We only have had the thin crust pizza, but it is some of the best we have ever had. Definitely will…read morebe going back!

Ordered a pizza and some cheesy bread for pick up and it was done on time. The ambiance and staff…read moreare fine. Very bummed though because I feel like this could be an excellent pizza place but the pizza was just about burned. It was very dark. The cheesy bread WAS burned... I threw away all the outside edge pieces and I had to peel the bottom off of the ones I ate. Next time I order I'm going to tell them to make it "light". If it's still burned, we won't be going back.

Good Brunch Choices. Loaded Bloody Mary was really good. The rest of the table went for the…read morebottomless mimosas and they loved the different flavors. Crab cakes with Mac & Cheese was okay.

We've been wanting to try this place for awhile & finally got the chance. We loved this place! The…read moredrinks were great and we happened to get there when they were half off. Had the wonton mozz sticks, delicious. Husband had the fish fry & I had the pesto alfredo gnocchi with grilled chicken. Great portion sizes and we were both happy with our meals. The service was great. We'll be back!

Great pizza! Fries are always good and salty and delicious. Service is great for the most part and…read moreclean, would recommend!

Great pizza, friendly service and quick delivery. I will order again. Prices were reasonable.read more

A top spot in Madison and my favorite Friday night bar stop with chef Dave concocting tasty…read morecocktails. The feta pizza is a can't miss

Been to NG several times and never really thought about stopping but tonight we did. And let me…read moretell you, wonderful! Being from the Chicagoland area, we think we have good pizza. Well Wisconsin strikes again. Sugar River had so many choices in pizzas. We opted for the Rigto-be-kidding me pizza, then and crispy. We weren't even half done with our salads and the pizza was ready. Plenty of cheese, meat and sauce. Very very good. Even the side salads. They had all kinds of veggies chopped up and very fresh. Might I suggest a combination of the ginger dressing with blue cheese. Hands down, great place. Clean, quick and pleasant. If you need to take a break from all the Swiss food this town has to offer, try a pizza. You'll be more than happy!

Went on a day trip from Madison because it sounded like a neat town. It was pretty boring actually…read moreand virtually dead on a Tuesday. Everything was closed. The one bright spot was Sugar River Pizza, which was open and fairly busy...our server Piper was absolutely wonderful,a real sweetheart with a wonderful attitude and despite waiting close to 45 minutes for the food to come out,made everything right by bringing a delicious Oreo cheesecake for my friends birthday and it was free...her coworker also was super nice but man,it shouldn't take so long for the food to come out!! But I will say the salad was HUGE!!...thanks Piper!

I recently visited this casual Italian restaurant that offers a spacious, open space perfect for…read morelarger groups or a small groups. The menu features a variety of classic Italian dishes, pizza and sandwiches. They offer specials every day of week. We ordered the 119 sticks, famous lasagna and portobello ravioli. Starting with the cheesy pizza sticks, they were very gooey and the crust was soft. It's basically cheesy garlic pizza without the sauce; however they do come with a side of marinara. The lasagna offered layers of noodles meat, creamy cheese and sauce. There were some larger chunks of meat (I prefer more mine to be more ground) and didn't have quite the flavoring I was looking for. It was comforting and filling, but could have used a bit more seasoning or herbs to really make it stand out. The portobello ravioli came with a red sauce and was all served over a bed of angel hair pasta. The extra pasta appeared to be common on the menu. The flavors of the mushrooms inside the ravioli really hit the spot. To make it pop more, adding some portobellos to the top of the dish would be a nice touch and the extra angel hair pasta was a little too much. The side salad was fresh but simple and refreshing with a mix of greens, tomatoes, cucumbers and dressing of your choice. This salad was included with the entree orders. Although staff were friendly, service was slower than expected, and all of our food came out at the same time with the cheesy sticks then the entree then our salad. If you're in a rush, this might be the spot but if you have time, check the place out. I was eyeing up the pizzas and would try one next time I visit.

Went for the first time recently and got the fish fry. Started with the French Onion Soup and it…read morewas HOT and DELICIOUS! We were given bread and butter for the table. I got the Trio: shrimp, perch and cod with the fries. Options for sides: baked potato, garlic potato, spaghetti, hasbrowns, fries or broccoli. Service was great. Plenty of seating on a Friday night for 2 after 7pm. Parked out front on the street. Looks like others didn't like their Italian. I'll just come back for the fish fry.

Unexpected light and space at 5th Quarter! It's in a strip mall type setting so we didn't expect…read morethe wonderful atmosphere. We sat ourselves and were greeted immediately. I ordered the hand battered chicken sandwich and my son ordered the Cowboy Burger. Everything was good and I was happy the chicken sandwich was not a frozen chunk. It was actually hand battered! Prices were $14 and under for each of our choices. This was a good stop on the way home to Iowa.

I'd say this place is serviceable... decent service and the foods alright. I had the perch, pretty…read morebland but serviceable. In terms of ambiance, it has a modern sports bar vibe... it's a sport bar.

Our absolute favorite wings, hands down! The atmosphere is fun, and the staff is friendly. Even…read morewhen we order takeout, the wings are still crisp and delicious when we get home. The Amazin' Cajun dry rub is literally finger lickin' good. This place is a staple in Verona, and very close to the pottery studio where I am a member, so it works out great to just run over and grab some food while I'm working.

Solid sports bar with decent food. Service was decent. Food came out quickly. Best thing on the…read moremenu that we sampled were the Buffalo Chicken Wantons. It's great that they serve a little later and that they seem to work to accommodate special requests.