The food is amazing every single time because it's fresh ingredients…read more The service is always good because even though it's a weekday, it's not as crazy, plus it's only spring time so hopefully it'll be a little busier during the summer... it's nice to walk into a bathroom that I was actually functional.. I want to request something though that my mother brought up when we had our pizza the other night... spicy or pepperoni or sausage, especially when it comes to the pizza selection... doesn't have to be every pizza, but it would be nice to have some kick in our bites.(add medium to spicy options)

The pizza was so good! It was very cheesy which I prefer. The staff was very friendly. The vibes…read moreinside were a little lacking though. Also, it was a Friday night and they were very understaffed. It took about 45 minutes to just get a personal sized pizza.

I grew up going to this place! It literally hasn't changed in 40+ years and it shouldn't! IT is…read moreperfect! The pizza is delicious, the pizza sauce is the best I have ever had, and the toppings are top notch! (see what I did there?) We will always get pizza here anytime we are in town!

We had been eating here since 2010. We decided to drive down to Oregon and eat there again and…read moresomething has changed regarding the ham on their pizzas. Pizza tasted bland and the ham tasted dry and flavorless. Not the salty, crispy, ham we remembered eating for 16 straight yrs. Did they change suppliers or brands regarding the ham?

Exceeds all the hype. Legit pizza by all standards. We had sausage and mushrooms, and it was…read moreperfect. It was ready when promised and served with a smile. Super yum!

It's take out pizza. Pure and simple. I called right at 1700 when they opened, placed my order for…read morethree pizzas, and they were ready for me 30 minutes later. The inside decor is like an abandoned office building waiting room, but I was there to pick my pizza and leave. Pizza is fairly pricey, but good pizza always costs more. People like pizza in various styles, and this just happened to be EXACTLY what I like. Crispy and charred crust on the outside but thin and chewy in the center. Toppings, including the plain cheese, were flavorful and good quality. It's not a pizza parlor, folks. No video games, soda fountain, or salad bar. Call in your order and pick it up. Simple and delicious. I'll grab a few pies every time I stay in Seaside. I have a feeling the negative reviews come mostly from Portlanders who are used to the most garbage, overrated pizza places I ever had.

Visiting in the area, but my mom is a local. Yes the pizza was very tasty and came out in a timely…read moremanner. But the customer service was phenomenal!! Our server was very attentive, made sure we had everything we needed and when it came to boxing up our food he even asked if we're local or staying at hotel so they could box the food up to fit in the hotel mini fridge if needed. While we didn't, the fact that they thought (and know there's so many tourists) to make sure customers can actually store their leftovers is awesome! Nice if you want to just pop in and grab a couple slices or you can enjoy the nice dining area, which can seat pretty large families/groups. While it will be awhile until I come back I definitely will next time I'm in town!!

Fantastic pizza, great service even just picking up, loaded me up on Parmesan and red pepper…read more Highly recommend the princess margheriute (prolly spelled it wrong) but it was fantastic. Reheated super well the next day in the oven too. If you do take out, grab the pizza, a bottle of wine and hit sunset beach for sunset and drive on access 10/10 way to spend my birthday

We came here for my boyfriend's 50th birthday, on recommendation from a friend whose beach house we…read morewere staying at. She suggested the beef medallions with mushrooms, so we got that, as well as the house lasagna. Both were absolutely delicious! Lasagna is his all time favorite - and what his mother would have made him if we had been able to make it back East for his birthday, (but we got stormed out). I was thrilled that he thought this was just as good. I don't do mushrooms but can maneuver my way around them (which means picking them out at putting them on my boyfriends plate). The restaurant is charming and intimate and decor very much takes you from Seaside, OR to any small town in Italy (or Little Italy in NYC). Maria was our server (according to the receipt) and she was awesome! She was personable, and spent time visiting with us and telling us the history of the restaurant. She also helped me be sneaky and hid the little birthday cake I snuck in my bag and hid it in back, then had brought it out later; adding a bunch of ice cream to it - and got the other restaurant guests to suing Happy Birthday to him. My boyfriend is fairly private so this intimate setting and delicious food, was exactly what he wanted and a wonderful surprise for him.

We visited Nonni's last week for dinner and had an enjoyable experience. It's been a couple years…read moresince we were last here, so we went in with little in the way of expectations. We were seated and served right away, which is always nice. Our server was very pleasant and took good care of us throughout our visit. The food was good, but didn't impress me as much as it did on our last visit. I had carbonara, which is always my go-to baseline meal, and it wasn't bad, tasted ok, but didn't blow me away at all. My wife did enjoy her dish, however, and our drinks were very tasty too. It might have just been me, so I'm not going to say don't go here, you absolutely should, because this is probably the most authentic Italian you're going to get in this area and it's worth a visit!

Very good pizza. Compared to the last of from Gearhart it was very good. Will order from here again…read moresoon.

This place on yelp says it is dog friendly. We walked in the front door and they made us leave…read morebecause we had a dog. They said only service dogs are welcome, not pets. I was a little disappointed in yelp, pointing me into their direction for dog, friendly establishments. It is not. And they didn't seem to care at all.

What's with the haters??? I just ate my FOURTH slice of the olive oil-based artichoke pizza (with…read moreadded Italian sausage) and I'm in pizza heaven. I like pizza. I'm picky about pizza. This is righteously good pizza

Phoned in order with our specifications. About a dozen people combined in the order and pickup…read morelines... no very busy. Just busy. We ordered a thin-crust pizza baked extra crispy. We got chewy bread dough instead. Minus 1 star. They make a big deal about their marinara sauce, which was very good., heavy in the rosemary but not in oregano. Plus 1/2 point. Pizza a'fetta is very proud of their homemade Caesar dressing, but what I received in the small container inside the salad box said that as long as there's a funnel and a working water spigot, they'll never run out of Caesar salad dressing. In other words, the dressing inside my box of Caesar salad was water-thin and, frankly, tasteless. Minus 1 point. Since I can't give a 1/2 star rating, and as the effort was less than superlative, I'm rounding down: the only thing remarkable about their pizza was the marinara sauce.

What an insult to the Fultanos name! Please quit serving the public! I guess this is the food you…read moreget when no one cares. - -We ordered a large----we got a medium -Beef taco pizza? The worst excuse for one I've ever had. -Clearly the owner doesn't care.....and that translates to the workers.....who care even less. No pride....poor character....doing their job is obviously an irritant, and it shows. Absolutely horrible. If you want good pizza, GO TO WARRENTON FULTANOS!!!! Gearhart bowl is spitting on the name.

We had a great experience! Clean and updated bowling alley! Food was good for the price! Polite…read moreservice. We would bowl and eat here again. We got nachos, salad, etc

There is a good view of the Haystack Rock from the dining room…read more We had the clam chowder and it was very very good. I had the Halibut and asked for no sauce and not encrusted in anything. It was a good fish. I enjoyed the mango chutney. My husband enjoyed the Salmon. The rice that came with both was underwhelming. The seasonal crisp was raspberry and mango which was VERY good and I am picky about my crisps. The chocolate dessert was good, my husband had it. TLDR: it was a good meal with a good view with good service. What more could you ask for?

Absolutely loved our lunch here! The beach view alone makes this place worth visiting, but the food…read moreand service made it even better. We started with the oyster shooters and they were amazing - fresh, flavorful, and a perfect way to start the meal. We also ordered the crab sandwich which was very cheesy in the best way possible, and the soft baguette paired perfectly with it. The clam chowder was honestly one of the best I've had. Perfectly made with a thick, creamy sauce and full of flavor. Definitely a standout dish for me. We also tried the salmon fish tacos. They weren't necessarily "to die for," but they were still really good and fresh tasting. The steamed Manila clams were amazing! This is one of my go-to dishes anywhere that serves them because it can really be hit or miss, but Wayfarer absolutely nailed them. For drinks, we ordered an Old Fashioned and the Purple Hazestack - both were made perfectly. On top of everything, both the waiter and hostess were extremely polite and welcoming. Great food, amazing drinks, incredible beach views, and wonderful service. Would absolutely come back!

We received the wrong pizza and we were so exaughsted from traveling we didn't say anything…read more It was a happy accident and the pizza was quite delicious. Huge portion for the price and the ingredients were definitely fresh. We would stop again and get this same accident pizza.

Well that was $30 down the drain. Worst pizza I've had in my life. Threw the whole thing out. And…read moresince when did pizza become $30? Yeah do not order pizza from this place :(