** Update definitely giving this place 5 stars now tried the ruby ice cream cake and it was heaven…read more Think elevated strawberry shortcake ice cream bar. I also found out they have discount Tuesdays on soft serve and this place was buzzing! They continuously give the most top heavy soft serve cones with a smile. My son is officially addicted lol Worth every penny! Super cute place! Very family friendly. I took my teenage son who is a soft serve aficionado. He got the regular vanilla on a cake cone. They have classic flavors and some interesting sundaes. My son said it tasted like froyo or McDonald's soft serve without the nasty extra additives, he did say chik fil a is better lol He also said it was light almost like whipped cream. It was 4.50 flat for a regular cone so you can't beat it. I'm a ritzys ice cream girlie so I didn't try it but if you love soft serve like my son it's worth a shot!

Soft service is best, love all the ladies name for the sundaes…read more Service was outstanding Very clean

Delicious gelato and great service! Their cookies and milk flavor is the best cookies and cream…read morestyle flavor that I've ever had. I also love that it's healthier than traditional ice cream. Definitely can't wait to have this again!

My son was wanting a snack after we went to the park, and I happened to see Coppa Gelato from the…read moreroad. The tables outside were full so I figured that was a good sign. The guy working was very friendly and offered some samples. I got my staple, pistachio and since my son loves cookies & cream he gave the cookies and milk flavor a try. Both flavors were excellent and the texture was even better. The shop is kinda small, I can imagine in the summer during peak hours this place can get very busy and seating sparse. Right now it's a bit toasty inside but hopefully it won't be as warm in here as the days get hotter.

Stopped by Whit's Frozen Custard in Uptown Westerville this afternoon after riding up State Street…read moreand spotting the sign for the flavor of the week: Twisted Coffee. The sign did exactly what it was supposed to do, it made us stop immediately. The frozen custard was smooth, rich, and very creamy, exactly what you want from a great dessert spot in Westerville. The coffee flavor was tasty and well balanced, with fudge, peanut butter, cookies, and crumble mixed in, making it a fun and unique treat. I would have liked just a little more coffee flavor to come through, but it was still absolutely worth the stop. If you're looking for the best frozen custard in Uptown Westerville, this is a great place for an afternoon or evening treat while walking State Street. The location is right in the heart of Uptown, which makes it perfect for a spontaneous dessert stop. Address: 46 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081 (Uptown Westerville Inc)

We were in town for a quick weekend retreat. We visited Whit's after dinner for a custom treat that…read morewe couldn't get at home. It seemed like everyone had the same idea because this place stayed pretty packed during our time there. I had the brownie blitz ands my mini ordered the nachos. We both enjoyed our desserts and my daughter's nachos ended up dripped on her shirt and lap...a great sign that she was satisfied and didn't come up for air . The warm brownie was perfection and confess I enjoyed that warm treat along with the custard. Happy we decided to make this our stop.

This is an update to my review from 2022. Graeter's is still great and is still my favoriate ice…read morecream shop. The reason for today's visit was to introduce my Colorado grandkids to Graeter's. My son grown up loving Graeter's and wanted his kids to experience what he calls "the world's best ice cream". We now have two new devotees for Graeter's ice cream. Who doesn't like Graeter's.

Today me and my Family went to go to Graeter's as a nice Sunday treat. It was 2:30 PM and the…read morestore was closed. There were paper signs on the doors stating they were closed and there was an employee inside sweeping the floor. What a huge disappointment for us all. I had been looking forward to my raspberry chip ice cream all day. We had to go to the frozen custard place on the other side of the street, but it was not the same. I scream, you scream, we all got no ice cream!

Another stop along the greater Columbus ice cream/froyo trail. Reminds me of a place I loved back…read morehome. Plenty of places to seat inside and a few outside. Today's visit featured a variety of tart, sweet, and chocolate flavors. I went with birthday cake, white chocolate strawberry and pistachio. White chocolate strawberry was hands down the best flavor! Pistachio had an unusual after taste and the birthday cake tasted like vanilla. The toppings bar had a good variety of dry toppings. My favorite was the cupcake bites which you usually don't see. Not enough fruit toppings. The price per ounce was a little more than I expected. Overall not a bad place for some fro-yo. Tip: If you are looking to get more than one flavor, pick up a divider! First time I had ever seen once. Tip 2: Pull the handle slowly since the fro-yo comes out rather quickly and don't want to overfill your cup before you load on the toppings.

The Orange leaf has really great yogurt and tons of toppings to choose from. The decor inside is…read morereally cute and colorful. The space is open and not cluttered an plenty of parking outside. The yogurt cups are self serve, but the toppings are behind the counter.

I love the ice cream at this place and it is very close to where I live. My favorite kind of ice…read morecream is orange sherbet.

Creme Corner is an absolute staple for everyone within the Sunbury community. The service is…read moreimpeccable every time and the desserts, of course, are delectable and nostalgic. It's always full of people, even for being a small location, which makes it feel so at-home.

3.5 stars Shakes are…read moreawesome, presentation was great, and staff was friendly and helpful. This place needs a super deep clean. I added a few photos but it doesn't do it justice how dirty it is in the business and bathrooms. The stickiness on my shoes was disturbing. Expect a bit of a wait if there's a line, decor is a bit cheap, but again, shakes were wonderful! You also get to keep the yard cup and there's a cleaning area so that was cool.

10/10 always good for my cravings ask for Quan he has the best service and is always helpful when I…read morehave questions

Rita's in Westerville is the place to go if you're looking for a sweet treat . Their exclusive…read moreparking lot (shared with one other business) is refreshingly easy to maneuver, a rare luxury on State Street. I love that there are two ways to order: outside at the window if you want fresh air or inside if you want to escape the elements,. It's a very choose your own custard adventure. Service though can be inconsistent. Visit 1: Three workers, zero greeting s. I actually pinched myself to make sure I was alive. Visit 2: Three different workers, all Energizer Bunnies. Visit 3: One worker, friendly and quick. One small suggestion: since they already wear Rita's shirts, a consistent dress code for bottoms would make the team look more professional. In other words, no pajama bottoms thank you. As for the treats, the twist custard, which is half vanilla and half chocolate is a dream. The mango Italian ice was tasty but a tad too sweet for me, and the strawberry milkshake was delicious with real strawberries. With great parking, great custard, and service that's occasionally perfect. I recommend Rita's - pajama pants and all.

A solid non-dairy treat (unless you add their yummy custard!)!…read moreFast, friendly service at the counter, especially today on free Rita's day to celebrate spring. I tried their new mystery Peeps flavor - still not 100% sure what it is.

Jeni Ice-cream Goat cheese with red cherries…read more Salted peanut butter with chocolate flecks

I live in Louisville, but ever since I discovered Jeni's Ice Cream while visiting Columbus, I've…read morebeen hooked! In fact, I make special trips just to grab a scoop in one of their amazing homemade waffle cones and stock up on at least six pints to bring home. Jeni's isn't just ice cream--it's an experience. The flavors are incredibly creative, rich, and unlike anything you'll find at a typical ice cream shop. Every scoop tastes fresh, handcrafted, and packed with flavor. And don't even get me started on those waffle cones--they're worth the trip by themselves! I've tried a lot of ice cream over the years, and nothing compares to Jeni's. If you've never been, do yourself a favor and go. Just be warned: one visit may have you planning road trips for ice cream like I do!

The woman helping us was knowledgeable and patient with us since it was our first time. My husband…read morewanted a super thick shake that's almost like blizzard, and she was able to make it for him. Everything was delicious! We will definitely be back some time

Brought my nephews as we're doing a tour of ice cream places in Columbus. Small interior but…read morefriendly staff who let us have samples. One got a strawberry shake, another got the cotton candy and some other kid flavor ice cream and I got a flurry (like a blizzard- vanilla ice cream with Reese peanut butter cup pieces). I wish there was more than one size because it was huge but it was really tasty. We all enjoyed what we had, they didn't haven't bottles of water when we visited but they did give us cups.