I have been trying to go to Lititz for forever because of Olio!!! I love Olio so much mainly because I like to make my own dressing for salads and other things. You can taste test oils and balsamic, which I am a taste-tester, and the service is amazing! They always encourage your items! I love the ambiance, especially as I mentioned earlier, that there are oils and balsamic just laying around for someone to taste!!! Overall, 5 Stars. If you ever go there, I assure you that you will love it!!!! GREAT job, Olio! read more

If you are looking for a delightful shopping experience this charming store is a must visit! The owner and his staff are incredibly knowledgeable and genuinely passionate about what they do - they are happy to make suggestions and offer tastings to help you discover a new favorite. Whether you are looking for a special gift, something to elevate your own cooking, or just want to treat yourself to a little culinary indulgence, this store is a true find. read more

Many various oils, unique flavors, clean environment. Friendly welcoming atmosphere. Prompt service, friendly staff who are versatile and willing to answer all questions regarding olive oil. read more

See all

I have been ordering the amazing olive oils and balsamic vinegars from Olio for years but finally made it to the actual store in Lititz and figured it was time to review this really incredible family owned business. They have an impressive array of oils and vinegars, all of which you can sample in little plastic cups. This makes it an interactive experience akin to tasting ice cream flavors at an ice cream shop. It also makes it a blast for kids though they have to be old enough to know how to turn on and, importantly, off, the spigot on each barrel. The fig balsamic is one of my all time favorites. It's thicker than most and has a wonderful flavor that I like to trickle on top of salads and grilled veggies. The smoked Sonoma extra virgin olive oil is really something special and can go on salad or over grilled vegetables or can turn a standard sandwich into something creative and delicious. I tried the savory and sweet white balsamic for the first time and thought it was fantastic. My kids loved the sweeter options like the lemon white balsamic (tastes just like lemon ice) and the chocolate strawberry balsamic (tastes like it sounds). They prices are reasonable. A small bottle is $5 and they get progressively bigger and more expensive but even a larger 16.9 Oz bottle is only $22. Some exceptions like truffle oil are more but most are very reasonable. They also sell a huge spread of spices, flavored salts, rubs and more. Try the truffle cheese seasoning. It's amazing on popcorn, over eggs or really anywhere. If you can make it in person it's worth it, otherwise order online and enjoy! read more

See all

Great selection of goods. Terrible hours for commuters passing through town at or after 5:00PM. If I'm lucky enough to be a few minutes early on my commute I would shop there. A couple of times the shop waas closed at 4:57 or so, so NO SALE. Too bad they won't stay open until 6:00PM like the Savory Gourmet up the street. I'll find my gourmet oil and vinegar somewhere elst. read more

Wonderful store! Pete helped me get just the right olive oil and balsamic blend to replace. Mix I can no longer get. We left with new ideas and treats! read more

This store is definitely bigger than it looks from the outside! It had a really nice selection of oils and balsamics as well as a selection of honey, pasta, and salts. Their salt selection was really nice and they even have some sample packs you can buy. The staff were friendly and very attentive. This is a good place to stop in and up your seasoning game. read more

Love this store. Customer service is amazing. I especially like the balsamics. Strawberry is my favorite. Have been buying for years read more

The shop owners are exceedingly helpful and informative. The variety of oils and vinegars is extensive, with free tastings. The prices are reasonable given it being a smaller family owned business with a niche in olive oil and vinegar. read more

Let me start off by saying Joe is the man!!!! Very knowledgeable in his product and great recommendations. We walked out with Raspberry Balsamic, Pesto Olive oil, Greek Olive oil, sun dried tomato truffle pesto paste and truffle cheese affectionately known as "crack". The flavors of every product were phenomenal and we are having so much fun finding different ways of cooking with them all. We will definitely be back for more exotic flavors that blow the mind and put your pallette on overdrive. read more

The owners are there and their shop is beautiful inside. There are sooooooo many options. You could spend several hours tasting and picking stuff out. The owner was truly helpful directing me to try a few. Great place for the gourmand, foodie or gift-giver. The Spanish olive oil is light, but I don't think I should be cooking with it. It destroys the flavor. Love the lemon white basalmic and orange mango passion fruit white basalmic. I found the ingredients really work when lightly drizzled on cooked meats or veggies. I tried marinating some things prior to cooking and it was less potent in flavor than a tiny drizzle after cooking. I will be back, but I'm bummed out about the little cups they have for tasting it. Plastic cups, hundreds in the trash, maybe they're recycled? I hope. It appears wasteful, I wish they had something that was more environmentally friendly. read more

Olio Olive Oils & Balsamics - Specialty Food Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

The first time I went here it was with a 'pro' taster who assured me slurping oil & balsalmic vinegar from a paper cup is not only normal but expected. Now? Even though I live in NC, I order their product via their super easy website and try to convert others to The Cult of Olio. The people that own/work here are beyond friendly. They are the High Priests and Priestesses of the Cult of Great Cooking. The prices are a little high...but so worth it. If you find yourself in Lititz and wonder which shop to go to...I highly recommend Olio. You WON'T regret it!! read more

This shop is amazing! Olive oils, balsamic vinegars, salts, and honey from all over the world. You can sample all of the oils and balsamics. They have so many flavors you could spend hours in here! They also have nice gift sets, bowls, and beautiful Italian ceramics. If you are in the Lititz area, I definitely recommend stopping at Olio to try some samples. read more

Step away from the olive oil section of your grocery store and experience the many varieties of olive oils OOO&B has to offer. In addition to the geographic varieties of oils, the infused and flavored oils are incredible. The garlic infused oil is incredible and I used it to make a wonderful bruschetta later. The variety of balsamic are fun to try also. The owner was very helpful and made us feel welcome to sample as long as we wanted and provided additional information when needed. This is a great little shop which foodies and non-foodies would enjoy. read more

BEFORE I walked into Olio's the mere idea of slurping balsamic vinegar or olive oil straight from a cup would have me on the verge of feeling ill. AFTER I walked into Olio's I'm always excited to go back and throw down a straight shot of Bordeaux Cherry balsamic or Roasted Chili Olive Oil. Wow, their selection is amazing. I think they have over 50-taps combined now. I made the owner explain why his vinegars and oils are so much better than the other stores with taps I've tried. He says they're completely independent. Most of the other stores are part chain stores. Either way, I can say their products really are fantastic. I've converted several people to the Olio way. The owner and staff and really nice, informative people who have an obvious passion for their business. read more

Fabulous find in Lititz. Very friendly and knowledgeable owners. Huge selection of high quality olive oils and balsamic vinegars from Italy, California, Greece, Morocco, Chile, Argentina, Turkey and Spain on offer. Many different sized bottles at reasonable prices. Owners encourage tastings and samples - so do try before you buy. They also has a nice selection of cookbooks and other gourmet items. I was vacationing, but if I lived there - I'd be in weekly. A must visit! read more

They have recently expanded their store so they are able to serve thier customers. Great selection of infused oils, vinegars and salts. These are must haves for cooks! read more

I can't say enough good things about this store. An amazing selection of balsamic vinegars and olive oils. The balsamic vinegars are so rich you don't need as much olive oil to make a very thick dressing. Don't throw those little pieces of paper away - they hold great suggestions for how to use their products. I have a full shelf in my pantry devoted to their products. And FYI - if you can't make it to Lititz, they offer free shipping for orders $100 and over. read more

I have never been to an oil shop with so many opportunities for tasting the oil and so many flavors to buy. We left with two. One of which we tried at the Cafe down the street. read more

Very good! You can taste just about everything. We come here twice a year for the olive oils & vinegars

Absolutely awesome. I thought I knew about good olive oils but I really didn't this place blows away the competition. The finest olive oils and balsamic vinegars that I have ever tased. The owners are wonderful people and are experts and can offer great advice on the pairing of their products. Don't pass up this store in Lititz, PA. Since I am from out of state, I was delighted to hear that I can order their fine products online. read more

Cute little place in Lititz that features a vast array of different flavored oils and balsamic vinegars. It is worthy of a stop whether you live in Lititz or not. You can make up some great items to cook with or just top a salad! read more

Olio has excellent service and their quality is like no other... stop in and find out for yourself, while enjoying the beautiful town of Lititz. Thank you for your great products and service ! read more

This is a cool place they have a crazy amount to try. Also balsamic and friendly staff. Nice place to stop while visiting.

At Olio, you can taste what you purchase. It is the perfect way to sell a product. Every flavored oil and balsamic vinegar is available to taste and displayed in beautiful, shiny, clean containers with small disposable tasting cups. Very classy. I always feel like I'm at a fine wine tasting when I visit the store. There are suggestions for great oil and vinegar flavor combinations that are amazing. Some of my new favorites are (1) cucumber & melon white balsamic (2) lavender balsamic (3) mushroom and garlic olive oil and (4) habenero maple syrup! Too many to mention...try it and see for yourself. read more

I first went to Olio's looking for some olive oils and balsamic vinegars that I could use on my salads...But I never knew the kind of variety there was until I entered the shop. It is wonderful being able to sample the olive oils and balsamics and combine them. Each has a description and suggestion of how to use it. Compared to your store brand products, these will last you a much longer time. A little goes a long way! In addition to these, Olio's carries different salts, flavored sugars, honeys and more. As with the oils and balsamics, you are able to sample the other products. If your looking for something to add to your food, look here! read more

Always a great experience here! Knowledgeable staff and owners offer suggestions as needed, but the descriptions on the vats are also quite helpful as to pairings or suggested uses. Olio has a wider selection than most stores of this type I've seen. The quality of the products in addition to the oils and balsamics is also outstanding and there are some unique offerings (honeys with varied flavorings, as an example). Don't miss this place when in Lititz! read more

Staff is always friendly and they have an interesting assortment of more than just olive oils and balsamics. It's worth the trip!!

Nice shop. Beautiful products. Rude staff. I intended to buy some vinegar but left with nothing after being made to feel like an idiot by one of the people working there. read more

Another tasty reason to love Lititz! I moved out of state from Lancaster recently. I stocked up on my favorite balsamics and oils before I left, but they have so many NEW flavors, I will be having more shipped soon. My all-time favorite is the white 25 star balsamic. It is all I need to dress my salad. read more

I visited Olio in Lititz, Pa on Thursday. This was my first time but surely will not be the last. I purchased several oils and balsamic vinegars. I'm was so eager to use some of the vinegar that I purchased that I got a chicken sandwich and used some of the raspberry balsamic vinegar on my sandwich and ate it in my car. It was wonderful. I will back again real soon. If you want a change from plain boring food give it a try. You will love what you find. read more

Best Olive Oils in Pennsylvania! This was a fun trip to Amish Country! This gourmet olive oil store is in a little town called Lititz, PA. We had so much fun tasting the huge selection of olive oils and balsamics! You need to try the Moroccan EVOO paired with the Strawberry Balsamic...so yummy on salads! I'm not a local, so glad to hear I can order online! http://oliooliveoil.com/ Try it! read more

I love this olive oil! Have been ordering from here since we discovered them in 2011, on a cross country trip to relocate. I wish there was a cheaper way to ship it, as it is a bit heavy but they do pack it beautifully. It would be nice to not have to pay as much in shipping cost as it is basically for the six pack of 2oz bottles. It's a great gift, and everyone that I've sent it to, comes back for more. One way I've found to save on shipping is to order a larger amount and then split it up and use prepaid USPS boxes, you can fit alot in the small $5 box. Anyway, in regards to the olive oil, my very favorite is the Fig, you really have to try it. The selection is awesome, I especially like the white ginger as well, it works well with everything, especially because we live in Hawaii! Whatever your palette choice you can't go wrong! Overall, shipping cost is justified by the great customer service and product quality! Happy dipping! read more

Amazing gem in Lancaster County!! Best balsamic vinegars and olive oils. So many flavors and sizes! New ones come in all the time! Samples and recipes available. Owners are so helpful! They have added more products too! Hard to believe there is inventory like this in Lancaster!! Takes your cooking to the next level. Love this store! read more

Great new store in my hometown of Lititz, if only I still lived there! Wonderful selection of top quality oils and vinegars, taste as many as you want before you buy. The small "make your own" samplers are a great way to try new flavors at a minimal expense. The staff is very knowledgeable, friendly and helpful. I will be going back every time I visit "home." PS - "Friend" them on Facebook!! read more

Very friendly and knowledgeable business. You get to sample the products before you buy them. So many to choose from. You'll love it.

A must visit if you find yourself in Amish Country. I stopped by while I was in town visiting my parents. Obviously I walked out with some really good oil and Italian balsamic (and great recipe suggestions), but I also got some AMAZING peanut butter that is made by a relative of the owners. I live in NC and everyone that tastes it (half almond, half peanut, with sweet cranberries) wants to know where they can get it. I'm stocking up next time I visit. read more

I love Olio. I love that I can taste the oils and balsamics before I buy them and it's really great that they tell you what they would be good with and which ones pair together nicely. The quality is far superior to a grocery store. read more

We are from Pittsburgh and always go to Olio's when in the area. Love it, all the balsamic and oils are great. Love trying new ones each time. So great on salads and To cook with! read more