We had a great meal and service, and would definitely go back. The scallop entree may be the best we've ever had. The bolognese was also outstanding. Serving portions are large but not overwhelming. The oysters were excellent and the Caesar salad good. The wine list is approachable and the grapefruit cocktail was excellent. Our service was attentive l, friendly and knowledgeable. The ambiance is nice and inviting - enough buzz but not too loud. Give it a try. read more

Seafood restaurant at Sag Harbor, NY After visiting Wolffer vineyard, we drove to Sag harbor to have a lunch at the restaurant around 1:30pm. We had a reservation and was seated right away. The restaurant wasn't too busy. They serve lunch from 11am to 3:30pm. We ordered the following appetizers and dishes and shared: 1.Jumbo lump crab cake-$24 3out of 5- too much mayo, not much of crab taste 2.Charred spanish octopus $23 5/5- the octopus was very soft with nice smoked flavor 3. Mediterranean quinoa salad $17 5/5- really enjoyed texture of quinoa with arugula, tomatoes, cucumber, olives and feta cheese Main dishes: 4.lobster BLT-$32 3/5 very small portion of lobster 5.cod fish with vegetables in cream sauce-$34 4/5 the fish was cooked perfect but didn't like the creamy sauce too much. 6. Marinated skirt steak sandwich $25 3/5 7.garganelli pasta bolognese $24 2/5 sauce was very dry and salty, i asked our waitor whether sausage & broccoli rabe or bolognese pasta was better and he recommended this dish and it was a big disappointment. I am not sure if i would come back to dine here again. read more

See all

This is such a cute place! My friend and I met for lunch after Labor Day weekend, and it was still filling up, and service was great! The staff were friendly and everything was quick to come out. The food was fresh, and delicious! read more

Beautiful restaurant, great location right in town, and lovely outdoor seating. They accommodated my large group with a reservation just a few days in advance on a busy Thursday summer night. The service was a tad slow, but unless I'm in a rush, I don't necessarily mind. The menu has plenty of variety to satisfy all tastes. The scallops were excellent... very fresh and broke apart like a piece of butter. Slightly bland at first, I enjoyed it more as I got through the meal, appreciating its lightness and freshness. read more

The ravioli appetizer was really good but unfortunately the extended wait for the main course was ridiculous and when the duck confit finally arrived it was incinerated (literally burnt black). While the flavors were all good the slow service and terrible presentation of duck confit were enough to turn me off ever considering them for a meal in future. read more

I had the Charred Spanish Octopus with spicy nduja sausage, spaghetti squash, sun-dried tomatoes w/smoked paprika vinaigrette. It was very good. I wish the portion was bigger. I think this was more of an appetizer not an entree. We were there for brunch but no mimosa came with it. The service was great and the restaurant was very pretty inside especially during Christmas. read more

Had a lovely lunch here. The waitstaff were friendly and attentive and the food was nice. The vegan grain bowl could probably have done with some additional sauce but overall we were happy with the food. If you get a chance to sit outside, take it! read more

Page Sag Harbor - Lobster BLT - New American Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

See all

Excellent food, staff, and ambiance. What more do you need? A bit pricey, but that's life on the East End.

Great place brunch was amazing eggs Benedict 5 starts steak and eggs great French toast amazing service was on point Erick great job

Came in on a rainy evening to celebrate a friend's birthday and was met with excellent service. We were seated right away and the hosts took our coats for us. All the food was exceptional and this place had a perfect wine selection. The first course plates were quite small although very tasty. We tried the Gnocchi with wild boar, the Kale Salad, and the octopus. I had the Braised Short Rib on Polenta for myself with the side of Mac-n-cheese. Both were cooked perfectly and presented well. It was definitely more than enough food. This is a place worth going back to, possibly the next time I visit Sag Harbor. read more

Page Sag Harbor - Braised Short Rib - New American Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

See all

We came here with friends. Wonderful food and very friendly staff. However, it's very dark in here and it's hard to see the menu as well as your food. It's also hard to take pictures unless you put the flash on, and then you light up the entire table when you do. A little pricey for the lamb although it was very good. They continued to refill our drinks even though some of us didn't ask for a refill, but that's not terrible. Waiter forgot one of our appetizers (the Octopus) but it wasn't on our bill either. Good bar in the back (the Back Page). Liked the unisex bathrooms. read more

See all

Had a wonderful dinner with my best friend. The bouillabaisse is a must try. Oysters were very fresh! The ambiance is very welcoming and charming. Amazing wines, food and service. Our first time here but for sure we'll be back soon. read more

See all

Went for lunch. Crowded and lots of obnoxious kids with oblivious parents but food was good and service was excellent considering how busy it was. I like the way it's set up but way too crowded most of the time. read more

Very delicious eggs hollandaise, especially the crab cake version. Great service and delicious bloody Mary's. read more

Page Sag Harbor - New American Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Wow! Such a great meal. Everything from the salads and calamari to the pasta, scallops, shrimp, and seabass. The sauces really brought out all of the dishes. The server and the hostess were both very polite and provided us with an outdoor table per our request which we really appreciated. 5 stars!! read more

We just love this place. The people are always so welcoming and the food has never disappointed us. We like to sit in the window and watch the world go by in beautiful Sag Harbor. It's our go to restaurant when we are on the south fork. read more

Delish food and lovely, professional service. We'll be back! Warm and friendly with interesting menu items.

Great food. Service Friendly staff. Have never had a bad meal Wonderful brunch and lunch besides their dinner menu read more

Good place for family crowd and adult Excellent service We posted pictures of food Rigatoni was the best and crab cake too read more

See all

An awesome stumbled upon lunch date had me singing their praise when it came to the Bloody Mary and lobster BLT!! Service was another story, but it's sag harbor, they're all a little pompous. read more

Page Sag Harbor - Lobster BLT - New American Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

See all

Nice ambiance in this nice place to go in the summer on Main Street in Sag Harbor. Scott the bartender was exceptionally helpful and friendly. We sat at the bar and ordered salads. Nice and unusual greens, grilled melon, blue cheese and a perfect super light dressing. The family that operates Page, descends from late 19th century whalers from the Sag Harbor area.. read more

See all

Stopped by for a casual lunch. Top notch professional service. Excellent food. The monkfish sandwich was perfect. The chicken paillard was also. Great atmosphere. Classy but casual. The organic Mexican coffee also was excellent. Will certainly return when in the area. Hopefully for dinner. read more

Page Sag Harbor - Chance encounter at Sag Harbor. - New American Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

63 Main turned out to be a decent spot for a rainy day lunch. A group of us booked a reservation a few days earlier and came in early afternoon; we were seated in the enclosed patio area which was lovely (and a nice break from the mid-day downpour). A few of us started with cocktails -- I opted for the some kind of pineapple-cucumber libation which was really good (wish I remembered more of what was in it!). For lunch, I ordered a caesar salad with chicken ($24), which came with shaved parmesan, white anchovies and croutons. Pretty average as far as caesar salads go but glad they added the anchovies, a lot of places don't. Others in my group mostly got sandwiches, quinoa salads and grain bowls - no real complaints but nothing really stood out either. Not sure if I'd seek it out again but wouldn't hesitate to return if I happen to be in town. read more

Page Sag Harbor - New American Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

See all

Came in again and sat at the bar with Ernesto and Mario. Both of them were amazing. We had great conversations and lots of laughs! Ernesto's sangria was out of this world! Ernesto switched to the floor so Mario continued with us. His cocktails were outstanding! He made 2 drinks that he was very proud of which were an espresso martini and a rum mojito. Definitely stop in for great food and great people! read more

Page Sag Harbor - New American Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

More of a local crowd, especially off season. Better quality fair than most Hamptons places and more reasonable prices. Nice bar scene.

Had a bad vibe when I went to this bar. Bartender named Allen was rude to me, and trying to flirt with all the girls. Not going back here.

Unfortunately our first night out in nearly 3 months due to COVID-19 was ruined when the owner/manager asked us to leave the table as a new party was coming in. Nowhere it was mentioned that reservation would be limited to 1 hour. Bad bad service! They were bringing the food too fast, couldn't even enjoy it as the whole experience was rushed. We came from NYC to have a nice relaxing time and this place just ruined it all. Please avoid this MONEY HUNGRY restaurant as there are plenty great restaurants in Sag Harbor. SHAME on you! read more

The food is excellent warm and welcoming staff and the desserts by Irina outstanding!!!

Came here with a small group for a bachelorette. Had a reservation, we were led to their second location that is behind the main restaurant - we were first concerned but really enjoyed the ambiance of the outdoor area! Extensive wine list but no cocktail list. One entree was unfortunately forgotten about, but waiter was apologetic and the missing dinner came out piping hot not too much later. Overall a cute option for Sag Harbor would try again. read more

See all

This place was awesome! When you nail atmosphere, decor, food, and service its a good sign. This is a must visit stop for lunch or dinner or just drinks. read more

Page Sag Harbor - Gemelli Pasta, Sausage & Broccoli Rabe was light and excellent. Cavatelli crab pasta stole the show though. Simply amazing - New American Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

See all

Wish we were able to sit in the back patio area. We were in and out in less than an hour for brunch. The food was good but it felt like they were trying to rush us out even though it wasn't busy at all. Also a bottle of Pellegrino was $20. read more

Came in for brunch on a beautiful weekend. The service was fantastic. The waiters went that extra mile by making sure my friend's son's food was out right away so he wasn't antsy at the table. When we wanted to split a salad, they actually had it put onto two separate plates so we could easily have our own portions. The flavors were really delightful. Loved the kale salad with peaches and nuts, super summer flavors. Then the grilled halibut was on point. Really amazing place to enjoy a meal out in Sag Harbor. read more

Really enjoyed a nice quiet brunch outside. The waiter was on top of his game with refills and any condiment requests. He even was great with recommendations based on what we said we enjoyed for drinks. Oysters were very fresh and the cocktail sauce was on point. The portions were great and the price point was just what you'd expect for the quality. My chicken was crisped to perfection with a nice dressed arugula salad on top. Only recommendation would be is to add a shaved cheese on top. The eggs Benedict was cooked wonderful with a tasteful amount of hollandaise sauce. 10/10 would go back. Great food, impeccable service and a relaxing time. read more

See all

Used to be my fave but today just sucked! I go to have a late lunch at the bar, after all it is a restaurant and not a "bar" and I felt at home going there as an escape from working at home. Today was different. There were two totally DRUNK and LOUD women at the bar and when I mentioned it to the manager Jackie, she said she wouldn't do anything about it. Many people left, SAD If you'd like a sophisticated place to hang and have a drink and a quick bite at the bar this is no longer it. I used to love this place. read more

Thank you for being nice again! Food excellent Chef's Outstanding Staff being nice Overall is good to be back!! Sag Harbor is better with love and nice atmosphere! read more

We came here for a spontaneous lunch and everything was so good! Service is exceptional, food delicious, and we loved the Christmas decor. My husband said it was the best rueben he's ever had, and my lobster blt was so so good! read more

So we were on vacation and figured we'd give this place a shot needless to say for the prices the service wasn't great. I asked about the Lobster Roll if the lobster was fresh and was told it was froze. Major let down for a restaurant that's literally minutes from the water. The waitress didn't even come check on us until we were finished with our food so needless to say my wife finished her salad without the chicken that was supposed to come on it. Next trip we will not be revisiting this location. read more

We were going to go across the street to Donna Karan's place but it seemed to be riddled with onlookers looking to be obsessed with other people. This place is cool! The food is excellent. Cant how good it is. The drinks were very lite on pouring of alcohol.... The pink shirt guy told a Black guy ," I was going to tell you to that we had jerk chicken!" I have seen the guy in town and I know he's been around....and seem to be swell liked by many. To say that was culturally rude... insane. He's little rude. Food was good, service was good .... drinks weak management not so cool read more

Pleasantly surprised! Expensive but not outrageous and the fish was excellent. Wished they had more vegetarian items on the menu

Last Thurs. eve (August 22, 2019) my husband and I went to dinner at Page. The little town of Sag Harbor was bursting at the seams even though it was a week night and Page was full and very busy. We were seated immediately. There was no wait, AT ALL to speak of, in between drinks, apps, dinner and dessert. Our waiter was wonderful, went above and beyond, the food was absolutely mouth watering and scrumptious. Here's the thing and I do not say this lightly: we've never had such a wonderful dining experience ANYWHERE, EVER! I do not exaggerate. We were both so impressed we asked to speak to the manager, Eric, so we could tell him. We have been married over 40 years so you know we've dined out a few times. I can't wait to go back there. What a wonderful experience! Go! Dawn L. read more