This used to be one of my favorite places to order from and dine in. However, it has gone down hill. The food delivered is cold and the bread sticks are literally pizza dough flattened and sprinkled with garlic salt. Disgusting. The pizza was cold and the fries were barely cooked. Will not be ordering again. It's sad to see this place fall apart. read more

Maybe they were busy, or maybe they were having a bad day. Order delivery and when the driver came the price was higher than when I placed the order, the food arrived cold, and one of the pizzas had the wrong topping! read more

This place is great! And cheap! The employees are pleasant and the food is good. Highly recommended."

The interior isn't fancy but the food is delicious and cheap! Note: Their food portions are huge! A large pizza is more like XL. read more

I really like this place. These are the best wings and blue cheese i have found in town. Delivery is a little slow compared to other areas i have been in, but that seems pretty common for this area (i am guessing due to the amount of people). The only problem i have is that the food they sell is not consistent at all, the cheese steaks are good when the meat isnt burnt and they dont skimp on the meat. The sauce is hit and miss, some days it is good some days not so great. I have never received anything so bad that i threw it away but its something they could fix easily and be much better. read more

Awesome crust! They make their own Italian dressing. Decent burgers. Great prices. Can eat in. 4 booths.

Good prices , fast delivery, but mediocre food tbh . If you're drunk though I'm sure it helps .

The dough wasn't really cooked well, it was a little chewy. Plenty of tasty sauce and cheese. Not greasy like Park Pizza. The delivery was pretty quick. read more

Some of the best pizza in Williamsport, and my usual go-to for local pizza. The restaurant itself is very "hole in the wall" and really built for take out more than eating in, but seems clean and nice. Street parking is available outside, but there is also a big public lot just on the other side of the library. The pizza is New York style, with a thin, fold-able crust. Toppings have always been fresh and well distributed. Delivery is reasonably fast, and I have never had an issue with the staff. I have gotten food here several times, and will continue to do so. read more

Quick stop for a quick lunch while passing through. Nice place, clean. Friendly staff/owner, good pizza, reasonably priced.

Ate here for the first time- pizza was actually very good and I am a bit of a pizza purist. The husband went deep into garlic wings. Very deep. Currently wearing sauce. Ahem. Anyway liked it well enough - $19 for large pizza half pepp, aforementioned wings and large soda. Will return. We took our food to go. Environment definitely "rustic" and old school. Maybe a good cleaning is in order but staff doesn't seem to be too concerned about that. read more

Once again took some advice and check this place out glad I did little place in town good food good service will go again

The best hole in wall pizzeria. My wife had cheesesteak and I had wingzing and small pizza. Cheesesteak just had enough flavor and very cheesy. Loved it. Pizza was New York style pizza. Wingzing was just enough heat to make you want more. This place is the "shit"! Good shit, not the bad shit that you are thinking. I would recommend to everybody. read more

Very cheap slices. The pizza is just okay. You get what you pay for. I went there very late at night and it was full of drunk folks after they left the cell block. No place to sit and noisy. Seating is limited. I went because it's the cheapest place to get a slice. read more

Cheesesteaks were so good! The roll was awesome! I don't know what took me so long to find out. Definitely recommend!

These dumb azz ppl brought me the wrong order and then when I called them they asked me to give them back the messed up order and never brought me the right order and the guy that answered the phone sounded high! read more

Amazing pizza if the right person is making it, cheesesteaks would be way better if the bun was toasted. Prices are awesome.

Old School has the best pizza and cheesesteaks in this town! Incredible staff and very reasonable prices. Highly recommend giving it a shot if you're in the area! read more

The pizza here is very good. I like being able to go in late at night and get just a couple of slices. Prices are all very reasonable too. I also really like their cheesy bread. read more

can't go wrong with anything on the menu at all, everything is cheap and it all tastes great. Easily the best pizza shop I've been to in years. Be sure to try the cheese bread too, that completes it. read more

Just left on 8/22/15 with 2 pizza at 9:00 pm.. They were cold and burnt on the bottom . I had several people for company no one liked the pizza. I had to Try to microwave it without it getting anymore burnt. Didnt work well. There was also a gritty taste felt in your mouth. I hope to receive and email back. I have pizza left my guests nor myself will finish it. What a waste of time and money. Call ahead for pick up live 5 minutes away and cold burnt piizza is what I bring home to my quests. Last name was Kinney please check back to your order ticj ets on date and this time. read more

Absolutely disgusted with this place. My clients with developmental disabilities went there to enjoy lunch. Apparently there was an issue in the women's bathroom. The manager had interrupted my clients' meal to discuss what specifically was going on in the bathroom and ASSUMED it was my clients who did it. Not only did she embarrass my clients, interrupt their meal to talk about bodily fluids WHILE THEY ATE, but assumed my clients are the ones who did it Why? Because they have disabilities? I called to report my disgust, and the manager was rude and called them "my people". Disgusted is an understatement. NEVER will I take my family or recommend this place to anyone. read more

Good atmosphere, dollar slices and the best cheesy bread I've ever had! When I'm in the area, we drive 45 minutes just to eat here.

Wow! Excellent pizza and inexpensive. Best pizza in town. One tip, pick up is better than delivery if you can swing it.

Food poisoning and when contacted about food poisoning they told me that I just had a stomach bug and that all their ingredients were cut fresh every single day. However the thing about that is a stomach bug is not on said as fast as food poisoning and you don't go from running around to being passed out for the next 24 hours. Don't eat here don't cause yourself to be sick read more

What I like the most is the ambiance.Pizza is great but you have to have it hot and fresh.Sweet little hole in the wall pizza joint.Very "Old School". Go figure. read more

One of the best choices for Pizza in the area for sure. You can't go wrong with $1 slices. Their pizza pies are extremely cheap and the dough/sauce is unique, fresh, and homemade. Love everything else I've had on the menu as well. Staff are warm and friendly and the interior is charming. Just double-check your order before you let the delivery guy leave your house, they've screwed up our orders many times. They were, however, always quick and apologetic about fixing it. I love their food and prices so much I say it's worth the risk. Local businesses are where it's at. read more