I'd give this place 0 stars if I could. Besides me waiting 15 minutes for one sandwich, I asked for and was charged for extra bacon... There is one literal piece of bacon on here. Its cold. The asiago bagel is chewy and stale tasting. The kid at the window is more worried about asking for a tip rather than making sure your order is correct. Skip this place. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - bacon egg and cheese bagel - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

This place is okay. I ordered a customized breakfast Lox Bagel. I added sprouts, avocado, cucumber, wasabi CC instead of plain and removed the onions. The last time I ordered the breakfast Lox Bagel with no customizations it was absolutely foul!!! The moment I opened the container at work there was a horrid stench of old onions, so much so that everyone that sat in a 20 ft radius of me was complaining of a nasty onion smell. I was so embarrassed!! On top of it the avocado was very brown. Needless to say I called and got a free bagel. This time was MUCH better!! The only issues was that they were out of cucumbers but didn't bother telling me until I went back in to tell them about my messed up order. Also I ordered wasabi CC instead of plain and that was the other reason I went back in. The lady that made my sandwich adamantly insisted she made the wasabi CC that day and since she got so many complaints about it being too spicy, she put less wasabi in it but there WAS wasabi in it. I told her I have a VERY good sense of taste and I picked up ZERO hint of wasabi flavor. Let's be real, ANYONE who is complaining about the heat of wasabi has no business ordering wasabi CC in the first place, PERIOD! I will say, the people that work there are so very nice and accommodating!! read more

See all

Im glad theres a bagel shop around the mustang yukon area. I really like Einstein Bagels but since there isnt one much around here Old School can help. The bagels are pretty good. Soft and chewy inside and if requested toasted to perfection. My only criticism is that wish the specialty bagels will have more toppings. Example, jalapeño cheddar bagel please make it chessy and add slices on top like what Einstein bagel does. Same with the Asiago bagel, add more cheese on top. Einstein also has green hatch chile piled high and its amazing. Wish this place had it. I really do love the wasabi cream cheese. Never seen a place had this and its awesome. Overall like this place allot if I have a bagel craving. Lots of options to choose from. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Bacon and Chive cream cheese on a Asiago bagel. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

See all

Underrated champions of breakfast. Saved my morning countless times. Roses are red, muffins are blue, you need at least 85 characters in your review. read more

There is hardly any meat on these. The picture shows way more meat and you could barely see any once you got the sand which. It's almost like overpriced bread. I had the cowboy club. Bread did not taste toasted. read more

This location has recently added sweet and flavored tea. It's a really nice compliment to their menu. Lunch here is really good with variety of options. The establishment is always clean and well kept. For me it's worthy of regular visits. read more

I love to stop in for a good warm breakfast bagel. They have many options, including my favorite, the jalapeño cheddar. You get a nice jalapeño flavor, not too spicy, with a crusty cheese outside. So good! You can different options: egg, bacon, sausage. You can get breakfast or lunch bagel anytime! For a sweet bagel, I love the French toast...so good toasted with butter! Yummy! A nice crunch on the outside with a soft inside. Multiple cream cheese options to choose from if that's what you like. My favorite part of this location??? A drive thru! Yep, wonderful! This Is a small location, with not many parking spaces. But, they are quick and efficient. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Mustang Bagel - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

See all

I have to give it a 4... I love the coffee's and they generally made correctly, however on occasion they are not correct but drinkable. I have enjoyed the various bagels I have tried. My biggest complaint is the tipping aspect. They deliberately make you sign your credit card slip in hopes of getting a tip. This is insane! You make a coffee drink and deliver food as does every other drive thru or fast food style restaurant. I have asked for my receipt on multiple occasions and they say it is emailed... clearly they are capable of printing one as they make you sign one. If I want to tip I will but I definitely will not when you make me sign a receipt with the tip line on it... not to mention it is awkward and extremely obvious they look at the top line when you hand the receipt to them. This is truly enough to make me want to change my coffee destination. read more

The staff is super friendly and funny! They were super helpful with recommendations and bagel choices! We got breakfast bagels and they were so good!! Will for sure making this a regular fast morning bagel stop! read more

I tried this place after doing some searching for solid location for a good coffee and breakfast sandwich near my new house. I don't like that the method they use for heating the bagels is in the microwave, but the fact they my sandwich was made to order and was overall very good made up for that. (Must try the Cuban!) Service was fast, and the place was very clean and relaxing. There's a cute little reading nook in the corner with a tv and fireplace to chill out and enjoy a coffee. Manager was friendly and stopped by the ask how my sandwich was. Definitely give them a try! read more

It quickly becoming a staple for us. Incredible service! Delicious food! What more do you want?! read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Double Lox on a jalapeño cheddar bagel. Freaking awesome! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

First time here. The service was excellent and the food was excellent. We ordered a Ruben sandwich and a sooner club. The sandwiches were excellent. We will be returning to this restaurant soon read more

I have come back a few more times because let's face it the food is some of my favorite. They do have the music volume under control now. So I am updating my review to 5 stars. I love my Lox and Cream Cheese. read more

There's absolutely no one in here as you can see. I walked in looked and menu. I stepped up to the gentleman at the front and he said I'm off the clock. I said I'm sorry. The person at the drive through told me I'll be with you in a second. I said okay thank you. He comes to the register to help the guy clocking out. Doesn't acknowledge me. Then he comes from around the counter to get something. I'm still waiting so I just left. Im not sure how long it takes to order. Horrible service. read more

Great food, great service, and the restaurant is quite clean. If you love bagels, you'll love it here!

Everything is microwaved. Bagels are so much better toasted. Brown food tastes good. The coffee choices are great. I really enjoyed my latte. read more

We were hesitant to try based on past reviews of this location. However, today we ate here for the first time. I'll start by saying the restaurant was sparkling clean. We ordered the Mile High Club, Cowboy Club, and a kids pizza bagel. All sandwiches were packed with meat and veggies, as ordered. An extra win was the tiny "sonic" ice! read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - a ham sandwich with lettuce and tomato - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

A great location. The service was wonderful and they have excellent sandwiches. They also now have some new teas as we had the opportunity to sample. Very friendly, excellent service, a great manager who continued to check on us. An absolute great experience. read more

Always so good. They have a cheddar jalapeño bagel that is 5 stars. Definitely the best place to get bagels in town.

These bagels were delicious and soft! I have dentures so hard chewy bread is hard to eat but not these!!! read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - We ordered the Turkey Avocado and it was fantastic! - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

See all

This place is delicious!!!! I have a specific sandwich I get every time and they make it perfectly. Very clean and the employees are so friendly! I go so much that they already know my order when I drive thru . The manager is so helpful as well. I will be back! read more

Bagels are good. However, I've been going there for months ordering decaf lattes. I always ask if they have decaf and they say yes. Was just informed by the manager who placed orders that they don't even order decaf. I'm glad I'm not extremely sensitive to caffeine, only a little bit. Not sure what they've been giving me but it's not decaf. I assume full caffeinated espresso. It would make sense since I always feel more jittery than normal after their lattes. read more

Consistently slow with fulfillment of orders and severely lacking customer service. I like their food, but don't think I should be waiting 10 minutes at the drive through just to tell them about a mobile order placed 25 minutes ago. It also wasnt ready until 45 min after it was placed versus the 20 minute estimate. Place wasnt even busy. read more

Purchased the Bricktown with extra meat. For the minimal amount of meat on the sandwich, I might as well have ordered a bagel with spicy mustard. Certainly not worth the $12 I paid. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - Bricktown - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

We love this place when our food is correct, however, the last 3 times we have ordered a BACON Breakfast Croissant and a HAM Breakfast Bagel, the meats are switched. I am not certain if this is an order taker problem or an order maker problem, but something has to change!! Today, I specifically said I'd like a BACON Breakfast Bagel and the guy said, "do you want sausage, bacon or ham?" Ummmmm...I'd like bacon on my BACON Breakfast Croissant. ‍ read more

I usually love their breakfast items... but today i got a bagel sandwich that had bad avocado on it. i just don't get how they saw this bad avocado in front of them, yet still decided to go ahead & add it to my sandwich... this location seems to be very hit or miss.. read more

Old School Bagel Cafe - breakfast - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Mustang, Oklahoma

Had a great experience & great food, as always! My boy friend got the spicy bagel & I will definitely have to get it next time. It was great!! read more

Came from Colorado to try this ! Such good bagels and bagel sandwiches, made fresh! best snd nicest staff that treat the customers with utmost care. Try to make it when Max works--cares most about the people. read more

Old school bagel cafe has the greatest customer service I've ever seen! I was having difficulty using Apple Pay and the manager made everything so much easier! She helped me try and figure out the issue and then when we both could not figure out what was going on she comped my entire order! A lovely way to start my Saturday! read more

We decided to give them another chance. We ate there once before at this Mustang local & wasn't pleased. We ordered online to do a pick up order. All three of our breakfast sandwiches were cold & not toast. They used the wrong cream cheese on two of them. Which you pay $2+ extra per sandwich. It was very disappointing that we paid almost $30 for 3 breakfast sandwiches and they were not made as we ordered. It seem like pure laziness. My husband said they weren't even busy. read more

First time at this new location after frequenting another favorite location several times, and it's HORRIBLE. I should've followed my gut when I read and saw the Google reviews with literally no meat on the sandwiches and nothing like what the pictures look like both in the store and online. Leafy lettuce is actually iceberg lettuce, and they give you one shard for a seven dollar sandwich. This is ridiculous! My husband did not receive half the condiments that were supposed to be on his sandwich, and when he went and asked for them, they gave him two pieces of iceberg lettuce that were almost all white, which is pretty much not edible, and the tomatoes were the size of quarters. If you were expecting your bagel sandwich to look like it does on the website, keep driving. It will not be piled high with meat, lettuce, tomatoes, etc. You will literally receive one slice of turkey, one slice of ham, etc., and you will be charged more than seven dollars for each item. Your chips will also be stale, and very close to date or expiration. Oh, and did I mention that my order was also wrong? I was so frustrated and starving that I didn't even ask for it to be made right because I didn't have any faith in the people running this location. We will never be back! To pay $30 for lunch and get not one part of our order right is the worst customer service I have ever received. Go elsewhere. read more

If I could give less than one star, I would. Sandwiches came out cold, could read through the bacon, there was a small piece of cheese that didn't even cover the bagel. Sad! read more

They left out two bagels from the order and were not will to deal with the issue. Horrible service and pushy about tips. Never even addressed message left after calling several times and them not answering. read more