I have dealt with o'tooles on occasion never a bad experience but super overpriced. I was quoted $1000.00 for new tires/mount/balance. I bought my own tires online and took my bike to a different shop total cost $590.00 with better tires than they offered me.imo. I did not get a wash though. read more

Pray lay back place they have all kinds of bikes. And they seem to know there stuff. All kinds of new and used bikes

Bought a brand new 2021 Electra Glide Unlimited. After visiting several dealerships, O'Toole's gave me the best price. I was treated extremely well. Everything was done timely and the staff took the time to keep me updated with the status of my purchase. I'm very happy with the overall experience. read more

See all

Words can't explain what a WONDERFUL experience it was to purchase our new bikes from Dan and the crew. We travel over 100 miles to deal with the BEST Harley Davidson dealership in New York, while there are 3 here in our backyard. Bob in parts is so efficient and precise, thank you. We HIGHLY Recommend O'TOOLS Harley DAVIDSON. Thank you as always for another GREAT experience. Love you guys. Diana and Bob read more

O'Toole's Harley-Davidson - Motorcycle Repair Near Me - Wurtsboro, New York

Great guys with wealth of knowledge. Didn't now they been around for 40yrs! Always great to hear the folks stories. Best advise is "take the long way home"...Cheers! read more

GREAT PLACE. Awesome staff from sales to service management is very welcoming, professional and approachable they are my top choice for Harley dealers and they should be yours ! I definitely recommend thus far ! From K.D read more

I bought the bike over a month ago there's some shifting problems and the guy told me oh well we only do 30 day warranty but meanwhile the salesman told me that we do a 60 day warranty so I would never use old tools again they are lying piece of shit they supposedly went through the pipe before I got it never did they take stuff off the bike when you ask him to leave it on This fucking people are fucking liars . read more

Great shop, good selection of products, staff was extremely friendly and helpful. Don't know about the service department.

Kim, Frank and the tech Tommy, always do a great job taking card of my Harley, Super Staff.... Fast Service, Always Courteous... Nice place to do business. Ken Smith Port Jervis read more

Called parts to try and find a replacement part and because the guy had other customers in store he "couldn't help me". Lame

I've purchased Harleys from other dealers, Tom goes all out to get you the right bike for your riding style and budget. Frank and Kim in service are a real pleasure to deal with also. Bottom line they may be farther away than other dealers but trust me it's worth the trip to buy here. read more

O'Toole's Harley-Davidson - Motorcycle Repair Near Me - Wurtsboro, New York

My wife and visited O'Toole's for the first time this past weekend. The people were very friendly and helpful. As a first-time Harley owner I had a lot of questions and needed some patient help getting outfitted for a new helmet, boots and other items. We will definitely be back. I will update this review when I bring my bike in for its 5,000 mile service. read more

After a extensive search for my new bike, I was drawn to O'Tooles by their sales manager Richie. He was helpful and outgoing over the phone before I ever stepped in the door. Once I was there with my trade he worked tirelessly to get me a good deal. I would pick these guys over any other Harley dealers in the area. Their entire team is great and you won't regret the experience of buying from them. read more

Horrible! Should not be an authorized Harley dealer!!! Couldn't be bothered for anything! Rude!!!!! Don't waste your money here.

While traveling I-84 back to Connecticut from West Virginia, the overtemp light on my 2015 FLHTKL came on. Before I made it to the next exit, my check engine light also came on. My GPS Dealer Locator identified O'Tooles as the closest dealer. I called and explained my predicament to Kim, the Service Manager. She told me that as long as the Check Engine light was yellow and didn't change to red, I could safely drive there. She said they were quite busy and didn't know if they would be able to fit me in, but she would try. When I arrived, Tom, one of the dealership owners, offered to drive me to a local restaurant if I was hungry while they determined the cause of the overtemp condition. My bike was brought into the service area and diagnosed with a faulty coolant recirculating pump within 15 minutes. Fortunately for me, they had a replacement in stock. Kim said she would try to rearrange the scheduled work in process to free up a lift for my bike. I was offered a ride to a local motel in the event that the repair couldn't be completed by the time they closed. This story has a happy ending for me. Kim was able to free up a lift, the part was replaced, and I was on my way out of their parking lot as they were locking up for the night. Because of my Extended Service Plan, I only paid $50.00 for the repair. Consider this the next time you're in the market for a new or used motorcycle: If this is how O'Tooles treats a stranger they possibly will never see again, think about how they must treat their customers! read more

Every experience is better than the last. Never had anything but positive experiences. I'm getting another bike from there this week. Great deal, great service. Highly recommend this place. read more