This place was so good! OMG the cheesesteak was perfect! I was pleasantly surprised at the size of "Adrianne" cooked to my order and the bread seamed like it had been steamed! Just delicious! I also had the fries the entire to go container was full of seasoned fries. For me they needed more flavor. But I give this place a 8.5 out of 10 and a must try. Forest Hills new Gem. read more

The food was amazing, I did the steak Philly. Service was great, really friendly and helpful!

The pizza was fantastic and for the price even better than fantastic. Personal size pizza was more like a medium! The owner was a total gentleman. read more

NY To Philly Steak - Personal size sausage pizza. - Burgers Near Me - Tampa, Florida

This place hot wings are fantastic! Amazing people . Little worried but my God that guy be throwing Down in that kitchen!

Was traveling for a weekend thank god I looked up this place we went for the pizza and ended up getting pizza and a Philly cheesesteak Wow best pizza and Philly cheesesteak we had flavors of the cheesesteak was great the pizza was also cheesy and ever the bread on it was good the service was amazing meet the owners amazing ambiance was great would definitely recommend this place read more

Great subs! Nice little place w friendly owners. We tried the Philly Cheese Steak and the Chicken Parmesan sub...both were delicious! Prices were reasonable too. We'll be back to try the pizza and canzone :) read more

NY To Philly Steak - Burgers Near Me - Tampa, Florida

I ordered a veggie pizza because it was the end of my busy season at work and I was just tired. Did not want to cook. This. Pizza is so good and flavorful with just the amount of rice toppings without being over the top. I will definitely be ordering again because I live right around the corner. read more

NY To Philly Steak - Veggie pizza - Burgers Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Hands down my favorite place in town. The quality and consistency if off the charts. And then there is the customer service! Next level! Go enjoy your time as a new regular. read more

See all

I absolutely love this place. This is my favorite pizza/cheese steak spot in Tampa. The service is so welcoming and homey. Keith, the owner and staff are always so cheerful and helpful. I have been going to them for years. The food is delightful, my daughter is a very picky eater and she loves this place. I have tried mostly everything off the menu even the new dishes and never disappointed. Reminds me when I was back in New Jersey enjoying a nice slice around a great atmosphere. read more

NY To Philly Steak - Burgers Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

A cheesesteak that would not be at all out of place on Broad Street right here in Tampa. Cozy little spot, food came out quick and delicious. Can't wait to come back and try their pizza and wings. Owners were super friendly and they even make zeppolis! read more

There is a new pizza guy in town. Located on old W. Linebaugh Ave, open only about 30 days, Keith moved from his food truck to this new location. A veteran pizza guy from New York, he bought the stack ovens he used to use in N.Y., refurbished them and brought them to Tampa. Keith specializes in Pizza, Wings, Burgers, Subs and Philly Cheesesteaks. A 16 inch thin crust Supreme Pizza and 18 wings set me back $55 tip included. The wing prices were very reasonable, the pizza price, not so much. Most places I rate a 5 are cheaper and have extra cheese. It was a heavy laden pie that is difficult to describe, the flavors kinda meld together for a very good pie that I will rate 4.5 stars. The cheese and sauce were somewhat bland and the bottom crust was very thin yet not crispy. The wings however were excellent in size, price, flavor and quality. I also saw another customers chicken parm which looked delicious. Next visit I will try the Philly and a hot sub. The business is new so expect a brief wait or call ahead to order. They take pride in offering fresh homemade product that is not pre-prepared so it takes a little longer. I prefer to wait for made fresh anytime. read more

See all

The menu offers a wide variety of deliciousness. The owners are welcoming and friendly. They having seating for you eat there and pretty clean. Pizza was made fresh and very delicious. read more

NY To Philly Steak - Supreme pizza - Burgers Near Me - Tampa, Florida

The best Philly cheesesteak I've ever had! Amazing food at great prices! I became a regular customer from that first day and bite! Good prices for amount and quality of food! And the owner was Patient, friendly, easy to talk to, hard working (as he has been the only one working every time I've been there!!) and took the time to explain and offer suggestions based on what I explained I was searching for! I LOVE small businesses that hit the ball out of the park and they certainly did! Never a mistake or disappointed! One of my new go to places! Must try for anyone! read more

NY To Philly Steak - The Mr. T- Extra Steak with Cheese (no onions on mine) - Burgers Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Solid 4 starting for me. Really good subs, pizza, and wings. Service was friendly and helpful. Would prob be my spot if I lived in the area. read more

See all

I ordered the Mr. T. It was by far the best Philly cheesesteak I have ever had in Tampa. There was an overflowing amount of steak, a ton of cheese, and enough mushrooms and onions to taste them in every bite. I made it a combo, and the fries were nice and crunchy with great seasoning. I walked in and ordered and the service was fast. I'm so glad I found this place! Hands down, the only place I will get I will get a Philly from in the future!! I will definitely be back... read more

Best Philly Cheese Steak around. Hands down. I've had a lot and this beats out every Philly spot in Tampa and in Philly itself. Very helpful and friendly and the atmosphere is welcoming. read more

Great owner amazing Philadelphia cheesesteak sandwiches. I will be back. He even gave my two dogs a Nathan dog hotdog read more

NY To Philly Steak - Amazing sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Tampa, Florida

This is the best pizza I have had in a while must try !! I can't wait to try everything else read more

I am new to the area and tried the pizza here after trying a different spot down the street a few weeks ago. While the pizza was not very good at all, the customer service was on point and the restaurant has potential. Way too much cheese on the pizza and I asked for it crispy. The only crisp was on the outside crust and the bottom was a soggy and greasy mess. The pepperoni had a strange taste to it. Just seems like they use cheap ingredients. I personally would not eat there again unless that changed to better ingredients or improve their cooking skills. If the taste of the food matched the customer service this place would get five stars. I liked the motorcycle in the dining area. read more

Ordered the burger and French fries. The French fries were soggy and greasy. The burger had good flavor but after a few bites the bun was falling apart. I was very disappointed. read more

The philly cheesesteak was amazing. The owner and staff was very friendly as well! You have to give it a try!

Knew this place as Magdelina's years ago. Went through a down time with other owners - BUT NOW - it is BACK with GREAT FOOD and new, amazing owners committed to the craft. Went back for the first time week of 3/17/2025 - met Keith and Chinseea (I'm sure I misspelled that - she's awesome) - great people with a passion for what they are doing. Had the cheesesteak - tried it with mushrooms, onion, green pepper and provolone. Was outstanding. The meat was plentiful and well-seasoned. I'm not from Philly and don't know about the cheesesteak "cult" (lol) - but this was dang good. We tried the personal pizzas Friday night and it was very good. Great red sauce, the bacon on the adult pizza was salty & plentiful - it was great. The kids personal cheese was great - the Littles loved it. The restaurant is clean - Keith's motorcycle is showcased inside and it looks great. Friendly, inviting - nice in every way. We are excited to have the hidden gem back in our little corner. Can't wait to try the whole menu. read more

Had 2 Mr T Philly cheesesteaks and a Stromboli delivered today. Both were amazing. Spoke with owners Keith and Cynthia before ordering for info on menu items. Both were very gracious and helpful and I knew with their passion for their food I would not be disappointed! Highly recommend and will visit in person soon! read more

This place is fantastic! I had a cheesesteak it was perfect plenty of veggies ,cheese , and meat . The fries were crisp and fresh. What more can anyone ask for ? The owner came to ask if I needed anything. Which I didn't. It's small place with lots of personality. Another customer had a pizza to go . I could smell it as they walked by. It made me want pizza too. I will definitely be coming back . read more

best cheesesteak ever and the most lovely people! can't wait to go back, and recommending it to everyone.

Eating here if you close your eyes you'll swear you're in Philly. Best Cheesesteak outside the 267. Sooo good.

Very nice people, always giving quality food and positive atmosphere. I'd recommend this place well over the other pizzerias.

Are use yelp to find a pizza place that had a luncheon special. I went there yesterday to try their lunch special. Unfortunately, they look to have closed their doors. Next to it was a food truck, but they had just move there and didn't know wat ad happened to it. He has not rented the place to open a brick and mortar for the food truck. It was called New York to Philadelphia steak. Selling sandwiches and pizzas. Since I was already there I decided to order. Obviously, they are known for their steak sandwiches, but I decided to try their Burger which I was told was 1/2 pounds of meat and hand dipped onion rings with their own special roulade sauce. Though did not expect much, it was a food truck, it was the best burger in 20 ears! He had seasoned it with his own special seasonings with: Mayo, catsup, pickle, a large cut of a juicy, ripe tomato, and a large section of crispy head lettuce (I did not want the mustard) I could barely get my mouth opened wide enough to take the first bite which was a blend of the crispy lettuce, condiments, the juicy tomato, and the very tasty burger. It was just a delight. I was in burger heaven. I cannot wait to go back the though I live in Spring Hill close to 50 miles away. And the onion rings, WOW evenly coated with I believe was panko breading .. The roulade was sort of like a French dressing (the homemade version and a bit of horse radish. It complimented the rings so well. So, far I have not found them oh this site, but until then just go to the truck beside the closed pizza shop. You will thank me. read more