The place smells amazing when you walk in. Customer service is great. A very easy straightforward…read moremenu. You can order by the slice or get a whole pie for yourself. This pizza is absolutely delicious and has a unique crust that is not mass produced. Highly recommend.

I was born and raised in NYC. I'm in SD for a few months. That said, THIS PIZZA TASTE JUST LIKE…read moreHOME. NO JOKE! It is my top 3 pizza spot EVER! It strongly competes with my fav nyc pizza spots. So good. I got an 18" pie, half vodka, half regular. TOOOO GOOD. Random side note, the pizza box was built inside out and made me laugh rlly hard.

We are in Sioux Falls for cross country and really wanted some good pizza. We found it at Big…read morePoppa's Pizza. Friendly staff. Clean restaurant. Pizza was great. Thank you!!

The deep dish pizza is phenomenal! Every bit as good as Chicago favorites! I went to school in…read moreChicago and this pizza is great!! It is amazing and I believe one of the best pizzas in Sioux Falls! Love it. I will add pictures! Please try it! Btw today special the medium 2 topping deep dish was only $19.95. An amazing price. Go get one you will not be disappointed!

As someone who loves thin crust, this place is amazing. The location is really nice with the…read moreneighborhood feel. Service both times we've been here is so fast! The price is good as well.

Great pizza. Fast service and cool little neighborhood vibe. Well worth the very reasonable price…read more Highly recommend eating here.

It's definitely not the same as the old Valentinos, but it's still very, very good. I like the…read morelasagna with meat sauce. It's my go-to every time I order. Be sure to take a look at the lunch specials as there's a ton of food and the prices are hard to beat. I wish they would bring the s'mores desert pizza back!! It's worth a visit!

What is going on with Valention's? I have been ordering the same pizza since they opened. Even…read moreafter I broke my tooth on something in there beef. We order beef, mushroom and extra mozzarella cheese. Each time we ordered the toppings got smaller and skimpier each time. today I was met with a pizza with pretty much no sauce, very little cheese ( definitely not extra cheese) and hardly any beef or mushrooms. I don't think I'm going to order from them anymore. This is ridiculous. the same thing happened with their pastas. Godfathers anyone?

When you walk in it kind of reminds you of a Subway set up. It's a make your own pizza type of…read moreassembly. You start with your choice of white or wheat crust, the sauce, and the the cheese. I had a garlic and white sauce with provolone and mozzarella cheese. After that you add your meat and cheese. I had chorizo, bacon, and artichokes. We then added feta cheese, black olives, and tomatoes. Once you've picked your toppings they put it on a cooker grill that moves it through and cooks it. I was really surprised at well it baked. It was delicious. I paired it with a root beer and they had the most delicious cilantro ranch dipping sauce. I loved how light the cilantro was and it tasted fantastic with the crust. The pizzas were some of the best I've ever tasted and I loved how quickly the line moved which makes it a perfect place to stop for a quick lunch or sit and chat with friends.

This is our go-to spot when we are in need of great food and a downtown excursion. I love the…read moreoptions here and the store feels like a NYC pizza shop. The owners make it authentic.

My husband and I actually stumbled onto Tomacelli's completely by accident while cutting across the…read morewest side of Sioux Falls on our way toward downtown. And honestly, those accidental discoveries sometimes wind up becoming your favorite places. We were absolutely famished that afternoon and wanted something different from our usual stops when we noticed this little pizza place sitting quietly inside a fairly non-descript strip mall. At first glance, you might not expect much. Then you walk inside. The atmosphere immediately drew us in. Warm, casual, inviting, and filled with the kind of local neighborhood energy that makes you feel comfortable almost instantly. It had personality. Not manufactured "corporate chain pretending to be cozy" personality either. Real personality. Thankfully, the food completely lived up to the vibe. We ordered a large specialty pizza loaded with all the trimmings along with a smaller pepperoni pizza because my husband and I have fully embraced the philosophy that ordering "too much pizza" is not actually a real problem. It is simply future happiness. And because we apparently cannot order pizza without wings, we added a small wing order as well. The pizzas were absolutely fantastic. The crust had wonderful texture and flavor, the toppings were generous, the cheese was gloriously hot and melty, and everything arrived piping hot exactly the way pizza should. Even the smaller pepperoni pizza impressed us. Sometimes simple pizzas reveal the quality of a place better than overloaded specialty combinations do, and Tomacelli's absolutely delivered on both. Now the only small critique we had involved the wings. My husband and I personally tend to prefer traditional deep-fried buffalo wings over baked-style wings. That is simply our preference. However, even with that bias, the wings here were still flavorful and enjoyable enough that we really did not mind very much once we started eating them. And honestly, the biggest compliment we can give this place is simple: We kept coming back. Even though we live on the east side of Sioux Falls now, we still happily make the drive across town because local gems like this are worth supporting. More importantly, the consistency has remained excellent every time we have visited. That matters. Any restaurant can accidentally have one great night. The places that keep earning loyalty are the ones that continue getting it right over and over again.

It was my last day in SD. Saw the falls and wanted some pizza. Found Tomacelli's on my map, let's…read morego. Has a nice divey feel with the graffiti all over, Already lovin' it.! See the 80s video games, and my comfort level increases. I get to the counter and ask the guy "what's the signature item on the menu?" He offers a couple of things. One the recommended items was the Tomacelli Special. Lots of pepperoni, lots of cheese, sausage and ranch dressing as the sauce. Order and get some quarters to play Galaga. I get the pizza and it has tons of pepperoni, the crust has a nice color and cheesy. Grab a slice has some tasty pepperoni oil on there. That pizza is delicious. I didn't even miss the pizza sauce. Also got some cheesecake. Good stuff- solid dessert. I definite revisit and recommend.

The pizzas I ordered were the large version of Woody Allen (vegetarian) and I also got a split half…read moreand half sausage and cheese. Also some garlic toast. To go. The bill was $73 w a small tip. Worth it? We'll.. It's definitely tasty pizza. I would bring the right audience to this place in a heart beat.

I ordered ham and pineapple got pepperoni and sausage. They closed in 20 minutes by the time I got…read morehome and they wouldn't even answer the phone call. Worst place to get a pizza in Sioux Falls. I recommend a highly against it. No accountability for their mistakes no way to get a hold of them. They just let the phone ring and ring

Placed my order THREE HOURS in advance to a specific time. They were 25 minutes late and the pizza…read morewas luke warm at best. Service is key,, not impressed.

I love the pizza! Great hand tossed crust. Chewy and crispy edge, not too doughy. I had the Big…read moreNick. Loaded with toppings. Delivery was fast.