A hidden gem. Very tasty pizza. Lots of beer choices. Great atmosphere. Lots, and lots, of outdoor seating in the nice weather. Get there early or be ready to wait! read more

Great food and beer!! Service is fast and friendly. Coolers of frozen German food to purchase and you can also purchase your favorite beer to go. Loved it all read more

The Germantown area doesn't have a plethora of restaurants, so it's nice to see a new option in Old Germantown. I didn't have time to sit down and eat today, so I ordered smoked kielbasa with crinkle fries to go and had a 12oz glass of Sprecher root beer while I waited. I'm glad that I had checked out their website first and knew exactly where to go because the restaurant is tucked behind a barn and there's no signage (yet) indicating where the restaurant is located. There is a red wagon out by the road as a marker for those who know to look for it. The building itself is really cool looking and a nice change of pace from standard, cookie cutter restaurants. The smoked kielbasa had great flavor. I liked the toasting on the bun, but it made the bun super flaky and a bit messy to eat in the car. The crinkle fries came with a dipping sauce which I chose not to use. Without the sauce, they we lightly salted and had some grated parmesan cheese on them. I thought they could have used another minute in the fryer to get a little crispier. My total came to $14.50. According to the menu the kielbasa and fries were $8.99, which means the 12oz Sprecher was much more expensive than it's worth. Unfortunately the menu doesn't list prices for soda, so I'm only left to simple math. I look forward to stopping back when I have more time and ordering a wood fired pizza. The one I saw leave the kitchen before I left looked awesome. read more

See all

First time trying OG! Busy Friday night, but everything was delicious! Loved, the beer, sausages & pizza! They even brought us beer samples, so we could try allthe different beer. read more

This place is a hidden gem in the countryside. We went the other evening and I felt like I was entering a secret world. The sounds of nature, the stars, the big open seating.. it was so relaxing and one of the best meals I've had in a long time. The Mexican Street Corn pizza was AMAZING. One of the best pizzas I've had in a very long time. They have a great variety of interesting pizzas. I will absolutely be back here...multiple times! In case the owner reads this, some ideas to add to the menu are: -Caramelized onion, pear, and goat cheese w/ a honey drizzle pizza -Loaded baked potato pizza -Goat cheese & fig melt (like the Brie & fruit) w/ warm bread or warm pita I think you guys would rock these flavors! So great here. Truly such a good find. Can't wait to come back. read more

Old Germantown - Mexican Street Corn pizza: mouth watering and DELICIOUS. - Pizza Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

Service was never there. Food? To long and tasteless. Ok ambiance, not worth effort to get to.

Great, fresh. Need breakfast menu Bigger pizza. Excellent food. Great people. Just wish they had a breakfast.

Relaxing, patriotic & family friendly restaurant! The service was SO quick- within 5 minutes of ordering we had our food! Everything was fresh and delicious, and the wait staff were so pleasant and courteous, we gave them a big tip. They also had live music which we loved, so that was a plus! read more

See all

I've lived in Germantown for 14 years and didn't know about this place. We decided to try something new and ended up here, and I am so glad we did. Everything was amazing! Customer service was great and friendly. The restaurant and bathrooms were super clean. The best part of this was obviously the PIZZA! Man o man, this pizza was one of the best I have ever had in my life. Full of flavor, the cheese was perfectly gooey, and the crust was addicting. 10/10 read more

Old Germantown - Mushroom Ricotta Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

If you are looking for a family-friendly refuge from a brisk fall day, this is the place! The beer is fantastic, decor & ambience is warm and inviting, and the pizza is unique and delicious! The owners and staff are extremely welcoming, and accommodating - highly recommend the Jack-o-lantern, and Mexican corn pizzas! read more

Old Germantown - Pizza Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

See all

Down home family run restaurant on a farm. Awesome venue even in the middle of winter. We have been multiple times, but haven't typed a review until today. This is an awesome venue, even in the middle of winter. The restaurant is on a farm just outside the main village of Germantown. Old Germantown offers great pizza, yes pizza, as well as delicious fresh made sausage, and 18 local beers on tap. I've only posted a few photos over the last year or so, but we have not been dissapointed with any of our orders. Give it a shot, hope to see you there. read more

See all

Really interesting place. You need to know it's there to go there. Glad we found it. Great pizza and in house brews. Comfortable and cozy. Great service. We will be back for sure. Scott and his wife are onto something special in casual dining. Thank you for your creativity and hard work. read more

Great food and wonderful people! A unique atmosphere!! We have been going since they first opened. My wife wanted a salad and at that time they did not offer one. They made one for her out of what they had!! On our way there tonight! read more

We came in with a large group of Four Families on a Sunday afternoon around 3:00 PM. There was enough space for us to sit right down and grab tables inside. Parents all enjoyed a few beers ranging from the lagers to the fruit ales. I only heard good things. My wife and I split the angry chicken pizza and a salad that were both excellent. Our boys enjoyed a cheese pizza and the pretzel bites. One of the other couples went with the Greek pizza and I was a little jealous. After dinner, we went outside and enjoyed the beautiful view in the massive outdoor seating. The kids busied themselves while the parents socialized for a little longer. Several of the kids enjoyed root beer floats for dessert. Not to bury the lead, but I also purchased some of the smoked sausages to go. Four chicken gouda, one jalepeno cheddar (for me), and an oktoberfest. We cooked up the chicken gouda and jalepeno cheddar sausages last night. They were amazing. Worth a return trip by themselves. This is a beautiful space with excellent food and drinks. We will be sure to stop in again when next in the area. read more

I love this place! This looks awesome. The staff is great. The owner is wonderful. I can't say enough about their brewed beer. Love love love. read more

BEST! Gem! Ever! I had the most positive experience here and I cannot stop raving about it to family and friends. While following the GPS, I definitely thought we took a wrong turn, but surprisingly the dirt road means you're heading the right direction :) The staff was beyond friendly, the local beers they have on tap are all scrumptious, and the pizzas... oh the pizzas were out of this world. My boyfriend and I ordered the Currywurst pizza and Charcuterie pizza. They were very unique and tasty. We inquired about playing the Marquette basketball game on the indoor projector, and they promptly honored our request. It was a real peak of the night. I selfishly want Old Germantown to stay a "hidden" spot, so the wait times don't blow up, but I wish only the best for this business! read more

See all

I'm just done with this place. 90 minutes. For a pizza? Get more ovens or more staff. I'm just really disappointed this place can't build up more capability. Wait times are ridiculous. read more

Old germantown is a great spot! Pizza is wood fire and every one I've had is delicious. Beer is good as well. My kids love the pretzel bites with beer cheese. Love the rustic inside but the outside patio is what makes this a wonderful summer spot. Service is more self service (walk up and order and they deliver to your table). Usually wait for food isn't bad but when it's busy it can become long as they can only cook a few pizzas at a time read more

This is a pretty cool place. They have live music on the weekends. I've looked and looked for some good Hungarian sausage and thankfully I found it here. All of the sausages are homemade and probably some of the best I've ever had. The big hit though seems to be the wood fired pizza, and I can see why. I would compare it to the pizza served at Via Napoli at Epcot. They have an in-house brewery which is always a nice addition. They sell the sausage by the pound to take home with you as well. Try both the regular as well as smoked Hungarian their beyond fantastic. Lastly, they have these crinkle cut fries (old school style) that are out of this world. read more

See all

My husband and I made reservations for a Friday evening at 5:30. Our first time here. We both had a taste for pizza. We ordered in line and we're directed to our table. A few minutes later we were told it would be 1.5 hrs before the pizza would be ready or we could order something else from the menu. We chose sausages on buns with fries. The food was good but wasn't that desired pizza. It was suggested by "seasoned" patrons and an employee to get there earlier or another day besides Friday. Their menu is basically many amazing looking pizzas, 2 types of salads and a sausage platter or sausage on a bun w/fries...and a couple desserts. So it's a pizza restaurant. They only have ONE wood-fired pizza oven. We WILL try again for that pizza! The atmosphere was comfortable, a little loud, but kinda beer garden-like. Employees all were super friendly. Loved the farm setting. Husband didn't like the dusty gravel road! ‍ read more

This was our first but not last time here! The menu had something for everyone and the beer list was unlimited options!! Truly great food, beer and service. A must see and taste experience!! read more

Old Germantown - The Forager and The Red...Delicioso!! - Pizza Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

Awesome location and spacious interior with a large amount of outdoor seating. The owners and their staff were extremely polite and accommodating when the place was packed! The pizza was very good and the beer selection was decent. We will be back! read more

I can't speak to the food but getting to the restaurant is a challenge. There are no signs from the road into the restaurant. We just drove up a driveway that looked right according to my gps and even then there were no directions as to where to park. I understand the restaurant was closed that day but do they really take all signage down.? We did peak Into the eating area from the what we assume was the parking lot. It did not look inviting. Picnic tables on gravel I don't think we'll be back when they are open read more

Cutest hidden restaurant. Tons of craft beers and the best pizzas. Numerous specialty pizzas, I tried the Greek with feta cheese and olives while my husband had a pizza with pulled pork and burnt ends. They're known for their sausages so we'll be back. Highly recommend! read more

See all

We arrived at about 4:30, we're told the pizza wait was about 40 minutes. Great, no problem. We quickly ordered two pizzas, and appetizer, and drinks. Or appetizer and drinks came out very quickly. One pizza came out within 30 to 40 minutes, what we expected. But then our second pizza never came. After over an hour of waiting we went to ask about the pizza. The cashier told us she would check into it. We never heard back. And we never got the second pizza. Finally, after over 2 hours we closed up our tab and left. The one pizza, classic cheese, was delicious. The craft beer was really good too. However, there's a problem with service. The kitchen clearly cannot keep up with the demand. Because there are no actual servers and you just order everything at a counter, there is no one who can help you if you're already gets lost. read more

Very cool venue with really good food and hospitality. Worth the detour as it's a bit off the beaten path. Homemade sausages had great flavor and there were so many things on menu we wanted to try. The gentleman who was helping our table gave us a lot of recommendations for things to do in Green Bay, even though we were Niners fans :) Suggestion to make seating and ordering process more clear. Probably wasted a good 15 minutes at beginning waiting for QR code or menus to be brought to table and wasn't clear if we were supposed to go to counter to order or not. read more

Old Germantown - Pizza Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

Great new restaurant featuring homemade sausages and wood fired pizza. We had three pizzas (Chicken sausage and peppers, Pepperoni and black olive, and Charcuterie). All were great- thin crust sourdough cooked at high temp for crisp crust and nice char on the bottom. Barbecue beef sandwich was good but pizza was better. They make all their own sausage - lots of love goes into their food for sure. Sourdough is handmade too! 10-12 beers on tap including lots of local choices and one of the their own. Brand new facility in a wide open space . Planning to have brewery and market on site and expand the restaurant hours beyond the weekends as things progress. Menu changes daily but I assume they will have some regular items. Nice folks - owner stopped by a couple of times to ask about the food and service. We will be back and highly recommend! read more

Old Germantown - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

See all

Delicious food and wonderful atmosphere. Definitely a hidden gem! Tried several of the local beers and enjoyed most. Pizzas are great! Haven't tried the sausage yet but will soon! Lovely place to have dinner in the summer if you can snag a seat outside! read more

Have been wanting to visit for several months, went yesterday afternoon, certainly did not disappoint. Pretzel bites, sausage sampler (came with a huge basket of hot crinkle cut fries) Street corn pizza and Margherita pizza. All of it was so good. Excellent variety of WI craft beer. Live music. Staff was very friendly and attentive. We will be back again soon read more

This place is absolutely great! Wonderful and friendly staff. Awesome beer selection. The pizza is to die for. We loved the sourdough crust! Highly recommend. We were a little lost when we first drove in so be sure to take the driveway on the left to the back of the property. read more

Old Germantown - The Forager pizza - Pizza Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

Loved this place! Fantastic service!! Everyone was sooo nice and friendly! We even had the nicest man who kept coming around and making jokes and asked if we wanted him to take our group pictures. It seemed like everyone working there actually really liked being there and that shows. We had a margherita pizza with pepperoni and it was delicious. Our friends all had different ones and everyone enjoyed them very much. Super place with a nice pour on the wine to boot. Thanks for a great evening! read more

I have been here many times, and it's always awesome. Had the privilege of meeting Scott the owner. This is simply the best pizza in Wisconsin and they also have a great beer selection. They also have a large outdoor area which was great because it was a beautiful night. read more

Awesome place, hard to find but worth it. The pizza is amazing. Definitely worth the drive. read more

Old Germantown - Pizza Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

A hidden treasure in Germantown. Fantastic pizzas, delicious homemade sausages and live music for starters. A great selection of Wisconsin craft beers to compliment those pizzas...our family favorite pizza's: Mexican Street Corn and the Greek MVP. Look for their own craft beers in the near future read more

Old Germantown - Mexican Street Corn - Pizza Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

See all

Yes yes yes!!! Nailed it. Pizza and beer on a kid friendly farm with staff that makes you feel like family, what more can you ask for?! Oh yes! A dog friendly patio. Lots of wood fired pizzas and beer which is brewed there. Ample outdoor space. The inside is smaller so it can get tight during the winter months. Heads up-they can get really backed up during peak times so keep this in mind and anticipate long waits. read more

We had a large party and shared several different pizzas. They were all delicious and everyone was happy with the beer selection, too!

Great!!!! Been there so many times, never had anything we were disappointed with!! The owner is the best!!!!

Nice experience, Food tasty, great service and ambient was also surprisingly nice.We will definitely go back. read more

Love the sausage platter as an appetizer if you have a large group. The pizza is only available Thursday through Sunday. They can run out of pizza as they make a set amount of dough for the wood fired oven. Very friendly owners. It can be hard to find. Look for the red wagon on the east side of the road and follow the dirt road to the left. read more

Oh my goodness how did I not know about this place? Pizza and beer menu is inexpensive. Great service. Off the beaten path, but totally worth it. A great vibe! read more