We got takeout the pizza was delicious and the order was on time. I would like to try different kinds one day. read more

Pagliai's Pizza - All meat Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mankato, Minnesota

See all

Terrible customer service. Gave them a chance after the first round of nonsense. Just walked in and walked out today. I don't care how good their pizza is. 1. Their staff is rude; 2. The pizza comes all sloppy and a hot mess in the box; and 3. "Za" is right across the street and they make NY style pizza. read more

Pagliai's is a very busy place with fabulous pizza! Even the cheese bread is a must to get! We had 1/2 Sweet Heat and 1/2 "B" special. It was divine! The flavors and seasonings are perfect and the service is fast considering how busy they are. It's a small place with big flavors, fast and friendly service that you don't want to miss! Great for take out or dine in! read more

In a town of amazing pizza, Pagliai's stands alone at the TOP of the mountain! Cheese glorious, cheese! Plenty of staff to crank out the eat in orders. A nostalgic place like this should have Coke products, but I didn't come here to drink soda. They have 6 beers on tap, including Modest, a twin cities best in class craft beer. read more

Pagliai's Pizza - Plenty of staff to crank out the eat in orders. - Pizza Near Me - Mankato, Minnesota

Tried the restaurant week special: wonton pizza. Loved it for something different. Will always recommend Pagliai's for pizza in Mankato. read more

Good Best in town and cut in squares. Fresh ingredients I miss the shrimp on the pizza read more

We were traveling through New Ulm. We ordered a pizza over the phone and when we picked up the pizza we got back on the road and got out of town before we started eating it. Found out they had given us the wrong Pizza. read more

We've been to Pagliai's way too many times without writing a review, so here it is. This place has two of our favorite pizzas that we've ever eaten. My wife loves a good Taco pizza and they have the best we have experienced so far. My favorite is the bacon cheeseburger. They have Al the classics and we have never been disappointed with anything we've ordered. My son is not a big pizza fan and orders their pasta and sandwiches/subs and loves them. Service is solid. They have a small selection of domestic and even local brew beers. They also have a nice selection of ciders if you're into those. It is a classic pizza joint. Don't expect any fancy seating or decor. The pizza ovens are on full display up front, dinner and a show! read more

Pagliai's Pizza - Half and half, taco and bacon cheeseburger. Taco comes with taco sauce and sour cream. - Pizza Near Me - Mankato, Minnesota

it is the 2nd best pizza i have ever had if you go you will get great serves and great pizza

I could not wait ti get off work Friday 2/26/26 to go to this restaurant to get the garden pizza. I had only had this pizza 2 previous times and it was so good it left a awesome taste in my mouth. I was so disappointed. The tomatoes on top of the pizza did not look fresh like last time a month ago. The bottom of my pizza had black ashes on it as though the pizza oven had been used so much and not cleaned that the soot was on the bottom of my pizza. Not only was soot on the bottom there was a piece of soot in the box. The pizza looked sloppy and I thought what happened. I expect this pizza to look fresh it fid not taste all that well either something was missing so I liked the cheese up well there we a few onions on my.pizza as though they may have run out. I decided to take it as a $27 loss not leave a tip. I thought about calling, but sadly good service is not what it should be. I did not want to get into an argument. I just decided to write a review and never return. I'm disappointed because I been telling people how good and fresh this pizza was when I ordered. Although, it was on a Friday is no excuse either they were not to busy. I do have photos. I don't have a login. read more

Greatest pizza in Minnesota! I've been coming here for years. Worth the trip from the cities.

A very happening spot in downtown Mankato. I was in town for my bday, and had lunch here with a friend. Great hospitality & service, delicious. The name is pronounced "Polly-Eyes" ... my brain keeps wanting to say "PAGLIANI's" (which is a different place, probably in New Jersey lol) Due to my east coast upbringing, my pizza standard are high. While this one doesn't 100% meet Jersey pizza... they do have solid pies and garlic bread. Everything feels authentic in the food. Plus, they let me play Frank Sinatra and were quick to correct an error in our order. Quite busy during lunch, which is a good sign; however, next time I'll come during a quieter time. Liza the manager is the sweetest, as is the rest of the staff we met. read more

See all

We ate here for dinner the day of the Marathon, so it was expectedly busy. Regardless, we located a clean table near the back and were waited on within a few minutes. The server was helpful and pleasant. We ordered the Pagliai Special (sausage, green pepper, and onion) and it was delicious. The crust was thin and crispy - which is a key to successful pizza in my book. Would return and recommend. read more

Good pizza, but too much sauce for my liking. Our server was super attentive and told us about all their specials and checked in on us regularly. My husband and I both got personal sized pizzas for lunch, and it was more than enough and a steal for $8 with a pop included. If we're down in the area for lunch, we'll definitely stop in again, I'll just order with light on the sauce. read more

College town pizzeria was my expectation, but I was pleasantly surprised by excellent wait staff!! And awesome food!! The salad I started with was fresh, colorful, very tasty! Then came a "Huge" plate of spaghetti with excellent sauce. The cheese bread was wonderfully covered in melted, gooey goodness! The final topping to an amazing meal, the bill With a 20% tip was only $17.00.... And I have enough leftovers for a full lunch meal!! When in Mankato, and your ready to fill your daily carb needs, definitely visit Pagliai's with a hearty appetite, you won't be disappointed read more

Pagliai's Pizza - "Regular" size serving of spaghetti with meat sauce and 4 slices of cheese bread!! - Pizza Near Me - Mankato, Minnesota

You get hit by the old school pizza aroma the second you walk in. Fantastic service, pizza is classic thin crust, heavy on the toppings and cheese. Very good! read more

This place is quite possibly the best pizza place on earth. They put the pepperonis underneath the cheese (which is huge), their cheese is perfectly melted, sauce is great. You can't teach it. Tremendous pizza. Great service. Recommend to all family members, friends, and strangers. Can't say enough about this place. read more

Pizza never fails to be amazing! We always make a point to stop here when we're in the area! read more

One of Mankato's oldest restaurants brings you tap beer, perfectly baked cheese bread and DELISH deep dish and original crust pizza. The Pagliai's moved from Italy to Iowa around the start of WWI and served pizza in Ames to a growing crowd. Eventually the family loved its business to Iowa City, where it's still owned by members of the original family. During the years, other Pagliai pizzas sprouted up in college towns across the Midwest. Thankfully. And Mankato citizens and area college students are all the happier. Not much goes back into the decor - it's frankly a dive. No matter. The service comes with a smile and the best 'za around. Enjoy. (We devoured our pizza and cheese bread before we could get out the camera.) read more

Solid pizza We're inside of their expected delivery time. All specials are worth trying. read more

Old school style pizza. We liked it but had it at home. I suspect the crust would have been crispier if we had eaten it in the restaurant. Next time we'll eat in the restaurant. read more

See all

Excellent very filling pizza that is thin in the crust but full on the toppings also an amazing garlic cheese bread with Canadian bacon and if you want a drink have a good selection. Very good service and a nice atmosphere. Can I am told he rowdy on nights when college games are playing. read more

My girlfriend and I recently moved from Arizona and we're trying new places to eat in stumbled across this pizzeria. Tyler, the manager is beyond excellent with his customer service the ambience of the vibes he brings to his establishment. Kudos for having spectacular food or I highly highly recommend yall stopping by for food made fresh to order! read more

See all

My husband wanted to order from this place whole we are staying at the City Center Hotel and toss place delivers so a nice plus. However, delivery was quick but we didn't get utensils or plates and napkins to eat our food. The milk that was listed for delivery only said it was in a glass bottle but when it came it was in a 32 oz. cup for soda. The pizza was greasy and had little shape integrity. The spaghetti was good. The garlic toast that came with the spaghetti was over toasted and burnt. Overall, it was a decent first experience since I like the ability to order online and customized with special requests. There was a good pizza list but it didn't have the kind that I wanted and would have to customized which turns out to be way to expensive so I went with one of their pizza options. Will stick with Domino's even though it's a chain. At least I'll be able to order it the way I like online without having to use the phone to call and not be able to look at the menu while on the call and would have to put the person on speaker. read more

Pagliai's Pizza - Spaghetti - Pizza Near Me - Mankato, Minnesota

See all

Good pizza. Order out. We hung out waiting for the pizza and I missed the warm good smelling atmosphere of a pizza joint. The restaurant was cold and you couldn't tell it was a place where pizza were made/baked. read more

Best pizza I have had in a minute! I have brought multiple people here and all could not stop raving about how good it was.

This has always been my favorite pizza place in the state. Don't forget to try their poor boys. You know it's good when you love it the next day reheated. read more

Went to this place a few weekends ago now. Boyfriend order pepperoni and sausage pizza. The toppings and cheese were plentiful. Although the crust fell a bit short. Kinda bland and a bit too thick. I ordered the spaghetti which came with cheese bread and a salad. Both where a very nice portion size. There was a bit of water in the bottom of my bowl, which I know can sometimes happen. Overall I feel like it's worth visiting again if I'm in the area. read more

Pagliai's Pizza - Pepperoni and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mankato, Minnesota

See all

This is not a deep dish pizza. This is a normal pizza with a giant crust. Flavors are awesome. Service is great. Delivery - on time. Deep dish?This is not. read more

Pagliai's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mankato, Minnesota

Some might call it a hole in the wall, but absolutely the best pizza in Mankato. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. Price and service are reasonable, but no pizza can touch pagliai's quality and taste! read more

Well the pizza is pretty okay. They've only got average water cups though.. Shout out to Pepsi I guess. read more

Pagliai's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mankato, Minnesota

Pagliai's Pizza is a must when in Mankato! Best pizza and garlic cheese bread around. Love the ambience, nostalgia from our College days, and the food is always on point! Keep up the great work! We'll be back! read more

What a great find on the whole traveling late @ night. The pizza was awesome and thin. Very tasty. Dogs scraped up the left overs! Great little downtown. Fun college town pizza. Friendly staff during covid times. read more

See all

They were fast but the pizza was all stuck to the top of box and ruined for my daughters birthday party so I'm not very satisfied for the price we paid read more

Pagliai's Pizza - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Mankato, Minnesota

Definitely, this area's best Hometown Pizza. Well, the restaurant itself is that big, the flavors and originality are. The wait time when ordering can be a little long but it's well worth it. read more

If i could give a fifteen star i would! Fantastic pizza, atmosphere and staff! Forever will be a customer of this wonderful place.

This is a small place that is always packed. A lot of cheese and toppings. Great food.

Great pizza. Great service. Great atmosphere. Good cheese. All in all a wonderful experience. read more

Pagliai's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mankato, Minnesota

Waited 1/2 an hour for an in house order. We were pushed behind all the delivery orders. Waitress was nice but wait time is ridiculous! read more

Pizza is amazing, perfect amount of sauce, very liberal on toppings, we were at a hotel and they brought us plates without even asking. 10/10 would say best place in Kato read more