I have had their subs. the subs are well seasoned and meaty. they are my "go to" when I order at Paesano's. staff are courteous and helpful with any questions one may have. they also have specials that are tempting. read more

Family owned and run sub and pizza shop. They also have meals and portions are always perfect. Staff is friendly and cordial. Price is also right. read more

Best pizza in Southern York County! I also personally recommend the Steak Boil with mushrooms added. The wings are always crispy. Great location for take out or dine in. read more

Food is great you can not go wrong with any selection. Pizzas rock! And they will custom make subs to your order.

We always have a consistently pleasant experience for carryout here! Things are ready by promised pickup time, online ordering is super easy, staff is nice, and food is always what we expect. This is our go-to carryout pizza place. read more

Great food and great people. Authentic Sicilian. A must! Plenty of food to take home. Don't forget to order some extra bread to go. So good Update: we've also tried takeout. Also another great choice! Get their app and they post specials read more

Paesano's - a plate of pasta with mushroom sauce - Pizza Near Me - New Freedom, Pennsylvania

See all

Good website. Clean restaurant. I got takeout of two pizzas and a wrap and was blown away by the $70 price tag. But it smelled great so I thought I was in for a treat. When we got home, I was shocked by the bland pizza and overly greasy Wrap. We even found heavy chicken fat in the wrap. After a couple slices and a few bites out of the wrap, we found ourselves, throwing the rest away. I hope this restaurant is able to find some of that Italian charm in the future. I have to say it will be a long time before we visit again. If you're gonna spend $70 there are many other places in the New Freedom area that can provide a better meal. read more

Other than wishing that the pizza here had less flop and more of a crispier crust, Paesano's delivers. The food is consistent, the team there is polite and attentive, and while it falls short of my NY upbringing / pizza snobbishness, it is as good as you will get in the area. read more

My husband got me hooked on Paesano's. I crave their grilled chicken salad at least once a week. I'm an adult so I show restraint and get one every other week. Haha He always gets a pizza and while they do have gluten free for me I actually prefer the salad. It's pretty big regardless if you eat there or take out. We do sometimes eat in since they've done their renovations. I love how bright and spacious the dine in area is now. If you're in the area stop in and support a beloved local biz. Also, go right next door to Gill Ice for some good ice cream, gelati, etc! read more

Paesano's - a plate of chicken salad with tomatoes and lettuce - Pizza Near Me - New Freedom, Pennsylvania

Looks like a small pizza and sub shop but the food is like a 5star restaurant. From the pizza to the dinners have not had one bad meal. Chicken parm delicious must stop in if In the area Great food. read more

Good food for a walk-in restaurant. Weekly (or more) stop for me. Been going there for more than 3 years.

We came to New Freedom to ride the train with our grandson. This place is right near the platform and seemed a good choice as we were really hungry! The men inside were not overly friendly. We ordered a large pizza, fries and 3 drinks. The place was clean and comfortable. When the pizza came, I could see the crust was burnt looking. As I started serving slices, the bottom of the pie was also burned. Not a little burned; burned that you could smell it. I should have brought it back, but our little one was hungry and cranky and we gave him the least burnt piece that he would tolerate. We choked down sections of the other slices and left 2 slices behind on the tray...un salvagable. One man/worker was standing behind the counter that faced the dining room, playing on his phone. He saw me standing up, peeking under each piece trying to find a palatable one and sawing away at the slices, cutting off the most burned sections. He said nothing. I know it was my responsibility to take it back and to take pics to verify my review, but again, everyone was super hungry and a bit cranky from the long day. The fries were fine. I hope this establishment better learns to cook a pizza and/or check on their clearly unhappy guests. read more

The Arby's of Italian food. Overall blah experience. For the cost of the food, you would expect it to be delicious, but alas its not. First, the fact that the soda is self serve, in paper cups, come on now. Next, the pay first and then wait for your food, I'm sorry did I stumble into a fast food place? I thought this was supposed to be a nice Italian restaurant, not BK or McD's. But I could forgive all of that if the food was good, it wasn't. I'm pretty sure the Chicken Parm (patties) just came from Sam's Club and they just pour the cheapest sauce they could find on it and throw a slice of cheese on top. The Fettuccine Alfredo sauce was watery and nearly tasteless. Couple that with the fact that to add chicken (unseasoned) and broccoli was an extra $8 and you've got a recipe for a bad review. The atmosphere is no different than most fast food places, millennial grey and subway tiles and drop ceilings, with a couple pictures of trains on the wall, which is a shame because it used to have a nice vibe to the place. Sorry, but I would advise anyone and everyone to steer clear of this place. There are plenty of good restaurants nearby. read more

Hidden Gem -- Great find while riding the Heritage Trail. It was exactly what we needed - lunch and cold drinks. The homemade bread/roll is excellent and the service was friendly. We ordered a turkey boat and cheeseburger -- both tasty and fresh. Good quality turkey meat. French fries were also good. Will definitely put this on our list for next bike trail ride. Clean bathrooms also. Thank you! read more

The Italian subs were so good I ordered two nights in a row. The bread is quality Italian shop bread. Fresh and delicious! My order has always been made correctly and service has been exceptional as well. I'd love to try other menu items, but having a dairy allergy makes that's difficult. I absolutely recommend. read more

Paesano's - Super Italian Sub - Pizza Near Me - New Freedom, Pennsylvania

See all

Average food . Pizza crust had good chew , meat lover Stromboli was cold inside and had way too much deli ham , Caesar salad came with a packet of dressing(at least put it a cup Or something to make it look more professional) and had mozzarella which was odd . Decor not very warm and Italian. Wasn't sure if you want to a carry out or sit down as the set up is strange . read more

Had a "super Italian boat" sub last night and it defined generic tastelessness. Cost cutting meats weren't Italian but quite American. I think I got the small and not the large that I ordered & was charged for with cc upcharge %. The pizza I had a couple months ago was good but this sub harkens a visit to two other sub shops nearby namely S of S, or V D. Last timer here. read more

Best pizza in the local area. Far better than any other pizza in New Freedom, Glen Rock, or Shrewsbury. The closest comparable pizza is Mamma's in Loganville. read more

There's not much else to say about this place except it's the best Italian food around. Small store/eating area right off of the NCR trail. The staff is friendly and the food comes out quickly. Try the chicken marsala. They do take out as well. read more

Excellent pizza and subs. Get there before the train arrives to get a table. This little Italian Restaurant is a perfect complement to to the Northern Central Railroad just across the street. read more

Fresh bread that elevates flavors of subs/ sandwiches. Every time I get a cheese steak somewhere else I tell myself why bother because it doesn't compare to Paesano's. Love their pizza as well- sauce and cheese flavorful. Hawaiian is one of our fave's. read more

A cute local spot. They were very crowded and had a line out the door for pickups. Everyone in our party enjoyed their meals especially the chicken Parmesan. Unfortunately my raviolis were not homemade which was a disappointment:( read more

Good food, owned by real Italian family -- Ambiance could be cozier .... My only complaint is they charge extra for too many things , items that should just be interchangeable like cheese on a sub .... Italians are known for abundance and generosity ; don't be stingy, keep the customers coming for more. I had to pay extra for a pasta dish with gnocchi that clearly had not enough in the first place . You can still run a profitable business by loosening up just a little ! read more

My first time ordering and eating here. We choose to sit at the window bar for a little more privacy. I was craving Eggplant Parmesan without the pasta. Paesano's has an Eggplant Platter, which is a larger size of just Eggplant Parmesan without the pasta! Comes with salad and rolls. You order at the counter, but then they service you. Our waiter was great and attentive! The dinner was fresh and great, one of the best I've had. Not greasy, fried... My husband also enjoyed his Shrimp Fra Diavolo. I tasted his the sauce and it was also very good, fresh! Hubby also had ordered waffle fries for an appetizer. I didn't want to eat any, but they were so good! We will be back! read more

Paesano's - Eggplant Platter - Pizza Near Me - New Freedom, Pennsylvania

See all

Great sandwiches! The service was top notch. Very courteous. And the place was very clean. Highly recommended!

They are actually Italian... need I say more? As a native New Yorker, with Italian Grandparents, I love this place.

the mozzarella sticks were very good,extremely crispy and nice cheese pull 10/10 would try again.The cheese pizza was very nice a little to cheesy for my opinion but i would get again. read more

I have driven from Hanover to New Freedom to hit this place for dinner. It's much more than a "pizza joint". Their dinner entree's are delicious. However, I normally have lunch here (I work locally). Their pizza, subs and salads are all excellent. The rolls that come with the salads are stellar. read more

A local staple! This is the best pizza we've found in southern york county and has become a regular spot for our family. From pizza to sandwiches and even the pasta meals, we've loved everything we've had so far. The service is quick, the atmosphere is nice if you want to dine in and online ordering makes take out easy. read more

Eat here regularly. Very good pizza. Excellent meat ball sub. Clean with updated appearance. Good service.

We took our soccer team here Sunday after doing a charity event at nearby First Fruit's Farms. We were the only people in the place at 4 pm with 12 kids and 7 adults in our group. We received very good service from the staff. All the food was made fresh and very delicious. We were glad they had a TV to catch the end of the Raven's game. Unfortunately an unruly customer came in a 5 pm and yelled and cursed at our group for being too loud. I guess this customer never had kids and is used to eating at a lonely restaurant. read more

Paesano's - Kids table - Pizza Near Me - New Freedom, Pennsylvania

See all

The restaurant is in the heart of downtown New Freedom, PA. They have ample parking. I ordered a Spaghetti with Meatballs dinner as a take-out. The preparation time was reasonable. When it was ready I took it home. The dinner included a salad and some homemade bread rolls. The rolls were delicious. The spaghetti and meatballs were good. The salad was fresh and crispy. The only reason why I can't give them 5 stars was when I got home, they had not given me a fork or any type of utensil, nor were there any napkins. Luckily for me when i travel, I always bring my own utensils. I suspect it would be a great meal if I had chosen to eat at the restaurant. read more

Love this place! There pizza is a 10/10!! What I usually get is there stuffed shells, which is also great! Over the summer a Jill ice opened, which is so good! I love their mango! And the workers are so nice! (Sorry if I spelled Jill ice wrong) read more

Great pizza, cheese steaks and sandwiches. Quick to go! Salads are good too. Fries are always big and hot.

Stopped in for pizza after we rode the Northern Central Railway with our family. We're not local and weren't sure where to grab lunch. So glad we stopped here. The pizza was delicious. The owners were nice and the prices are reasonable. We will be coming back when we visit again. read more

Great Pizza, friendly staff, very close to the train and train station. Best pizza in New Freedom!!

It was the first time we tried this place and the last. We dined in, the atmosphere was more of a modern chilis look, no Italian anything, not even music, that should of been our first sign. Two boys that were maybe 16-17 took our order, they had to repeat the order back to us a few times because he put it in the computer wrong. On the menu it stated wings came in 6,10 and so on. So we ordered a 6 piece boneless. We also ordered what is pictured. When we sat down, an older man approached us saying the boneless wings did not come in 6 so we got 10 and he marked it on the receipt saying we owed more for them, we stated that the boy that took our order should of known that and that's really not our problem he wasn't properly trained. When our food came out, my portion (Chicken Marsala) could of fed at least 4 people! The sauce was more of a sweet Alfredo and the "chicken" was nasty and rubbery. My spouse got the gnocchi dish, the sauce was way overly sweet, gnocchi wasn't cooked long enough so it was chewy and the "sausage" was the same sausage they put on the pizza. We paid $60 for some wanna be Italian food with greedy owners or managers (whatever they were) Bread was good! But only fresh. I don't recommend. read more

See all

Very good Italian cold cut sub on delicious bread. Polite service and safety measures in force!

This is one of those places that's too well hidden, just a few minutes from I-83, Shrewsbury exit, awaits the finest lobster ravioli, the most magnificent, craft made pizzas, and the best staff, and passionate family owned, little piece of Sicily that you could ever hope to find. So many mouth watering choices, you'll have to come back a lot. Plan to take the family, they are welcome by the Paesano's family every day. No joke, make it your next destination for authentic, memorable, truly Italian getaway for lunch, dinner, or take out! read more

This place has NEVER disappointed. In my opinion, they have the best pizza in southern York County! Everything we've had from here has always been delicious and just what we ordered. Highly recommend! read more