Ordered delivery from Brooklyn's Finest Pizzas after a long workday and got the Little Italy pizza with the Italian chopped salad. Everything showed up still warm, and the order was packed carefully so nothing was messy when we opened it. The pizza had a really good crust and enough toppings without feeling overloaded. I also liked that the salad tasted fresh instead of something thrown together last minute. Delivery timing was close to what they quoted online, which I appreciated since a lot of places run late on weekends. Solid experience overall and definitely better than the usual chain pizza spots nearby. read more

While in Northwest today, my assistant suggested stopping by Brooklyn's Finest Pizza for an authentic New York style slice, and it proved to be a thoroughly delightful choice. Situated right on the corner, the location offers convenient street-side access and a cozy, well-maintained waiting area. While the interior is somewhat compact, it remains impeccably clean and remarkably convenient for a swift, comfortable bite. The entire aesthetic pays a charming homage to classic Manhattan charm, and I was pleased to note their seamless options for both takeout and delivery. The service was remarkably patient, courteous, and efficient. To begin, I ordered a classic Margarita cocktail, though I was equally impressed by their well-curated selection of fine craft beers. For my meal, I selected the Supreme pizza, customized with black olives, green peppers, red onions, and an extra portion of savory meats the customizability here is truly wonderful. When the pizza arrived with impressive speed, it was an absolute triumph crispy, hot, and rich with bold, nostalgic NYC flavor. Between the spotless environment, remarkably fast service, and authentic culinary execution, Brooklyn's Finest Pizza earns a very solid four stars. A wonderful, high-value spot I shall certainly be returning read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - My order supreme pizza & margarita - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Food - really good Service - got delivery Ambience - got delivery Delivery for 2 pies. Mulberry Street Bell peppers, red onions, mushrooms, black olives, tomatoes, roasted garlic, and mozzarella cheese. Awesome flavor, crust was soggy, may have been rushed out-o-de-oven. 4 Cheese Garlic Lover (Olive Oil Sauce) Olive oil, fresh garlic, roasted garlic, mozzarella cheese, fresh mozzarella, provolone, and pecorino romano Good za with a mild sauce and excellent garlic flavor. read more

I tried the pin wheels finally.... Even more impressed with this place. Absolutely delicious. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Chicken Parm Pinwheels - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

I was craving an Italian sandwich. Called to place an order to pick up and was given the impression that I must go online to place my order, which was annoying. I did it. When I showed up 20 minutes later, the order wasn't ready yet, or even started. That is okay, I was 10 minutes early, but why sit on the order until the last second before making it? The point is, ordering was kinda annoying on a couple of levels. Anyway, it was a beautiful day, so I took a short walk, and my sandwich was ready when I returned. The sandwich was great. It came with chips and a pickle. I definitely enjoyed it and would have it again. Lots of parking in the free parking lot. read more

See all

You can't go wrong with Brooklyn's finest pizza only once was there's something on my pizza that I did not like, which was pineapple, and to be honest, I did give it a try just because, but it's still not my cup of tea to have pineapple on my pizza I called spoke with the owners they got my information down, and they told me that yes, something like that could possibly happen on accident because of how close they are name wise on the computer pepperoni/pineapple so they gave me credit for another pizza because I've ordered from them for at least two years now and it's always been fresh and delicious you call to place your order and whoever is on the other line answering at Brooklyn's finest. Pizza is always friendly and they do care about their customers. I have yet to be in to the restaurant itself but I'm sure once I get there it'll be just as fabulous as the rest of my review, so if you haven't tried them yet give them a try ! Thanks For The Read Until Next Time ..... read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Delivery - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

Maybe the most disappointing pizza I've ever ordered. From the top, looks very promising. You flip her over to discover charcoal triangles crumbling to ash in your hand. I think someone fell asleep at the stove... but no quality check?? Cmon guys. I could barely bite through the "dough". This is an offense to Brooklyn. read more

See all

Loveeeee this option for delivery. Great NY style pizza, which is hard to find in Denver. Definitely recommend!

I love this chain !! On my big back mode... I decided to get their eggplant parm... And somxe it was my bday they gave me tiramisu.. let me just say this.. my man tried my eggplant parm and wanted it for himself and that wasn't happening. The parm was good... definitely on my favorite list... Can't wait to go back. read more

Service when we walked in we were greeted very welcoming, for the ambiance the shop looked clean, it is on the smaller side and right across from Regis Univeristy so I'm sure lunch might be packed. They gave us some suggestions for first time eat we ended up ordering the largest pie they had which was the 18" I believe, this thing is massive. We did a half and half our pizza was half cheese and the other half was pepperoni, mushroom and cream cheese. Only thing I didn't like was the cream cheese we got was sweet on he pizza I was hopeing for regular, but other then that this pizza has my new Yorker husbands stamp of approval pizza was delicious we will be back to order again also they do have other locations this one is just in the way home. Keep up the great food and work. read more

See all

Asked if they could half bake it to finish at home. A nasty women screamed from in back having overheard my question and screamed she won't do that. The pizza is good given the choices in the area. But the rudeness was unnecessary read more

This is the best pizza in the northside. Stop order cheap pizza and treat yourself to authentic New York style pizza. I have had a chance to chat with the owner a couple times and makes me feel right at home. In the years that I have been coming and only had my order messed up once and they made me a new pizza immediately. I usually get the Bronx bomber or grand central and a salad. Pizza pinwheels are a great hit to take to a picnic or a potluck. Being across the street from Regis university I believe they offer specials for students and faculty. read more

See all

Strip mall and small dining area. Beer, wine and frozen drinks and coke machine. Pizza by the slice was excellent! Friendly staff. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

We got a couple slices and some cheesy bread. They did not disappoint. I had a couple pepperoni slices and they were big, thin, and had a nice chew to them. New York style all the way. Wifey got the cheesy bread and it was loaded with cheese. read more

See all

Another great pizza. Friendly staff. Hot and ready on time- what else can you possibly want from takeaway?? The best part is we tried a slice of cheese (one of my absolute favorite pizzas that we never get because my husband and son always want sausage) and my 4 year old LOVES it. In fact he says it's better that sausage!! Hehehe we'll be back for cheese!! read more

See all

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza serves a solid New-York style pie with a thin, foldable crust and fresh toppings that hit the mark. Reviews highlight the hot, flavorful slices and friendly service. read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

We were warmly greeted when we walked in, and the place looked clean and cozy. It's a small shop right across from Regis University, so it probably gets busy at lunch. The staff gave us great suggestions, and we ordered an 18" pizza -- half cheese, half pepperoni, mushroom, and cream cheese. The only downside was the sweet cream cheese; I expected regular. Still, the pizza was delicious and even got my New Yorker husband's stamp of approval. We'll definitely be back! read more

I wasn't even going to eat lunch today but I see a sign claiming Brooklyns Finest and immediately checked the reviews.. Seemed pretty good so I had to try because NY pizza in CO sucks usually and I'd love to find a good one. I got a regulah and a pepperoni for this test and cleaned them both. This is the new default if I'm craving NY pizza, it's hands down the best I've had since moving. read more

Found this place on yelp and it was really good! It is in a strip mall with a liquor store next door and this place is extremely busy! We went on a Monday night and it was packed. Luckily I ordered ahead and when I arrived, my order was ready. I ordered the God Father pizza, caprese salad, and the spicy sausage calzone. Everything was so good! the calzone was spicy and really tasty. The caprese salad was fresh and really good! Will definitely be back! read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Mozzarella Caprese Salad - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

See all

4 Cheese Garlic Lover Ordered the 4 Cheese Garlic Lover for takeout and it lived up to the name. The garlic hit was strong without being overpowering. The mozzarella cheese was reallllly good! The crust held up great for takeout too. read more

While not necessarily a comfortable dine in option as there are metal tables and chairs outside and some high top chairs inside this was such a great choice for pizza and a salad. The "large" salad is huge so be prepared to share, we definitely made that mistake. The Greek salad and the Cesar salad were delicious. All veggies and lettuce were cold and crunchy. The Godfather pizza was banging! Perfect crust and amount of toppings! Service was sweet and quick! read more

See all

Got a meatball and feta pizza. Ingredients were fresh and plenty of it which made the pizza fantastic. Also friendly service at the register. read more

Regular customer for the last 6 years and never a bad pie. One was delivered by a third party service without a warmer and was not hot, but their delivery is in house now, so problem solved. Yesterday I ordered a 12" and received a 10" by mistake, asked for an adjustment to the lower price and they refunded the ENTIRE PRICE of the larger pizza! This is how customer loyalty is achieved, above and beyond, totally unexpected! read more

Very good quality ingredients very friendly employees fast would definitely come again

Sorry but truly nothing special about this place, don't know why it's at the top of so many "best pizza in Denver" lists. It tasted good and fresh but it was too thin for my taste and the cheesy bread was too greasy. Nice and responsive staff but I just did pick up so can't speak much to that. However at this location there's not many places to sit, it seems to cater more to carry out. All in all, overhyped serviceable pizza, from a strip mall lookin location, not the #1 pizza in Denver read more

I'm sorry to write a poor review. I remember I ordered from these guys many years ago, and didn't think the pizza was very good. So just never ordered again. After so many years- and so many rave reviews, I thought I would give it another try. I ordered the eggplant parm pizza. The last time I had true NY pizza I was in the Times Square subway where there's a pizza to go place some friends recommended. I had the eggplant pizza, and it blew my mind it was so good. So, I'm aware my expectations were not necessarily fair. But I'm honestly confused as to how it was so bland. The sauce didn't have any real flavor. The cheese seemed strangely gluey, and the crust was tough. Add to that - the eggplant was so fried it was like overcooked hard little flavorless squares. I do not understand how this place comes up as the best pizza place in my neighborhood. read more

Hands down the best NY style pizza in Denver and it's not even close. Crust is perfect, great sauce and quality toppings.

Finally found my favorite Denver pizza joint. It's been a while since I've had a good New York pizza, and there's no better way to know than to try a slice of cheese. The crust was thin, chewy and crispy, the sauce was the perfect balance of sweet and savory, and there was a perfect amount of cheese. The Stromboli was pretty tasty as well. While this shop is a far drive from home, it is on the way home from the office. Kind of. Whatever, it doesn't matter because I would gladly go out of my way the next time I'm in the mood for pizza! read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Slice of cheese and Classic Meat Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

We came almost at closing. They got a lot of good deals and discounts for the university students. They also have a different signature flavor pizza for the different day of the week which is nice. You order at the register. There's limited seating and you'll find it next to a gas station/convenience store. You can view the different decorations they have on the wall while you wait. I liked the grand central which is double pepperoni. I'd describe it as thin and crunchy. I was gonna get a couple more slices but they ended up running out of pepperoni lol so we decided to call it a night. Good place to visit if I lived here. Visited in feb/March read more

Brooklyn's Finest Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Denver, Colorado

Good food, take out friendly Great Pizza. Never disappointed. The time for pickup is always accurate read more

Always amazing pizza my opinion the best in town very friendly staff might go to when I want real pizza not conveyor belt pizza

Not a single disappointment so far except we've never gotten it hot (temp-wise) even when picking up. Love the location, the cozy interior, the vast menu, the friendly staff, and of course the PIIIIIZZZZZA. Certainly no Joes or Prince St but it's a damn good thin crust pizza with plentiful toppings every time. Never takes more than 15-20 mins for pick-up. Caesar salad is always on point too. Definitely recommend for your next pizza night! read more

See all

Always a delicious Slice! And the Stromboli is incredible as well. They have a downtown location as well on the 16th st mall that is equally delicious. One of my favorite Pizza joints in Co. read more

Unfortunately, the gluten free crust was incredibly difficult to eat, literally. It was the hardest gluten free crust I've ever had - it actually hurt my jaw a little to try to eat it. I'm not sure what went wrong with my order, but this was kind of crazy. read more

Man, this place surprised me in a good way. I went in craving a solid slice and left genuinely impressed with the dough, the garlic knots, and that perfect crispy fold. If you want real NY-style pizza in Denver, this is your spot. read more

We were absolutely starving on the way home from a hike and seeing that Brooklyn's Finest was on the route home was like a beacon of hope. I placed an order online for a 12 in pizza with pepperoni on half. When we got to the restaurant, we needed to wait a bit longer for the pizza, and it was happy hour, so we did the logical thing and had some beers ($1 off during HH). The pizza was OK but pretty disappointing overall. We both thought the crust was pretty dry and the pizza itself did not have much flavor, almost just tasted like plain crust without anything on top. The pepperonis were fairly mild flavored and greasy. I doused my slices in parmesan and pepper flakes, as did my partner. For the size and quality, I would not pay $16 again for a 12 in pizza from here and left feeling a bit ripped off. I would maybe give regular slices a shot to see if full-size proportions do the trick, but the smaller pizza just did not hit the spot. The staff is super friendly, I am just not the biggest fan of the pizza here! Brooklyn's Finest did save me from a bout of intense hanger, so I do thank the restaurant for that :) read more

Amazing food, incredible service. I cannot recommend this place highly enough. The staff was amazing, friendly and welcoming, the pizza was delicious with high quality ingredients. My wife and I instantly decided this would be a place for date nights. 5 start well earned. read more

This place is gross. Go eat somewhere else. They serve chicken that comes pre-cooked from their vendor and serve it like that. I ordered a Greek salad with chicken, but it was raw. They refused to cook it, insisting it was already cooked, and they couldn't take it back because I had left the premises and returned. How would I know the chicken was raw unless I got home and opened it? I brought it back; they didn't offer to fix it. A fat, gross woman with dirty clothes came out to argue with me instead. So unprofessional. She claimed that she knows 100% it is cooked because it comes pre-cooked from the vendor. Can't get any worse. All I needed to do was cook it a bit longer, as it was still pink when I first opened it. This place is absolutely disgusting. They take advantage of the fact that college kids don't know any better. read more

So many pizza options! We were having a company lunch and got catering from this location. The menu selections were so overwhelming we had to choose them all! I had The Godfather which is a meat lovers pizza. It was so good I had to go in for a second slice! The rest of my coworkers said that the other pizzas were delicious and fulfilling. read more

See all

Worst pizza I have had in quite some time Order slice of cheese and they total over did it. Product like this should of never left the kitchen. Pizza is like sex even if it bad it's still pretty good. NOT this time. How do you mess up a slice of cheese pizza. I do wonder if the pie was fresh would it of been better? read more