Again, wish I could give 1/2 stars because I would give it 4.5 stars. If a place ever earned the phrase "don't just a book by its cover", it is this place. I had chosen this place to have dinner with friends from out of town that were vacationing in Sag Harbor. Reviews looked pretty good and fit what they were looking for: good food, water view, not too far from where they were staying. When we drove up, I was seriously questioning myself. The outside looks like a little dated and small. But as other reviewers have said, the interior is very nice and spacious! We were lucky to get a window table although it was foggy so we could not see a lot of the water; just the parking lot and dock. But still better than nothing. I forgot to take pictures of the apps but we shared multiple orders of the burata, fritto misto and salmon tartare (yes, you read that right). All were good and I did enjoy the tartare. For entrees, I got the fish and chips, Cathie got the bouillabaisse, friends got the chicken Milanese special (what a deal!!), Scottish salmon with ramen, burgers, and another bouillabaisse. We all loved our choices but highlights were definitely the chicken Milanese dinner special (because even with slight up charges for certain items, it is an amazing deal!!); and the bouillabaisse. As some other reviewers have said, this is a MUST ORDER! The broth is not too tomato forward but instead is very flavorful with other spices, not just saffron, and the same food is generous and prepared so well! I will come back just for this! My fish and chips were good, even the Cole slaw although I prefer meatier French fries (although these were still good, nice and crispy). Desserts were also very good and service was good after a couple of bumpy starts. read more

See all

Bell and Anchor is located outside of the Nautical town of Sag Harbor. The food is scrumptious and the service is ideal. Securing one of the tables by the window overlooking Noyac Bay is definitely a splendid bonus, especially when the summer sun is setting, making it a picture-perfect time to capture the spectacular cotton-colored sky. Reservations are almost mandatory during peak season; wanting to book same day is challenging, however, late evening oftentimes works. A long, dark bar sits by the entryway with cheerful bartenders awaiting. The Bouillasse is a favorite, with clams, muscles, fish, shrimp and lobster in an an unbelievable pinkish-red stew flavored with lovely saffron. I was slightly disappointed the lobster didn't budge easily out of the shell. Nevertheless, the Bouillasse still remains a favorite. Without a doubt, I'll be back for more. read more

See all

My favorite spot for oysters and martinis in the hamptons. Great staff, great service and a lovely menu that features many seafood staples plus a few dishes with creative flair. The restaurant is always full and busy yet still remains intimate and timeless. Highly recommend! read more

Bell and Anchor - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

See all

Very cool place with delicious seafood. Great friendly staff. Nice nautical decor. I had the 1 and 1/2 pound lobster and it was cooked and served perfectly. read more

Bell and Anchor - Maine Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Pleasant and lively setting. Had made an early reservation and were seated by a window with a view of Noyac Bay. Had littleneck clams on the half shell which were superb Shared the Cobb and Hearts of palm with Bibb Lettuce and toasted pistachios. Both had fresh and tasty ingredient We had four entrees and each of those was prepared exactly as we ordered. The Bouillabaisse had all the seafood (substantial) perfectly cooked and its tomato saffron broth The roasted fluke and the fish and chips were enjoyed by our friends. I had the roasted Scottish salmon with ramen noodles edamame Napa cabbage and the lemongrass-ginger broth that enhanced the flavors of the salmon which was perfectly done "rare" The service complemented the food as it was done efficiently and well. read more

Bell and Anchor - Scottish salmon with ramen noodles on a lemongrass-ginger broth - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Very nice spot. Our server was awesome, the view was really good, and I liked the food and drinks. Tried the oysters, steak, and negroni and was super pleased with everything. read more

Our server Valerie could not of been nicer or more professional. The food was amazing! The whole night was just a beautiful experience.... Sorry it took us so long to find this gem. We will become regular customers!!! read more

Decided to check this place out while we were visiting Shelter Island. Just took a ferry over and enjoyed the beautiful views on the way over. We had a reservation for outside, but it was so hot we asked if we could sit inside, and they were very accommodating. We ordered the frito misto, surf and turf, and the lobster pasta dish. Everything was amazing! Would definitely recommend if you are in the area! read more

See all

Everything was great: food, ambience, service staff. Carl and John at the bar are fantastic! Very popular establishment and hence reservation are a bit difficult BUT worth it. read more

We had a lovely experience with the family at Bell and Anchor. Food was amazing and service was top-notch. Atmosphere was lively.

This place is like the Tardis. Small on the outside and bigger on the inside. The food is good but not great. I got the Ribs. The spinach that came with it was raw and unseasoned. The fries came out cold while the container it came in was hot. The ribs themselves were good. They call it a "Guava baby back ribs" but I tasted no guava. The lobster risotto had only traces of lobster at best. The cod dish was pretty good. Service was average. They brought out the food super fast. There is always something cold or undercooked when food comes out that fast. Today it was the fries. The dining room is kept so dark you can't see the food that's in front of you. read more

See all

Love this spot! The ambiance and service was overall great. They have great happy hour deals

Ambiance was beautiful. Located on the water and the interior is decorated so pretty. The waitress was very attentive. And the food was delightful. I will be returning next summer! read more

Bell and Anchor - Super cute spot located on the water. I enjoyed everything we ordered. - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Fantastic restaurant. We always go here every summer. Bouillabaisse is a must. Steak is delicious. Service always impeccable.

Food was alright. Ordered the clam clowder and mixed calamari + other seafood. Portion isn't enough. Service was great. We didnt have a reservation, but was able to get seated very quickly. Parking right outside the restaurant. It's for a special occasion (a date) although hangouts are fine too. read more

Delicious meal served by friendly and attentive staff. The restaurant is spacious yet warm and inviting.

This place deserves more than 4 stars. Nice ambience inside and nice view. Really great seafood and fast attentive service, we started with the fritto misto which was very good. I ordered the bouillabaisse and my husband got the flounder. Both were really good! We swapped halfway through - the sauce with the flounder was incredible. Next time I want to try the mussels appetizer. The ladies next to us had steak which also looked great. We will definitely come back when out in the hamptons. read more

Bell and Anchor - bouillabaisse - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Amazing all around. Chowder 10/10. Boulabaisse 10/10. Almond cake 10/10. Cocktails fantastic. Service on point. Right on the water. What else could you ask for? We will definitely return again and again!!! read more

This is a good option for the hamptons with a nice location, but I didn't find the food to be that great. The tuna was a little salty, there was way too much soy sauce. They forgot to bring our shrimp dish for us. The lobster pasta was good, but unlike the tuna, it needed salt (and pepper). The muscles were good, but I wish they would give us bread to soak up the sauce. read more

Vibrant atmosphere. Really good seafood. Love the menu and all the seafood options. Sometimes it is a little loud inside and hard to hear. Okay service. read more

My favorite restaurant. Easily passed by from the street - yet so pretty inside. Lovely atmosphere (bar, lighting, ceiling, plants), not pretentious, friendly attentive staff, very fine menu selection that would please everyone, tasty appetizers, fantastic entrees, steak perfectly cooked every time. read more

See all

Amazing !!! Don't let the facade f the restaurant fool you. The restaurant opens up to a beautifully appointed space!! The food was amazing!!! read more

This is up there for best meal I've had. For appetizers we got a dozen of the East coast oysters which were very fresh and sweet, The Naughty Blu was very good and, when asked, got a generous amount of extra blue cheese olives, the Apple Bread Pudding was amazing and a decent size. But the star of the meal was the Local Flounder Francaise. The fish was flaky and well seasoned, the veggies were perfectly cooked and the beurre blanc sauce was nice and rich. Overall, *french kiss*. Giving 4 stars though because, while our server was nice and attentive, they didn't know whether one dessert had nuts in it or not, which one person in our party was allergic to. Luckily, before she ate it we luckily caught it in time. But with nut allergies being so serious and common you should know what does or does not have nuts in it. read more

Every experience at Bell and Anchor is memorable. The service at the bar or the table, impeccable. The dirty martinis in a cold glass, delish. The food...don't even get me started. Truly a 10/10 for every south/sag Hamptons trip. read more

Unassuming from the outside, excellent on the inside. We were the last table - eight people, no reservation, and a quick call ahead before arriving - on a sleepy off-season Thursday night. We left happily satiated after being very well taken care of. Bell and Anchor offers good cocktails and wine and the food, from appetizers to entrees, is excellent. We started with a couple dozen Montauk oysters which were terrific, which you'd hope for since they come from just down the road. I could eat these for hours with a nice, non-sweet sparkling wine. The Oaxacan old fashioned, with Mezcal, drew good cocktail reviews and I had The Mary, a fresh and clean drink with cucumber vodka (light on the cuke taste), St. Germain, and a splash of pineapple juice. For food, the mussels were awesomely juicy and cooked for just the right amount of time, with coconut milk and lemongrass. The burrata salad - always a favorite - was yummy, with arugula, roasted figs, pomegranate seeds, and a light balsamic dressing. Bell and Anchor has nightly entree specials and we were lucky that Thursday is bouillabaisse night. Several of us ordered it and all were happy with it, especially on a chilly night. Great meal, fair prices, and excellent service. Highly recommend. read more

My wife and I were looking for a romantic sunset seafood dinner. My search found this place one of the only restaurants nearby that was open on a Tuesday in November. We came for the sunset and found an exceptional dining experience. I took some spectacular pictures when we arrived but once we sat down to eat, we forgot about the sunset. We ordered the calamari salad special. It was fresh crispy calamari on a bed of arugula and frisée served with a creamy chili dressing with peanuts. It was a spectacular salad. We loved it so much, we asked to purchase some of the dressing. We then ordered fish and chips. We recently travelled to England and loved the fish and chips there. The fish here was well buttered and very crunchy (just as I like it) It came with two healthy pieces of fish. They served it with both malt vinegar (traditionally British) and tartar sauce. Came with a overflowing serving of fries and delish slaw. All were fresh and tasty. Kevin was our server and he was excellent, checking in on us frequently and very attentive. We finished the dinner with a brownie and ice cream. I bit too fiudgie for me. Also if the brownie was warm I t would have been a nice touch. But I won't even count dessert. This was a pleasant find and we will be back. read more

See all

Food never disappoints, views are pretty of water. I wish the outdoor seating was nice and location is okay. We love this as a family dinner spot! read more

My favorite restaurant out east!! The food is spectacular every time, and the service is incredible. If you eat at the bar, the bartender Carl is the most personable, efficient, and experienced staff member you could ask for. Definitely check it out, the cobb salad with salmon is my go to!! read more

Ive been going to BnA for quite a few years. Was always consistently good until this past season. Our party ordered the special which was swordfish with spinach gnocchi and carrots. The swordfish was stick your throat dry, carrots underdone and gnocchi was doughy and tasteless. All a big disappointment at quite an expense . The past couple of dinners the fish dish on the menu was also way overcooked. What to say? I love this restaurant and I'm hoping the kitchen pulls it together. The owner is a great guy and the staff always friendly and efficient. read more

Delicious and lovely staff. It's lovely for fall and winter too with a warm feel inside!

If you're looking for a great dinner than look no further. We were seated promptly at a gorgeous table overlooking the sunset. The restaurant itself has a really warm, classic vibe and great views. Service was well above average. This is one of the few restaurants where you really don't feel rushed. Everything was timed appropriately and we never had to ask for anything. The food was PERFECT. And I mean perfect. The pork chop was super moist and flavorful. Burger was on point. The fish was very fresh and cooked well. An all around fantastic experience. 10/10 can't wait to go back. read more

Bell and Anchor - Grilled Herb Crusted Pork Chop - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

See all

Came in for our first time and sat at the bar with Carl. He was very personable and funny. Carl was very knowledgeable about the menu and the drinks. We were blown away by everything we had which you will see in the pics. The atmosphere is very nice with a beautiful view. Carl's drinks were absolutely incredible. I highly recommend stopping in here for a great meal and drinks! read more

See all

My god. My human god. What a place. They boasted about their bouillabaisse once. I had never known how to spell it, but a sign near the bathroom said "it's back." I had never heard of a bouillabaisse being "back", much less gone in the first place. But it sounded like their bouillabaisse went on a trip, found itself, and returned stronger than ever, with a new sense of purpose and vigor for life. And it did. Yes the chowder is amazing. Yes I have eaten the mussels and accidentally eaten the shells of the mussels, drank the broth on purpose and lived in the parking lot for two days. Of course everything on the menu is what heaven looks like if you have been good. But the bouillabaisse is something you take home to your mother and she forgets about you, and she starts bragging to her friends that the bouillabaisse did well in school AND made friends at summer camp. So. Get the bouillabaisse. Get anything. You'll be happy. But... Get the bouillabaisse. And don't bring it home to mother. You know the expression, "it's nothing to write home about"? Write home about the bouillabaisse- do not take it home. Summer camp will never be the same. -the oyg read more

I went with a large group. We tried many of the apps; chowder, mussels, tuna and entrees; lobster pasta, branzino, burger, chicken, as well as the special for the night (swordfish). All the food was great. The ambiance is very nice. The service was a bit slow, no check ins for drinks, took a long time to place orders. The cocktails were inconsistent. Some very good, a couple undrinkable. But overall good experience. read more

Simple bar/restaurant with great water views. More local crowd and better price/value relationship relative to other Hamptons places.

Terrible cocktails. And waitress has a bad attitude. Zero charm . Entree steak not cooked as ordered.. sides were cold and lacked presentation. Very expensive too. Disappointing... will not be returning read more

Cute place with a cozy atmosphere. The service was great and the food is good. All my choices (Fries, arugula salad, vegan lasagna, apple bread pudding and the harbor non alcoholic drink) were very good! read more

Bell and Anchor - Vegan Lasagna AMAZING! - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Always great to- never a contrary experience. Food -A1; service - A1, not loud, excellent

Glad to report Bell and Anchor is back to high standards! Service, atmosphere and food were all phenomenal this past weekend. Local fish (halibut) with jasmine rice and coconut sambal is so flavorful and delicious - and not too spicy! One of the best dishes I've had there without a doubt. Wine selection and dessert perfected the meal! Definitely was an off night the last time I went and haven't experienced a bad night since! read more

Food is great from apps to dessert Service is quick The restaurant is unassuming, nice, good views Almond cake is incredible Highly recommend read more