What a find! I was just perusing on google maps looking at what's nearby and stumbled upon this…read moreshack. Without actually vetting this place out beforehand I would've never stopped by. I'm here to continue with spreading the word that this place serves top quality sandwiches. I even reheated my leftover sandwich for my husband the next day and he gave it a solid 9.2 saying it's one of the best chicken sandwiches he had (tried the somerset). Imagine if he ate it fresh? When you order, they even deliver it to your car. Think Sonic vibes. Definitely stopping by again in the future to try more items.

This was my first time and I kept it simple with the Rueben (special sandwiches section on the…read moremenu). It contains Swiss cheese, Roasted Turkey, Sauerkraut, and Thousand Island on Rye bread. I also added sauteed onions. Overall, it was okay, lacking some flavor and it was not as filling as I'd expected. I wanted to understand and experience the hype about American Melts, but it fell flat for me. It was just okay. Despite being underwhelmed, I am still giving 4 stars because the service was great and I am impressed with the price range. Every sandwich on their menu is under $10, and that stands out especially these days when a mediocre burger is $15+ minimum. You can even "build your own grilled cheese" sandwich. For these reasons, I am willing to give American Melts another try and perhaps a different item on the menu.

Just in town visiting family. This place is awesome. Got an air-bnb nearby. The gentleman working…read morethe day we went in apologized for the wait cause he was working alone. Truly, each item we asked for was done well and came out very quickly. The bread was a special thing. They make it here. My Wife makes bread at home, so She's picky about stuff like that. She had high compliments on Her sandwich. If I lived here, I would be stopping by all the time.

Found this place by accident, haven't stopped going back. Great customer service. The food is…read moredelicious. The fact that the order keeps growing because more people from the office are joining when I order speaks volume. The ambiance is great, I look forward to sitting down and eating there one day soon.

Third time coming by here and all was delicious! Ordered a family chicken combo and they made…read moreeverything fresh on the spot. The second time we ordered some burgers and lamb over chicken..super delicious, chicken and burgers were moist & hit the spot. Came in tonight for some lamb over rice again and it was on point. Customer service is great, prices are reasonable and food is equally as great!

I love food there, great service and chef's food is amazing. Love the ambiance and the new menuread more

My childhood sub shop still hits just like it did when I was a kid. This place is cash only, so…read morearrive with your dollars in hand or use their atm machine. I always love a cheese sub. Here, it comes with lettuce, tomato, mayo, spices, oil and vinegar. The bread is soft, the cheese sub comes with American, provolone and Swiss. The folks working here are always polite and make sure you get exactly what you like. The shop looks almost exactly like it did when I was a kid in the 90s, they actually have the price lists from years past posted at the register. Pretty wild to see though this place remains very affordable.

Roast beef was okay, but the roll it was on wasn't great. Cash only. Was made very very fast. I…read morethink they have all the meat pre-sliced. It wasn't bad, but I'd probably try someplace else before coming back.

Tried for the first time and the turkey, roast beef and Swiss sub looked great but had one major…read moreissue - end pieces of the roast beef were not discarded and was tough and chewy. I ended up removing most/all the roast beef to salvage the sub. The remaining turkey and Swiss sub was pretty good. With so many good choices in northern nj. This was my first/ last visit, unfortunately.

Super clean and fresh subs! Came here for lunch and I was craving a turkey and cheese sandwich. So…read morehappy I came to the right place. The bread was super soft the amount of cheese, turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, oil and vinegar was just right! I liked how the bread was super fresh. I feel that makes the whole sandwich when your bread is nothing but softness! The pricing was decent $6-7$ for a half. I would def come back and would highly recommend this place!

It's a very small, unassuming place with limited seating but the service is good and so if the…read morefood! I went for breakfast and really enjoyed my french toast, scrambled eggs, and beef bacon everything was delicious! Honestly, better than I expected! Don't judge a book by its cover! Sorry there's no photos or videos, I was starving and had to eat before the camera this time

Upon walking in, we were greeted (a glance and a slight nod) by 2 old men behind a diner counter…read morethat was basically just one small table away from the door's "clearance." So imagine walking into a very WIDE room with a diner countertop in front, but with such narrow sides that only a table of two with 2 chairs each fits on each side. This threw me off a bit but here we were. I wish had better things to say, but I simply can't. The place looked dingy and a bit dirty, rundown and dusty. We were in a hurry and I think my husband just immediately didn't want anything upon seeing the place (he said he wasn't too hungry but, I know my husband). I ordered the lentil soup that was priced $5.50 on the menu. I asked for some kind of bread with it and one of the men asked me what kind of toast. I know I should have skipped it in that moment for a few reasons but I simply muttered back, "whole wheat, please." The soup came in a plastic bowl accompanied by a plastic spoon. It was straight up canned soup 100%. I had about 3-5 slurps and didn't touch the toast. Why, might you ask? I saw the other old man behind the counter handle the bread without any gloves. I'm sorry if that seems pretentious to some, but for me, it's a must. And of course seeing it just makes it that much worse. Made me think this is a common occurrence around this establishment. In the end, the bill came to $7.50. For a few spoonfuls of soup. La, Shukran. No, Thank You.

I ordered a tuna sub, and it really was not the best quality, but I'll try it again in the future…read more Really not satisfied with a plain tuna sub.

Best Subs in town. Food is nice a fresh. Great customer service. I will continue to order for all…read moremy family and friends gatherings. Thank you.

Great sandwiches, good menu, my go to spot anytime I am going on the train, would recommendread more

It's an amazing little deli breakfast lunch right at the Elizabeth train station what a convenienceread more