Ali's is the best pizza in New Castle. It's crust is actually a raised style crust. Most of the…read morespots in New Castle have a flat crust, undercooked, floppy and lifeless. Or overcooked hard and cracker-like. Ali's crust has a great chewy lift to it. Under the sauce and toppings, the crust holds up. Biting into a slice has just the right feel, and taste as well. A flat thin crust doesn't have a flavor. It doesn't have the air in it that lets the flavor get out to you. The flavor of Ali's pizza crust is just about perfect. Like a great French or Italian crusty loaf. And no baking soda! This dough was yeast raised, like real pizza dough should be made. The sauce on this pie is also just about perfect. I hate a flat tasting sauce. Or a sauce that is too sweet or too tangy. Sauce on this pizza was just right, in taste and amount. Had a beautifully seasoned flavor which was not heavy on anything. It was center of target bullseye. Impossible to describe except to say, I liked it. A lot. Toppings... well, I had cheese and pepperoni. The cheese? It had a flavor! There was plenty of cheese too, when you get it home, hot, and pull a slice and there is enough hot gooey melty cheese to roll off the edge of the slice, and that's plenty of cheese. And it had mozzarella flavor. Not some generic cheese like a Bob's House'O'Cheese! This cheese tasted fantastic! The pepperoni was sliced thin, and covered the pie. Just the right amount for a perfect flavor and texture. First time order, after living here for nearly two years, figures. On the other hand, if I had come to Ali's for pizza first, I would have hated myself for not just getting Ali's every time. Getting Ali's after getting every.other.pie makes me feel like I had to work through all the mediocre pizza before I had finally earned the right to appreciate how good Ali's pizza is. The only extra instructions I gave when ordering was to brown the cheese that comes up over the roll of the crust. So, now that I've found pizza I like in New Castle, all I have left is changing around the toppings and whether I want the pepperoni brown on the edges, or the crust dark, or very dark. FINALLY I can stop driving to Youngstown to get Cornersburg, Belleria, Coca's or Uptown. Which if you like those, this is just as great!

I've had the pizza once and it wasn't terrible but I didn't really care for it. My wife was the one…read morewho picked it up so I didn't get a chance to go inside or see how the service is. One of these days I may give it another try seeing they have different items on their menu.

Food and service was very good I will continue to order from there I just moved here from…read morePittsburgh one of the best sandwiches

First time going here and had the New York style pizza, it was excellent! Definitely crave-able…read more Also tried a cut of chicken bacon ranch Sicilian style also very good. The restaurant was clean and nice size and has its own parking lot. There were a lot of staff and all seemed to be happy and friendly. only bad thing is it's and hour away from home.

I'm unhappy. We ordered pizza tonight 4/28. It took them 45 minutes to bring the pie. It came…read morewith 10 minutes left to eat. The waitress set it down and asked if we needed a box; we asked how we would know. Well, she told another customer that they close at 8:00. When she said that we were eating our first slice of pizza. Mind you, the pizza was excellent. But how can you enjoy it when you're feeling rushed? The waitress piled on by saying, when asked how many are out there, "just that one." Not "a couple," or "the wife and husband." No, we were "that one." She clearly was in a terrific hurry. We will not be back.

Excellent dining option for singles, couples and families. There are tables that can seat at least…read more8 and tables for as little as two. The staff is friendly. The menu is homestyle Italian and everything sounds appealing. I stopped in for the Meatball Stuffed Loaf and it did not disappoint! Massive meatballs, stuffed into a crusty loaf of freshly baked bread. The bread is soft on the inside, but not so much that all the delicious red sauce and rich melty cheese make it soggy. The sauce is somewhat sweet, but not that kind of sweet that lingers and makes you not appreciate the flavors of the tomatoes and seasonings. I really don't even like meatball subs, but something about these lured me in... I'm glad, because they're incredible and you should definitely stop in and have one! *Mangino's is an hour from my house and I made the drive 4 times in 2023, simply for the meatball stuffed loaf and french fries! I'll stop at a few of the waterfalls in the area to make it a day, but I'm making the trip for the loaf. I've purchased extras to bring home to my family and they were enjoyed as much as my fresh one.

Best pizza around. Crispy crust and sauce is so good. Staff very nice. Can get a whole pie or by…read morethe slice. Definitely recommend. Love their party platters too

The food is delish!! Customer service very friendly. Great assortments of pizza ready to eat. She…read moreasked if we wantes it heated. It was great! The chicken soup was so good on a cold day. Great atmosphere. The building is lovely new and modern. Fun music. Overall great experience.

Took the recommendations from Yelp and ordered to-go after a long day of travel. So glad we…read morelistened!! Two pizzas and a focaccia bread were amazing. Great crust, great flavor, fresh topping and wood fired. Staff was friendly when we picked up as well!

Credit where credit is due. After my second visit, all of the kinks have been ironed out and they…read moredelivered some of the best neopolitan pizza (and desserts) I've had in a LONG time. Each was perfectly seasoned and cooked, and I especially loved the "The White Buffalo" pie. And to top it off, friendly service again. Feel flvery lucky to have this spot close to home.

Ordered our pizza for delivery and it was on time and still so hot that the cheese had a cheese…read morepull. I live 15 minutes away ! Super nice when they delivered and the food was fantastic! We will order again from them! With every penny!

Excellent pizza! We ordered an extra large with pepperoni and a large poor man's pizza (plain…read morewhite). Amazing crust & sauce. Absolutely delicious! Kind, attentive service. Good price! Well worth a visit for pick-up or call for delivery!

After visiting Living Treasures our party of five searched for a place to eat and came across Mr…read morePizza. The large pizza was quite good and I am still amazed by how inexpensive the bill was. Large drinks with refills $1.27. Pizza pricing from what seems like the good old days. The menu was quite diverse with equally impressive pricing. Also the service was quite fast. Be sure to visit and you will say "I'll be back".

Very well know spot around town and have excellent deals! On Monday's they have $5 - 8 cuts which…read moreis awesome. Recently I had their tuna fish sub and it was really good and only like $4.50. Their Italian subs are really good too. Sometimes if you order a pizza though in transfer if it slides it bunches up on one side. Make sure it's level. Everyone there always seems really friendly. And if you decide to sit inside it's really original and a nice little spot along a main road to have lunch.

Just visited this Restaurant tonight. Had heard a lot of reviews about their Pizza tasting like a…read moreold local favorite. If you're local to the area, the pizza in reference is Augustine's Pizza. It's a small restaurant in a small town with BIG flavor! We ordered a large Pepperoni with extra Cheese and Chubby Bites. The Chubby Bites are a Local Sausage (Joseph's) and deep fried. These were wonderful!!! The batter/breading was phenomenal. The Pizza came out shortly after and didn't disappoint. It came with sliced cheese instead of shredded. We truly loved the sliced cheese over shredded. I was impressed with the classic stringy cheese as we tried to cut it and it stretched from the pan all the way to our plates. The sauce definitely reminded us Augustine's Pizza. The crust was light and crispy with very subtle sweetness. The staff was amazing and very friendly. This was our first time here and the manager made us feel like he had known us a long time. They have a large enough menu that we will definitely be back to try the next items.

We had to make a visit to the local post office so stopped in for dinner. The owner talked to us…read moreand couldn't have been more gracious! He explained the history of the sauce they use and let us try a special sauce he makes (which I highly recommend you buy) to go along with the pepperoni bites. The food was yummy, but a local place, with such a wonderful atmosphere, make this place EVEN better.

If anyplace needs yelped it's this place. Pizza Joes in Portersville Pa…read more Stopped for first time and purchased their pizza slices. It was awful! Crust was so soggy and sauce not good. Had a funny taste to it. I love Pizza Joes but this location is not in line with their recipes Don't know WTH they are doing there

Consistent good pizza. Unique to our Western PA Eastern Ohio area…read more Staff is friendly and offers advice as requested. Family friendly seating.

We visited the waterfront hall location in Wheeling for lunch. Fast service and absolutely amazing…read morefood! Highly recommend the Bianco and flying pig pizzas! The building is absolutely adorable, full of history and beautifully decorated.

Went to the waterfront hall location with family for lunch. The workers were very nice and brought…read moreout our food fast which was great. The location is amazing like stepping back in time with the old brick building. I tried the cheese breadsticks which were some of the best I've ever had. My mom also really liked her Margherita pizza as well. It was really good food and we will definitely go again at some point.