Love the concept of Orange leaf! Self serve fro-yo. You select a cup size and select flavor(s) to your liking. There are an abundant number of flavors to choose from. You're also able to request a sample for any of the flavors since there are so many different types. For certain flavors, you can also "twist" them together- ex. swirl chocolate and vanilla. Great idea! The toppings selection is also vast. There are fruit toppings as well as candy toppings- so there is something for everyone! Payment is based solely upon weight of your cup- toppings and fro-yo both. Typically, I find myself spending around $6 for a decent sized amount. I once loaded the large cup full to the top and the total was around $9/$10. You can take your cup to go or hang out with friends at their unique orange seats. They even have outdoor seating. Great idea for post-movie treat since the movie theater is located right across the parking lot. Staff is awesome, talkative and friendly. I have no complaints! read more

We've been to other Orange Leafs and they are fun, especially for kids. A nice cool treat that you can essentially build yourself. This one is tiny, as they all are. Clean. Super friendly service. I was looking for a root beer float thing I had heard about, and they weren't sure, but they said it is a "fizz cup." And they did have one on display, and some signs promoting it, so yeah, I'm sure that's what I heard about. They essentially screw a bowl on top of a bottle of root beer, A&W in this case, and fill it with your choice of yogurt. Then you squeeze the bottle, the root beer comes up, and you flood the yogurt. Mix and enjoy. Definitely leave the lid on when you are squeezing, because it spouts like a whale or volcano. Their spoon is awkwardly shaped for the little bowl; one or the other has to change size and shape. It made a nice little float. It was fun. It was awkward. It was potentially messy, especially for kids. It is definitely not something to drink in the car, as I'd hope to do. I don't think I'll get it again, just make a float at home, but it was unique. read more

The food was delicious the best frozen yogurt I had in a while. The service was mid the girl asked for a tip when I did all the work. The place was nice and clean but the floor was a little stick. But overall it was a great experience. read more

The food and service is incredible and the ice cream is an addiction. please come here and try it, it taste like heaven. read more

Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt - Yummy Vanilla Froyo Cookie Sandwich - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

We like to come here so the kids can customize their own treats. Like many other yogurt places, they charge by the weight and offer many different flavors and toppings to choose from. My only gripe is the floors sometimes have toppings spilled on it so I end up with fruit chunks or other toppings on the bottom of my shoes if I don't check every step I make. read more

Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt - a hand holding a cup of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Great flavors. Pick as many as you want in one cup you can choose a waffle cone as well. You can choose the dividers that can assist you with getting three flavors in one cup or you choose to swirl option in the middle of each dispenser. They have countless numbers of toppings to pair with each flavor. Everything is paid for by wait so be careful if you're not trying to go over board but with so many options it's kind of hopeless LOL. Much healthier option than ice cream but it tastes so good it makes you feel just as guilty LOL Check in and get 10%off read more

Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt - Flavors - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Brought the kids here for the first time, they loved it! Truly a masterpiece. One of my kids choked but all was good! We will be returning! read more

Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt - yummy! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Anytime you buy movie tickets you get a coupon! I've been getting frozen yogurt from here for years! It's such a fun time. Always plenty of fun yogurt options and the best toppings. I'm always a fruit and the funky gel beads. Yum! read more

Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt - Fun little hang out spot - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

First time here on one of the hottest days of the year so obviously crowded and as a result of which the floor looked sticky and wet. But, their yogurts tasted so good. They have a wide variety of fro-yos with different toppings and were reasonably priced. Beautiful that it's totally self served and priced as per its weight. The employee was friendly and was asking each of their guests if she/he had been there before possibly to tell them how the serving/pricing work there. The only downside: the place is too small. read more

Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt - orange leaf frozen yogurt - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

This is your typical frozen yogurt joint. I really like fro-yo so I was pleased! The staff was very friendly and gave us free samples (you just have to ask!) They had a pretty good flavor selection and lots of toppings. I would go back! read more

See all

Rude staff - not helpful. Someone sleeping on the entry couch. Not a good look for you. Won't go back.

What a weird time to be a franchisee or own any type of restaurant, during covid. I took my wife and 2 of my girls here today. Owner was one of the nicest guys I have had the pleasure of speaking with. After helping us he told us we were his first customers of the day... 330pm. I simply said, "I can't imagine trying to run a business right now". That opened up the flood gates. Remember people. It's one thing to shop local and I do recommend it when you can. But franchise owners are in that boat. They don't have back up funds from the companies. They will just replace them. So if you visit here talk to the owner, he is far from shy. I didn't catch his name, just that him and his brother owned it for 7yrs now. read more

Maybe 3 stars is harsh but 4 seems too generous. Something just feels "off" from previous experiences but I can't quite put my finger on it. It felt like there was a lack of attention to detail or just a lazy air about the place. Maybe because it's more of an "off season?" Either way, it was just ok. read more

Interesting concept: you pick the flavored frozen yogurt, then decide if you want any toppings on it. Pay for the concoction, based on the weight. And eat it. First, I must add the following disclaimer: I am not a big fan of frozen yogurt. I DO like a few I've tried over my years of existence, but generally don't purchase it. This was a free family treat, thus I figured what the hey. A three-section cup was picked. We decided to fill the sections with Pineapple, Pomagranite and orange. We then moved to the toppings bar. In the pineapple: Chunks of the real stuff; Juice-filled tapioca pearls in the Pomagranite; and mandating oranges in the third. The end product was ok. I only ate a few bites, as the fruit flavors where not melding with my taste buds. The service was good, though. And the selection of toppings was a highlight. read more

See all

Close to the office. Check. More than one variety of boba balls. Double Check. Self Serve Froyo!!!!! I'm there!!!!!! Boba balls in my mouth are always a good time! When I visited they had 4 different flavors----so fab! Some nice things---they had about 12 different flavors, all the toppings had lids on them (I know pretty strange because I've actually have never seen that anywhere else), checked in and received 10% off--hooray for discounts. They also offer same day discounts if you watch a movie at the theatre next door. The place was bright and I agree some of the chairs are a little strange. I'm absolutely in love with their orange shovel like spoons---so cute. #froyoyolo read more

The staff was nice and friendly. My problem is that this place is tiny! Like how did they build this plaza and thing someone wanted a space that small. Another issue is that today, 4 flavors were out. The toppings bar isn't labeled so I'm asking what is this or that like a little kid. I also don't like that they handle the spoons. They are touching money and every bodies credit cards and then handing you that stubby spoon. The ice cream was great but this is just a strange little place that needs help. I'll try and find another location! read more

Self serve fro yo with all the toppings you can choose from! No samples due to COVID protocols, which is perfectly fine by me. The owner was very personable, greeted me as soon as I walked in, and made sure I understood how it all worked! Will definitely be back. read more

Back in the day there was The Country's Best Yogurt (TCBY). I loved it so much I cried when it went out of business (sniffle). But times are changing- Today we have Orange Leaf! You can't get better than this (puts feet up on orange plastic stool. Lifts hands behind head and leans back)! Self serve frozen yogurt- wwhhaa?? Yes, my friends- dangerous! Let me say it again, SELF SERVE frozen yogurt! Frozen yogurt in a variety of flavors for your choosing! Forget plain 'ole Vanilla or Chocolate. Ptew. Who needs someone behind a counter telling you to pick ONE?! Not me, I prefer to carefully chose my 4 (not that you need a limit, but 4 is my personal limit, as things get too hairy after 4 choices) flavors by calculating the ratio of sweet to sour. What do you think of Peanut Butter, Birthday Cake, Rasberry, Cheesecake!? Or how about Pineapple, Vanilla, Brownie and Creme Brulee? Or a Peppermint Strawberry Funnel Cake (ok, I might have made this one up)?! But seriously, flavors change a lot around here, so I would definately recommend coming in often- you never know what flavor is coming next! And if that werent enough- there is a toppings bar with Butterfinger, Granola, Gummie Bears, fresh fruit, nuts and these little squishy liquid balls that I have no clue what they are called (lol) and more! Then, as is that weren't enough- there are sauces to put on top of the toppings! Butterscotch, caramel, fudge and a new one I eyeballed today- ghardelli white chocolate!!! Oh it is heaven to my lips and hips.. Dangerously addictive. Don't wait for warmer weather- go get some yogurt tonight! read more

It's pretty good froyo. I've only been here once, so I only tried one flavor; passion fruit, and I liked it. Topped it with a scoop of fresh strawberries and some boba balls. The place was very clean and the barista was very friendly. There were about 10 flavors available, on their website they have about 50 or so (a lot), but I think they must rotate the flavors since they don't offer the full website selection here. I didn't pay since it was being treated for my birthday, however, it was over $10 for two people. I think that's pretty expensive considering we each filled the smaller bowl about a third of the way with only a few scoops of toppings. I couldn't imagine what it would cost if someone filled up the bowl, especially like the one pictured on their website, it looks like it could feed the whole family and then some! If it wasn't so expensive, I'd give it 4 stars. read more

Best frozen Yogurt in Columbus! I have tried them all and Orange Leaf is the best in price, variety and most imporantly TASTE! All of the flavors are so rich and yummy, I usually get a bit of each one and skip most of the toppings, because the froyo is what it is about, s hard to believe this is healthier for you than ice cream, it is so creamy and full of flavor I will definetly be back to Orange Leaf, I paid less than $2 for a descent size cup with a bit of each of their 8 flavors that change daily, who can beat that?!! read more

Honestly one of the worst customer service experiences I've ever had. Can't believe they are still in business with management like that. Good grief. read more

Not impressed, I have had better frozen yogurt and the fruit toppings were not very fresh. Almost all the toppings were candy and there were not many "healthier" options. The employees were not very attentive, and it seemed to only be two high school age kids handling everything, which is fine but it seemed they were not on top of things. The pineapple flavor tasted very artificial. I really just wanted plain but that was not an option. A few of their machines were broken so maybe that is why. read more

It is like every other fro-yo shop you've been to. The good: always clean, lovely, modern decor and usually friendly staff. The not-so-good: lack of variety. Not impressed with the flavors they typically have and there's always at least one fro-yo machine down. Flavors haven't changed since before summer so I always know what I'm getting. Decent toppings available - crushed chocolate bars, cookies etc and various sauces. Slightly pricey. If you get greedy in these kind of self- service spots (I just can't help myself!) it will run you over $5 per cup. read more

We had a small celebration for my son's birthday in here after our private cinema at Marcus Theater. My son is dairy free and they have several varieties that are dairy free. Many different toppings available as well. It was clean, staff was friendly and accommodating. Fun atmosphere. Highly recommend! read more

Me and my friend went to go get some Orangeleaf today and saw the most bizarre enter counter. The owner actually was freaking out on two customers because they threw a cup away because it wasn't the right flavor. He became very upset and even chased them out of the store for just simply wanting to get a new flavor. Let's be real the cup probably cost him .50. It was honestly so sad to see this. I felt as if I had to ask the employee that was working if she was OK because the owner was acting so out of line. I was so concerned. This was disturbing to watch him act as such to two customers that just wanted to get fro yo. Would never come back. read more

I love this shop! Every flavor I've tried has been fantastic. I'm partial to the coffee flavored yogurt. The shop is always clean and the owners are so friendly! A perfect snack after the movies! read more

Since being introduced to Menchie's in Dublin, I've been wishing there would be something similar close to me. Little did I know that Orange Leaf had been hiding, practically in my back yard, since May. On this particular day there were fewer fruit flavors, which was what I had been hoping for when I saw their sign. I ended up mixing chocolate, cheese cake, and gingerbread; then topped it off with crushed Heath bars, almond slices, caramel, and butterscotch. Even though I picked out the smallest dish, I filled it up with plenty of frozen yogurt to satisfy my palate. The whole thing cost me less than $5. They had somewhere between 8-10 flavors on tap that day. During a warmer time of year it would be a great place to have some outside seating to enjoy the weather with a friend and a nice bowl of frozen yogurt. read more

The owner is a colossal jack@$$. Have gone there many times. Never encountered the owner. Today was not our lucky day or maybe it was. My son did not like the vanilla. Got a new cup through about a dollar's worth away. Husband said he would pay for it after the jerk started ranting and raving. Then did not stop went on to demean other customers who wasted 6.00 dollars or more ouf product during the day. The guy is an ass. He is lucky there was no one else in the shop. And he lost customers. We had a groupon first time but still spent 20 on top of that. So it was not about the money. The guy is horrible. There are a lot of good businesses in Pickerington, this is not one of them. read more

i went there about a year ago with my mother inlaw and sister inlaws and i was so amazed by the kind staff that worked there. they let us try any flavor we wanted. so yummy...wish i had some right now... read more

Half of the machines were out of order, just about every topping was empty and things didn't seem to be very clean. The one person working was trying, but it was obvious that he couldn't keep up with everything by himself. I don't like to leave negative reviews, but this experience was deserving. read more

Because Yogurtland has yet to come to Columbus, alas, I have resorted to finding a second-best, yet equally delicious alternative. Actually, as a matter of fact, if Orange Leaf were to one of these days just decide to throw a Yogurtland sign on top of their existing sign, I wouldn't know the difference but for the construction-cone orange seats. So you got me, Orange Leaf, good play. Sometimes you have the weirdest flavors, particularly winter ones that I just don't care about. It may be my Scrooge-like heart, so please don't blame yourself. Only blame yourself for not having enough froyo machines to supply the world with 31 flavors like Baskin Robins does. Oh, the insanity! So keep doing what you're doing, Orange Leaf, because you have won my frozen yogurt heart! read more

Delicious! Lots of toppings, good service. A little pricey when you add stuff on, but overall worth it!!

Is it just me, or is the shop owned by 19 year olds? I never see any older adults. Ever.

Not a good customer service. I've been there a couple times and it was a good, but this time we left disappointed because one of the young girl employee was rude. when I was trying to get my frozen yogurt the handle got stuck so some of the frozen yogurt was left behind. the handle didn't work properly. She try to blame it on me, the customer for making her job harder. she said she had to wash the tray again. But I think that is her job. Now I understand that is close to closing time and she probably just want to get out there as soon as possible, but again I don't think is was my fault and to be honest I saw her when she took the tray back to wash it and it took her 5 seconds to rinse it. read more

Gotta admit, the only thing I can find wrong with orange leaf is their ridiculous chairs on the inside. This place loads up the goods with plenty of flavor and topping options. Their froyo is creamy and delicious. I wish it had a bit more tart kick to it, but tart probably wouldn't marry well with some of their flavors, which tend towards the rich side (cake batter, cheesecake, brownie, etc..) read more

I don't always love the flavors, but I had Rootbeer Float the last time, which was awesome!

Great yogurt wonderful staff. But seemed owner didn't like when I asked about smaller containers like we were told they used to have and from the staff they said owner refuses to bring the coffee flavored yogurt to her store cause she don't like it. Customers pays the owners bills and its popular at other orange leafs from what we have heard. Let the customers decide on it. If you don't like it don't eat it but it might be a best seller! Worth a try. This is why rating went from 5 stars to 4. read more

I have to agree on the chair comment, low and trendy like? Ridiculous like....but in terms of yogurt, flavor, selection and toppings they cannot be beat! The flavor choices are abundant and they all taste great, something for everyone! Cheap also! read more

I have only done frozen yogert once before and the last time was not so impressive. This time I was pretty pleased. I liked the flavors at orange leaf much better than the last place, they do well with the toppings too. I love the pumpkin flavor they have for seasonal. I will be back. read more

This place was awesome when it opened! Now it's dirty, they're always out of toppings (tonight out of both kinds of chocolate) and the staff isn't friendly at all. Such a shame to watch it go down hill :( read more