Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mama Lucia's Italian Restaurant

    3.0 (1 review)

    Mama Lucia's Italian Restaurant Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Mama Lucia's Italian Restaurant

    Recommended Reviews - Mama Lucia's Italian Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Mama Lucia's Restaurant

    Mama Lucia's Restaurant

    3.4
    (163 reviews)
    0.0 mi
    $$

    If I could leave less than 1 star, I would. The food was of shockingly low quality. We got the…read morewhole story about the owner and his mom and her picture and yada dada da but the food fell incredibly short of authentic. We were a large party and ordered all over the menu. The items were as follows: Eggplant Parmesan: lacking sauce and it was served on a bed of overcooked and naked angel hair noodles. I couldn't believe they weren't even al dente and the water wasn't even salted. Chicken Cesar salad: hard to mess this one up and I can't say I'm disappointed. It was exactly what I expected and I'm glad to have played it safe Barramundi: this was NOT barramundi. This was tilapia at best. Barramundi is a sea bass. This was thin and overcooked in a "white wine sauce" that tasted like lemon and milk. It was incredibly disappointing Shrimp scampi: the shrimp was overcooked and they tasted fishy. Low quality and the sauce was lacking that punch of garlic one would look for. Too heavy on the lemon which I assume was intentional to mask the fishy flavor Chicken tenders: wow. Just wow. They were from a package at best. Can you at least obtain something of higher quality? Strawberry salad: seriously?! It was just mixed greens and a few slices of strawberries with plain walnuts. So minimal and not worth the price Garlic bread with mozzarella: O M G. The plate was HUGE. This by far was not made in house. Tasted like Texas toast with a slice of cheese melted on top. Cannoli: burnt shell and overly sweet inside Creme brûlée: one side was firm and the other was soupy. Made me worried about having undercooked eggs and getting sick Chocolate cake: we were literally told this was homemade in house. Cooked from a box is not "homemade" - it's prepared. Low quality, artificial flavor. The coffee was disgusting. I'm sorry. I try to be so polite when leaving reviews but that was by far the worst coffee I have ever had in my life. M Tiramisu: tasted basically like baileys and whipped cream. For an Italian restaurant, you would hope they could at least get this menu item right... but nope. The service was sub par, I think it's because there were so many of us but a lot of things were missed. I asked for a glass of wine and it never came. Another individual had to ask for their beer multiple times, just to be brought a glass of red wine.... And then they still forgot about the beer to make it right. The servers were nice, however. I think they probably don't have the tools to succeed and know the food isn't up to the standards it should be Lastly it was HOT and HUMID in the room. The thermostat didn't work and we were told it barely works at all. That was disappointing and made for an even more uncomfortable experience. *oh, and for yall that think the portion sizes are small... they are HUGE which would have been amazing if the food was good. Portion sizes don't matter if the food is not worth eating. I would not patron this restaurant again. The calories were not worth it at all.

    Upon trying to decide where to eat after an event, we ran across Mama Lucia's from YELP assistance…read moreper usual. This is a great place for Italian food, off the beaten path. Linen table cloths, great ambiance, and top notch service from Francesca. She gets 5 stars alone. We ordered Chicken Parm, Chicken Piccata w/fried artichokes added for a tasty surprise. Yummy ! Dessert was Creme Brulee, one of my favorite desserts! I'll be back to try other things on their menu. Good stuff!

    Photos
    Mama Lucia's Restaurant
    Mama Lucia's Restaurant
    Mama Lucia's Restaurant

    See all

    Frank's Family Restaurant

    Frank's Family Restaurant

    3.4
    (256 reviews)
    9.0 mi
    $$

    Franks is the best kept secret of the south if you ask me. I was leery, because the restaurant sits…read moreon the side of a gas station, but trust me. No gas station food there. The selection of the Greek/Italian/American food choices is tremendous. You truly have to settle your eyes and push down the urge to order every single thing on the menu. Our server was awesome, super attentive and just flat wonderful. So was the lady that seated us. Ambiance is kind of simple but charming. The decorations are just cute and not overwhelming. Close to the airport to where I will take time out to stop before or after a flight if time permits. Can't wait to come back!

    Prime rib Liver and onions…read more Need to focus on less all-inclusive soup, salad breadsticks in the entrée. And focus on the main event Soup was so thick it was almost disgusting Greek salad dressing was bad oil The creativity:/inspiration for the sautéed onions for the liver was poorly executed with some unknown inclusion Prime rib came fully vested with a wilted, useless, garnish, with the meat fully surrounded by capped plastic condiment of horseradish, au jus and sour cream. Accompanied by two tubes of airline quality, sour cream, and two nicely plastic containers of officially whipped butter. Uncertain of what was on top of the meat was something lacy and crusty totally unrelated to the meat, reminiscent dirty pans. After asking the waiter for his opinion for asking the kitchen to explain what this accessory was, it was dismissed and nothing important needing no further explanation in his opinion. In my opinion I was blown off . We've been here before, we've like delivering onions before. Frankly, no pun I don't think we'll be back. Humbly stated for a $95 tab. We would've been better going to the roadhouse with more cheerful and probably better Service and significantly better quality with probably half the price.. (and half the plastic) I debated the tip and reluctantly gave my 15%

    Photos
    Dessert case just inside the door- we did order two slices of cheesecake to go and they were quite good
    Dessert case just inside the door- we did order two slices of cheesecake to go and they were quite good
    Philly Steak Sandwich
    Philly Steak Sandwich
    Restaurant interior

    See all

    Restaurant interior
    Partners II Pizza At Summer Grove

    Partners II Pizza At Summer Grove

    3.9
    (121 reviews)
    1.3 mi
    $

    Service was a joy. The cutest girl with braids helped us. She was a joy. The rest of the staff…read morewas pleasant. We had a variety of food and all of it was great. Nice atmosphere and great service.

    My, how 6 years makes a difference-- I had knee surgery and…read morewas out of commission for two months. One day after a few weeks of physical therapy, I decide to take my son to dinner by walking with the aid of my cane, to the neighboring Partners. We got there around 8:34pm. I walk in, sweat pouring down, and we ask to be seated to get our usual variety of entrees. It's Saturday night. The little girl at the counter says she can't seat us, seating ended at 830pm, and they close at 9pm. I said, 'oh wow, we just walked all the way over here and I didn't realize that." So she says, ' well, you can do a takeout order.' And I am, thinking how is that going to work taking a carryout order with my cane? And so we leave and go across the street to Christo's Pizzeria who also closed at 9pm this particular Saturday evening, and they provided professional customer service, great food and conversation! Thank you for showing my family how you sacrifice service to the neighborhood you serve in the name of 9pm. And I do not care if you do not care, because I will tell everyone and post everywhere what took place. You didn't even try. Because for those who know, the front of the house reflects the culture of the back of the house. Although, wouldn't it be less effort just posting a sign on the door, saying, 'Hey Coweta, just go to Christo's, we tired.'

    Photos
    All the specialty pizzas. The Potato pizza is unique & a favorite
    All the specialty pizzas. The Potato pizza is unique & a favorite
    Cailzones
    Cailzones
    Gluten free menu

    See all

    Gluten free menu

    Mama Lucia's Italian Restaurant - italian - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...