Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pennington Pizza Grill

    3.8 (41 reviews)
    ModeratePizza, Italian
    Closed 10:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Pennington Pizza Grill Photos

    PENNINGTON PIZZA GRILL ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Good for groups
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    More like Pennington Pizza Grill

    Recommended Reviews - Pennington Pizza Grill

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Double birthday celebration
    Jessica C.

    Love the food, service, and serving size . Nice and clean. The pasta is amazing and our waitress Berta was so warm and friendly as well as the people at the pizza counter. Best Italian place around and now they even have a bit of Spanish food as well if you're in the mood. BYOB and enjoy!!

    a heart shaped cheese pizza
    Tiffany F.

    Best pizza in the area, hands down. Consistently good. Other pizza places in the area aren't bad but Pennington has the best flavor. We've had their mozzarella sticks and calzones from here too, also yummy. Can't speak on their pastas or salads, need to try. They do a heart shaped pizza for our kids for Valentines Day, so cute. Definitely recommend. Easy to get to on 31.

    A soupy, gloppy disaster
    Jeff S.

    Is there a zero star? Literally the worst pizza I've ever had. Soupy sauce , congealed cheese, tasteless crust. Toppings literally slid off the crust it was so wet. Got my order wrong. Garbage pizza. Stay far away.

    Regular cheese used on the Brooklyn Pizza which reads fresh mozzarella.

    See all

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Pennington Pizza Grill

    Review Highlights - Pennington Pizza Grill

    5 $), but you will not be disappointed by their tortellini pizza or anything with a deeper crust.

    Mentioned in 3 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 9,693 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Osteria Procaccini - Pennington

    Osteria Procaccini - Pennington

    3.8
    (139 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    $$

    2.5 stars. I had dinner here tonight and was not impressed. The restaurant seemed nice when we…read morewalked in. There's a bar area and a restaurant area. I've heard good things but they did not hit it out of the park for me. I have dietary preferences that I found very hard to make work here. I had looked at the menu beforehand and identified two options that would work for me. The crispy wings and the burger. It turns out I could try neither of those options as they were out of both. It's a Wednesday dinner service and the restaurant was empty so imagine my severe disappointment. I ended up getting a Caesar salad which was fine but let's be honest a Caesar salad is lettuce, cheese, dressing and croutons. There was nothing to write home about with this one. The other three members of the group got pizzas. Here comes the next disappointment - it took more than 45 minutes for the food to come out. There were only two other tables with people so I cannot understand why it took so long. All this to say I waited almost an hour for my sad plate of lettuce, which was not my first or second choice. I was annoyed and still left hungry. The rest of the group seemed to enjoy their pizzas, but I will not be returning.

    Looking for a light lunch today as the temperatures hovered in the mid 90's, we decided to give…read moreOsteria Procaccini a try. Upon entering the nicely cooled place, we were warmly greeted and promptly seated by a window adjacent to the wood fire oven. This was our first visit. The room is very lively. Thankful we were seated in the corner which helped with the acoustics. With the dining room mostly full at lunchtime, it was difficult to hear my bride on the other side of the table. We were in no hurry so overtime, the place thinned out a bit and the volume subsided. Could be a real issue on a busy night. Might try the bar room side next time. (Some decorative acoustic ceiling tiles would greatly reduce the noise.) There were menu additions as well as a limited but decent selection of value wines. We decided on the Shrimp Mango Avocado Tower and a Shrimp Caesar salad and a bottle of Villa Antinori. The Shrimp Mango Avocado salad is one of the best salads we have ever had. Really. Blueberry, strawberry, arugula, candied pecans, feta cheese topped with a limoncello dressing and aged balsamic with a few grilled shrimp. Was hoping for more shrimp, but the salad is very filling. The interplay of the various flavors was very tasty and the wine was a good paring. The Shrimp Caesar salad was also very good. I loved the anchovie and dijon forward flavors with just the right amount of garlic. The homemade croutons with just the right flavor and crunch. The pace was perfect. Server (manager?) was attentive but not overbearing. We had a nice relaxing and delicious light lunch. Exactly what we were looking for. We will definitely be back to try the pizza and some desserts.

    Photos
    Osteria Procaccini - Pennington
    Caesar salad
    Caesar salad
    Trenton Mustard Pie

    See all

    Trenton Mustard Pie
    Piccolo Trattoria

    Piccolo Trattoria

    3.7
    (290 reviews)
    2.1 mi
    $$

    Sorry, no pictures! This was my first time here and if I lived closer I would definitely come back…read moremore often. I tried to make a reservation on Open Table through their website. It wasn't showing up on my account. I called the restaurant and they were able to find and confirm. I don't know if it's an Open Table glitch. They were so accommodating upon arrival when our party went from 9 people to 7. The staff was amazing and on top of everything. We ordered apps off the dining room menu but they let us order large pizzas instead of the 12" ones. We had calamari and bacon wrapped shrimp. I love that they offer the calamari in both fried and grilled. I was outvoted on the grilled but I have to say that the squid was perfectly cooked. Not chewy or fishy at all. Very tender. The breading was light and not greasy at all. The bacon wrapped shrimp were interesting. The shrimp were huge. They were drenched in BBQ sauce. I thought it was ok but I'm not sure about the flavor combo. We ordered a large plain and a large pepperoni. I thought the plain was delicious. The dough was good and not too much flop. The sauce was a bit sweet, which I like. The only issue is that the cheese and sauce didn't stick to the dough so it slid off while cutting. Overall, I think they did a great job with a large group during weekday lunch.

    Excellent Eggplant parm. Good value Variety of pizza. Love…read morethe Brooklyn and margarita. What distinguishes this place from other neighborhood pizzeria are the sauces. Not bland tasteless.

    Photos
    Interior
    Interior
    Piccolo Trattoria
    Pizza

    See all

    Pizza
    Villa Francesco's

    Villa Francesco's

    3.8
    (93 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$

    I attended a luncheon with over eighty people. I was so…read moreimpressed with the service offered. The waitresses were extremely attentive. The food was perfect.

    I typically never leave negative reviews because I know how difficult customer service and the…read morerestaurant industry can be. We all have bad days, and I truly understand that. However, after witnessing how my elderly father and his group of friends were treated during lunch on Wednesday afternoon, I felt compelled to share this as constructive feedback. My father and several of his friends, all gentlemen in their 70s, 80s, and 90s, met for lunch. There was some confusion about the final size of the party. Initially, they thought there would be six people, but as more friends arrived, the total ended up being eight or nine. One of the gentlemen immediately apologized for the mistake. I completely understand that changing table arrangements can be frustrating. However, what upset me was the way the hostess handled the situation. The first group of gentlemen had already been seated when additional members of their party arrived. Rather than simply moving them to a larger table, the hostess appeared visibly annoyed and began squeezing more and more chairs around the small round table they were already sitting at, repeatedly reminding them that they had said six people. She rolled her eyes, rushed them along, and spoke to them in a curt manner that made these older gentlemen seem like an inconvenience rather than valued guests. What made the interaction particularly confusing was that the dining room on that side of the restaurant was largely empty at the time, aside from people coming in for takeout slices. From my perspective, there appeared to be plenty of room to comfortably accommodate everyone, which made the frustration and lack of patience all the more surprising. As I dropped my father off, I witnessed this interaction myself. I was honestly shocked by how little grace and patience were shown. When the hostess later laughed it off to me and remarked that "they didn't know how many people there were," I simply replied that mistakes happen and that these are older gentlemen who deserved patience and kindness. Before leaving, I even asked that they please take good care of my father and his friends. When my father returned home, I asked how the lunch went. He mentioned that while the server did her job, she and the hostess were both rather rude throughout the experience. I wasn't present for the entire meal, so I can't speak to every interaction, but I can speak to what I personally witnessed, and it broke my heart. If you have an elderly parent or loved one, you understand why this upset me so much. But honestly, this isn't even about age. No one should be made to feel belittled or like a burden. My father taught me to respect my elders, and I was disappointed to see so little respect shown in return. The reason I'm giving two stars instead of one is because the food itself was enjoyed, and thankfully my dad's friends have a wonderful sense of humor. By the end of the day, they were actually laughing together about how mean the ladies had been. But that doesn't change the fact that kindness and patience are just as much a part of hospitality as the food itself. This review is meant as constructive criticism. Service is hard, and everyone can have an off day, but I hope management takes this as an opportunity to remind staff that a little patience and compassion go a long way. For the record, I watched these gentlemen arrive, and there was no complaining, arguing, or rude behavior from them whatsoever, just an honest mistake about the headcount. People remember how you make them feel, and unfortunately, that is what will stay with me most about this visit.

    Photos
    Party room
    Party room
    Penne Vodka Chicken Parmigiana
    Penne Vodka Chicken Parmigiana
    Plain pie

    See all

    Plain pie
    Boro Market Restaurant Bar

    Boro Market Restaurant Bar

    4.1
    (91 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    The BEST dining experience we've had in a long time. We decided to come the day after Valentines as…read moreit was quiet. We often have odd dining experiences, from our first date 20 years ago to last month. This is my second time at Boro, my wife has been there a couple more times. What sets this restaurant apart is not just the food, but the service. Genuine smiles when we arrived and left. We were sat next to a couple with 4 kids. Not a big deal for us as we have two. The kids were great. As they were leaving, only 15 minutes after we sat, our server said they paid for our first round. It was such a nice gesture even though they were no problem to us. Ok, the food and drinks. I've been hooked on this cocktail recently, a Paper Plane. I asked if they could make it and they sure could. It requires one specific brand of Italian spirit so I was really impressed. My wife had a cool cosmo with white cranberry juice and elderflower liqueur. The reason I will come here for one thing and one thing only is their Crispy Chicken Appetizer. It's everything that you ever wanted sesame General Tso's chicken to be, and more! Just enough so that you'll lick the bowl clean and order some to go...I did. The lobster risotto and chicken we had for entrees were fantastic. My second drink was a seasonally warm take on an old fashioned that was served with a flaming sugar cube and had me saying mmmm after every sip. The Zeppoles....theyre gluten free!! My wife loses her mind over these every time. Well done, Boro. I can't wait to come back.

    Boro is a cute space with a decently sized bar. The dining room also manages to feel intimate and…read morecozy because there aren't tons of tables. We started by ordering the crispy chicken, and I ordered a drink from the bar. The crispy chicken was the highlight of the night--very flavorful. The drink arrived 15 minutes after ordering, when we were halfway through the appetizer. I could see the bartender moving slowly, and I heard other patrons complaining about the wait time. It happens, and if the rest of the experience was good, I wouldn't have even remembered that. Our waitress brought us some bread, which was a bit stale, but the butter was fantastic. Our main courses were very average--I had the grilled branzino, which is a simple dish but just lacked flavor or anything to make it stand out. My husband ordered the short rib pappardelle, and the pasta itself was good. The sauce was very, very heavy due to too much truffle. By the time we finished eating, we were fully sweating because the restaurant was so hot. It was a very hot day, and maybe the air-conditioning was not working. Again, forgivable, but on top of everything else, it made for an unpleasant experience. Overall, it felt overpriced for the food and service.

    Photos
    Boro Market Restaurant Bar
    Carrot cake
    Carrot cake
    Drinks were great

    See all

    Drinks were great
    Marco's Pizza

    Marco's Pizza

    3.5
    (38 reviews)
    1.5 mi
    $

    I like Marco' s Pizza. They'll take our orders in English or Spanish: they're friendly, polite, and…read morefast. Days when you don't feel like cooking, Marco' s Pizza with their awesome salads are the way to go--especially on days you haven't gone exercising of for a long walk. NJ pizza is its own kind of thing, and their sauce is just right: not too sweet, nor too salty. The bread crust is fantastic and a bit of dip in Alfredo or regular sauce lets you not waste the food like our grandmothers taught us not to do. After all, we have people in today's world who do not get to eat any more--imagine being subjected to that by those who also received blessings from The Lord. Perhaps we can have proceedings go to charitable causes--who knows--good places do exist that care about the well being of fellow humans, globally, not just locally. But pizza lovers are optimists anyway. Marco's is beyond the marketing; just good pizza. Good salads.

    Amazing food, and I ordered their lunch specials, cripsy chicken sandwiches, and fries, and it's…read moredefinitely worth it. The service is fast. The chicken was prepared very well, and the grandma sauce was delicious. The fries that came with meal tasted very food. I will order from here if I am around this place. Definitely support this business. Good service, and they do have indoor and outdoor seating, a very casual atmosphere. Restrooms on premises, too. Small parking lot. The menu is robust.

    Photos
    Marco's Pizza
    Dont bother going to any pizza place in pennington at all for pizza or any food, they wont give you what you ask for
    Dont bother going to any pizza place in pennington at all for pizza or any food, they wont give you what you ask for
    Marco's Pizza

    See all

    Pennington Pizza Grill - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...