As a local who has been living in the area for 20 years , I've seen the ownership change over multiple times. I used to come here all the time and eat when I was younger with friends and family, however since the new owners took over years ago it has not been the same. The price of food has gone up significantly and the quality has gone down. If you are a tourist I would recommend driving 15 more minutes to Cole's Corner and eating at the Squirrel Tree. There prices are about the same but you get way more food, and it's consistently good. I'm sorry for this review but the last 2 times I've eaten here has disappointed me enough to leave this comment. read more

Great cool at home pizza, an easy bake, and a big treat. BBQ was excellent, but the sides were outstanding! Spinach and seasonal Brussels sprouts ran out fast! read more

Good food. Astonishingly bad service. When we asked for silverware that the server didn't bring us, instead of handing it to us (5 seconds max), he turned around and took another table's order. We had to get it ourselves. I asked for refills of coffee 3 or 4 times before another server took pity and brought some over. Pointlessly bad really since he only had the one other table. The food was good enough I'd still go back and just hope he's off that day. read more

*Diner food with friendly down home service *I had the chicken fried steak and while the gravy lacked flavor and was loaded with flour the hasbrowns were crispy and the sausage was juicy *Good to support a local place and their wallpaper and logging history is cool too read more

See all

New owners fabulous breakfast!!! I saw the reviews and was a bit hesitant but I'm so glad I went!! I was here on a girls weekend and came her with 4 friends it was so good, the biscuits are amazing, they even have a gluten free English muffin for one of us who couldn't have those amazing biscuits!! Eggs were done perfect ham and bacon were great!! We will be back! read more

We took a little trip and found this place by our air b&b the food and the staff were great! I wish we had this in Los Angeles! Would recommend if in town :) read more

ok, i live here. i don't know why it took me so long to eat at the Old Mill Cafe...im sorry i waited so long. The Beef Brisket Sandwich was delicious, excellent flavors..., great additions to the inside (i cant remember what they were) but it was juicy, flavorful, and generous of size. the homemade chips were delicious too. Owner Kim seals the deal, friendly and welcoming. Try it, you won't be disappointed. read more

TL,DR: Great food, especially the meats. Clearly home-made, home-smoked, and home-seasoned. Gluten free is done really well. The menu is a bit limited, but it's a cafe not Red Robin, so that's expected. Where they really shine is in the variety of meat choices available for their burgers and sandwiches, and in their attentiveness to food source, simplicity, and allergies! My wife had their lamb burger (Gluten Free) which was done to perfection, and I had the pork sandwich. While I was expecting a pulled pork (I didn't read the menu too closely) I got a glorious smoked pork sandwich which far exceeded expectations. My wife has Celiac, so when the owner/hostess/waitress (yes, she's all three) told us that all their meats, sauces, and rubs were gluten free I thought my wife would jump up and hug her. It can be a struggle finding places that inspire confidence, Old Mill Cafe knocked it out of the park. This little spot was a great find for us, and we definitely plan to be back. We were staying at Fish Lake when we needed dinner; rather than drive all the way back to Leavenworth for something to eat, we gambled and ended up here. They even left the place open a bit after closing for us and one other straggler couple; treated like locals on our first time there. I like it. read more

Fantastic! Ribs, brisket sandwich, chili, Rosemary French fries, salad: everything is home cooked and tastey. Prices are very reasonable. This is the best food in the Plain area by far. Just heard the mac and cheese is great! These are new owners and they're doing a great job. read more

Old Mill Cafe - American Near Me - Leavenworth, Washington

Love the Old Mill. A family I work for has been coming here for years (20+) Never had a bad experience and my favorites are the prime rib special on the weekends and the chicken fettuccine Alfredo. I'm not a dessert person, but the Marionbery Pie has changed my mind on pie. The staff is always very friendly and prompt. Love this place. read more

Great burger, wings and feel! This place has the local feel but extremely welcoming staff! Best burger in Peshastin !

We were just taking a drive and decided to stop. The menu was a surprise. Both my husband and I have lived in Texas in the past. The owners are from Texas. My smoked macaroni and cheese with brisket was delicious!!! My husband had the smoked burger that had a layer of pork belly on top of the burger. Scrumptious. The Old Mill is worth taking a detour to. Prices were reasonable, quality excellent. Expect to come here again. They are doing drive through take out you order online. read more

We love this place! Great food and great people. Corn beef hash is my favorite breakfast. The hot wings are excellent and the smoke house burger is mouth watering! Old Mill Cafe is a great place to eat! read more

Old Mill Cafe - American Near Me - Leavenworth, Washington

Small town charm with pleasant & efficient customer service. I was really happy to see how clean the entire cafe was. Most smaller diners I have been in tend to let that go, but not here. The biscuits & gravy were some of the most flavorful we have ever had with just a touch if rosemary. Bacon was definitely butcher cut. The 1 waitress handled the place alone very well & didn't even seem overwhelmed. Prices very reasonable for their entire menu. This is the example if the "perfect small town cafe". We will have to try the pizza next. read more

We were happy to find Old Mill open at 6:30pm the day of our arrival to the area with 5 hungry kiddos! I called to make sure the kids burgers were plain and they were so kind and reassuring. They cooked our order even though it was close to closing time and were gracious when we picked up. The food was quite good and everyone was happy with their order. Thank you! read more

Highly recommend to eat here if you come to lake Wenatchee Park. Very good food and atmosphere just about 4 miles from Lake Wenatchee state park. There are only 4-5 restaurants and diners around here, and I don't want to drive 19 miles to Leavenworth for lunch. This cafe is in a cute small town called Plain and located in the plaza with cute hardware/souvenirs shop, coffee shop, and grocery. I order smoothies, mac&cheese, brisket slider,and tater. Everything tastes fresh and great. This place could be in Seattle and survive. I don't eat here because of limit choices, but because of the food quality. People who like big plate might not satisfy. This place has medium and small plate. Small plate is just about $5-$6. My small piece of slider and smoothies come out about 10$. *** kid mac&cheese is so good. It does not taste like kid food*** read more

See all

We celebrated our 26th wedding anniversary in lockdown. (Well, stay home stay safe). Old Mill made it perfect. Not only did they deliver delicious food to our front door, but they wrote very encouraging messages on our take out boxes. Food was perfect, hard to do in a to-go box. Highly recommend! read more

Excellent service and delicious food. I came in with my wife and 2 friends. They both got Skillet Scrambles and my wife & I split the Pork Burrito. The burrito was good, not greasy and, when paired with the valentina salsa picante, it was quite yummy. We had the large orange juice (Simply Made) and it got the job done. Would recommend and would return! read more

Breakfast was great!! Got our food to go. Ordered through the online menu and picked it up at the drive through window. Staff was super nice and friendly. We had the biscuits and gravy, breakfast sandwich and the skillet. Brisket was tinder and the right amount of smoky flavor. Bacon was thick and crispy.... needless to say but we couldn't of been more happy. Hats off the the Old Mill Cafe. I'm sure I'll be back soon! Probably tomorrow. read more

Great customer service. Quality food. I ordered the streusel french toast. It was delicious. Ambiance is nice.

We were pretty disappointed in our experience. We sat at the counter and based off the way our glasses stuck to the counter, the counter had not been wiped down in a long, long time. I ordered the Morning Sandwich with the cheddar bagel and bacon. The bacon was on one side of the sandwich and there was no tomato which was supposed to be on the sandwich. My husband ordered a beer and according to two servers, there was something wrong with the taps and/or the CO2. So, my husband opted for a bottled beer and his first two choices were out. Our food timing was also really bad. My husband's meal sat on the counter for a good 10 minutes before my meal was ready. About half way through our meal another server came on and simply turned on the CO2 and poured two beers for other customers. The staff seemed very disorganized and the food was meh. It's possible we just came on an off day but for a Friday on 4th of July weekend, I was very let down. read more

Who knew I would find the best breakfast in Plain Washington! I chose the skillet scramble (mushroom, broccoli, poblano peppers with smoked pork) IT WAS HEAVEN!! Service was excellent too. Can't wat it to return. read more

Great people and an excellent breakfast. Donuts rock as well. Extra thick bacon can't miss

Honestly menu selection was decent but overall the food was greasy in terms of too much cooking or frying oil on the dishes. Perhaps more detail in how their menu is prepared we might see improvement. Interior was not clean, chairs and table were 'sticky', can tell its been a while with a good wipe down. Carpet was unsettling, needs to be removed. Concept and direction are there just needs better execution. Maybe it'll get better. read more

Love this little cafe! I had the Cast Iron Skillet with some kick ass brisket and my niece had the Incredible Brisket Biscuit. Our food was delicious, waitress was super fun and friendly, service was great! We will definitely be adding this place to all our future mountain day itineraries!! read more

Great food and customer service. Clean, family friendly. We now have made it a point to eat here when we are in the Plain and Leavenworth area. read more

We ordered two lone star BBQ platters, one with brisket and the other one with pork. For sides we ordered slaw, corn, fries and beans. BBQ pork, corn, beans and biscuits with honey butter were pretty good. Unfortunately, brisket was not edible as it was half pure fat and remaining meat portion was very difficult to chew. Slaw was probably days old with veggies turning black. I was really looking forward to have a Texas-style BBQ brisket again, but it was not even close to BBQ I had in Texas. Perhaps since we ordered a take-out they felt it was acceptable to pack this to go. read more

The owners are amazing and are super friendly and prompt. They are very accommodating with our orders with any changes/add ons. And the food is delicious, comes out fresh and hot! They have outdoor and indoor seating and it's very clean. We will definitely be going back regularly. read more

Found this spot on our way back from Leavenworth; what a great find!! Staff was super friendly and relatable, and food was incredible!! Would absolutely recommend! read more

Old Mill Cafe - Country Breakfast Platter - American Near Me - Leavenworth, Washington

Nice restaurant environment and friendly staff. We went for their signature Crab/Shrimp Louie salad. It was a big disappointment because despite advertising fresh it tasted old and dull! My first clue should have been that nobody else was eating it. read more

We have been making the drive from Leavenworth to the Old Mill for years now. Unfortunately, we have only had their breakfast, which is fantastic! We will have to try and come for lunch and dinner. It is family owned and run and everyone working is happy, fun and great at customer service. The food is really good as most of it is all homemade in house. The owner/chef smokes his meats. The bread and pastries will shove you off your diet but once in awhile is ok. they also seem to do a booming drive-thru coffee business out a side window. read more

We are spending the week at Natapoc Lodge in Plain, WA. Old Mill catered our lunch on 5/30 and it was amazing. We had brisket and BBQ pork that was incredibly tender and well seasoned. The sides were delicious and the chocolate chip cookie to die for! Thanks Old Mill from the Brookdale Senior Living Nurses. read more

Great place to hangout and relax. especially with a nice friendly waiter like Michael, I appreciate his professionalism and he was very attentive! thanks and I hope to visit this cafe soon. great quality atmosphere:-) 11:11 good luck read more

Being the closest thing to our cabin we decided to get dinner from here. Chicken fried steak was good but everything else was mediocre. Chef was not wearing a mask while preparing our food. Mac and cheese was bland even with the added bacon bits. Brisket was half fat so didn't get our money's worth. read more

Such a cute place with historical Plain community charm! From the walk down history lane In pictures surrounding the cafe, to the comfort food menu, this place has it going on. The wings are maybe the best wings in WA state... seriously, not a better traditional style wing on the East side of the Cascade mtns. Try the pulled pork or the brisket sandwiches, they are outstanding. Great smoke, the fried onion bits kick it off with a special crunch. So good! The local family that recently purchased this establishment are super friendly and have really stepped it up a notch. Cheers! It's in Plain but far from Ordinary;) read more

New management sucks. Horrible service, sub par food. Spent two hours here and spent the majority of the time waiting for menus, waiting for food, waiting for my check and a to go box. The waitress kept disappearing for ten minutes or more at a time when there were plenty of people waiting for seats, waiting to get their orders taken, and tables waiting to be cleared. I ordered the biscuits and gravy which tasted pretty good aside from one entire biscuit being completely dry as they only put gravy on the two bottom halves. My boyfriend had the brisket platter and said his biscuit was way too dry, the beans had no flavor and the brisket was just "alright". Won't be coming back unless maybe they change owners again - shame as this is the only restaurant actually in the town of Plain. read more

Good food outside of Leavenworth as we were staying in Plain. A little overpriced for the portion size. We would've returned for breakfast but decided against it as a $15 p/p. But definitely suggest it as an alternative to driving into Leavenworth. Covid safe with masks and outdoor seating. read more

First time customer. Renting a cabin nearby and thought we should try some of the local food and we were very happy with our breakfast. My wife wants to know the secret of the great potatoes. Make sure you give them a try. Thanks Tom. read more

Small quaint restaurant which is kind of hidden away but worth the wait! Came in on a Saturday morning for breakfast, although place was very crowded knew it had to be good. Sat at the bar area and ordered oatmeal (Ya I know, watching what I'm eating though) and side of toast. However they ran out so I ordered a scramble with toast and it was delicious! Looked small but filled me up quickly and even though I didn't order a biscuit I saw others and those are huge!! Next time I go back will have to try one!! read more

Food was great, very overpriced. 16.50 for a coffee, 2 eggs, toast, potatoes and one slice of bacon.