarters when I paid with a 5 to make change simpler. So it was actually $4.25. Yay. The main thing to point out about the donuts here are that they're a lot bigger than regular donuts. Maybe about twice the size of a regular donut. So that's great. I have to say that I thoroughly enjoyed both donuts, with no real complaints on taste. They both tasted a notch above regular donut places like Dunkin. So while they weren't mind-blowing, they were definitely very solid. Probably would've been even better if I got them in the morning I'd imagine. So with all things considered, I'd go with 3 stars. I definitely feel like the donuts are not mind blowing enough to justify a price over $4. In general, I feel like dessert places have a tough standard to compete with as pastries you can find in regular supermarkets are often pretty solid IMO. If the donuts were like $3 I'd probably give out an additional star. Cheers. read more

See all

I'm not even a donut guy and big on sweets but I will say this place is 10/10 when it comes to donuts. When I first tried duck donuts in Center reach I was blown away, but these donuts are different. Amazing donuts made fresh to order. Hard to go anywhere else after you have had these. The staff was very friendly and helpful in choosing since they have quite a big selection. Their glazed donut is pure heroine and they have so many amazing flavors to try. I also loved the fruity pebble donut they have, as well as other they offer. Nofo is the real deal and hands down the best donuts I ever had in my life. Amazingly delicious! You can't go wrong no matter what you choose! Highly recommend 10/10! read more

North Fork Doughnut - glazed, sour cream, boston cream, and napoleon - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

The donuts don't taste bad but the service is horrible. Had an Uber eats order that came unsealed and open, when I called the store, the employee told me sometimes they have stickers sometimes they don't. They just send it out. So I asked to speak to a manager she goes to me. You need to ask Uber for a refund we don't deal with refunds, not even an apology nothing, she proceeded to lie to me that it was sealed when the previous employee told me it wasn't. Very poor attitude she couldn't give less of a crap about the situation would not recommend the people. Came in a paper box, any sticker would have clearly left a sign. She then proceeded to blame The driver, implying he opened it. Learn to take responsibility, don't understand who hired her as a manager, very poor judgement by owner. read more

This store just reopened after being closed for about a month due to a gas explosion, which occurred in the opposite end of the building in Mattituck where the business operates its factory. North Fork Doughnut business co-owner Jimmy said on his IG page #NoFoDo that no damage was done to his kitchen and that he has just created a grand re-opening menu. The lemon ricotta doughnut is one of the new menu selections. It is moderately sweet and is probably lower in carbs than his menu basics. This is a doughnut that I would recommend for dieters like myself who want to get their doughnut fix. Welcome back, #NoFoDo. read more

See all

Christina J. recommended this donut shop so I gave it a try and was I glad I did. I got the Boston Cream, jelly and some glazed donuts, all were freshly baked and they weren't skimpy with the fillings in the jelly donut and the Boston cream. All of them were absolutely delicious the best I ever tasted. I will definitely be going back for some more of those Boston creams and to try out a variety of different ones. The parking might be a little difficult with all the restaurants in the area but it will be well worth it. read more

See all

Wanted to save this review for national doughnut day and oh my god this place is so cute and SO good! I sampled the blackberry jelly donut and the Samoa and boy was it delicious. The Samoa is only around for a short time so get it while you can! The woman at the counter, I totally forgot her name but had the best smile, customer service and energy was letting me know that it's not common that on a Wednesday at 11 a.m there were still donuts. They open at 6 and I hate to say it but I think the sweet spot is 800 right before the morning rush for all the businesses nearby. As I was talking with the worker, a gentleman came in and took the rest of their most popular flavor, the crumb cake, for an office birthday party so it really is a first come first serve experience. The donuts were amazing though, definitely a little pricy but so so so delicious. I will definitely be back and I'll try my best to get their early! read more

North Fork Doughnut - Samoa - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

The FOURTH time we've tried to get weekly specials and they've been sold out. I keep giving them a chance because the flavor forecasts seems so good but now I'm just wasting my time. I even asked the previous time when is a solid time to come and I was told before 10am is a pretty safe bet. I went at 9am this time and the two flavors were sold out. Seemed like they had been for a while, patrons after me were disappointed as well. At this point I feel like there should be a good gauge of demand-to be sold out by 9am means someone is missing the mark. At the very least update the social media accounts to tell us when the flavors are sold out. read more

I went in at 7:12 pm says that close at 8 pm the store was getting packed up and when asking about coffee drinks listed on the menu the worker said sorry the machine is shut down for the night. read more

If you love donuts there's no place like this. So fun! I love that they have a rotating menu which makes it fun and makes you look forward to coming in. The service is always great and the ambiance is fun. I wish there was space to have a small table to sit down and eat it there. read more

North Fork Doughnut - Coffee crumb, cannoli, classic strawberry, and Samoa donut - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I.keep.coming.back!!!!! I can't stop. Why haven't I reviewed them before?? I guess I'm too busy devouring the donuts! Light, fluffy, large, tasty, sharable, keeps me coming back. Check out their weekly flavors and their signatures. I am OBSESSED with the Boston cream and strawberry goodness. They donuts are so f Large but once they were so large they didn't fit the box... worth every mile and every penny! Please check them out in mattituck and bayshore. And bring the kids, they are so kind to them and just play into their awe in picking donuts. Love the donuts doesn't even explain my real feelings. Damn now I need to go buy a box today read more

North Fork Doughnut - Strawberry, cannoli, Boston cream, raspberry, m&m and half eaten Strawberry lol - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

We had had dinner next-door. We were leaving I guess as the store was closing. A wonderful worker was outside asking us if we'd like to try donuts. I'm always up for a good donut so I said yeah so we went inside. She handed me a box of six donuts. I said how much? She said no they're free. We're closing soon so there for you to try. I will definitely go back. The donuts were fresh, tasty and full of flavor. The Boston cream donut is as I remembered as a kid, but these were really filled with cream that had very good taste. The chocolate on the outside was perfectly balanced. Donuts fried perfectly. I save some of the donuts to have with my son. We shared the fruity pebbles one. The frosting was like milk. It was so fluffy and delicious. The chocolate, glazed doughnut tasted like a devil food cake glaze was perfect. we shared a really good jelly doughnut with lots of raspberry filling coming out and a perfectly sugared outside of a fluffy light donut. I will definitely go back and buy my share of donuts in the future. The woman was amazing who ran the shop very kind. She had such a good smile. It was great for me, since I wasn't going to have a valentine the next day so that meant I wasn't getting any love food from anyone. She helped me not feel as bad for Valentine's Day to be coming the next day. read more

Tonight July 21 2024 was the best night of my life. Walked up to this place to get a donut for my date but the door was locked. I arrived just after closing, but the staff kindly offered let me buy their last box of donuts. They were not only beautiful but also tasted amazing! I mean perfectly sweet and savory, doughy but also like clouds. The flavor profiles were simple yet complex. Toppings classic yet innovative. It's now my life's mission to bring everyone i love here. I love you, No Fo Do Co read more

North Fork Doughnut - Pancake, Orange Creme, Blueberry, Waffle, Lemon Creme, Everything Bagel w/ CC!!!!!!!!! - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Friendly staff!I ran in at the last minute and almost fainted.Everything looks so good and extremely fresh doughnuts.They taste as good as they look. My finger no longer has spiced sugar on it,I ate that too!I can not wait to share this gem with my family and friends... read more

North Fork Doughnut - My face while savoring my doughnut!Say yummmtastic 2x! - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Ok. I love donuts but these were super dry & lacked flavor they are one of thickest donuts ever. We order whatever was left in the store which was a pumpkin, glazed and popcorn donut. It's sad to say we threw them all away because they were dry. We understand that you want to stay open until 7pm but you can't sell day old donuts. Especially for the people who don't live near by. You get two stars because your staff was amazing. I hope to revisit & have better luck next time. read more

See all

Having wanting to go here for a while, but never being in the area I haven't had a chance. I was in the area after having lunch, so I figured why not. I was greeted upon entering. Having never been here (or the other location) before, I had a few questions. The girl behind the counter was very friendly and helpful. Super nice as well, and appeared to like her job. Instead of only getting one donut (who really orders just one?!), I went with a half dozen. I got cookies and cream, chocolate frosted, jelly, pumpkin, caramel apple pie and caramel coffee cake. I tired a bite of pumpkin, caramel apple pie, and a bite of caramel coffee cake. All were delish! Not overly sweet like I thought. Each donut was light and airy. My mom enjoyed the cookies and cream and my stepdad enjoyed the chocolate frosted. Someone ate the jelly, but nobody is fessing up to it. Haha. All donuts were enjoyed! Will be back to try new donuts of the week. Gotta keep up with the "Flavor Forecast!" read more

North Fork Doughnut - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

So happy to see North Fork Doughnut closer to home. We've always been a huge fan of the company by always visiting the original location in Mattituck in the eastern north fork of Long Island. This little location is in the heart of Bay Shore's town. They offer many rotating flavors as well including many of the originals and interesting flavors. They also offer many local drinks including Sail Away Coffee. I love how their doughnuts are fluffy and tasty. It's definitely a spot you can't pass up. read more

See all

Made two stops along the way one here and one and one at doughology! Can say with confident NoFoDoCo was the winner as I favor a fried donut over a baked cake donut. Size comparison was a no brainer and flavor variety was nice. I typically wouldn't travel for a donut but these I would make an accordion for read more

North Fork Doughnut - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Okay, I get it - very tasty donuts but omg, omg $4.00 a donut!!! Whew!!! I guess I'm not enough of a donut person to ever spend that much. But... if donuts are your thing, they are very good and HUGE!!! read more

If you have a sweet-tooth like me, you better come here asap! This was my first time coming to this small and clean donut shop and I will be returning. When I walked in, the employees were welcoming but weren't very enthusiastic, it didn't bother me but something I noticed. The donut glass was fully stocked when I arrived, everything looked very colorful and delicious. The shop itself is very cute with the wall decor. The donuts were outstanding! It was very fluffy, not overly sweet but hits the spot! I ordered the fruity pebbles donut, Boston cream, & the cookie dough M&M. For a box of 4 the total came close to $20 which I think is a little bit on the higher side but for these flavorful donuts I would do it again! Defiantly would recommend this doughnut shop if you are in the area and are looking for something sweet and tasty! read more

See all

The service was good. The doughnuts are expensive and honestly not worth it. The toppings on the doughnuts were stale and overall left a lot to be desired. read more

North Fork Doughnut - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Once again I was told 2 hours before posted closing time THEY RAN OUT OF DONUTS!!! What in the world is wrong with this place?! I'm not the only person this has happen to. A co-worker told me it happen to them a few weeks ago in the afternoon when they were on their way back to work from lunch and thought to pick up a dozen donuts for his workshop. Nope, sorry, ran out!....At least Dunkin always had donuts! Hey owners, are you listening? read more

Ginormous donuts and Instagram-worthy. Very tasty with the exception of the Apple Fritter. Usually my favorite, it was very undercooked this time. I did like the Strawberry Unicorn donut, the Cookie Butter and the Coffee Cake donut. I brought a dozen to a friends and they were a big hit. $43 is rough to pay for a dozen donuts but because of the size of the donuts, it's more equivalent to two dozen. I'm still a fan even though the Apple fritter was such a bummer. read more

See all

I'm not a doughnut guy, like at all. But I was offered one of these at their next door neighbor JBBQ. Wtf, maybe I am a doughnut guy now. I cut the thing into !eight! pieces, and 1/8th of a piece was enough for me to discern that these are worth the trip. Pick up a bunch and you'll make friends, promise. This was a fruity pebbles doughnut, soft and delicious, just enough sweet, and the crunch of the fruity pebbles. Yum. read more

North Fork Doughnut - Friggen yum - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

This is really a 3.5 rating. It's an excellent donut but the flavor of the specialty donuts need to be stronger. I tried them at a food festival. I bought the Churro and somoa flavor. The Churro didn't taste like Churro and the somoa had a faint coconut and caramel flavor. The donut itself was moist and fluffy. It's also a pretty big donut. If I'm in the neighborhood, I'll try the regular donuts. read more

North Fork Doughnut - Churro Donut - Donuts Near Me - Bay Shore, New York