This place is well marked has easy parking not usually a long line and a lot of great options…read more It closes at eight sharp, so get here early. They serve soft, serve and hard ice cream and cones cups. They have shakes sprinkles and everything in between. It's your classic Mom and pop custard shop. Seating is only outside. Very casual. Flip-flops encouraged. Open 12pm-8 daily! I highly recommend you check it out

Dairy up here tastes so much sweeter and fresher!…read more The ice cream and custard was delicious! They also make the waffle cones fresh to order, which is amazingly delicious! The cow decor is entertaining and goes perfectly with the giant cow on the roof. You can spot this ice cream parlor from a mile away on the quiet one lane road into town.

Beautiful spring day and Reese's was nearby! I had their delicious Coffee Espresso ice cream which…read morewas very full of coffee flavor and very creamy. I had to have it in a chocolate - nut waffle cone.....what a perfect match, and the chocolate dip tasted like dark chocolate, so perfect. Service was good and everyone was very friendly.

Stopped for our first I've cream of the season!! It is dang cold out today, but when offered to go…read moreget ice cream I gladly went. I tried their new flavor PBJ Cheesecake ice cream. I had it in a cookie sandwich made with Casi's XL Peanut Butter cookies! Wow!! It was fantastic! My boyfriend got a strawberry sundae on soft chocolate ice cream. He loved it. Always a favorite place to come for fun I've cream flavors!! And the quality of the homemade ice cream is fabulous! So rich and creamy and good. Looking forward to trying some new taste combinations this summer!!

Such a pleasant surprise on our vacation. The medium soft serve ice cream was humongous! They take…read morecard, and have plenty of seating around the corner. Very nice and clean.

Best soft serve! Great service, even better soft serve! Try one of the fun flavors, or stick to a…read moreclassic--you won't be sorry! Go get you some!

Fantastic custard and duck eggs - plus a full working duck farm…read more Don't miss the Cookies & Cream and Strawberry Rhubarb flavors. Oh - and the super fresh house-made waffle cone is worth $1.25. Every time we visit this area, we visit Spotted Duck. Note - they close daily from 5 - 6 PM for a dinner break.

Spotted Duck Creamery came highly recommended, yet it still managed to surprise us in the best…read morepossible way. Imagine asking, "What would an ice cream stand be like if it were crossed with a fine FLX winery in a beautiful farm setting?"--that's exactly the vibe here. Elevated, serene, and absolutely delicious. The facility and grounds are immaculate, with a peaceful, pastoral atmosphere that makes you want to linger. The staff was warm and welcoming, and they generously offered samples so we could explore the flavors before committing (dangerous, because they're all incredible). We ultimately chose three flavors: * Cookie Monster (Real Cookies & Cream) -- Their take on cookies & cream is next‑level. It's built on their handcrafted vanilla cream base and loaded with hearty chunks of their own legendary chocolate chip cookies. Think of an ice cream sandwich turned inside out--rich, decadent, and deeply satisfying. * Fleur Bleu -- A gorgeous blend of local organic blueberries, subtle French lavender, and their classic vanilla cream. It's delicate, floral, and beautifully balanced. This one kept us slowing down each bite just to savor the nuance. * Ditch Mint Chip -- Made with hand‑picked fresh mint and dark chocolate chips. Bright, refreshing, and leagues above the artificial mint flavor you get elsewhere. It was excellent, though admittedly overshadowed by the other two standouts. The frozen custard itself is among the best we've ever tasted--rich, creamy, and unbelievably smooth thanks to their signature use of local duck eggs. Even the vanilla base was a sleeper hit, with a depth of flavor you don't expect until it hits you. The setting is perfect for a Finger Lakes outing. Whether you're spending the day visiting wineries, hiking the gorges and waterfalls, or just exploring the region, you need to make this a stop on your route. It's one of those places that elevates your whole day. A truly special spot. We'll be back.

Delicious as always. Travel to their Interlaken location on the west side of Cayuga Lake. Admire…read morethe lazy bumblebees that mosy around prior to entering the building. The interior is the same as always, while the available flavors are unpredictable, but a taste makes everything right in the world. Their flavor menu has been updated to indicate which flavors contain gluten and which ones don't. They also now have a protocol for those with strict gluten allergies. This time it was spring, so they didn't have my favorite Jalepeno Popper this time around. But they did have Lavender. For the second and third scoops we got Pistachio, followed by Butter Pecan. As a reminder, they use 14 percent buttermilk, and their ice cream emphasizes FLAVOR over sugar. Despite the high fat content, their ice cream doesn't feel heavy while you're eating it. Take that as a warning, since you might feel it after you consume too much. The Lavender was fantastically floral. The Pistachio was like eating Pistachios. Each flavor is exactly as described. Previously, I had also gotten my coworkers ice cream from here several years prior. Hand-packed into pints, you'll need a serious amount of self-control to avoid finishing them in a single sitting. They've also opened up a location in DeWitt Mall on the Seneca Street side of the commons.

Cayuga Lake Creamery was a great ice cream stop. They have a large selection of homemade ice cream…read moreand they have hard, soft, custard and sundaes to choose from. They also have some savory food options if you're interested in that. The ice cream was great, my wife enjoyed the cake batter and her waffle cone and I got the Reese's pieces sundae which was incredible! I got the small and it was way more than enough. Only go large if you haven't had food in 24 hours. The place was busy but we really had no wait at all. The team was working fast back there. Prices are average for ice cream nowadays and I thought portions were appropriate. They have an inside and outside eating area attached to the creamery and there is more outside down the hill where there is extra parking as well. It's nothing special inside but for an overly hot day nice to have. The outside down the hill provides shade so that is nice as well. Either way a great stop for ice cream if you are in the area. Enjoy!

Had dinner in the area and this place was recommended by one of the servers. Tried their hard ice…read morecream with a waffle cone. So creamy and delicious! They had a bunch of unique flavors, I had the caramel, mocha chip and got it to go.

I got ice cream and thought the coconut cake looks delicate and soft so i added a slice to my…read moreorder. It was as hard as a rock. I don't know if it's supposed to be like that or it ls not a popular item and sitting there made it hard. Well I'm upset because i ate most of it and if im taking the calories, i rather it be something that's worth it. The rest goes to trash. Im disappointed. Just keep operating as an ice cream shop if u can't keep up the baked goods fresh or eliminate the ones that don't sell.

Ricky was so nice and the fried clam sandwich was so good I could die for it! I love the whipped…read morecream and nuts on the ice cream there topping choices are amazing. I recommend to all who come to get the fried clam sandwich with ketchup on it. Thank u have a good day!

Decent ice cream choices. Good service. Quaint, roadside,…read morediner-style, restaurant that's been around forever.

Good ice cream but terrible service. The two girls working at 6:30 on Sunday, Sep 21st were slow…read moreand rude. First, the girl scooping my ice cream said "we are running low on nuthouse" and the other goes "don't use it all", uuuuh... pretty sure that's not how that works, give me the size I paid for. Then they messed up one of our orders. It was supposed to be in a cone, which is typically no big deal, we would have been fine without it. But when I pointed it out, she couldn't give a f**k, just gave the most deadpan "oh" possible. I didn't want to deal with this chick so we left, and if we had asked to fix it, we would have been there for 20 minutes because of the snail speed she was working at. But here is the kicker, I'm walking to my car, I take a quick glance in the window, and lil Miss Sassy McGee is giving me a big ole dirty look, lips snarled and all. Girl, your job is to serve people ice cream, chill out

A very nice place with good inside and outside seating. All of the staff is very nice, and there's…read morea good assortment of ice cream. It's a little more expensive than more ice cream places, but nothing too crazy

This is probably one of the better Ice Cream stands around Cayuga Lake. The frozen custard is…read moregreat, the portions are large, and all the picnic tables and trees surrounding parking lot provide plenty of places to sit comortably. It is a the middle of nowhere a bit, but worth driving a bit to get there.

Everything is Awesome! Go immediately! Fa ily friendly and…read morethe ice cream is great!!!

A nice respite and reward for our college halfway drive home stopping point. Very friendly…read moreproprietor who was very helpful in sharing the flavors. Almond espresso, chocolate extreme, banana foster.... all excellent. A cute town with a beautiful lake. We'll have to return to check out this picturesque region and some more gelato!

The shop itself was warm and welcoming and the store owner was our server! When we asked for…read morerecommendations he jokingly said: "I made them all! Their all my babies!" With that said, I just chose what I felt attracted to: the coffee gelato. It tasted like a sweet cup of coffee! I think I would have enjoyed it more if the texture was less icy! My friend got the salted caram flavor and the texture was great, but, the flavor was a little too sweet for me! I think any with a sweet tooth and a soft spot for caramel would go crazy for it!