On 8/20/16 we reserved at The One on opentable because of the location, then read some reviews (newest first) and canceled. But we inadvertently ended up there anyway, and really really liked the food. Staff was good and and gave good service. One server was more the curt-efficient CA[nadian] style than the style in the other CA[lifornia, where we're live), you know: "Hi, I'm your server, how are you folks doing today." She warmed up when we complimented her on her gorgeous nails. Everyone else was cheerful and competent from the get-go, without being smarmy/vapid. {OUR ACCIDENTAL VISIT: Since we were going for an early dinner, we decided after canceling that rez to walk around Yorkville and see what looked good. We came across a patio with many happy diners - didn't notice the place's name - and asked if they had a table for us even though we had no reservation. The hostess - in a smashing dress which we said was designed for the restaurant when we noticed it on another hostess, too - said most of the patio was filled but they had 2 tables at the end on Hazelton that we could see, or we could sit inside. We checked out the outside tables, both at the very end of the patio on the side street. We LOVED the farthest - bigger than usual, with no nearby tables, and less car or foot traffic than in the front. She said it was where she sat movie stars. (Joke? Didn't matter.) True, it was (a) next to a bussing station so there was the occasional sound of crockery, and (b) the piped-to-the-outside - and unnecessary - music was a louder than we liked, but basically it was a fine table. Then I looked at the menu and laughed, "This is the place we just canceled because of the terrible reviews, bad service, cheating on the bill ..." My husband said, "Well, it seems very popular. Let's give it a try."} FOOD: We each had a glass of wine (good, but not particularly memorable, and then salads. H had the kale ceasar. Delicious. Bits of bacon, a mild horseradish flavor, beautiful kale. I had the heirloom carrot. The carrots, although very pretty to look at with a nice grilled texture, were alas without flavor. The rest of the salad - the greens, avocado, pistachios, pickled golden raisins - were, however, fabulous. We next shared a hamburger, cooked to our order, with good pickles and fries, and a side of sweet potato. The sweet potatoes were excellent, cooked perfectly, with sunflower seeds and a bit of creamy dressing which tasted lovely and was nicely decorative but was unnecessary to us. We were going just to have coffee after that but read the dessert menu and when we saw that we could get a scoop of Ontario Strawberry sorbet for $3, we ordered it. Utterly delicious. I don't usually bother to write reviews - and always am suspicious of good reviews following bad ones, esp. on yelp - but just had to speak up on this one. (Also, we checked the addition on our bill: no mistakes.) We'd go back. And would specially reserve that movie star table. read more