Hands down one of the most underrated pizza joints in ACo! Peppinos has been around for decades and it always delivers. I contemplated getting a second slice for a solid 10 minutes. Great flavor ! Greasy and all 10/10 highly recommend! read more

Peppino's Pizzeria - Sausage & Pep - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

Door Dash to the rescue!!! Here in the area visiting with my grandkids and my granddaughter wanted Pizza. Searched Door Dash and something kept me going back to Peppinos Pizzeria. We didn't want anything fancy. Just a pepperoni pizza. And I am so happy we chose this place. Yall.... Their pizza is really good. The cheesy cheese. The right amount of sauce. And the tasty pepperonis make a perfect pizza. I'll definitely tell my son about this place and will be ordering again when we come back to visit. read more

Peppino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

See all

Service is good prices are high for what you get no drink refills is the killer. Crust is a little dry but the rest of the pizza is very good. Garlic knots were amazing. But for mall pizza since sbarros is out of business it's pretty good read more

Peppino's Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

Nice staff. Decent NY style Pizza. Good amount of cheese and the sauce has a nice taste to it.

Food was AMAZING, Very large portion. Workers were nice, vibe of the store felt calm and welcoming. Would come again.

messed up me and my brothers stomach. pizza tasted old. do not recommend unless you want to spend your day with a stomach ache on the toliet. read more

Upstate New Yorker here. Denver is one of the most beautiful and bountiful places in the United States. Foodies from all over to get their fill of nearly any cultural or ethnic style, what's hot, what's not, whether it's hot or cold; whatever they are craving, authentic NY style pizza is incredibly hard to find. Peppino's, though nestled in the side entrance of the Aurora Town Center Mall, is a hidden gem for anyone looking for your classic NY City style pizza. I ordered a half cheese half pepperoni pie. The cheese was perfectly silky and melted. The pepperoni was slightly spicy and just right. It was hot, delicious, and I wouldn't change a thing. I used ApplePay to make my purchase, and 10 minutes later, I had a huge pizza sitting in front of me of me. Peppino's, it just hit the spot tonight, THANK YOU! read more

See all

This is my all time favorite pizza place and I've eaten pizza all over including New York, Boston, Philadelphia and somewhere in Connecticut. The dough has a nice crisp, the texture of the cheese is perfect and the sauce flavor is the finishing touch. I've gone here since I was little and now my kids do also and it's their favorite pizza place. This place is the only reason I go to the mall anymore. read more

Good food, good price points, gets five stars for how hospitable the staff is. This place has been around for over 30 years in the same place since I was a kid and is still standing/busy. I got spaghetti today and to add meatballs was extra cost. Got just one big meatball haha. So if you're expecting a meatier meal, maybe request extra or maybe they will read this and change that. Either way, 5 stars! read more

Peppino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

Been going here for about a decade and the Pizza is still delicious.. Staff is polite..

They are back in business . Best pizza in Aurora for me . Lucky to be 5 mins from here read more

See all

Excellent pizza and calzones. We've been going here for decades and always the highest quality of ingredients and preparation. The marinara sauce is amazing. read more

Decent mall-quality pizza. A step up from Sbarro. Garlic knots were okay. No refills on fountain drinks is a a bit ridiculous, especially as I was the only person in the place. read more

TLDR: If angry, anti-maskers are your style, than this is the pizza place for you! I was disappointed when I walked in to see only one employee, out of four or five, wearing a mask. Upon seeing this, I requested a refund ( I paid for my pizza over the phone) and explained that I was not comfortable eating food from this environment. After being told by the cashier several times "Okay, but there's nothing I can give you", I was charged at by the cook. The cashier had to literally grab his shirt and beg him to stop as he aggressively approached me while shouting obscenities. Two days later, accompanied by mall security, I went back in to ask for my refund. Once again, the cook (Barry is his name- I assume he's the owner to behave like this) began shouting loudly and accusing me of trespassing. I'm paraphrasing, but he said I must be mentally unstable and I should be locked up in the loony bin. He went on to add that he's "sick of these liberals". The officer had to ask him to be nice; he did not oblige. Needless to say, I have not gotten my money back for the pizza I never took. read more

How the heck does this place have 3.5 stars?? It's freaking AMAZING pizza! I've never left unsatisfied from Peppino's Pizzeria, and when this whole crap happened with coronavirus, I prayed these guys were still open!! Yes, that should detect how delicious they are. They have that...thin, New York style pizza going on with their HUGE pizza by the slice ordering. And the flavors? All I gotta say is "mmmm." Those bread knots are pretty darn good, too. Unfortunately, I haven't had the pleasure of ordering their other menu items, but when it comes to that NY style pizza fix and are sick of that commercial pizza like Dominos (eew), Peppino's Pizza is totally worth it! read more

service is zero out of ten . 0/10 . They have no nutrition facts . no idea about anything to accommodate for diabetics. and they are also rude when ask questions concerning health made questions. Never been to an establishment that doesn't have a nutrition sheet on their food first in forever . read more

Tbh I like this a lot really good pizza haven't tried the rest of the stuff but id definitely give it a try if your thinking about pizza

I used to love Peppino's Pizza, but just ordered one today and their selected delivery partner, SLICE, never delivered my $50 order. When I called and asked Peppino's what was up after waiting an hour and a half, the female who answered rudely told me she'd sent the order ages ago, and it wasn't their responsibility because it was the fault of the third-party delivery partner. SERIOUSLY?? Who chose the delivery partner, if not Peppino's?? Do yourself a favor and don't order a pizza from here unless you're wanting to spend a fortune for nothing -- rudeness, high cost, and no food!!! read more

Quality of pizza is ridiculous..rudeness will not come to this again .would be nice if they would put more item to make it worth the price

I've walked past this place ever since my high school years and would love to drop in here and there. However, although the pizza is great, the staff is beyond rude. I had my Grandson with me and looked forwarded to ordering our pie. What's sad, is it started right off the bat and into the rest of the service. When I requested to speak to the owner, I was very surprised to find out that one of the staff being the rudest, was in fact part owner. I love the Pie but will unfortunately will NOT be returning. After reading other comments, seems to be a common thread. Again, very unfortunate given the challenges over the past few years for small businesses. We'll just have to find another small/local business to support. Pray things get turned around. read more

Always great pizza and calzones here. Love the crust, sauce, everything. Wish I lived closer.

I was shocked today I craved for it but it was said temporarily closed. I wonder why. I tried calling but no one answered read more

I had Peppino's pizza for the first time today and the pizza was excellent. The crust is an authentic New York style crust, the sauce is fresh and slightly sweet, and the cheese is incredible (not the plastic stuff)!! The toppings were also very fresh, all served to you in one of the cleanest pizzerias I have seen!! Barry and Michelle the Owners were super nice and the prices were very reasonable. I will be back and absolutely recommend this to friends. The the house special pizza!! read more

This could be a good place if the staff was more pleasant, The cashier which I imagine is the owner was rude in trying to force a 15% tip on people, for handing you a pizza? That's their job. My grandson had grease on his hands and wanted to wash up, he was denied the bathroom, said there is no bathroom anymore. She was really rude and in a bad mood. I certainly will not be going there ever again. The pizza is good, the employees SUCK If you can't be cordial, change your job. read more

Very hit or miss on delivery, some times hot sometimes warm BUT today was the worst. Pizza was left at door with no notification it was delivered ( I was in living room by door waiting for it so someone was even a bit sneaky with it ) I'm 5 to 10 min. from pizzeria depending on traffic so after 35 min. of no updates or pizza after it showed on its way I started contact with company ordered through to find out what problem was. Pizza was past stated delivery time at this point, took 10 min. of conversation for me to be told to see if it was left outside......SERIOUSLY WHO DOES THAT WITH FOOD DELIVERY??? Drop it off, don't ring doorbell, don't knock on the door. I asked for refund or replacement pizza as pizza was cold and who knows how long is been setting outside at this point and I was concerned with if this was even safe to eat. I was told I'd get 25% off and tip and delivery fee refunded. THATS FAIR?? I've been eating here since before it was even Peppino's but no more and will be contacting my credit card company to do charge back and don't care if I have to pay more than this charge to do so, sometimes its just the principle of the thing. They could of given me an edible pizza and I'd of gladly given the nasty one back or they could do the right thing and refund money read more

Food is great. Employees are great for the most part too. My only complaint is that I worked for them for a short time last year and never got paid for it and have tried contacting them several times in several different ways but haven't heard back from them and still never got paid. :-/ it really is a nice little family owned restaurant though. They will custom make anything you order. Everything is homemade and soooo delicious. Huge portions. Fun atmosphere. read more

Fresh thin crust pizza for $3. Nice little Italian place tucked in by one of the entrances to the Aurora Town Centre mall. They have enough seating, good to grab a bite while shopping or before a movie at Century Aurora theatre. Everyone is nice to you. Good place. Must try if you are in the mall. read more

See all

The best way to experience this place is to order a whole pie. I've had a few slices and thought it was decent but when I first ordered a whole pie... it became my favorite local place to order from! The crust, the cheese, the sauce... they are all delicious! You can tell it's a made with high quality ingredients. The only downside is having to doge the survey company in the mall on the way in to pickup a pizza! read more

They have the best gluten free pizza! And it's not a puny little 10 inch one either! I discovered this place by accident and have been back twice! It's great! read more

So good I'll slap yo momma! I can't slap mine cuz she'll slap me back! But seriously, what more can u ask for, good food, and a trifecta of cute ladies in the back running the place. Prices are good considering this outrageous inflation. And I did notice the ladies being a little serious at first but they were super nice to me. After sitting in the dining room and witnessing how utterly rude and entitled people are especially with them being women I now understand why there a bit stand offish. Manners are free from what I last remember. It's not always the employees who are bad there is such thing as bad customers!!! Keep it up Peppinos. oh yeah can you guys get different mushrooms please cuz I'm not feeling the ones u have. ;) read more

Haven't had quality NY/NJ-style pizza in eight going on nine years. I could smell pizza from around the corner. I walked by and saw the house slices and knew it was going to be great. Grabbed three pepperoni slices, 4 garlic knots and a half pound of wings. Threw some garlic salt, parmesan cheese and red pepper flakes on the pizza and went to town. I loved the pizza. I grew up in North Jersey right outside of NYC. Eating here felt like eating at home! read more

Best calzone in the Denver metro area and really it's not even close. Real ricotta and fluffy dough. Absolute perfection

I love this place. I'm not a pizza expert but I think it's way better than most slices I've had IN CO. Plus its family owned. Get garlic knots too read more

Looking for good pizza after a long bike ride and found this gem. The pizza was more than expected. You can tell they use quality ingredients and the crust that I normally don't finish, was devoured! This pizza is worth the tourist price!! read more

If you willing to walk a little farther in the Aurora mall than the food court, it is worth it. read more

Peppino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

How does a pizza that looks so damn good , taste so damn bad.... Shucks looks like I'm never going back read more

Ask any longtime Aurora local what the best food in the Aurora Mall is (you'll know they're a trustworthy source if they call it "Aurora Mall" in the first place). Will they recommend a place in the food court? Sbarro perhaps? LOL you're funny. Nope, actually nearly every time you will be referred to the lower floor off to one of the side entrances to Peppino's Pizza. Can't go wrong with a slice, but the calzones are truly where it's at. On behalf of the community of Aurora, don't bother with that silly food court upstairs. Trust us. read more

We went in and ordered a 12 inch pizza. It comes out of the oven. We pick up a slice to eat it and the toppings just slid right off. We tried another piece and it happened again. It was just dripping with grease. So we ask the cashier and she told us it was our fault for eating it right away. Refused refund. Refused to make us another. Offered us 2 fresh slices. 25 dollars for inedible pizza. Told us it was our fault. Got charged for extra cheese that wasn't put on. And she proceeded to tell us how much her cheese was. She said it was 4 dollars a pound. Charged us 5 dollars for extra cheese. Did they put a pound worth of cheese on there? Hell no. It was mostly sauce and salt. The cheese and pepperoni were bare and it just slid right off. read more

Fantastic Deep Dish Pizza!!! My daughter and I went to our favorite pizza place today. It is an hour drive from where we live, but TOTALLY worth the drive. We call when we are about thirty minutes away so it is ready. Even if you don't call ahead, try this pizza restaurant. They also have amazing sandwiches. The staff is friendly and make us feel like their most important customers of the day. You will not be disappointed. read more

Best pizza in the mall, and a step above Pizza Hut outside. The pizza is served by people do put love and care into the food. I wish the cooks put a little less seasoning into the food. It seems a little salty to my taste, except the pepperoni pizza which is very good. A slice of pepperoni, a drink...you got a quick lunch on the go. Not bad...room for improvement. read more