We rarely order from here but am reminded why. Long wait times on seemingly non-busy evenings (Monday night order took 1+ hour to be delivered and we live quite close) and the options within door-dash order app are limiting. On top of that, order came with several things missing or odd (no Caesar dressing on/with the Caesar salad - it gave you options and we DID choose dressing but didn't arrive, and it [salad] was overwhelmingly loaded with croutons as a percentage of salad composition) It's a small-town shop with decent pizza, but beware if ordering out; late delivery and disappointing inconsistency. read more

I'm done with this place. They can't get simple pickup orders right and it's just infuriating because their food isn't bad. This is the third time in a row that they screwed up our order and it's just mind boggling, never again... Tonight we called in to order a square/Sicilian with half pepperoni, half sausage and when I pick it up I'm given a medium round pizza half cheese and the other half with sausage and pepperoni. When I called them out on it they just showed me the wrong order they rang up and said that's what the order was. Another time we ordered mozzarella cheese fries and actually received a container of melted mozzarella separate from the fries. How is this possible!?!? The other messed up order was another pizza mix up where we didn't get what we ordered. Also, tonight's order had a new sticker on the pizza boxes to keep the box closed. I'm pretty sure they started doing that to make it tougher to check your order when you pick it up to try and limit complaints. Luckily I saw them pulling the pizza out of the oven to box it and adding it to our order knowing we didn't order it. Only eat here if you dine in, stay away from calling in orders because they are completely incompetent. Do better. read more

Papa Mark's Pizza & Grill - Somehow this is what you get when you call to order a square/Sicilian, half pepperoni, half sausage... - Salad Near Me - Honey Brook, Pennsylvania

Customer service is excellent!!! Pizza is great! Would definitely recommend trying it out!

Very friendly and helpful staff. Excellent pizza and entrees. I have never had a bad meal or bad service. Always have table reserved with prior notification. Always helpful and pleasant. read more

Purchased lunch there after a recommendation from a family member. They didn't disappoint. They were friendly, fast and made one of the best club sandwiches I have ever had. The frys were cooked as requested and the amount of food for the price is amazing. Clearly one of the best sandwich shops in honeybrook. read more

Maybe you have driven past here a million times- but let me encourage you to GO IN!!! You can get a real Hoagie, an excellent Calzone and tasty pizza here!!! The service is fast, the atmosphere is calm! Never had a bad or even okay experience there!!! Always good, every time!!! read more

the cheesesteak had a good size and was cheesey but kind of bland read more

See all

We go here almost every week and they never disappoint. Amazing employees and food. Tonight we requested this pizza and as always, it was delicious! I thought it was only necessary to write a review after years of extraordinary service. read more

Papa Mark's Pizza & Grill - White Chicken, Spinach, & Ricotta Pizza - Salad Near Me - Honey Brook, Pennsylvania

Some of the best pizza in the area. Burgers are delicious and their lamb and beef gyro are among the best around. Looking for a new place for pizza night? Give Papa Mark's a go, you won't be disappointed read more

This is the best local pizza shop in the area! Fantastic food, great service and still priced affordably. I found this place after living here seven years and I'm disappointed that I haven't been spending my dining out budget here. read more

We tried Papa Mark's for the first time today. We ordered a BBQ chicken Sicilian pizza. Absolutely delicious! We will be going back for sure! We did take out. The gentleman at the counter was very friendly. read more

Papa Mark's Pizza & Grill - BBQ Chicken Sicilian Pizza - Salad Near Me - Honey Brook, Pennsylvania

We had a cheesesteak Stromboli and a chicken cheesesteak. Food was very good and reasonably priced. Not much atmosphere but quick service and nice people. Also great takeout. read more

We moved to Honey Brook and only had a few options for delivery and decided to try Papa Mark's. so glad we did ! From day one they are very friendly, quick delivery, and the owner even delivered a few times and was very welcoming to us as new neighbors! Their pizza's are good- rich sauce, plenty of cheese and anything we ask extra is quality. The cheesesteaks are delicious too- plenty of nicely chopped meat, cheese and when I get mushrooms, they put a good amount in there. My husband enjoyed his turkey hoagie as well - so far we like everything we tried - stromboli, mega fries, etc. Got to say they are my go to at this point!! read more

I really like this place; they have great deep dish pizza and cheese fries. My husband also likes the chicken cheese steaks. The only issue we have with the place is they have delivered us the wrong order once and forgot two things another time so I never know how it's gonna go. read more

We just enjoyed our first Sicilian Thick 17" about 2 hours ago...Simply AMAZING! Fresh dough, meat and cheeses. We've lived in the area 2 years and this by far is the best find yet! WOW! You must try this place!!!!! We'll be back! read more

Recently relocated from Philadelphia to Honeybrook. Papa Marks is the one place that reminds me of home. I also lived in Italy for a short time. The pizza is great. The calzones are great. The cannolis are great. Garlic knots are great. I love talking with them, very friendly staff. They are very accommodating when you were looking for something specific. They are very fast when picking up. Delivery is a little bit slow, but considering where we live I expected that. If they are running a little bit late with a delivery, the delivery person is very apologetic and kind. I have tried other pizza joints around, and this is the best one that I could find. Plus they are open on Sundays, which I didn't realize was rare. read more

We stopped at Papa Mark's on the way home from visiting friends in Lancaster. When we pulled in, we were pleased to see this was an independent pizza shop and not some chain. And the sign on the building is right -- you can tell the difference in quality. Not being from the area, we have no idea how long this place has been in business, but it was so clean and we didn't see any damaged seating or tables. The person who served us, whom I think was the owner, was very polite. The food itself was so fresh and everything tasted great. The bread on our hoagies was definitely made there or by a bakery nearby. And the portions were generous! Other customers seemed happy. We plan to stop in again whenever we're coming through. Unfortunately, I forgot to take note of if there was a changing table in the restrooms. read more

This is my family's go to for our Friday's pizza night. My daughter has celiac and my husband is lactose intolerant so we've always had a rough time finding a pizza place that can meet our dietary restrictions AND is yummy. Papa Mark's hits the spot for all of us. Their staff is friendly and efficient. Highly recommend it. read more

Had the worst hoagie ive ever had from here. The pizza and everything else ive had from here is below average. They do deliver, which is good considering alot of places out here don't. read more

Two takeout dinners. Tried the gyro platter, which could have been quite a stretch, but it was delicious. Good quality meats, pita fine, tsatziki good enough. Next time I tried the eggplant rollatini. Large platter, good amount of the rollatini, and a huge helping of angel hair pasta w marinara sauce to fill out the remainder. And a small salad, typical quality. The rollatini was good. So, 2-for-2 and will be going back. Nice-looking place, also, and so far the staff was friendly both times. read more

First time ordering from Papa Marks and the staff was awesome and the food was delicious. Definitely will be ordering again

Best pizza in the area Very friendly people and great food! Not sure why this place isn't packed on the weekend read more

Well our order was supposed to be 25 minutes but instead took an hour. The entire staff was not wearing masks, except the cashier who had just her mouth covered. The whole kitchen staff not wearing gloves or masks. I get the whole COVID thing. I'm a nurse. It's annoying to wear a mask. But to be making and serving food and speaking to customers without a mask while we're in a pandemic? ridiculous. read more

I never quite understood why this town requires three pizza shops but regardless I have tried them all and I have to admit that Papa Marks is my favorite. Their pizza is very good but what I love the most from this pizzeria is their pasta selection, especially the seafood pastas. Honestly it's great food which I find is surprising to come by in such a small town. Also all of the men that work there that I have encountered are very friendly and polite! read more

Excellent little Italian restaurant not we're you would expect to find one. Clean , good service and can't go wrong on any of there entrees. Our favorites, Chicken Marsala, parmigiana, delicious pizza and home made soups. All reasonably priced with great value. read more

Can't even get a simple request right. I ordered a pizza with light cheese. I even went on to say"very little cheese". No problem, I'm told. Get there & look at the pizza, and it looks like your everyday cheese pizza, dripping with cheese. Pizza guys laughs, "Sorry". No offer to re-make or anything. Just ha/ha sorry. It's not a hard request. If it somehow goes against your Tao of Pizza to make it without thrombotic levels of cheese, just tell me that and I'll go elsewhere. Which I'm doing anyway. Thought I'd try something different, what a mistake. read more

if i could give 0 stars i would. my friend went to papa marks for a salad and some fries. one they didn't even put cheese or bacon so they had to go back, but while he was eating his salad he saw a whole bug. that is nastyyyy. they then went back and wanted a refund because they found the whole bug. they were giving them attitude about it too. which they shouldn't, and the food isn't even that good and they can never get the order right. read more

Papa Mark's Pizza & Grill - a close up of a piece of paper - Salad Near Me - Honey Brook, Pennsylvania

ordered yesterday for pickup ch steak, chkn fingers, and garlic knots. should of been around $18. sent my daughter in w $25 and she came out and said bill was over $28 but the guy said dont worry about it. got home and checked menu price online and should of only been around $18. this happened yesterday 03/26/21. i wont be back read more