Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pensacola Cakes

    5.0 (1 review)
    Open Open 24 hours

    Pensacola Cakes Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Pensacola Cakes

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Sara L.

    Sara L.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Pensacola Cakes

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Custom Cakes 304 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Craft Gourmet Bakery

    Craft Gourmet Bakery

    4.6
    (134 reviews)
    4.7 mi
    $$

    I was in town for a wedding. Pensacola also happens to be my home town. And I wanted to find a nice…read morebreakfast one day. I hopped online to do some quick research, and found this place. Definitely new since I left home. I was interested. Ambiance was wonderful. A good amount of seating with each sitting spot feelings mildly secluded, which is nice. No one wants their coffee shop gossip being overheard. And when you walk in, you're first greeted with that classic glass case of available pastries and goodies. It was hard to not just order one of each item. Service was nice. It was counter service, and they bring your order right to your table. Can't ask for better service than that. Nice folks, good small talk. And the food, it was delightful. We got a couple of fancy coffee drinks, which were well-flavored, not too sweet, and the iced one was presented in a mason jar. Classic. We also shared like four food items. The pull-apart monkey bread was sweet and dense and delicious. Don't order this if you're alone. You'll need help to finish it. Got a creme filled pull pastry thing. That was nice. Flakes for days. This was no rough puff. For the chocolate croissant, also known as a pain au chocolat. Again, very flakey, very buttery, the perfect touch of sweet chocolate. And a savory, massive scone. Bacon and chives, I think. Also very good. Crumbly. Overall, I was very surprised. There certainly wasn't anywhere like this in Pensacola when I lived here. This place is a quality bakery that could easily be found in a medium-sized city. I was so pleased and will definitely come back.

    Pros: Ambiance was great. Pastry everywhere, nice seating…read morearea, and the smell of fresh baked bread in the air. Service was very friendly. They brought all that we ordered right to our table. Very nice. And the pastries themselves were very high quality. Flakey, not dry, well filled, of a good size. Definitely a high point. Cons: No real cons. I didn't have enough stomach space to try everything I wanted. Lol. Tips: The chocolate croissant and the creme filled thing we got were delicious. The scone was also good, but maybe less good than other things we left on the table. Need to come back here!

    Photos
    Craft Gourmet Bakery
    Fresh baked bread
    Fresh baked bread
    Breakfast Pizza

    See all

    Breakfast Pizza
    Deep South Cake Company

    Deep South Cake Company

    4.6
    (28 reviews)
    24.0 mi

    First time trying this bakery and man it did not disappoint! The shop smells like a sugar cookie…read morecandle (perfect for a bake shop). They have multiple flavors of cakes, cupcakes and cookies. We decided on a classic vanilla "leftover" cake that was one day past Halloween. The sprinkles didn't scream Halloween, so it was perfect for my grandmas 90th birthday because she LOVES sprinkles! It was 50% off and man this cake tasted like a $100 cake! You can tell this was made with Fresh and real ingredients! The icing was my FAVORITE! It had a smooth bite to it! And the cake, Y'all it was sooo moist! It was a large round 2 layer cake. We had tons of leftovers for 6 people. Served with birthday cake ice cream and my grandmother LOVED it! I can't wait to go back and try their Carmel and strawberry flavors! 10/10! Supper local!

    I really wanted to enjoy my treats from here but sadly I thought they were really disappointing…read more :( I came in about two weekends ago while on vacation with my in-laws in the area. This small shop is located in a large shopping center next to a grocery store I was unfamiliar with (Rouse's, if I remember correctly). Thankfully, that makes parking pretty easy. The inside is simple but cute, and very clean. The one girl working that day sort of looked at me like I'd grown three heads when I came in and didn't offer any assistance, but warmed up when I chatted her up while checking out. She was quite nice once we spoke to each other but the lack of hello or can I help you after looking right at me in an otherwise-empty shop was kinda weird. I selected two cake slices: a caramel cake slice and an oreo chocolate cake slice. I was somewhat tempted by the German chocolate cake but couldn't discern any coconut or pecan pieces in the frosting. Maybe it was a more literal /german/ chocolate cake, rather than the chocolate cake with pecan and coconut frosting named after Sam German? I usually assume the latter in average US bakeries but who can say. The lady at the register informed me the cake slices were BOGO that day, so the price was right! Though I can't help but wonder if the fact they were BOGO reflected some kind of decline in quality or an older cake slice, because sadly I didn't really enjoy either cake. I will admit I delayed a day or two between buying my slices and sharing them with my husband, so perhaps that contributed to the deterioration of it. At any rate, the Oreo chocolate cake was very dry. The icing had kind of separated from the cake and had crystallized into a crunchy, saccharine strip. My husband wouldn't even finish his half of the piece. The caramel cake was better, a tiny bit more moist with slightly less "crackly" icing. Still not my favorite -- a little on the dense side, and still fairly dry. Again, perhaps this experience was partially on me for delaying a day or so in eating my treats, but I dunno. Perhaps cupcakes are the way to go instead? I'm not sure. I'm sad I didn't have a super positive experience, but I like the concept of this business and I wish them success!

    Photos
    Caramel, Oreo, strawberry
    Caramel, Oreo, strawberry
    Caramel
    Caramel
    Chocolate

    See all

    Chocolate
    Smallcakes

    Smallcakes

    4.3
    (61 reviews)
    4.4 mi
    $$

    Can someone please explain why Florida gets all the fun bakeries?!…read more My father-in-law surprised Jason with a birthday cake from Smallcakes after it came highly recommended, and now I completely understand why. Jason's grandparents have enjoyed their cupcakes before, so expectations were already pretty high... and somehow they still managed to exceed them. Jason requested a carrot cake for his birthday, and all his dad told Smallcakes was, "Carrot cake, golf theme." Smallcakes absolutely understood the assignment. This cake was GORGEOUS. Every little golf detail was so thoughtfully done, and it looked almost too good to eat! Seriously the sandpit and grass... just wow. (Keyword: almost.) Now let's talk about the icing... because I genuinely have not stopped thinking about it. Im SO picky with icing, I would happily eat it straight from the container with absolutely zero shame. It was rich without being overly sweet, perfectly smooth, and somehow managed to make an already incredible carrot cake even better. Every bite was moist, flavorful, and downright dangerous. (Side note pull out of fridge a little before eating). We're honestly a little heartbroken we're only visiting because I had every intention of trying half the cupcake display too. Unfortunately, we still have a mountain of birthday cake left. ...Then again, challenge accepted. If you're anywhere near Pensacola and need a cake for a birthday, celebration, or just because it's Tuesday and life is hard (which would be me at least 2x a week) do yourself a favor and stop by Smallcakes. Our birthday boy couldn't have asked for a more perfect cake!

    Small cakes Pensacola absolutely nailed it on my son's dinosaur themed birthday cake. The design…read morewas great and the cake tasted even better, thank you so much!

    Photos
    The pup Pupcake before eating
    The pup Pupcake before eating
    The carrot Peanut Butter Cup Cake
    The carrot Peanut Butter Cup Cake
    Freezer options

    See all

    Freezer options
    Four Seasons Market & Eatery

    Four Seasons Market & Eatery

    4.8
    (124 reviews)
    0.5 mi
    $

    This locally owned downtown restaurant has delicious food. Some of my favorites are duck gumbo,…read moreRuben sandwich, side salad and carrot cake. My wife's favorites are grouper Ruben sandwich, grilled shrimp salad and pecan pie. The service is very welcoming. Everyone gets greeted when they enter this cozy restaurant. Amber takes your order then follows up at your table to ensure you have everything you need. This restaurant also does catering and has a delivery service.

    My husband and I were just walking down Palafox checking out the menus of several restaurants and…read morethe Four Seasons had a board with all the fresh seafood listed on it. They had Amberjack and that's one of our favs that you don't see as much anymore. This place is owned by a very nice couple. The wife runs the front and hubby is a chef. She offered us a taste of his Gumbo (chicken,sausage) and it was really great! We are kinda picky about our gumbo and it passed our tastebuds with flying colors ! We shared a amberjack sandwich and ordered the Cajun potato salad as the side with an extra serving since we were sharing. The amberjack was a good size and grilled to perfection. I was wishing I got a whole sandwich! The potato salad was really yummy too! We will definitely be going back soon! We sat at a table outside.

    Photos
    Dining area.
    Dining area.
    Best fried chicken ever!! Brussel spouts not on everyday menu, trying something new! Everything delicious
    Best fried chicken ever!! Brussel spouts not on everyday menu, trying something new! Everything delicious
    Front order area.

    See all

    Front order area.

    Pensacola Cakes - customcakes - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...