Ordered a pizza and some cheesy bread for pick up and it was done on time. The ambiance and staff are fine. Very bummed though because I feel like this could be an excellent pizza place but the pizza was just about burned. It was very dark. The cheesy bread WAS burned... I threw away all the outside edge pieces and I had to peel the bottom off of the ones I ate. Next time I order I'm going to tell them to make it "light". If it's still burned, we won't be going back. read more

Thin crust pizza with ham was delicious. Ham pieces are huge! Food was ready within minutes of sitting down. Love that they have an arcade now! read more

Famous Yeti's Pizza - Create your own pizza. Half all meat and half ham. - Pizza Near Me - Stoughton, Wisconsin

See all

Pick up was quick and smooth. Great pizza at a great price. Loaded with toppings. Real cheese makes this pizza worth the trip. read more

Famous Yeti's Pizza - Lovely we got a half and half pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Stoughton, Wisconsin

Really good pizza plus the Greek Salad is great. Service, right on. Phoned in order and time they gave me for pickup was spot on

We got Famous Yeti's delivered to our wedding reception for the late night snack. We couldn't recommend them more! The pizza came on time, tasty, and HOT! We got so many compliments from our wedding guests, thanks to Famous Yeti's pizza! read more

Great pizza with great service. Their new location is nice and has a friendly atmosphere. Try the Yeti spaghetti or the Virgil grinder. You will not be disappointed! I also love their pepperoni pizza. read more

My husband and I have been going there for quite some time now and we love their pizza. Unfortunately, last few times we've gone.The pizza was horrible overcooked hard dry. So we've decided we won't be going back there the service is also horrible since they got rid of cat. read more

We wanted to like it. Read on Yelp that it was the best but to us New Yorkers? Sauce was too sweet. Hardly any shrooms and dry dry crust.

Ordered xtra cheese half pepperoni and sausage half ham and pineapple. Had hungry people at home no xtra cheese and no sausage just pepperoni. Called. "Sorry. The guy that usually makes the pizza isn't here." So. It looks like you can't order from Yetis on Saturday night. Looked like a tombstone. Last time read more

We love Famous Yeti's! We always make a point to stop for pizza on our yearly journey from Indiana to Minnesota. Toppings are fresh, pizza is hot and service is friendly. See ya next year! read more

Famous Yeti's Pizza - Pepperoni (no sauce) and Bumble's Best on regular hand-tossed crust. - Pizza Near Me - Stoughton, Wisconsin

we got the veggie pizza, Caesar salad & bread sticks. Such good quantity and so yummy! Don't be fooled by the location :)

A wonderful place to eat the pizza was the best the atmosphere was calm and relaxing and look forward to coming again .

We wanted delivery but the restaurant said their delivery driver was out. Still, they chose to deliver our pizza since we were close by! It also came super quick and was very tasty! read more

Famous Yeti's Pizza - Bigfoot sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Stoughton, Wisconsin

See all

In my top 3 pizza places of all time. Great service, too! Truly a must visit for anyone stopping by Stoughton!

Stopped in from out of town and grabbed a few slices based on Yelp reviews / rating. Staff was super nice, pricing was reasonable, 2 slices for $6. My only reason for giving the 5 stars was they took they slices out of the display and didn't pop them into the oven for a few minutes so our slices were warm but not hot. Would of preferred the cheese melty. Sauce was a little sweet but good read more

Best pizza in Stoughton! Always great service and always comes hot! Clean and nice for the most part, never really eat in there but from the most part its great! Would recommend! Tastes even better cold! read more

Two words: Spaghetti-stuffed Pizza Think, deep dish Chicago pizza, stuffed with meatballs and spaghetti, covered in a layer of bubbling, golden cheese. My favorite part of the menu is, you can create your own stuffed pizza and you just pay two prices, either 10" for $17.50 or 13" for $23.50, READ *as many ingredients as you want* for the same price as one of the specialty pizzas!! Don't forget to pickup some beer to go with your Zaaa next door too! read more

They're famous for their spaghetti-and-meatball stuffed pizza, but I actually prefer their grinders. The Fluffaletta is great - the bread is outstanding. To be honest, I actually prefer most of the things on their menu to the spaghetti-stuffed pizza. read more

The stuffed aunt margherite and stuffed yeti spaghetti pizzas were amazing! The service was friendly and the food came out fast.

Ordered delivery from their Cottage Grove location. Super customer service over the phone, quick and polite delivery. And AMAZING pizza. We ordered the cheese bread, which our whole family loved, and one extra cheese and one sausage pizza. Sauce has a perfect balance of spice, cheese was so good (not stringy, greasy, or waxy), and the hand thrown crust was incredible! Our family has voted this to be our new pizza place! read more

The odd location shouldn't deter you. The pizza is fantastic. I had the stuffed pizza (margarita) and it didn't disappoint. The device was great. When I mentioned that this was my first time there, the host gave me some cheesy bread to eat before our meal. I will definitely be coming back! read more

Yeti's is the best Pizza joint in town. Lots of places have fakey, spongy sausage. Not Yeti's. Their sausage is great & they use quality ingredients, and don't skimp. The sauce is fairly spicy, so I always get mine "light sauce". We prefer the Stuffed Pizzas. read more

Great people. Food is fresh and delicious. Tuesday slice special is awesome. Try the Grinders and salads they are great.

A local fan favorite for sure. I was reading a book on hiking spots in Wisconsin, and they even mentioned this as a go-to if you're in Stoughton. Giant pizzas, great quality and even though there's sometimes a bit of a wait, it's worth it. My family loves the Taco Pizza, but I'm a fan of the classic Hawaiian. read more

I've had the pizza multiple times. It was delicious. I love the homemade crust. It's amazing. I've also had their salads. They are made fresh and huge. I've had delivery and take out. My only complaint would be they are slow. It always takes an hour +++ to get our food if delivered. Keep that in mind if you are starving. I've gotten hangry a few times waiting on the delivery. It's great food and I recommend it. read more

There is nothing better than a hot slice of Yeti's! Best slice around. My kids swore by it in their high school lives.

Best. Pizza. Ever. Their stuffed pizza is amazing and the sausage they use is my absolute favorite. Bumbles Best is my favorite and I always have extra for the next day! read more

My buddy order pizzas and salads from here when we were watching the Superbowl and I was very impressed. He got us these stuffed pizzas they were huge HUGE! Really great basil and tomato I think it was the Aunt Margaret. We also had that Greek Salad so darn good. Honestly the salad was better than half the places in Madison. I will stop by here next time im in the town of Stoughton Keep up the great work guys!!! read more

Yummy, got thin crust with several toppings. Generously put together, excellent sauce and fine delivery. Eat yetis! read more

It's always hard to even see if they are open from the road because there wasn't an open sign or anything, so you'd have to get to the door to see the hours. They sell by the slice or full pie which is nice. They have unique options, but didn't have all toppings available when asked. My family enjoyed it, but with so many other options in town, it wasn't my favorite. read more

Mmmm, Famous Yeti's Pizza - what a great place! Only a few tables in their dine-in area, and it seems that folks rarely dine-in (at least whenever I've gone there for dinners), so I think it is a great place to go with a date or a friend to hang out and share some delicious pizza and quiet conversation. Nice staff and an outstanding menu with many unique pizzas. My newest favorite from their menu is the "Bumble's Best" stuffed pizza - so good and super filling; makes outstanding leftovers as well. I also like that their sauce is a bit spicy, which is a welcome change from what so many others offer. Easy to recommend - I've never been disappointed by the awesome food provided by the friendly folks at Famous Yeti's! read more

Okay, Yelp had this at 4 1/2 stars. I actually would go 3 1/2 but rounded down. I ordered a 10 inch supreme, thin crust, and crispy crust along with garlic bread. The garlic bread could have used a bit more garlic on it. Plenty of marinara served with it. It came out quick. It was toasted how I like it. It wasn't busy. The pizza came out pretty quick. Crust was crispy as requested. A little flop on each slice. It was tasty. I didn't notice any sausage on the pizza though. At least the sausage wasn't noticeable if it was there. Place is located in a bit of a strip mall type set up. Staff was cool and good with recommendations. I thought the music was a bit loud for how small it was. The soda fountain looked like it was out of at least three different flavors. Again, service was quick. I think I was expecting quite a bit more after reading the 4 1/2 star reviews and "Best Pizza in Stoughton" . Hey, it's better then Pizza Hut, Dominoes, Little Cesar's, and Papa Johns! read more

Best pizza in Stoughton in my opinion. Reasonable prices and pretty clean. Stuffed Zen Garden or Stuffed Spaghetti pizza are my favorites bath great thin crust pizza $5.50 special on Tuesdays for 2 slices and a drink. Great deal and great variety of pizza flavors. read more

Delicious pizza as well as awesome salads. The Marco Polo is a meal all by itself. Gluten free crust available.

Only and best stuffed pie in town. Long time favorite! I would strongly recommend this tucked away hole in the wall joint to anyone!

Average pizza... And warning- if you expect to feed children at or around dinner time, I would order elsewhere. Yeti's average delivery time is 2.25 hours to 4 days. Today was my third experience ordering pizza for dinner, and then have to make food for the kids - because the delivery driver never shows up before their bedtime. Ordered at 4:23pm, it is now 6:20 pm - and NO PIZZA. I called three times, which went unanswered and finally got ahold of someone on the fourth attempt. All they said is "we are busy. It's in the oven.".... So it takes 2 hours to place a pepperoni pizza jn the oven, and another hour to deliver. AWFUL, UNRELIABLE service. NOT worth the wait or the hassle. Pizza Pit is highly recommended instead, they actually understand the "pizza delivery" business. Thumbs down read more

Great atmosphere, but my sandwich was slightly over-crisped. Maybe some people like it that way. Takeout was brisk on Saturday night. Fabulous menu includes deep dish stuffed pizza. No single slices on weekends, and smallest pizza is ten inches. read more

See all

Mmmm. Love me some Yeti's pizza. What can I say? It's just great, consistently delicious, reliable food. I've had several pies now, and each has been yummy. Delivery is not always the fastest, but this place gets busy on the weekends! They are very popular! It is worth the wait. Don't wait until you're starving to order, plan ahead and give them the time the need. I promise, you won't be disappointed. I introduced some friends from out of town to Famous Yeti's this past weekend and every one of them was very satisfied with the pizzas we got. It's always a hit! read more

Two words: Yeti Spaghetti. The Yeti Spaghetti is one of the craziest pizzas I've ever had. Spaghetti, small and flavorful meatballs, and a spicy sauce get wrapped up in a crust galette style and then topped with a layer of melty, browned cheese. The spicy sauce is everything - it gives it the kick that keeps it from being too heavy. I've had this pizza a couple of times as a to-go order and am still shocked by its heft when I pick up the box. It takes about 30 minutes to prepare which is perfect for the drive from Madison. The large is truly a ton of food - a small is enough for two people with leftovers; the large will feed two people for days. The interior of the shop is cute if small - I've never dined in so I can't speak to service, but the counter workers are always kind and have me in and out in a few minutes. Someday I'll have to branch out and try another pizza, but it's hard to turn down this delicious spaghetti monster. read more

See all

Pizza is overall very good. The sauce is almost sweet with a hint of spice. It's really delicious. I have enjoyed the thin crust, stuffed crust and hearty thrown crust, all very good. The homemade sausage is delicious. If your looking for a new pizza joint to try out, this is your place. Highly recommend it. Also, they have lunch specials with slices that you get a lot of food for your buck. On Tuesdays, you get 2 slices (big slices) and a soda for $4 (includes tax already) from 11-2pm. Can't beat that deal. read more

Famous Yeti's Pizza - Small cheesebread and 13" stuffed Aunt Margherite pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stoughton, Wisconsin