Peoples Choice pizza

If I could leave less than 1 star, I would. The food was of shockingly low quality. We got the…read morewhole story about the owner and his mom and her picture and yada dada da but the food fell incredibly short of authentic. We were a large party and ordered all over the menu. The items were as follows: Eggplant Parmesan: lacking sauce and it was served on a bed of overcooked and naked angel hair noodles. I couldn't believe they weren't even al dente and the water wasn't even salted. Chicken Cesar salad: hard to mess this one up and I can't say I'm disappointed. It was exactly what I expected and I'm glad to have played it safe Barramundi: this was NOT barramundi. This was tilapia at best. Barramundi is a sea bass. This was thin and overcooked in a "white wine sauce" that tasted like lemon and milk. It was incredibly disappointing Shrimp scampi: the shrimp was overcooked and they tasted fishy. Low quality and the sauce was lacking that punch of garlic one would look for. Too heavy on the lemon which I assume was intentional to mask the fishy flavor Chicken tenders: wow. Just wow. They were from a package at best. Can you at least obtain something of higher quality? Strawberry salad: seriously?! It was just mixed greens and a few slices of strawberries with plain walnuts. So minimal and not worth the price Garlic bread with mozzarella: O M G. The plate was HUGE. This by far was not made in house. Tasted like Texas toast with a slice of cheese melted on top. Cannoli: burnt shell and overly sweet inside Creme brûlée: one side was firm and the other was soupy. Made me worried about having undercooked eggs and getting sick Chocolate cake: we were literally told this was homemade in house. Cooked from a box is not "homemade" - it's prepared. Low quality, artificial flavor. The coffee was disgusting. I'm sorry. I try to be so polite when leaving reviews but that was by far the worst coffee I have ever had in my life. M Tiramisu: tasted basically like baileys and whipped cream. For an Italian restaurant, you would hope they could at least get this menu item right... but nope. The service was sub par, I think it's because there were so many of us but a lot of things were missed. I asked for a glass of wine and it never came. Another individual had to ask for their beer multiple times, just to be brought a glass of red wine.... And then they still forgot about the beer to make it right. The servers were nice, however. I think they probably don't have the tools to succeed and know the food isn't up to the standards it should be Lastly it was HOT and HUMID in the room. The thermostat didn't work and we were told it barely works at all. That was disappointing and made for an even more uncomfortable experience. *oh, and for yall that think the portion sizes are small... they are HUGE which would have been amazing if the food was good. Portion sizes don't matter if the food is not worth eating. I would not patron this restaurant again. The calories were not worth it at all.

Upon trying to decide where to eat after an event, we ran across Mama Lucia's from YELP assistance…read moreper usual. This is a great place for Italian food, off the beaten path. Linen table cloths, great ambiance, and top notch service from Francesca. She gets 5 stars alone. We ordered Chicken Parm, Chicken Piccata w/fried artichokes added for a tasty surprise. Yummy ! Dessert was Creme Brulee, one of my favorite desserts! I'll be back to try other things on their menu. Good stuff!

See all

Positano Pizza Napoletana

Great salads!!! I love the Greek salad, the pizza is good as well. I will definitely eat there…read moreagain

The pizza and burrata here are just ok. I was really craving some pizza so thought I'd check out…read morethis spot. Up first, I tried the $16.99 Burrata Salad. Now, on the plus size the portion is huge. This is certainly enough for 1 pizza to eat, and not even bother with getting a pizza. However, I wanted to try the pizza too. For the pizza, I tried the $36.50 Liguria + $4.50 sausage + $4.00 mushrooms. The pizza was just alright. A whole lot of bread, and kind of thin on the toppings. The flop wasn't too bad, but I just wasn't feeling the pizza all that much. Ironically the bread that comes with the burrata was the best item here. Great location next to Dick's, Dillard's, and a bunch of would be mall spots. I don't think I'd come eat here again though.

Beautiful, authentic, Neapolitan pizza ... if you know, you know!

Delicious

See all

Positano Pizza

Del Porto Italian Creole

4.7(6 reviews)

1.7 mi

Our first time here last night. Had a large group for a birthday dinner. Fortunately we were able…read moreto walk in, minimal wait. Our server, Angie, was great! She made great suggestions, was friendly, and service was prompt. Food was delicious and had good portions. Even had good options for the kiddos. We'll definitely be back!

I travel through this area for business every few months and I always stop her for the wings…read more Definitely some of the best wings I've ever had, large, lots of meat, cooked to perfection. I will continue to return when in this area.

See all

Fazoli’s

4.3(14 reviews)

1.5 mi

I mean who knew. Went here got the chicken fettuccine. Service was spectacular. Guy who waited on…read moreus and served us belonged at an upscale place. I was shocked at the most excellent service. He should be commended. This place was great.

The food is fine, they were only one item short when packing my order, I guess everyone can't count…read moreto 3.

Dining area

Gotta love ordering a sampler with 3 different menu items!

See all

Interior

Frank's Family Restaurant

3.4(255 reviews)

10.7 mi

Franks is the best kept secret of the south if you ask me. I was leery, because the restaurant sits…read moreon the side of a gas station, but trust me. No gas station food there. The selection of the Greek/Italian/American food choices is tremendous. You truly have to settle your eyes and push down the urge to order every single thing on the menu. Our server was awesome, super attentive and just flat wonderful. So was the lady that seated us. Ambiance is kind of simple but charming. The decorations are just cute and not overwhelming. Close to the airport to where I will take time out to stop before or after a flight if time permits. Can't wait to come back!

I've been to Frank's quite a few times and always enjoy my meal. So much so that I got Frank's as…read moremy first meal in the hospital after giving birth to my daughter a few years ago! I usually get the same thing, Shrimp Fettuccine Scampi ($28.95). Fresh shrimp sautéed with butter, lemon, garlic, & capers tossed with fettuccine pasta. The portions are huge, always enough for at least 2 meals. On this particular visit I dined in alone. The place was empty so I was seated promptly. The website listed "$3 margaritas all day" so I excitedly ordered one, along with the shrimp pasta, a cup of baked potato soup, and a small Greek salad. The margarita came out first (2/5). It was definitely just a basic margarita made from a mix with minimal tequila added. I only finished a third of it. The soup and a garlic bread stick came out next (1/5). The soup didn't look or taste homemade. It was extra thick and not in a good way. It honestly tasted like it was made from a powder. The bread stick was extremely tough, almost stale. The Greek salad was next (4/5). The veggies were crisp and fresh. You honestly can't go wrong with a salad unless the dressing is nasty but their house made Greek dressing was delicious. It would've been better if the salad had been prepared with red onions instead of white and if the kalamata olives had been pitted. Last to arrive was the shrimp scampi (3/5). This time the dish seemed to lack the bold flavor that it usually has. I took a few bites and decided to take the rest to go so that it could be "doctored up" at home. If this had been my first visit to Frank's I definitely wouldn't be back but this must've been an "off" day as it's been delicious in the past. The service however was consistent, great as usual.

Dessert case just inside the door- we did order two slices of cheesecake to go and they were quite good

Philly Steak Sandwich

See all

Restaurant interior

Partners II Pizza At Summer Grove

3.9(121 reviews)

0.7 mi

Service was a joy. The cutest girl with braids helped us. She was a joy. The rest of the staff…read morewas pleasant. We had a variety of food and all of it was great. Nice atmosphere and great service.

My, how 6 years makes a difference-- I had knee surgery and…read morewas out of commission for two months. One day after a few weeks of physical therapy, I decide to take my son to dinner by walking with the aid of my cane, to the neighboring Partners. We got there around 8:34pm. I walk in, sweat pouring down, and we ask to be seated to get our usual variety of entrees. It's Saturday night. The little girl at the counter says she can't seat us, seating ended at 830pm, and they close at 9pm. I said, 'oh wow, we just walked all the way over here and I didn't realize that." So she says, ' well, you can do a takeout order.' And I am, thinking how is that going to work taking a carryout order with my cane? And so we leave and go across the street to Christo's Pizzeria who also closed at 9pm this particular Saturday evening, and they provided professional customer service, great food and conversation! Thank you for showing my family how you sacrifice service to the neighborhood you serve in the name of 9pm. And I do not care if you do not care, because I will tell everyone and post everywhere what took place. You didn't even try. Because for those who know, the front of the house reflects the culture of the back of the house. Although, wouldn't it be less effort just posting a sign on the door, saying, 'Hey Coweta, just go to Christo's, we tired.'

All the specialty pizzas. The Potato pizza is unique & a favorite

Cailzones

See all

Gluten free menu

The Italian Oven

3.5(144 reviews)

11.7 mi

We used to come a lot then the food was just okay. Then recently I feel like it's changed and…read moregotten much much better again. Not only has the food improved, the service has been excellent. Last night, even after a mix up when it took a minute to get a server, the manager came and personally apologized. Even though it wasn't a big deal, he instead on paying for half and making it right. Although we refused, he gave us a gift card and made us feel like important customers. If it's been a while or you're new, give Italian Oven a try!

A/C not working properly and staff said had been that way for weeks. Food not very flavorful,…read moreused to be a go to for us, not anymore. Felt bad for staff having to work in the warm conditions......

Mushroom Florentine

See all

Mama Lucia's Italian Restaurant

3.0(1 review)

1.6 mi

The wedge salad is a joke. I had to laugh out loud when I saw it. The service was adequate. Some of…read morethe staff were dressed as if they slept in their clothes. Food quality was good except for the bread which was like someone just picked it up at Publix. Ambiance, almost none exists It was hard to believe it took them so long to open. Maybe they ran out of money and plan on doing more later. How about spend a little money on some plants.

From the owner: Mama Lucia's Restaurant is proud to set the gold standard for fine dining in our community. Guests…read morerightfully expect the finest in luxury and sophistication, delivered by experienced fine dining professionals. Our chef and culinary specialists work tirelessly to create signature offerings which combine the finest ingredients with an innovative approach. Critics and guests alike acknowledge Mama Lucia's Restaurant's commitment to exceeding even the highest expectations.

Carrabba's Italian Grill

Food was fabulous . Our server gave us service with a smile. The ambiance is a little Italian…read morebistro with great food . Jessica is a super awesome manager . We will be back !!!!!

From appetizers, to drinks, to the actual meal- everything was fantastic! Amazing fast service with…read moredelicious food. Absolutely recommend this location for its ambiance and good food !

See all

Spezzano's Market

4.2(30 reviews)

11.6 mi

Spezzano's is a great market that sells high quality food. I especially loved stopping by to get a…read moresub sandwich. The meatball subs are absolutely legendary. I cannot praise them enough. I never thought I would chose a meatball sub over fresh cold cuts but the meatballs became my favorite thing on the menu.

Great sandwiches and they have a few seats! Great meat for bbq as well. Always enjoyed the weekend…read morewith one of their sandwiches

Order counter

Ultimate Ham, Cappacola & Salami

See all

View from the parking lot

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

16 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Sandy M.

0

1

0

10 years ago

My husband and I order from People's Choice and always enjoy it. We were so bummed one Friday night when the delivery person only left a partial part of our order. I called and let the restaurant know and they had our completed order out within 20 minutes (you could tell it was fresh and not something that had been left in a car for an additional 20 minutes) and even put in some cheesecake for the mishap. Mistakes happen, but when someone goes above and beyond to correct it, it really means a lot. We will definitely remain loyal customers of People's Choice! read more

emily L.

0

8

3

9 years ago

What an excellent pizza we just had. The crust was thin and crispy but also chewy, not like a cracker. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese; the toppings were fresh and looked like someone took the time to evenly distribute them over the whole thing. It was perfect. I really don't think I've had such a great pizza in ages. Thanks People's! ___________________________ And just so you know it wasn't a one-off... tonight we just got ANOTHER spectacular pizza, exactly as ordered, fast and delicious. This is the BEST pizza delivery in Newnan, hands down read more

Jason D.

0

1

0

10 years ago

Terrible food, very expensive. VERY RUDE STAFF Owner could care less for customer relations, all he cares for is making his own profit. The store is always an absolute mess and should honestly be shut down for how it is run. Nast floors, and counters ALL DAY. raw meat left on counters for hours on end, improper food handling and inexperienced cooks lead this to be one of the worst places to eat in Newnan. Don't waste your money buy an overpriced pizza when you could get the same thing for half price at dominos/pizzahut/poppa johns. read more

Steve Nikki B.

128

1

11 years ago

This pizza is very, very FRESH. It doesn't take much until your completely full. The dough is made daily, and all The vegetables are cut several times throughout the day. They also have the best wings in town with several flavors to choose from. They have hot and cold sub sandwiches as well as different flavors of wraps. Oh. And by the way, the deserts are delicious. Hope you enjoy, and like them on Facebook and Instagram for updated coupons. Remember, it's People's Choice Pizza of NEWNAN. read more

Jeremy T.

20

1

0

10 years ago

Of all the pizza places here in Newnan, People's choice is bar none the best! The fact they use fresh non-frozen ingredients and each pizza is crafted with hand made care, makes for some amazing out this world food. You owe it to your taste buds to try them. The Flavors are vibrant and irrestable, and the pizza crust has the perfect subtlety of crunchiness while simultaneously being pillow soft! read more

Paul C.

0

1

0

4 months ago

Today we ordered a large Bacon pizza and a medium Steak and Cheese pizza. Drove there to pick them up and they were ready when we arrived... Both pizzas were excellent! Pizzas were cooked perfectly with fresh ingredients.. We just moved here from the north and have been struggling to find a good place for pizza.... We just found it!! read more

Lisa C.

0

1

0

2 months ago

I decided to try People's Choice when I heard it had new owners. I am glad I did. I ordered Pizza and wings and they were amazing. It was also a pleasant surprise to see Jennifer was still working there. She always goes the extra mile! Great food and Great customer service.I would have given more than 5 stars if I could have read more

Sam H.

0

1

0

1 year ago

Best food I've ever had is the best food I've ever ate in a long very very long time the wings are amazing the pizza was great I love the garlic crust and the cheese was just just bright I loved everything about it and the customer service was wonderful read more

M K.

0

1

0

10 years ago

This poor excuse of a pizza place needs to get it's priories in line. I have had nothing but trouble with them. One of their drivers is clearly on meth and drives like a maniac. I'm pretty sure the whole place is run by teenagers and pill addicts. read more

Tony S.

0

7

2

10 years ago

There are only three places to get a real pizza down here on the south side and this is one of them. In fact it's the only place I've found to get a clam and bacon which is popular in New England. Their lasagna pizza rocks. read more

Nikki B.

0

1

0

10 years ago

Love love love some peoples choice. Try the spinach Alfredo pizza. It rocks! Also there are some new flavors for the wings. boom, boom flavor is awesome. Try it, you will love it. read more

Tiffanie T.

55

3

9

15 years ago

MmmmMmmm Good! Best wings & Pizza stop in Newnan, GA. Great prices and fast service! Try their Lemon Pepper Wings and say, "Yummy!" read more

Meg J.

0

2

0

2 years ago

Yummy and quick! We're regulars here! Usually pizza or wings, but try their garlic knots; you'll be addicted too. Nice folks too.

Greg F.

6

4

1

1 year ago

I received a pizza without cheese! It was the worst and saddest pizza ever. Even bad by Newnan standards!

Lisa H.

1

10

39

1 year ago

Always great food and service! Definitely one of our favorites. Potato skins are a must!

Lacey J.

0

1

0

1 year ago

Food was out fast and it was delicious freaking hands down the best pizza I've hadandthe

Peoples Choice pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Peoples Choice pizza also viewed

Karvelas Pizza - Newnan

3.7

(82 reviews)

It was O.K. The establishment is very casual, friendly and great for families or just a casual meet…read moreup with friends. They have a few selections of beer and soft drinks. The pizza is reasonably priced anywhere between $20-29 for a 16 inch which can feed 3-4 adults. I just wasn't really impressed with the flavor. But they serve really good fried pickles.

Been to Karvelas many times and it's always great! The artist in me loves their tables because you…read morecan draw on this paper they put on them :) For this specific review, I got takeout but the food was fantastic as always! Only downside is there is almost always a 20 ish minute wait, however, it's extremely worth it.

Fabiano's Pizzeria

3.6

(135 reviews)

I love pizza. I am a pizza fanatic. I love this place's pizza. I've always had good customer…read moreservice. Got my food on time. Never been a problem. I recommend this is a good pizza place for anybody visiting or those who live here.

Enjoyed our pizza slice and salad lunch today iatFabiano's in the old theatre of Newnan. Friendly…read moreand quick service, ambiance was fine. Salads - particularly the rocket or the spinach salads were excellent. Pizza slices are large and were delicious. All in all it seemed a touch overpriced yet the pi.- was very tasty!

Buck's Pizza

3.5

(42 reviews)

This little local spot deserves some recognition. From the outside you wouldn't think much of this…read morePeachtree a city gem. Upon entering Bucks pizza it didn't have much of a decor wow factor, but Lordy I could smell those cinnamon sticks cooking. We were greeted quickly and asked if we wanted any upsells etc. I love when people upsell me it means they know what they are doing haha. I Loved the menu they have gluten free pizzas the whole reason we dropped by. We ordered two 12" gluten free pizza & dessert: 1: Chicken BBQ 2: Greek Pizza 3: Cinnamon Sticks (not gluten free) Total: $43.70 Time from ordering to ready: 15 min. on a Friday night Taste: 5 stars good lord it was so delicious it didn't last the night Overall: Highly Recommend Check out this local slice of heaven

I love your pizza and menu…read more The service is always great and fast. What a great takeout.

Partners II Pizza At Summer Grove

3.9

(121 reviews)

Service was a joy. The cutest girl with braids helped us. She was a joy. The rest of the staff…read morewas pleasant. We had a variety of food and all of it was great. Nice atmosphere and great service.

My, how 6 years makes a difference-- I had knee surgery and…read morewas out of commission for two months. One day after a few weeks of physical therapy, I decide to take my son to dinner by walking with the aid of my cane, to the neighboring Partners. We got there around 8:34pm. I walk in, sweat pouring down, and we ask to be seated to get our usual variety of entrees. It's Saturday night. The little girl at the counter says she can't seat us, seating ended at 830pm, and they close at 9pm. I said, 'oh wow, we just walked all the way over here and I didn't realize that." So she says, ' well, you can do a takeout order.' And I am, thinking how is that going to work taking a carryout order with my cane? And so we leave and go across the street to Christo's Pizzeria who also closed at 9pm this particular Saturday evening, and they provided professional customer service, great food and conversation! Thank you for showing my family how you sacrifice service to the neighborhood you serve in the name of 9pm. And I do not care if you do not care, because I will tell everyone and post everywhere what took place. You didn't even try. Because for those who know, the front of the house reflects the culture of the back of the house. Although, wouldn't it be less effort just posting a sign on the door, saying, 'Hey Coweta, just go to Christo's, we tired.'

Aj's Grab N Go, Pizza & Wings

3.9

(10 reviews)

The food is delicious, and the service is quick with your order. The place itself gives off a gas…read morestation vibe where you can purchase other things other than just the food.

My sister & brother in law live down the road, so we popped in to grab quick food…read more They made everything as ordered. You can tell this place gets a lot of to go orders! They had a steady stream of customers coming and going. Place was well kept, staff is extremely friendly- I appreciated the southern hospitality- it was very apparent here. :). Thank you! I was also impressed with the boys phone greeting/voice- as he kept busy and was locked in when it came to handling things there. Then there is Grandma- that's what everyone calls her. She was a crack up and I can see where her nickname comes from. I will definitely be back when I come to visit and I highly recommend to everyone around and visiting or passing by. :) Food quality was pretty good- we were happy and satisfied. They also have thc drinks for 21 and older. I thought that was cool! I tried the flying kite drink and it definitely elevated my 4th of July. Thanks for such a memorable stop that I didn't expect!

Tour de Italy

3.5

(8 reviews)

Food and service are excellent. Surprised it was slow even on a Monday night even though I went…read moresuper early, but it filled up super quick. Will definitely be back!

Have been here many times and I'm never disappointed. Great food, nice atmosphere, and exceptional…read morecustomer service. Beer and wine selections for those inclined and occasionally, live music.

Oz Pizza

4.1

(247 reviews)

Positives: The young man who took our order was pleasant and…read moreprovided good customer service. Negatives: 1. Waiting 25 minutes for two slices of pizza is unreasonable, especially when "by-the-slice" options are advertised. 2. After that wait, the pizza wasn't even hot. 3. The Greek salad was very disappointing, ingredients tasted old, the pepperoncini was old, colorless and tasteless and mushrooms were off-putting. Overall, it lacked freshness and quality. 4. The pepperoni pizza was hard, overly oily, and lacked sufficient sauce. 5. The Mack pizza was not worth it heavy, undercooked meat toppings and topped with a large clump of mozzarella that wasn't properly melted or appealing. I've visited another location before, but unfortunately, this Fairburn location was a very poor first experience. Based on this visit, I won't be returning.

Early dinner/late lunch. I had 2 slices, pep/anchovies and chicken w/spinach. Pepperoni slice was…read moreokay. However, the chicken w/spinach was dry and underwhelming. The service by the cashier was great. He was friendly and polite. 2 stars for him alone. The place was pretty empty when I dined in. It's been awhile since I was last here. Might be that way again.

Milano's

3.8

(28 reviews)

Run, don't walk to the Milano's in Sharpsburg! If you want a delicious affordable meal with menu…read morechoices to fit a multitude of palates this is the place. First, the establishment has a very bright and welcoming atmosphere, outside the location is spotless, bright white with windows so clean they sparkle. Once you walk in, you're welcomed quickly and seated, surrounded by pictures and decor from Italy and classic Italian restaurant scenes. Floors are spotless, seating is well maintained, and the table linens are very clean. Brianna was our server, and immediately you could tell she enjoyed her job, was extremely attentive to our table, and made sure our drinks were always full, and properly timed our meal to ensure it didn't come out till our appetizers were complete. The moment we sat we were welcomed with some freshly baked delicious rolls and plenty of tangy savory housemade marinara to dunk the warm crispy rolls in. Looking at the menu my eyes were immediately trained on to the Greek combo platter, that was an exceptional crowd pleaser, chicken souvlaki was tender, well spiced and full of flavor, the gyro meat was also delicious complemented well by tzatziki sauce. Meat balls were crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, exactly how my mom makes Greek meatballs. Spinach pie bites were again crispy on the outside and deliciously powerful on the inside. There wasn't anything on the plate that wasn't exceptional, and at its price point, was an extremely good value, can't recommend it enough. Salads utilized a great mix, fresh tomatoes and cucumbers, complimented with crisp Greek peppers, Kalamata olives, and plenty feta cheese. Entrees really wowed! But at this point we were all getting full, we trudged on, trying to get a few bites of EVERYTHING. Milano's pizza is very well known and appreciated, I can totally understand why. The crust was crispy, covered with delicious high quality cheese and a very palatable sauce. Kids enjoyed it! My entree of chopped sirloin was very delicious, covered with perfectly cooked sautéed onions and served with a side of sauce, not thick goopy gravy like at many other places. Grilled vegetables were delicious! Perfectly cooked with just the right amount of char, And a flavor all of its own! Extremely magnificent! My wife enjoyed the Italian grilled sausage that came with freshly grilled peppers, onions and mushrooms served over a bed of absolutely delicious seasoned rice. Key takeaways from this establishment is that the location is great, the restaurant is clean, the employees are very very helpful, good at their job and the food is absolutely exceptional. We will definitely be back! And I also urge you to try for yourself and enjoy a great night out!!

This is an amazing small Italian restaurant, prices are really affordable, food is really good. I…read moretried the chicken parmesan and love it! Servings size are big, always take home left overs. I would recommend the grilled salmon with bacon topping, is just scrumptious!!! Only thing would not recommend is the pizzas, they are ok but a bit overpriced in my opinion.

AJ’s pizza & wings

4.7

(6 reviews)

Always fast and kept warm til you pick up. Love the loaded tater tots and their chicken wraps…read more First time trying the Philly and it's great!

Updated review…read more Second time visiting and they are constantly getting it done correctly. Great food, service and polite and local what more could you want. Go and try them out. Friendly atmosphere when you walk in to top it all off also.

Positano Pizza Napoletana

4.4

(282 reviews)