First time customer. Fries were very good, I like the coating, they gave a generous amount compared to other pizza places. Steak hoagies were good. One with pizza sauce, one with mushroom sauce. Cashiers was very friendly. Price was good. Will be back. Thanks for giving a good first impression and making a nice dinner for us. read more

NYPD Pizza Delivery - Steak hoagy with pizza sauce - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

This place has GOOD pizza! I usually prefer a thick, crispy crust but I like their sauce and toppings so much that I feel like the crust is a nice balance. I enjoy speaking with with the owner as my pizza bakes or seeing the same delivery people who have been there for years. My go-to is the Italian Hoagy sans pepperoni and cheese fries. I also like the garlic butter chicken wings and fried pickles. The family size garden salad will fill 4 bowls easily. If you want something a bit different than how it is on the menu, they are happy to make it for you. But the website doesn't do a great job with this, so you will want to call them. Phone number is 481-NYPD. Kids love the pizza bread and chicken strips! Support small business and eat good food!! read more

See all

The first thing we noticed as we drive up... Manager not wearing mask. Walking around the entire kitchen like she didn't care. Young Man making pizza dough balls had mask around his chin. I didn't take his picture as I am sure he was a minor. Young man at register also had mask around his chin, also a minor I suspect. We picked up the food as it was already paid for. Got home and heated it all again to proper temperature to kill germs. Proper temperature couldn't save it from how greasy and terrible it was. After a few bites, the entire family looked around at each other and collectively said "this is terrible." Into the garbage it went. Never again. Terrible food. COVID-19 non-compliant. read more

NYPD Pizza Delivery - NOT FOLLOWING COVID PRECAUTIONS. No Masks - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Service was good and the food taste good but the pizza was kinda soggy. Not sure if this a normal thing for them or if it was a one off and it just happened to be my first time getting food from there. We got the veggies pizza added chicken. Like I said. Taste good but soggy May have to try again before I say go or no go read more

I love the food but I don't appreciate how the tip was changed. I left $6 on a $24 order (which is a good tip) yet my credit card company alerted me to the fact that the tip was 10. There's no way that I would tip 40% for pizza delivery. I called the manager and was told that the slip said $10. Then someone changed it. The manager did absolutely nothing. Make sure to get the receipt. read more

Crime Buster Extra Cheese!! AMAZING AS ALWAYS, French fries with cheese.. perfect side!!

Basic but decent food. Cheap so I'm happy. Speedy delivery time. It's not the best pizza in the world but it's farrr from the worst. Will definitely order again. Especially for the price. read more

NYPD Pizza Delivery - two slices of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Fantastic pizza. I used to live in northside and was sad to move away and not be able to get it. Now I get it whenever I'm back in Cincinnati. read more

First time and last time I order. Could have been the dasher but the next morning I woke up with cramps and the runs. Never again

Got a couple of steak hoagies. They were great. The bread was crispy yet soft on the inside. The meat, sauce, and cheese were really good. Will definitely go back again. read more

The best steak hoagie there is. The spaghetti and meatballs are delicious also. Delivery is quick and accurate. I'll definitely order from them again. read more

I love this place great value and good food the meatballs & spaghetti are amazing everything is great owner at cheviot is super nice rare mistakes are corrected read more

Really excellent steak hoagie! Can't wait to try the pizzas, they look great...I'll let you know when I do!

Dude the hoagies are unreal . Just be a hoagie place 1 less star for doing too much. Do less Good sauce read more

Just passing through and found this place on Yelp and gave it a try. If I lived in the area this would have just become my go to spot. This was a light pizza with a great taste. You know it's good when you take another slice and you're already full. If we're ever in the area again I'd love to try some of your other items, with a slice on the side of course. read more

Just ordered small pizza and a steak hoagie from cheviot store it arrived on time nice and hot and fresh I was very pleased with the food and price Thank You Dale read more

I order from here often, I tip 20% everytime. I've been a big fan since moving to the west side. Tonight, my food took an hour and ten mins (I live 8 mins away)... I called to let them know I order the same thing often and this time it was cold... first the manager told me bc it's fries and pickles that take 3 mins and my hoagie takes longer... then she began to tell me the driver made it to my house and realized he didn't have my food so had to go back and get it.... So not only did my food sit for and hour and 7 mins I was only given a $5 credit (my tip was $5.02 tonight). Sorry but y'all just lost a loyal customer bc the manager I talked to was unreasonable, I've worked in the industry for 16 years. You didn't make my experience any better, just made me upset. So y'all may need better management ‍ js read more

Hey for all you pizza lovers out there! For those of you that are all about great customer service and delicious pizza this might not be the place for you and here's why.... This use to be one of my favorite spots to go to for pizza but, not any more. Im very disappointed with the service I received with my last order and because of it is why I will NEVER go back to this establishment. On 6/26 I ordered a large pizza and wings for delivery. I was quoted 45 mins and it took over an hour and 30 mins for the food to be delivered. When the food arrived the pizza and wings were COLD... not warm, or a little warm ... it was COLD!! I called to share my dissatisfaction with how the food arrived and spoke to Sarah (I guess she was the manager in duty that night). Sarah apologized (somewhat unapologetic) and said they had been busy and that was the reason why the food arrived late and cold. (But, that's not my fault). After asking how she was going to make it right, She offered to redeliver the pizza but, at this point I didn't feel like waiting another hour and 30 mins for hot food especially since it was almost 8pm. When I asked what else could be done, she said she could apply at $20 credit to my account and all I had to do was call in and it would be applied to my phone number. That was a LIE!!! I called on 7/6 to redeem my credit and was told I had to call back to speak to Kevin the owner because he was not available at that time. So, I called back 20 mins later and asked to speak to Kevin. Kevin said, "we don't give out $20 credits" (?even though my order was well over $20) and said he would have to go back and listen to the call because "he was not able to verify with Sarah because she was on vacation." Kevin told me to call back on Sunday 7/8 so he could have time to pull be call, which is today. I called back yet again and of course got the runaround and was told "Kevin is not available right now call back in 20-30mins." Do you see the pattern with this place. They are very transactional and have NO CUSTOMER Service skills whatsoever to be a manager/store owner. Needless to say I never got my credit and refuse to keep playing this cat and mouse game with them. This was all apart of their scheme so they don't have to own up to their mistake. If you have a taste for pizza do not go here... go to LaRosa or another establishment that knows how to treat their customers. I promise you if you go here they disappoint it's just a matter of time. read more

They forgot a hoagie last week.We went to order online as we my husband is already there in front of the Cheviot location. and online and phone call orders are not being taken due to high volume of orders.My husband said there has been nobody coming in or leaving for deliveries so why aren't they taking phone or online orders? read more

This place is so under rated. Every time my family and I order from Here ,it is nothing but great. The sauce on their pizza is awesome and I Love their steak hoagies.i would give them a try , you will not be disappointed. read more

The food here is seriously so delicious! If you're looking for a good local place for great pizza and wings at a good price, this is the place to go. The owner is one of the nicest human beings ever and his staff is always very friendly and accommodating. Would give 10 stars if i could ! read more

NYPD Pizza Delivery - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Calzones are amazing. Reasonable priced and short wait time. COVID park, pickup and Go worked great

Delivery was a lot faster than the quoted time and the pizza was very good. I think this is going to be my new go-to pizza place.

Great pizza and hoagies. The cauliflower crust is even tasty- my oldest son didn't realize the night sticks were the cauliflower and we didn't tell him until he was done eating - the boy who won't eat a veggie liked it! The regular nightsticks are also a favorite. Great value for the money. read more

NYPD is delicious every time we've had it! Whether it's pizza, hoagies, cheese fries... as long as you pick up or get your food once it comes out of the oven, you are in for a treat!! read more

For a quick weeknight dinner, my husband found himself nearby NYPD Pizza and decided to carry out a meal for us. (Only carry out and delivery are available from this location.) He was going to order a two-topping medium pizza, but was informed a large (at about $10) would be cheaper due to a weeknight special. Score for us! NYPD has a number of great specials, including two hoagies and a large pizza for only $19.99. Their menu offers the typical pizza joint fare: specialty and build-your-own pizzas, hoagies, wings, spaghetti, salads, cheese sticks. Our pizza, especially for the price was above average, better than a Dominos or Papa John's. The crust was soft and chewy, the sauce tangy and sweet and the toppings plentiful. A good deal for your money, but nothing super gourmet. read more

Have been a loyal customer since we moved to Westwood in 2005. Have had our ups and downs as far as the food but really like supporting a locally owned place. For about a year every time we've ordered pizza it's just barely cut. As in you cannot get a piece out and have to re-cut it yourself. Not a tragedy but annoying. Now, for the third time in a row the pizza arrived at least 1/2 hour late, not cut AND cold. I'd love to continue ordering when there's more focus on the quality. read more

I have never been disappointed with NYPD Pizza. Constantly good food, and unbeatable prices. Great food, great service, and fast delivery!

Worse pizza experience ever. My 11 year old bagged for NYPD for dinner tonight. He was craving the ziti pasta. We put the hamburger we were thawing out back in the fridge and ordered online. The order was quoted as a 45 minute delivery. After an hour with no delivery, I called and was told the food was in the car out for delivery. Another 45 minutes past (we live about 10-15 minutes from NYPD) before we received our order. For those counting - that's almost 2 hours. As you can guess, the food was awful. Stone cold and almost all of it was inedible. We thought ahead (after about an hour and a 1/2 went by on the delivery wait) and warmed up the oven. Even with putting the food in the over to heat up, it was still awful. So here was a $45 cost that most was thrown in the garbage. My sons pasta was thrown out, cheese fried in the garbage, 2 personal pizzas were only 1/2 eaten then thrown in the garbage. The only thing that was somewhat edible was the hoagy. If you can't delivery your food in a timely and in an eatable condition, don't offer delivery. I don't know about most of you, but we are living on a tight budget and to throw $45 out the window on our splurge night is not ok. read more

First of all the delivery guy had no mask on. I ordered a pizza 1/29/21 with a card. On my transactions it says pending. The following day I did the same thing and when the pizza man says that it was not paid for. If you order from here use cash only. The manager is T. This is thievery at its finest read more

This has become our family's go-to for pizza. List of fresh ingredients to choose from, and the friendliest owner of ANY restaurant/takeout place I've visited. Don't miss the fried pickles. read more

I basically survived off NYPD Pizza when I first moved to Cheviot. The staff here are always so friendly and the delivery is pretty fast. I LIVE for their cheese fries. Absolutely the best I've ever had. The hoagies are also super dope especially the steak and chicken ones. Also prices are soooo affordable which gives me even more reason to love this place! read more

Friendly staff and quick delivery. Food is ok. The flavors aren't balanced and the salt is overdone. Basic pizza but not a special flavor experience. The calzone is straight heavy mozz, not ricotta. Good for the price overall but not a special flavor. read more

So, I still haven't tried the pizza again. I've realized though, their real strengths are their hoagies. The steak hoagie is bomb, and for the price the portions are large. I also like their popcorn chicken. Although the hoagies are good, I don't reccomend the parmesan chicken sandwich; the sauce tastes like it from a can. read more

Great group of people that let me order some chicken wings even though they were technically closed. I was soooo hungry at the time, God bless that young man who unlocked the door. I do not think that I have had the pizza but will get around to it the next time I am in Cheviot. read more

NYPD Pizza Delivery - Pizza Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

The new cauliflower crust pizza is two thumbs up! Fast delivery also from the Harrison Ave location!

So, for Cincinnati, it's pretty good pizza. But it is not as good as it used to be. It used to actually be somewhat "New York" style. But not anymore. The sauce is good, but the crust is not NY style and THEY CUT IT IN SQUARES! Ugh!! That is not at all NY pizza! Over the weekend I tried to order online and there was nowhere that you could even specify that you wanted it cut in slices instead of squares. So I called to order and they acted like cutting it in slices was the most challenging thing ever. Seriously I got off the phone with the girl telling me that she would do her best. What on earth? (To be fair, it WAS in slices when it got here, but how is this not the default?!) read more

Good pizza good service! There's not a lot to say about this place other than I'd recommend it to anyone who likes pizza.

This place has tasty food! I love the steak hoagies and bacon/pepperoni pizza. The owner (Kevin) is a great guy as well. He will tell you jokes while you are waiting on your order. I have never met an owner as nice and accommodating as him. The prices are great as well! read more

Good food. Sure. But even better staff. I picked up a pizza on the way home from work tonight. The owner must have felt like I waited too long so after giving me my food and apologizing for the wait he told me to grab a 2 liter of soda on the house. Considering how many good pizza options there are in this city it can be hard to pick a favorite. This Harrison Ave crew just made it a little easier. Keep up the good work! read more