Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pegasus Pizza

    4.0 (45 reviews)
    ModeratePizza
    Closed Closed

    Pegasus Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Pegasus Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos - Pegasus Pizza

    12" pepperoni and sausage
    Matt M.

    This was our first time trying this pizza! Our rating is 3.5 stars. We ordered 2 pepperoni and sausage thin crust 12" inch pizzas with light cheese for dinner on a Sunday night. The total was $24.25 for both pizzas. The pizza was greasy. The amount of toppings was good and the toppings tasted good. The pizza didn't have a lot of sauce but the sauce had good flavor. The pizza crust had a good crunch. Our issue was the pieces on the edge had a burnt charred flavor that was not enjoyable! Some pieces were not burnt and tasted ok. We wanted to really like this place because it has great reviews! The restaurant was busy at the time of pick up! This was just not a great pizza experience !

    Joshua D.

    Review Visit: February 9th, 2016 I had a coupon. My friend and I enjoy a good pizza. So off to Pegasus Pizza we go! Well, that was the idea at least. Pegasus pizza was a very hard place for my friend and I to find. I had assumed it was a normal restaurant, but it's quite the opposite actually. It's situated in a building the size of an Ice Cream Shack. So the only room inside is for customers to order. Not a bad thing, but my friend and I were ill-prepared for dealing with carry out only. So we placed an order and killed time by going to the gas station, getting some stuff there and debating where we would eat. We settled on his place as it was the closest place we could think of. We go back, grab our pizza from just about the friendliest pizza staff I have ever dealt with, headed back to his place and scarfed down some pizza. The pizza itself was pretty good. It didn't floor me, but it didn't disappoint. But my friend really enjoyed it. I think my problem is the type of sausage they use. There is a certain style that my taste buds just absolutely hate. Any ways, if you want some good 'carry out/delivery' pizza and are in Morton, give Pegasus Pizza a shot. I think they even have free delivery. Disclaimer: No Pegai were used in making any pizzas.

    16" Sausage w/extra cheese
    Bryce S.

    Pegasus pizza is one of the best pizzas you can get in the area. Hands down the best pizza in Morton. Fast, good quality pizza at a fair price. I live down the street and always walk over to pick mine up. (But they offer free delivery) Friendly people in there and love supporting the local spots and those working in them.

    Totally burnt crust !   Can't  believe they sent this out knowing it was burnt!!!  Waiting for new pizza!
    Sally E.

    Sent this out. Totally burnt crust!! Waiting for a new one! Seriously get your shit together!!

    Cheese Only Pizza (12") Pepperoni and half sausage (12")

    See all

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Pegasus Pizza

    Review Highlights - Pegasus Pizza

    So far this is the best pizza I've tried in central Illinois.

    Mentioned in 2 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 1,697 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Garner's Pizza & Wings

    Garner's Pizza & Wings

    3.6
    (47 reviews)
    0.7 mi
    $
    Family-owned & operated
    33 years in business

    Review Visit: April 18th, 2016…read more This place definitely garners the attention it deserves. On one of my many trips (with a friend that didn't like being in photos), we stopped for pizza at the recommendation of many people we knew. We walked in on a sunny afternoon with empty bellies and high expectations. We were greeted by a friendly staff and a post-lunch winding down of the restaurant. There were a handful of employees who stopped in for a bite to eat but they all were wrapping up to go back to work. We were seated at a table and given menus and some waters. My friend and I have similar taste buds, so we quickly settled on the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza. If memory serves me right, I got my half of the pizza with jalapenos. I do love me a bit of a kick to my food. With the lunch rush past us, we got great service as we were really the only ones in there after about 10 minutes. Our waitress was prompt with everything and just great. It wasn't long before our pizza was brought out to us and boy did it look good. It's not stranger on this blog that I love pizza and Garner's was great. Each bite was full of flavor and each slice being exactly what our bellies needed before we started exploring Bloomington. About the only complaint I would have is that Garner's is in a weird location. It seems to be a newly-built area and I am not entirely too familiar with Morton but it seems to be in a weird location. When my GPS was taking us here, I had doubts the address was correct... but I am glad that I was proven wrong. Garner's was worth the hesitation while driving there.

    Their italian beef sandwich and bone-in wings were delicious tonight! The delivery was so fast that…read morenothing got cold even though it's only 23 degrees and very windy tonight. They paid attention to all my requested changes and got everything right! I ordered online but forgot to ask for the aujus on the side. I called the restaurant and they were happy to accommodate my request. This Morton restaurant is a new favorite!

    Photos
    Garner's Pizza & Wings
    Thin & Crispy Tavern Style Pizza
    Thin & Crispy Tavern Style Pizza
    Supreme pizza thin crust

    See all

    Supreme pizza thin crust
    Monical's Pizza

    Monical's Pizza

    3.1
    (30 reviews)
    0.8 mi
    $$

    The "breadsticks" here have left me absolutely flummoxed. Like a pretzel and a normal breadstick…read morehad a love child that neither wants to claim as their own.

    We planned on stopping at a different pizza place in the area but after seeing how awful the…read morereviews have been in the last couple of years we decided to give Monical's a chance. We were greeted as soon as we walked in and shortly after we were seated in the dining room area. The dining room was very spacious and had comfortable booths and open tables. The front room appeared large but apparently there is an even larger room towards the back where they accommodate larger parties. We know this because we saw them as they were leaving and it surprised us. Our server was very friendly and attentive. She took our drink orders and gave us some extra time to look over the menu. We decided to order a 16" Mighty Meat and a 14" cheese and sausage. We also got a family pack of bread sticks which included 10pcs and two sauces, we got nacho cheese. As we waited on the food we enjoyed looking at the decor in the dining room and having nostalgia over the items. The bread sticks came out first. The sauce was okay and the bread sticks were not great. Dough, dry and bland. We wouldn't order them on the next visit. Our pizzas came out and they were perfect. Thin crust. Crispy crust. The right amount of sauce to cheese and very generous portions of meat. Everyone enjoyed the pizza very much.

    Photos
    16" thin crust with sausage, mushrooms, green peppers
    16" thin crust with sausage, mushrooms, green peppers
    Cheese and sausage 14"
    Cheese and sausage 14"
    16" deluxe pizza (no hot pepperoncini) with premium cheese blend

    See all

    16" deluxe pizza (no hot pepperoncini) with premium cheese blend
    Pizza Ranch

    Pizza Ranch

    3.2
    (58 reviews)
    0.6 mi
    $

    I absolutely LOVE Pizza Ranch! We moved to TX & were back in town for Thanksgiving. I wish there…read morewas a similar pizza buffet restaurant in TX! We stopped Sunday for lunch. The restaurant was packed, but the cooks kept up with the demand with no delays. I love the fried chicken & my husband loves their pizza so it's a great place to go to satisfy both of our cravings! If you order buffet, you can order any special pizza combination you want & they will bring it to your table. The chicken bacon ranch is my favorite, but there are plenty of other combos to try as well. The food on the buffet was hot and fresh. There were also several dessert pizzas to choose from, but my favorite was the cactus pizza. Overall it's a great family atmosphere, delicious food and great value for the money! It's a "must stop" for my family any time we are back in the area!!

    We did not have a good experience at the pizza ranch. Tuesday night is kids night One child 10 &…read moreunder free per full-priced paying adult. The pizza left a lot to be desired! The pizza that was on the buffet around 4:45 pm on a Tuesday night was not good and lacked variety. We requested a thin crust ham and pineapple pizza with light cheese. The pizza took 30 mins to appear on the buffet. No one told us when the pizza was on the buffet. The ham and pineapple pizza did not have very many toppings and was just ok. The salad bar had iceberg shredded lettuce and wilted spinach. The cheddar cheese and French dressing were good. However, the lettuce quality is disappointing. The fried chicken was not cooked properly. The chicken was chewy. The chicken was overcooked. Unfortunately, we will not be coming back to the pizza ranch anytime soon.

    Photos
    Pizza Ranch's buffet offers a variety of pizzas. If you don't see your favorite, you can request it and they'll make it for you!
    Pizza Ranch's buffet offers a variety of pizzas. If you don't see your favorite, you can request it and they'll make it for you!
    PIzza Ranch buffet
    PIzza Ranch buffet
    Large pizza

    See all

    Large pizza
    Potter's Alley

    Potter's Alley

    4.0
    (3 reviews)
    0.5 mi

    Nice alley! Friendly front desk staff, reasonable bowling prices and have specials…read more Ate after bowling, tenderloin was good, hamburger couldn't tell there was way too much condiments made it very messy. Chicken quesadillas big disappointment so I wouldn't order that again, not sure if there was any chicken on it, fries were good. Pizza looked good but we didn't try it, definitely will bowl there again but probably pass on eating there. Was not impressed and not how it was shown on "you gotta eat"

    Food is surprisingly good for a bowling alley. Mr. Owner is really nice and pleasant but the Mrs…read more there berates the Mr. And staff openly in front of everyone. I will say their drinks are too expensive to sit around and really drink like you want to. I guess they get enough volume but don't realize they'd sell a lot more if they'd charge like a bowling alley, and not like a brewery. I keep on going back if that tells you. I will say consistent play is very difficult as opposed to other alleys because of really oily lane conditions. I've also had damage to my ball from lane 8 which happens I guess but probably shouldn't. The only super frustrating thing about this Alley is the placement of the score computer which is mounted directly in front of the ball return. You are always reaching over or around which is unlike any other alley I've been too. Gets really annoying because they have a platform that blocks your feet from being able to get right up to it.

    Photos
    Chicken Street Tacos
    Chicken Street Tacos
    Glow Bowl Birthday Party
    Glow Bowl Birthday Party
    Grab a Potter's Alley tumbler and get a discount on your Slushies!

    See all

    Grab a Potter's Alley tumbler and get a discount on your Slushies!

    Pegasus Pizza - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...