Best Italian food I've ever had. Meatball sub and pizza are the go-to's. Can't recommend this place enough. Plus it's in a historic building in a cute small PA town. One of my favorite restaurants of all time read more

Great roll almost no meat has went down hill with new owners. Ordered a large Italian and could not find any meat. Thought I ordered a veggie sub. Very disappointed. read more

Our food was terrible! Sub was made wrong, asked for well done fries, they weren't even cooked all of the way and the pizza was blah. No flavor in the bread or pizza crust. I'm so disappointed! $41 for food that went in the trash! SAD I miss the old OIP!! read more

First time trying the place. Ordered large meatlovers pizza and meatballs online. It was ready on time. food was great, pizza well made with real dough not that frozen premade assembly line crap. Toppings were generous. Meatballs were very good, really good sauce. Staff was friendly. read more

Delicious pizza, and many options. They use fantastic and fresh ingredients and the owners are very kind. Great atmosphere. 10/10 would recommend ! read more

Under new ownership. Pizza still good. However, their organizational skills are severely lacking. Last 2 visits: 1. Told it'll take 30 min took 75. 2. Ordered 2 pizzas. 1 was done and out of oven before 2nd one went in the oven. a. The kids made the pizza and you can tell. Not up to past purchases. read more

The food is below average at best. The staff is rude and incompetent. Our last two visited we waited for our carryout order after paying for the order and final asked where it was. The order had been ready before we had arrived. No one even asked what we were waiting for. Items have been forgotten in the orders. DO BETTER read more

Food is perfect service was excellent. Nice staff who always smiling strongly recommend

We have ordered out from this local establishment many times and have always been delighted with their delicious food From their tomato soup to their Linguine with clam sauce everything has been excellent. Their homemade bread makes their subs great and, even though I am a bit of a New York pizza snob, I am more than happy with every pizza we have purchased here. I was off work yesterday and after some shopping I did a quick stop here and grabbed two slices for lunch. I can honestly say the pie was the best slice I've had here in PA. since I moved from NYC six years ago. I am glad this joint is close to my house, and I will continue to frequent it. read more

Had a party catered by these folks this past weekend. Food was fantastic, portions were good, and the price was great. The new owners are off to a great start - and they even gave us an extra we didn't order. Would definitely recommend! read more

Great food. Great service. Great conversation. Not a lot going on here but they know how to make good Italian food fast. Never had a bad pizza here. Love the bread for subs. read more

Worst customer service ever. I tried to place an order for delivery and the owner said that if I order the wings special that I have to pay in cash. I asked him why I have to pay cash, its illegal to make cash madatory and he became very rude. He started cursing at me and said "if I give you a deal I want cash, it's as simple as that" "if you don't understand than I don't know what to tell you, don't be so dumb". So I said ok you don't have to be rude and he responded by calling me a dickhead. I've never heard of someone being so rude and unprofessional. I highly recommend avoiding this place. read more

Good pizzas I recommend this place to anyone that loves pizza m. Is in stewartstown. Pa

Ok tried this place since my Dad recommended it as the best in Stewartstown. Sorry Dad but if this is your standard there are no good subs in Stewartstown. Pic on their website are very deceptive. Cheesesteak was lacking in meat big time. It was ok. Fries were really good though and very generous in their portion. They have a lunch special Tues-Sat until 3pm where you can get a sub , fries and drink for $8.99. Not a bad deal for what is offered....however today was Sunday and it cost us $13 more for 1 less fries and no drinks. Pretty sad. Bottom line is if you get the lunch special it's an ok deal...if not you will feel ripped off read more

The pizza is top notch. This family owned and operated family friendly shop is great! I get their pizza almost every week.

unlike the first reviewer Monique - I have had pizza like this in 73 different places. I got two slices ($3.78) and by the initial look, I thought they were old london style. but that was just the shape. it's total new york style - or most northeast us style. thin crust, tons of cheese, sauce not too sweet. added hot peppers and salt to mine. very tasty. good value. very surprising find in the bowels of pennsyltucky. 5 stars for good food, good service and value price. read more

See all

The BEST food in Stewartstown - Not just their pizza! Once a week, we usually get their mild Buffalo chicken wings and their cheese pizza. The prices are good, and the quality is great! Also have wonderful subs with great bread, and good salads. Everything is always fresh. Can't recommend it enough! read more

Pizza is average and the price is okay. Nothing to write home about but will do the job on a Friday night when you don't wanna cook.

This is great pizza, like we used to get in New York. The crust is a little on the thin side, and is cooked to be just slightly charred (yum!). The tomato sauce is not sweet nor too salty: just right. We ordered a whole pie, so it needed to be cooked fresh, and it didn't take too long. Service was friendly. My only complaint was the 4 TVs blasting sports at us while we ate, but this is a matter of taste. read more

I have only eaten at this establishment a handful of times. The pizza is the only thing I have ever gotten there, so I can't make any comments on the other items on the menu. As far as the pizza goes... it's pretty damn good when you get a pie fresh from the oven. The decor? It totally sucks. I get it...your a Squeelers fan. I'd throw that crap out in the street. Who the heck wants to sit around a bunch of tacky Squeeler crap while trying to enjoy a meal. If it wasn't for the decor I'd give higher marks. Try putting more Italian into your restaurant and alot less yellow and black garbage. I mean...it is supposed to be an Italian restaurant isn't it? read more

I ordered my food on line at 5:37pm on a Friday night. When I placed the order it said it would be here between 6:22 - 6:30. I called at 6:37 to see how much longer and the girl who answered said the delivery guy just left and he will be there any minute. At 7:00pm I called back and said can I just get a refund my food is still not here and I'm hungry. The OWNER got on the phone and said (very loudly and aggressively) you people don't understand that we had two drivers call out and now you expect me to get food out on time! I said look your employees calling out has absolutely nothing to do with me. I just want a refund. The OWNER said I'm not giving you a refund you people need to understand! and slammed the phone down! I will never eat at this facility again! To have an owner scream at a consumer like that is mind blowing! When the driver finally got here at 7:05pm I said I'm so sorry you have to work for a man that thinks it's ok to speak to people like that. The young man said I know I agree! I do not know why he speaks to people like that! That tells me he speaks to people like that all the time! Completely absurd! read more

Have a great lunch special. For $7.99 you get a sub ,fries and a drink. The soda machine had lost its carbonation when we asked for a refill .They brought out a soda bottle for all of us and a cup with ice to take along and apologized. The french fries were like fredh cut .The sub had plenty of fresh mest and veggies. Will definitely go again. read more

I was excited to try this place as I loved OIP from my days at Penn State. But as I drove home with my pizza, I noticed a strange odor. When I got home, I smelled the pizza boxes and they smelled musty, like they had been wet at some point. That smell even transferred to the bottom of the pizza and it was disgusting. It was so off-putting, I couldn't even eat the pizza. I also got an order of fries which were just thrown into a paper bag and were soggy and bland. Needless to say, I won't be back to this restaurant. read more

Absolutely awful service and treated like garbage! We decided to dine in on a slow monday night and ordered soup, salad and a cheeseburger sub. After about 25 minutes our server brought the soup out which was obviously frozen and microwaved, and way too salty. Another 20 minutes went on and the server was nowhere to be found so we took the full bowl of soup back to the counter and informed them it was extremely salty and we did not wish to eat it. We also requested that the salad be boxed and sub wrapped as we had now spent 45 minutes sitting down without our main dishes and no explanation or apology for the delay. Our server did come back to us with the bill for our food we havent received and said out food was being wrapped up for us. We decided to go up to the counter and politely asked if the soup could be removed from the bill since it was not edible and that our wait was now 45 minutes. At this time the owner got an attitude towards us and said that we didn't wait 45 min and told us that he we weren't going to get our food and that he no longer wants our business! It's unbelievable that he would get so offended by our claim that his store bought frozen soup was bad and that he no longer wanted our business. While the subs are good (I've actually been a takeout customer quite a few times prior) be prepared to be treated like dirt if something goes wrong with the order. I'm glad that some other customers were at the counter and witnessed his sheer lack of respect to us as human beings and as customers. * to the owner or any one else associated with the resturaunt that is reading this review. You have done a excellent job and driving away a customer that once spoke highly of the food and experience. I will certainly not return and will strongly recommend to anyone to never spend a dime at that place. read more

Pizza is decent, workers are not. I paid for my food and waited patiently for OVER 70 minutes until the workers realized that my food had been sitting on top of the oven. I still calmly took my pizza until the owner snidely said that people SHOULD BE MORE PATIENT! Are you kidding me? Who wants cold food? Fuming, I took the food anyway, but after leaving, turned around and took the food back and asked for a refund, which he refused to give me and started yelling at me. What business person acts like that? WOW read more

The food is fabulous when they get it right. Friends and I ordered delivery two weeks in a row and two weeks in a row it was it was delivered wrong. That's understandable considering how loud a pizza shop can be. When I called to notify the shop of the error the owner was incredibly rude to me. He actually took it a step further to actually call back to cuss, scream & accuse me of "trying to get free food." When I tried to express the customer is always right he literally screamed "that's bullshit. " Won't be ordering from there ever again. read more

They don't offer a large sub anymore. But they'll gladly sell you 2 smalls for $16.16 (robbery). The pizza is meh at best but for a small town they get by. Joe has always been great with me but I've seen him and heard from others that if there is an issue with an order or question on pricing, he becomes irate. He'll scream at his customers. Again this is a small town shop but there are other options in town. Honestly done with this place for good. Not worth the price, not worth hassle from the owner. Just do yourself a favor and go to Messina's. read more

My husband insisted on this place as he wanted their wings. I ordered a grilled chicken sandwich with bacon. They delivered a fried chicken sandwich. The replacement sandwich they sent out was grilled chicken, but no bacon. The 3rd attempt resulted in requesting a refund. " Sure!" And she hung up. Really? Really. I. Am. Done. Never x 100 again. read more

Ive been ordering pizza from this place for years. They USED to have great pizza. The last few times I ordered there the pizza has been over cooked. I never bothered to say anything until it happened several times. I picked up the pizza and yet AGAIN it was over cooked. So I say to the girl at the counter, " Ive been coming here a long time and lately the pizza has been very over cooked." She gets the owner. The owner is the RUDEST man I ever met. I try to nicely tell him Ive been coming there a long time and never had this problem until recently. He tells me the pizza is not overcooked and that im crazy. Im looking at this almost burnt pizza and can't understand what he doesnt see. I asked maybe you changed your recipe then... he starts cussing at me. I do not recommend this food any longer and certainly the service Sucks. read more

If I could leave no stars I would. We usually order from here and get great service. Well..... Not tonight! Ordered, the girl on the phone told me 45 mins, okay no big deal. Get there a few minutes early. She takes my money, she says a few more minutes. A few minutes turned into another 20 mins. I hear a gentleman ask what is she waiting on, if it weren't for him, I'd probably still be standing there. They all scramble to look for my ticket. They reprint it and the young girl, looks at me smiles and says not my problem, like are you serious young lady??????? Then the proceed to give me a gift certificate for $10????? Umm....excuse me, I ordered OVER $20 worth of food and this is how I get treated? NO THANKS, NEVER AGAIN!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

I would of given them a 1/2 star if I could of. This is the second time I've ordered from them and their food stinks. The people behind the counter are extremely rude and they need to learn how to use a calculator. My husband and I placed an order and they overcharged us over $10.00 then the guy had the nerve to give my husband a dirty look for not leaving a tip. For what handing a bag to him?? Plus the food wasn't very good. I've had a lot better even at McDonald's. My spaghetti was loaded with grease. We won't be back even if they're Steelers fans. Maybe they need to go to Pittsburgh to see how to cook real Italian. read more

FINALLY a good chicken Caesar wrap in southern York county. Pizza is great and fresh. Staff and owner are super friendly.

You want bland with that? I don't know what's worse the food or the atmosphere. The crust was like cardboard and tasted like it too. It's the kind of pizza cheese that pulls off the crust in one hunk even after being cut. Its also is the kind that when you fold it the grease drips off the end of the slice. The old guy behind the counter was rude and made multiple nasty comments to me about some of the other customers. And finally.....we get it.....you like the Pittsburgh Steelers. Could you fit any more cheesy tacky Steeler knick knacks to in the store? I doubt it...and I am a Steelers fan. AVOID AVOID AVOID read more

The chicken cheesesteak is the best ever. They make their own bread, which is fantastic. The subs are huge- the small size is. If enough for me or the large size if I want lunch for the next day. read more

Who knew? This little place has great pizza. A little gem in the heart of Stewartstown.

Been coming here for years. Joe is awesome! And the food is good. I've never been surprised by bad food here. Everything has always been what I've come to expect from them. They make the sub rolls with the pizza dough and the result is yummy! read more

Old school Italian family that does it right!! Bread and pizza dough made fresh daily and it tastes like it!! Owners do not compromise on quality. Though it doesn't happen often, OIP would rather charge a few cents more or have you wait a couple more minutes than give you a bad product! Don't pass up this unpretentious restaurant. Pizza, pasta or subs no one comes close within 100 miles. read more

Awesome NY style pizza. Fresh made sandwich rolls. Make sure you have a few minutes to sit down and enjoy the fresh made pizza and sandwiches. Turkey club was awesome. Cheesesteak was great. Found this place because of YELP and very glad we did. read more

Run by the most friendly and welcoming family you will ever meet! EVERYTHING on the menu is delicious, best pizza around by FAR. The homemade bread is incredible. Always very clean, service is fast, orders are always perfect. I recommend them to everyone. read more

Original has been around forever... well, except for the couple times they mysteriously disappeared for awhile then reappeared. They were probably the first place we ordered from when we moved to town in the summer of '95. Always reliable, consistent pizza and subs. The Chic-O-Philly was always my *usual*. The one thing that always irked me was the homemade sub rolls. Never could get used to them. They're rather odd and seem more like giant dinner rolls than sub rolls. However, most people I know seem to love them. Must be just me. But overall, the food and service are very good. read more