I'm really not sure why there are so many negative reviews for this cafe. I have been coming here for years and they have the best bagels in the village. If I'm hosting a lot of people or catering for a work meeting people have requested the bagels from here. The wraps are also always fresh and delicious and the service has been nice. Always quick and easy. read more

Back after a few months due to previous poor and rude service. Same attitude with different employee. Snarky, rude and pretty ignorant employees = poor management = this customer will be going to competitors. I would advise others to do the same.​​ read more

Really enjoy the bagels at this spot as they're hot, fresh, and perfectly chewy. They have vegan cream cheese and you can add veggies, scallions, etc. they also have a plethora of other standard cream cheeses and non-vegan breakfast sandwiches as well. They have street parking or a parking lot our back with entry from both sides. Bathroom available for customers with key. read more

owner is rude to all her staff and attitude in general needs to be fixed! food is decent for a bagel but just all around never heard staff be treated so bad also doesn't seem to be something that is getting fixed considering every review is about how rude this girl is read more

Been coming here for bagels for years but this is the first time I decided to get a lunch sandwich. I ordered turkey American cheese lettuce tomato on a roll.. pretty basic sandwich. I was floored to find out the price of that sandwich was $15.00. I had asked her why is it so expensive since every specialty sandwich on their menu is less than $15.00. I enjoy this place but that price is absolutely outrageous. read more

Staff is rude, arrogant, like they are doing me a favor. Just left, one guy on line, 3 people behind counter, and was ignored, for 10 mins. I walked out, never to return. I only went there, bec it's located by my gym. Bye bye. Not only game in town. read more

Horrible service. A girl who said she is the owner accused me of having a "nasty" look on my face! I entered the store with my 7 year old daughter. The worker stared at me and proceeded to verbally assault me. When I asked her why she was saying this to me, She said I had a nasty look on my face. I was shocked. I am a nice person, a special educator for children with needs and people define me as kind and positive. I was shaking with embarrassment and tried re-entering the store to clear things up but this girl continued with her angry words and mimicking me. I can not emphasize enough, please do not go to this bagel shop, please. read more

Coffee tasted burnt, got a bacon egg and cheese, and it was 1/2 an egg - not even a whole egg, and cheese tasted weird. Waste of calories and money. read more

(Just gave the SAME review for the OTHER main bagel shop in town next to the movie theatre-- 2 days ago!) Attention YOUNG petite gals that work in bagel and sandwich shops: We know that you probably do not eat much and shy away from larger portions. That does not mean that your larger plus sized male customers are on the SAME DIET that you are on! There , I said it. This happens WAY too much now . Came in for a bagel w/ cream cheese. Bagel was big and fluffy- NOT NEARLY enough cream cheese to compensate . As if they were being micro-managed "Don't put TOO much cream cheese on there!". Prolly not tho. Said gal is just not a cream cheese hog. I could barely taste it and felt like I was eating a big fat plain bagel with nothing on it . What a waste. read more

The level of rudeness here is unparalleled!! One young female server in particular really needs some lessons on basic humanity. The bagels are mediocre at best. Why support a business like this when there are far superior bagel stores nearby who treat their customers humanely. Do yourself a favor- stay away!!! Too bad there is not a choice for 0 stars!! read more

The service here is horrible. As a Huntington resident I love shopping and eating local.. however, I will no longer get my bagels at village bagel. A young girl who works there claims her father owns this place. I was shocked because she is one of the rudest workers in there. Give your business to GOOD people, not these people. read more

Bagel was amazing but cashier was so rude to me and another friend of mine minutes before. Not worth dealing with annoying staff. Don't know why a young girl who's a cashier at a bagel shop has any reason to be rude. Won't be going back after that interaction Also... a cute sweatshirt hanging up I was thinking of buying but I touched it and 20 flies flew out of it!!! Nasty!!! read more

Great service , they handle walk ins and call in separate so everyone is taking care of ,, other business need to learn from them Great bagels and food, everyone so helpful and nice The only little issue is there cups for ice teas STINK and will spill all over you I love when places wrap the ice teas or use high quality cups read more

Diagonally across the US Post Office behind Main St, Huntington, NY, is the Village Bagel Cafe. I don't live in the area, but, was running errands, there, and thought to save a trip to my usual, local, bagel place, so, I went in. The six bagels and one flagle, themselves, cost about $11, which is a little pricey, but, the bagels were large (oddly, they had no holes; just depressions), so, I suppose, I was getting more for my money, and they tasted good, too (not great; above average; denser than most (okay by me), but, lacking in flavor (the mixed bagels were two each of onion, sesame, and cinnamon raisin)). I put $1 in the tip jar for the harried clerk, who had just finished large orders for two people before me (5 min wait), and she treated me very well: politely, friendly, and patiently. I asked for the receipt (not automatically given), thanked her, and left (3 people behind me; took about three mins to process my order). When I got home, I got sticker shock from the receipt: On top of the $11 for the bagels were a 30 cent credit card usage fee and a $2.20 "tip," which I had mistaken for "tax" (no bagel store had ever charged me for tax, but, I didn't think about it at the time). So, I was charged about 17% extra without having been told about either fee. Granted, it's becoming more common to charge credit card fees, which is unfortunate, especially since many establishments are trying to avoid cash for obvious reasons, but, keep in mind, I gave a tip before realizing that one was foisted on me. Any business short of a 5-star restaurant should not automatically impose a tip on its customers, and they - - if you'll forgive the glib phrasing - - should 'eat' the credit card fee. Again, both were charged without my knowledge. Now, look at the receipt. In H-U-G-E print, it shows ONLY the price for the goods, which I thought I was paying for. In eensy-weensy-tiny-barely-can-see print are the other charges, which I didn't notice until I got the credit card bill. That should be illegal, if not immoral. Those absurd charges and the "trick" receipt cost them a star. Totally unnecessary, and very off-putting. I won't be back. read more

Village Bagel Cafe - How much did I actually pay? - Delis Near Me - Huntington, New York

SO GOOD!!! Scott is super friendly & attentive, and the owner Madina and her family are also so sweet! Definitely a regular from now on, glad to pass this by on the village :) also tastes super fresh! read more

Village Bagel Cafe - Chicken BLT on a roll! So good - Delis Near Me - Huntington, New York

Place is extremely messy and dirty and the staff is all over the place. It was not even busy. Came in this morning with a simple order.. gave oat milk instead of almond, coffee tastes burnt, did not toast bagels for sandwiches .. all mistakes. Everytime I go here, it is not a good experience but it is convenient and close to work. Won't be going back at this point. read more

Village Bagel Cafe - Messiness on counters where we're suppose to grab our coffee. - Delis Near Me - Huntington, New York

village bagel just reminded me how great new york bagels an egg sandwiches really are i used to work in huntington moved to fl for the last two years and all i can say is wow this place is amazing the girls that work there are very pleasant... if i was able to take a suitcase full of bagels down south I would!! read more

Service was shit the cook was super rude ripped a gallon of milk and a cup of cereal when I clearly left money on the table, accused me of not paying ( I don't feed like a bum)so disrespectful after all I go there everyday I will never step foot in there again they need to learn to to talk to comustmers not get the fuck outa here ". To a paying customer I dispose this place, overly priced to Goood luck everyone read more

A dumpster fire when it comes to the organization. Nobody knows what's going on. Breakfast sandwiches just sit there to be rung up and if you ask someone to help you they act like you've interrupted their whole day. The bagel is okay. The breakfast sandwich is okay. The coffee is okay. But since this is Long Island, you can get good service and good food a block away. read more

Always the best bagels and the fastest nicest staff! They have. Great crew of smiling faces that make the line feel quick. As real New Yorkers we've tried all the shops in town and Village really is the BEST for taste and for service, keep up the great work. read more

Buttered bagel = $3.00 . Not cool. BLT on bagel with NO SIDES = $8.49. Not cool. Guy making bagel had sniffles , saw him wiping his nose on backhand side of glove while making bagels. REALLY REALLY not cool. I ate the bagel anyway because I know COVID was a scam. Keep wearing those masks you losers. read more

Good bagels. Smooth service. We went on a Sunday morning so it was busy and chaotic but everything came out and we enjoyed the bagels and rolls. read more

I really can't speak to the negative reviews since I ordered online for delivery. Everything was excellent. I'm near Ess-a-bagel NYC which is well known for great bagels, but the flagels, bagels and bialy here were at least as good if not better. Actually, probably the best flagel I've ever had. read more

Got their food through door dash today and it was amazing. Didn't order anything crazy either, just pancakes and a bacon cheese omelette with home fries, but it was really on point. Great amount of bacon and cheese, and the fries were so good. The pancakes are smaller but you get 5 and they were cooked very well. Sometimes with the bigger pancakes they get soggy but these were great even through delivery. Overall can't wait for next weekend to order some other things. read more

Only been here a few times but love it When you order an everything or salt or any bagel with a topping it's actually on the entire bagel not just half like the other town bagel spot Fluffy uniform bagels Love it You do need a menu though read more

Village Bagel Cafe - Yum - Delis Near Me - Huntington, New York

they shrunk the size of their bagels in half and raised the price. very noticeable...

This is one of the most underrated bagel places ever, their bagels are literally the best I've had on Long Island. Once you have them - all others will be subpar. Run don't walk here read more

I would give it zero stars if I could. I (was) a loyal customer since I've been working in the village. Every morning I'd grab a bagel and tip appropriately. Today, Frank (senior, not his son) decided he wanted to give his two cents about my tattoos. Told me "you'll regret that when you're 50. Wait til you're 50 to get your next tattoo you're in a 20 year old mindset." How f*cking dare you. Continued with "it's just advice" as if that was justifying what he said. I was in such shock I didn't even respond. His son even apologized and said "don't listen to him". Sorry man, it's already been said. Who do you think you are, Frank? You're not my father. You just lost my business. I suggest you keep your opinions to yourself. Don't go here unless you want to be degraded with other customers listening. read more

by far the best bagel place in Huntington. the employees are always so friendly and kind! it's a busy place and you might need to wait a few minutes to get your order in but they're on top of it & i promise you the wait is quick AND WORTH IT! fire bagels !!! read more

Every time I come to this bagel shop the staff seem both miserable and confused and it's been a consistent theme i've seen all 3 times I have gone. The bagels are average and not worth feeling like i'm ruining the workers' days for making them do their own job read more

This place is just so good! If you wake up late & want a really well made egg sandwich, you have to try one from here! What a great way to start the day. The staff is awesome & always has something cheerful to say, especially after they recognize you. Also-it's very clean! read more

I visited Village Bagel, a newly opened Deli/Restaurant in Huntington Village, at 46 Gerard Street. This will be my go-to place for breakfast AND lunch. Yes, that's right. It's clean, neat, and the food is incredible. It's not just bagels (although you'll regret not trying one of these amazing NY bagels), but it's lunch too, with incredible chicken choices and a full line of Boars Head cold-cuts. The sandwiches are piled high and will not leave you hungry. And the staff is friendly and always smiling. Check it out! read more

Village Bagel Cafe - Best Bagels on Long Island!!!! - Delis Near Me - Huntington, New York

been under new management since october so disregard those negative reviews, best bagels and egg sandwiches in town

Excellent sandwiches and bagels. They have a variety of salads, meats and cheeses that go great with their yummy bagels. Good find! read more

My flat bagel was hard, burnt, tasteless, and loaded with cream cheese. Much scraping ensued. I will not return.

So happy to find a delicious local bagel shop with a friendly staff. We have been there several times, with my family members always ordering something different. We are never disappointed. Super friendly staff- we have even received free bagels several times! :) And they have rainbow bagels- which are a favorite with the kids. read more

I went back this morning after not being pleased with the bland taste of my bagel quite a while ago. Quite a difference! My poppy bagel had a nice crust and texture but a little too sweet for my taste. My wife, on the other hand, loved her plain bagel! I will stock up on them for the freezer and I will make the 20-minute drive to Bagel Boss in Elwood for my freezer supply! read more

Tried this place for the first time. The store is clean and inviting. The bagels and desserts are fresh and tasty. Will definitely go back.

Quick and friendly service, even on a busy Sunday morning, clean looking place. Bagels and vegetable cream cheese seemed to be pretty good.

Love this bagel store. 10/10. Only bagel store I will go to in Huntington village. Best coffee, staff is friendly, and unbeatable prices. Family run and right next to one of the main parking lots in the village. The salads are always fresh, bagels are light and fluffy, and the cream cheese selection is very diverse. Delicious!!!! read more