5 Stars Whit's Frozen Custard - Sunbury, OH…read moreFlavor Tried: Peach (Flavor of the Week) If summer had a flavor, I'm convinced it would be the peach frozen custard at Whit's in Sunbury. My wife and I stopped in as part of a little retro-inspired day trip, and this sweet spot did not disappoint. The flavor of the week was peach, and let me tell you--it was creamy, refreshing, and full of real peachy goodness. The texture was exactly what you want in custard: smooth, thick, and rich without being heavy. Think soft serve's cooler, more elegant cousin. Service was fast and friendly, and the place was clean and welcoming. Whether you grab a cup, cone, or one of their famous Whitsers, you can't go wrong here. If you're anywhere near Sunbury and it's peach week again--drop everything and go. This custard is the kind of summertime treat that makes you slow down and savor the moment. We'll definitely be back to see what other flavors Whit's whips up next!

On the advice of a local, we hit up Whit's after dinner on Main St. Absolutely local and family…read morerun, this place couldn't be more welcoming or delicious. I went for their Buckeye flavor (we are in OH just so you know) and it was delightfully balanced. Peanut butter and chocolate, rich and dense custard - it was a perfect dessert and trust me, one scoop should be plenty for an adult!

This is a tiny spot in north Mount Vernon, Ohio and it's the typical best kept secret. I had tasted…read moretheir ice cream before and thought it was very good. And. It. Is. We got single cups of Almond Joy and Rocky Road and both were huge (!) who needs more than a scoop really and extremely tasty. You can also buy pints and quarts for the family. Great prices.

An old fashioned family dairy farm with handmade ice cream. A great place to take a break in a hot…read moreday.

A cute spot with lots of picnic tables to sit at, but the ice cream was super disappointing. We…read moreordered a chocolate milkshake and 2 scoops in a bowl with blueberry pie and birthday cake ice cream. The milk shake was pretty flavorless. I'm thinking they add too much milk as you could barely taste any chocolate flavor. The scoops of ice cream had decent flavor, but blueberry pie had an overwhelming number of large ice crystals throughout it that was very off putting. Parking is pretty tight on a colder spring day, so I can't imagine it at peak summer times. To me it's not worth any hassle for this level of disappointment.

Cute place with a super cute name…read more Inwas waiting fir pizza next door. Had 20 min to kill so I walked over to check out this ice cream place. Oh its the perfect country ice cream shop. They serve Johnson's Ice Cream which is made in near by Bexley Ohio. Johnsons has great ice cream if you haven't had it... try it you will love it. I guess here they add googley eyes to the ice cream. I just love that. I didnt get ice cream. I decided to go with a house made cookie. Butterscotch. They're true to their name my cookie was slathered in butterscotch syrup too. So my hands were super sticky! You might want to make sure you have wipes somewhere in the car. (i did). But wow. Great cookie. Wasnt expecting that. Will definitely be back next season. Couldnt find anything wrong. A+

Very large portions. Could not finish. The service was very quick and the staff were kind.read more

Little Ladies has been on my list for a while now, and I finally got the chance to visit…read more There are several sundae options. I got the Thelma with peanut butter ice cream. It was good, but honestly nothing spectacular. The peanut butter ice cream didn't really have a strong flavor. They also have a cooler with ice cream sandwiches and ice cream pie slices. The pie looked good but I didn't grab a slice. There are a couple of seats inside but it looked like most people got their treats to go. Little Ladies is a cute shop.

We love family ice cream at Dari Point! Small shop with delicious rotating soft serve ice cream…read more Our favorite summer stop by far!

OMGeee. I haven't been to Dari Point in YEARS and let me tell you, it held up. They have a nice…read moreselection of soft serve, and creative treats. it's walkable from a lot of homes in Delaware and has some parking. This place is old school, just some picnic tables outside and a few benches. Walk up counters. Service is pretty quick. My friend and I both got the black raspberry chocolate top pretzel cyclone. Yes, its' a long name! The combination of raspberry, chocolate, and salty pretzels was just right. We really enjoyed them. Also, their Blue Smurf ice cream (now called Papa Smurf) has gotten more elaborate over the years, and it made me so happy to see kids STILL eating that thing! This place is just summer in Ohio!

Pros: The were open on a chilly Easter Sunday…read moreTastes using regular spoon instead of plastic - the Earth thanks you! Super creamy ice creams with lots of flavor options Friendly service Cons: 6 dollars a scoop The caramel flavor didn't taste anything like caramel. If I closed my eyes I would have guessed it was vanilla. I'll try another flavor the next time. Pro tip: If you are visiting Buckeye Lake, it's worth a visit for the novelty.

While visiting Buckeye Lake, I learned that Weldon's Ice Cream Factory is the place to visit. It's…read morean institution, and it has been around since 1930! I'm not a big ice cream person, but I do love sweets, especially a sweets shop with history. I ordered a banana split. Though, it was difficult to decide what to order! This place has a peaceful vibe, but the signage is a little chaotic -- it's like walking up to a Dr. Bronner's bottle. I had to stand there for a bit and read everything while the poor girl behind the counter waited for me to get my bearings. (Luckily I was the only one in the shop at the time.) There are different colored signs everywhere, listing daily specials, new items, and things you can buy that aren't ice cream, like bags of ice and local honey. The banana split was delicious: A perfectly ripe banana split between two scoops of ice cream -- I chose vanilla and chocolate. It's topped with whipped cream, crushed nuts, and a cherry on top. It's one of those desserts where you lose track of time when you eat it, or at least I did. All of my concentration went toward eating that magnificent ice cream concoction as quickly as possible. I decided to shovel it into my face on the big porch, which overlooks the Buckeye Lake canal. There is also seating indoors, too. Weldon's is a must-visit if you're in the Buckeye Lake area!

Great Mexican ice cream! The blackberry cream cheese and queso ice cream is a must try and one of…read moremy favorites! Don't forget to get a selfie with Frida Kahlo real size mannequin! They also have a big variety of delicious Mexican snacks!

So colorful inside…read more Grabbed a mango, strawberry, kiwi popsicle and one scoop of the ferrero rocher ice cream. $8.50 The mango, fresa, kiwi popsicle is yummy. The scoop of the ferrero rocher ice cream is pretty good, but not as good or memorable as the popsicle. Could have more bits of the ferrero rocher to make it berry for me. Their ice cream is home made here.

My son was wanting a snack after we went to the park, and I happened to see Coppa Gelato from the…read moreroad. The tables outside were full so I figured that was a good sign. The guy working was very friendly and offered some samples. I got my staple, pistachio and since my son loves cookies & cream he gave the cookies and milk flavor a try. Both flavors were excellent and the texture was even better. The shop is kinda small, I can imagine in the summer during peak hours this place can get very busy and seating sparse. Right now it's a bit toasty inside but hopefully it won't be as warm in here as the days get hotter.

Cute and cozy gelato cafe in Westerville. Samples available to help make your decisions easier…read more Offers a variety of flavors from fruity to indulgent! The pricing goes by size not scoops. I didn't realize that until the customer after me. I recommend a small size. I went with the birthday cake and pistachio, great choices! Pre packed pints are also available. Coffee is also available making it a true cafe. Lots of seating both indoor and outdoor. Wifi is available if you are planning to stay for a bit. Friendly team who served me today.

Granddaughter loved the face painting at the anniversary party as well as her mermaid ice cream.read more

Classic Oreo milkshake. The shake was good but the service wasn't the greatest. There was no line…read moreas I was the only customer in the store but I had a long wait. Also, the two associates working that day weren't very friendly. I would try The Yard again but not this location.

Buckeye Whittie. Very solid, good peanut butter cookies and good custard filling! 10/10 will buy…read moreagain.

Stopped by Whit's Frozen Custard in Uptown Westerville this afternoon after riding up State Street…read moreand spotting the sign for the flavor of the week: Twisted Coffee. The sign did exactly what it was supposed to do, it made us stop immediately. The frozen custard was smooth, rich, and very creamy, exactly what you want from a great dessert spot in Westerville. The coffee flavor was tasty and well balanced, with fudge, peanut butter, cookies, and crumble mixed in, making it a fun and unique treat. I would have liked just a little more coffee flavor to come through, but it was still absolutely worth the stop. If you're looking for the best frozen custard in Uptown Westerville, this is a great place for an afternoon or evening treat while walking State Street. The location is right in the heart of Uptown, which makes it perfect for a spontaneous dessert stop. Address: 46 N State St, Westerville, OH 43081 (Uptown Westerville Inc)