On a busy Thursday evening we stopped in to order a pizza . The order person was super busy juggling phones and walk in but was super pleasant and helpful . The food was hot and excellent with a great selection. The downfall is that the bar and dining room are not open read more

We loved the website, menu, online ordering and delivery option because we are from out of town but the website pictures are VASTLY different than the food. It's fine for cafeteria type food but we were definitely looking forward to something at least somewhat like what was shown and described online. They really, really mean the 'food may vary from image' disclaimer. I don't know why they would even put the images other than for false advertising. Old Sturbridge P&R, put these pictures on your website instead. read more

See all

Typically I used to enjoy the food, not the wings, they are frozen garbage, also the shrimp are size of a bean, but they tell you 90 minutes, and its really 3 hours!!! Then apologize and offer a 50% discount then give you 15 read more

Usually the food is phenomenal. But today not so much.. The fried clams were frozen and disgusting . read more

Old Sturbridge Pizza & Restaurant - Fried clams??? They were gross. - Pizza Near Me - Sturbridge, Massachusetts

See all

PHENOMENAL!!! We had a hamburger and mushroom and it was our first time here. The crust was FANTASTIC, it says homemade on the menu... you can really tell. I LOVED LOVED LOVED IT!!! Come check this place out read more

Great that they deliver to Wales, but when I order two pizzas at 4:30, I expect to get them before 6:30. I understand there may have been a traffic issue but I still refuse to believe that when I called at 5:40 and they said pizza was going out the door, that that was the truth based on getting an email at 5:57 saying that it was on its way. And they weren't the least bit apologetic. Pizza was okay. read more

Ordered a pizza with roasted red peppers and onions. Received pizza with green peppers and onions so not the correct order. Waited an hour and 45 minutes for delivery - ordered at 3:30pm, received the pizza at 5:15pm. Used to be good but have gone downhill significantly in the last 6 months. read more

While my steak and cheese sandwich was satisfactory, the pepperoni pizza was entirely unpalatable.

Ordered nachos, after a half an hour wait the nachos finally arrived ( after going up to counter 2 times ) nachos looked like they were straight out of the microwave & almost as good as microwave nachos. Guy that brought nachos had an attitude & was told to" be patient bro" they are busy. Apparently I am the one who is in the wrong to wait 30 minutes for sub par nochos, though watched 6 people come in after me & get their food. read more

Old Sturbridge Pizza & Restaurant - Garbage nachos - Pizza Near Me - Sturbridge, Massachusetts

A few weeks ago my gf and I ordered a couple of subs from here and they were good . This past Sunday we wanted to give their pizza a try . So we both walked in wearing our Trump 2024 hats and immediately their delivery guy said " nice hats !" . We agreed and placed our order for a pizza . We were told 20 minutes. . We wait the time pick up our pizza from the clearly ( owner) anoid and go home . The pizza was 1/2 baked and we had to finish cooking it for another 20 minutes in our oven. It's too bad that they were triggered by a hat to give the same service to us as any other customer . They had a opportunity to gain a new customer and grow their business but instead they got a bad review on Yelp and we also told several neighbors in our apartment complex to avoid this pizza establishment . read more

Great pizza and subs! We order from here all the time. (We choose to pick up rather than delivery. ) They're consistent in their quality and service. The owner is very accommodating. Try the chicken, bacon ranch pizza - fabulous! read more

Ordered delivery last night and most of it went in the trash, including the menu. The chef's salad was packaged with the pizza, toasted sub and mozzarella sticks making it hot and wilted. The ham in the salad was very salty. The mozzarella sticks were decent but the sauce was also extremely salty. The Italian sub had very little meat and was also very salty. I actually had to search for the provolone. Please be advised that all of their subs come toasted per the menu, I overlooked that. I can't speak for the pizza because I didn't try it but it looked appetizing. We tried to call but there was no answer even though they were still open. I called again today and owner was slightly argumentative and didn't seem interested in any kind of constructive feedback. He also stated that he deleted my Facebook review. I did not request a refund none was offered. read more

Old Sturbridge Pizza & Restaurant - Italian sub. - Pizza Near Me - Sturbridge, Massachusetts

Wow what a outstanding place we definitely ordered late but pizza was amazing. We are from Illinois out here on a work trip. I would recommend this place if you are in the area. The fried broccoli was awesome and the mushrooms, you'd be suprised how funky those can get from other places. read more

Old Sturbridge Pizza & Restaurant - a slice missing - Pizza Near Me - Sturbridge, Massachusetts

Amazing service and food! This place is top notch. Would definitely recommend. Crust was great and the portions generous

Great food and customer service! Under-rated in my opinion. For a local pizza joint they are top notch. Get their NY style pizza for sure!

We ordered pizza, breadsticks and salad from this restaurant while staying in town for a bachelorette. The pizza was so-so. Not awful but not remarkable either. But the real reason for knocking down so many stars is that they forgot one of our salads. Our order wasn't huge, but it was too late to drive 20-30 minutes back to the restaurant by the time we got home and realized the mistake. Given all the other food options in the area, I'd recommend trying another place. read more

The pizza is really greasy and always falls apart its probably one of my least favorite places to eat the only thing that gives this two stars is there taco pizza. read more

Their NY Florentine Pizza is AMAZING. I ordered on the phone as I was driving through MA and they were so nice on the phone. They also had the pizza ready in 20 minutes which is pretty fast considering how busy they were when I walked in! This place looks like its the busiest in town! And that make sense, because their pizza is that good. The garlic oil and ricotta combination is perfection!! read more

Stopped here the other day thinking I was going too visit George's Pizza, another place I had not frequented before. Lo and behold, that's not what was on the signage when I pulled up. No biggie, I thought, I'll give these guys a shot I thought. I walked in and took a look at the menu so I could make up my mind. Pretty much what you'd expect, pizzas and subs, though many to choose from. First visit, I played it safe and went with a small cheese pizza. I had planned to share with my little one but she wanted fast food instead. Woo Hoo, more for me. Though there a a couple of tables inside, this is really more of a take out kind of place. The young lady behind the counter was friendly, the wait for my pizza was what you'd expect, about ten minutes. The pizza was OK, in spite of the fact they use a conveyor belt to cook it. I'm more of the old school, throw it in the oven kind of guy. Though we had no issues, I could see parking being an issue here. The lot is not huge and there is no street parking here. read more

See all

I ordered food waited 2 hours. The owner told me the driver just left but a half hour later no avail. I understand the place is "busy" but this is garbage I'll never order there again!!! read more

The owner/piece of shit refused to deliver to my disabled mother within the given timeline because he said he couldn't get home to his family in time. I called repeatedly, this dick wouldn't take my order within 1 HOUR of his stated closing time. read more

Best pizza and sandwhiches in town. Give them a try. You wont be dissapointed

2.5 stars, rounded up Pros: -Delivered to Wells State Park campsites -Pizza arrived warm, although much later than the quoted time -Flavor was standard, run of the mill pizza Cons: -Pizza was a soggy, greasy mess. I practically needed a spoon to scoop it all up. -We ordered a pepperoni pizza. They put the cheese on top of the pepperoni. On one hand, it made it slightly unique and helped keep the pizza together a little more. However, I think all this really did was contribute to the soggy, greasy mess. It trapped the grease of the pepperoni between the sauce and cheese with nowhere to runoff, escape, or be blotted off. So the bottom crust just absorbed the trapped grease. Would I order again? Well, it was a hell of a lot better than the stuff we woulda made over our campfire, but under any other circumstance, no. I wouldn't come back. read more

Great classic pizza place! Ordered while I was in town on business, will def do it again! Subs are delish

I'm sorry but this pizza was one of the worst I've had. I guess I'm spoiled being from Connecticut where are pizza is the best outside of New York. I don't recommend again I'm sorry. read more

This place is flat out not good, and it doesn't seem like they are even trying. The place is a mess, unused pizza boxes and pizza pans with dough in it everywhere. Very few places to sit despite the large space. I got a large cheese pizza and I really really wanted it to be good but NO, not even close. You'd be better off getting some Ragu or any cheap sauce putting it on a bagel with american cheese and cooking it in the toaster oven then ordering a large cheese pizza for $12.80 from these guys. This place when it was Georges years ago was outstanding then it was sold and then sold again and now this garbage. The outside of the place is indicative to what the food tastes like. read more

This has been under new management/ownership and is wonderful. Their pizza is great and everyone is always happy when I call or stop in. Definitely recommend this place for pickup or delivery!!!! read more

I ordered the meat lovers Pizza one of the best pizzas I've had in a long damn time delivery service was excellent Bob is a great guy done a truck driver a huge oh favor that's between me and him but a damn good man damn good pizza damn good family environment thank you Bob read more

Ordered large one topping pizza with order of BBQ chicken tenders and 2 litter bottle of coke. They delivered it right to the campsite where we were staying at the time they said it would be there. Food was very tasty. Would definitely eat here again when in the area. read more

The restaurant is closed since I reported to the Health Department in Sturbridge that pieces of glass were served in child's portion of pasta! On Facebook it states they are closed for vacation. Truth be told the Health Department shut them down to correct multiple violations in the food code! They did not refund our money and shortly after we complained and asked to speak to a manager we were told ( a party of 15) that they were closing. So much for customer service! read more

Heavy on the cheese. Sauce had an extra zing to it. Not sure what that was, though it was decent. Side of broccoli was $$. Pretty much a no frills place for pizza and subs. read more

PAY ATTENTION!!! Why is he yelling this you ask? Great question!! And here is why. We stopped in town for the night while passing through. We called Old Sturbridge to fill our bellies for the evening. We ordered a small bbq chix pizza, an order of honey BBQ wings and a small order of bread sticks. The pizza and wings were good. The bread sticks? Well they probably would have been good when they were fresh. They appeared to have been sitting under the warmer for a much longer time than the 45 minutes that it took to get our food delivered. So my guess is that their lack of attention to detail allowed for them to deliver us an order that had made much earlier than when I had called. Luckily I will probably never be in this area again. But if I am. I will NOT be ordering from them again. read more

Decided to try them for a change but it wasn't for the better. Pizza was adequate but not up to other places in Sturbridge or Brimfield. Mask usage was sub-par with a number of the employees wearing the mask below their noses and one delivery person not bothering to use his at all. read more

It took to hours for delivery just 2 miles down the road. Called 3 times and was told they were on the way. Fries were cold when food finally came. No apologies. read more

This place is awful. Placed an online prepaid order at 7 :15pm for delivery. 8:05 called to find out what is going on. No one picked up the phone . Drove to the restaurant looking for our order. Was told they had not even started making our pizzas because they got "busy". This is a dump read more

We just ordered from here, we have yet to find good pizza since moving to Sturbridge. We ordered a House pizza and an Italian grinder. Food was fresh and delicious, everything had flavor and loved all the fresh veggies. It is a Friday night and delivery was fast. Can't wait to try more menu items, and, pizza did in fact look just like the picture actually. I was surprised by some of the reviews on here. Thank you for the great meal! read more

Gotta give them 5 stars. They added the "Slice" app so ordering and paying is super easy and the new york style pizza is the best. their buffalo wings are a good size compared to other places in town and if there is a problem they don't hesitate to make it right. Good customer service is just as important as the food and they get it. read more

Friendly staff, quick service, but the pizza is very average with a pre made crust type of flavor. The antipasto salad was tasty but on the small size. Not a bad place by any means but nothing remarkable either. read more

This was a take out order, so my review is on the food only. Steak and Cheese Grinder - Where I'm from, it's known simply as a Cheesesteak, and this cheesesteak needed some help. 1) It was very dry. Chip steak is lean by nature, so you have to squirt some oil on the cooking steak. Sub shops back where I'm from have a squirt bottle of oil that's liberally applied. 2) It was salty, really salty! 3) Hardly any cheese! Where's the cheese? Again, back home the cheese is thoroughly mixed into the steak The sandwich could have used fried onions, but it wasn't available on the ordering app. Back at the house, I slathered my sandwich with ketchup in an attempt to add some flavor and juiciness to it. On the plus side, there was plenty of steak, and the roll was crispy. In summation, I would not buy another Steak and Cheese Grinder from Old Sturbridge Pizza. read more

False advertisement. Olives thrown on a garden salad doesn't make it a Greek salad and looks absolutely nothing like your menu picture. Not worth the money charged. read more