Great wings and crab bread! Service was great! We left VERY happy that we tried here! We will definitely be returning!

We had a party of 10 and they accomodated us. It took over a half hour but they did it. Our server was awesome. She put up with our obnoxiousness and request to split the checks up. The food was ok. We ordered crab bread and fried pickles. The crab bread was decent. The fried pickles were really good. I ordered buffalo shrimp. The sauce wasn't spicy at all, it tasted ok though. I just like more spice. The shrimp was soggy though. The fries were good too, we got old bay and curly. Everything seemed hot when it was served. We stayed awhile and the server said there was no rush to leave. She was very attentive and pleasant.. just the kind of server we needed. We are a tough, loud crowd and not everyone can handle it. She did well. read more

Best Tails, blah blah, just go and try wings, tails and ears. Tails are lightly breaded boneless chicken breast, wings are, well, wings and ears are breaded, flattened cutlets. read more

I was pleasantly surprised by this restaurant. I ordered the broccoli bites as an appetizer because I haven't been to many places that served those before and they were delicious. For my main course, I had a chicken cheese steak and I could tell the meat was really fresh and high quality. There were many dessert options, however I was too full to try any (very uncommon for me). I appreciated that this restaurant featured unique menu items, served really fresh food and had generous portions. This place is famous for their wings, however as someone who doesn't like wings I still had a great dining experience. Also, I would like to note that I arrived at this restaurant at 7:30pm, and there was a bingo game going on. It was free to play and myself (and four other people) walked away with hats, sweatshirts and glasses for calling BINGO! read more

honestly disappointed after all the hype. waitresses were nice, but not attentive or accurate in ringing in orders at all. my stepmom's filet mignon looked like road kill, but our server took it off the bill thankfully. honestly just not worth it and they aren't accepting to people of all races so i can't support a business that operates like that. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

Running around Wharton, Lebanon, and the other wooded areas up here always makes me hungry. The Pic is THE place to dine up here. It is comfortable, fun, and full of good food. Known for their wings, you won't be disappointed. I prefer "party pack" wings, but that doesn't negate these wings are excellent! Hot is good! I haven't each much else here over the years. Frankly, the burgers don't impress me. There are other sandwichy type and comfort foods here. This is a family run business. The help has always been friendly, helpful, and fun whenever I come in. They are very accommodating. The fish tank sports two large frogs, which entertain my son. This is that hole-in-the-wall, out of the way, bar that everyone goes to in the area. It is indeed a must visit restaurant. read more

The Wings R Great!! The service sucks. Choose your battles I suppose. That's why we're only here once a year. The place requires a HUGE CLEAN UP to stay current. If ur looking for a cold drink enjoy..anything more, keep driving read more

Wings awesome, but get the sauce on the side, very buttery! Russian Turkey & Potato soup were fantastic! Mac & Cheese leaves a lot to be desired. Staff very friendly. I would visit again. All in all, one of the better food spots in the area. read more

Good wings. Nice bar. Good not great but worth the drive for sure. Thanks!

Stopped here after Jeeps In the Vineyard Day at Valenzano. Was seated within 5 minutes - had fantastic service and food was seriously amazing. Had wings (smoker sauce is HOT but delish) chicken cheese steak and Filet Mignon sandwich - probably the best sandwiches I've had in a longgg time. Definitely hit the spot. read more

Friendly hello from the moment I walked in. Service was exceptional. Angela at the bar was a real charmer. Had not the opportunity to interact with any other employees. Every one seems happy. I don't get the negativity on other ratings. Seems to me the kind of place that would of solved your crisis while you were there. Any way thank you, for a great lunch. Glad I stopped read more

This Oklahoma girl was thrilled to stumble upon Pic-A-Lilli. What a fun place!! Everyone is super nice, down-to-earth, and the place just has a laid-back vibe. All walks of life are welcome here....lots of diversity and great people watching. We came on an evening that Mike Chet Beck was playing guitar. He was excellent and so entertaining. Cold beer, great music, friendly people, welcoming environment, and the BEST fried pickles....what more can you ask for? read more

Stopped in for lunch. We had the black bean burger, buffalo ears, and Mac n cheese. All was very good, no complaints. The staff was very friendly and the place was packed! Also had a Cosmo that was one of the best I've had. Will be returning for sure. Also about the Biker element, we had no worries there was plenty of families with children and older couples who appeared to be enjoying themselves. read more

Came here with a group of bikers (not the pedal type) during a ride through the Pine Barrens. Everything about the Inn is perfect. There is plentiful parking. Great atmosphere. Happy and helpful wait staff. The food is great I had the PIC burger and was taken back bu this tower of a burger. Complete with 2 hand made burgers and 2 slices of pork roll. Delicious. Others in the group enjoyed their weals as well. The food was served quickly and we were back on the road within a hour. The perfect stop for bikers, and anyone looking for quality food and decent prices. read more

used to have the best wings- service was always a hit or miss, depending who you got. upcharge for blue cheese is insane. charge for each refill of soda-insane. the place is dumpy and the reviews are pretty sad. how to destroy a business 101.....................! read more

Went to lunch here with my sister. Both sandwiches we ordered were delicious except both sandwiches had a wee bit too burnt sliced bread. So, we scraped and enjoyed. :) Other than that, good service and nice crowd. read more

Love the Pic-a-lilli! Great food, great service, bartenders are a lot of fun! Fun for all!!

Best wings ever, but very expensive. I will be back. Little hint go early or after 8pm if you don't want to wait to be seated and if you do wait make sure you check in every once in awhile because they will pass over you fast. read more

Friendly staff. Quick service. I was there on a Tuesday, which is probably a slower night for them, but I never need to ask for a soda refill, and the food was excellent. read more

Great wings... service? Not so much. We liked the wings so much we have ordered takeout two times even though we live 45 minutes away - spending more than $150 between both orders. They made mistakes with BOTH orders. They apologized, but never offered anything for the inconvenience. Not even a credit for the food that we didn't receive. Tonight someone got about $25 worth of food on us. Hope they enjoy it. We won't ever be going back. read more

Stopped here on a bike route with a few friends while heading through south jersey. Happy hour is reasonably priced and the tails were amazing. This place is a gem of a find in south jersey. This will be a go to whenever I'm riding through south jersey. read more

Like others, heard great stuff about the wings here so me and my wife took a road trip to try for lunch. First , the bar is a little old school but nice people . Country music which I'm not a fan but Hey it's a Inn..lol. Food took a little long for how slow it was when we went . Wife got a cheesesteak and fries . She did not like it but I told her ,you need to go to philly for a good cheesesteak (where were from). Wings came out Hot I got the hot sauce not the medium. They were pretty on point with heat and wings were a little tough I must say . Very large which is a plus . Its the drum and wing together. Old bay fries were good . Wings I would say 6 out of 10. Nothing to make a special trip for . read more

There is nothing I can say that hasn't already been said. Love this place. The wings are awesome. A lot of great memories in this restaurant with family and friends. read more

2.50 up charge for fries that they didn't tell us about. Service not great. Food only ok.

I hadn't been here in years and wanted to take my teenage son (who loves all things spicy) to taste, what I remembered as, the best wings ever. I went online yesterday and was nervous after reading some recent reviews but I'm happy to say it was just as good as I remembered! My son and bf enjoyed the Smoker Wing sauce, which was very good but a little too hot for me - I tried it but stuck with spicy. The wings tasted good even without sauce, they are big and cooked perfectly. Our waitress was extremely attentive and very nice. We will definitely not wait so long to go back. read more

Best wings I've ever had anywhere! Cozy , warm atmosphere. I try to visit this place at least once a week.

Never worked soo hard for such little meat. I see why they serve the wings in dog bowls, because dogs eat bones. Never again.

Just had our traditional New Years Eve dinner at the Pic-a-lilli Inn. There were 4 of us and all of our meals were not good. The "surf and turf" was a 3 to 4 oz unrecognizable gristly piece of meat with 4 pieces of shrimp instead of Lobster tail. The meat was awful and so was the shrimp. One of us ordered a filet mignon sandwhich which was absolutely aweful... dry and no taste whatsoever. I seriously question if that WAS filet mignon. It looked and tasted like a burnt shoe sole. The best thing on that plate was the fries. One of our salads came with the wrong dressing and our wings were supposed to be hot wings, but they were a mixture of honey BBQ and hot.... and some of them were ice- cold. Beers were all supposed to be bottles... one came in a can. The margaritas were very good... lots of liquor.... they were not cheap with that. Our total bill was 150.00 before tip. We really have always enjoyed the atmosphere here, but unfortunately we will have to go somewhere else next year for our traditional New Years Eve dinner. Feeling sad. :( read more

I think their food was disgusting. The whole place is a dirty and the wings were dry like some kind of chicken jerky. The meat was actually grey, and makes me think they are using expired meat or something. They tasted horrible, no wonder they offer all you can eat. I could barely choke down more than two before I threw the rest away. You can eat all you want from a dumpster too and it would be a better deal and probably better tasting. read more

Me and my friends went there and because one of my friends who spoke really well of the restaurant i decided to try it out and man was I ever pleased. I ordered the Buffalo ears and the Buffalo calamari and both the sauce and the breading was nothing short of amazing and what really got me was the homemade chunky blue cheese which was outstanding as well. The service was great and had a desirable atmosphere too! I will most definitely be returning there very soon read more

This place is quaint and wild a pub restaurant with the best food you will ever have! Family owned and the family has been around for a very long time it's a historical land mark!! Eat and enjoy the prices are right! read more

Great food, great people/vibe, and great setup! If your in the area you MUST stop by and try out the wings! They also have another location in Atlantic City which is also AMAZING! read more

AWESOME !!! A Indian Mills Landmark...1st place I tried to buy alcohol back in the day in when they sold package goods... Great food , great tails & wings... BonnieLynn is great there and her Mom would be very proud!! read more

The Buffalo tails are the best. Wings are small. Not a bad spot to grab some food and drinks.

My husband and I have been going to the pic for over a year now and we have not once had anything other than GREAT food and a really good time. It's a real down to earth and relaxing atmosphere and the staff there are the nicest people I've had serve me in a restaurant in a long time. The bartenders know how to make a drink and if ya like to keep your glass full they can certainly accommodate that! We love it there and will be returning again and again.. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

Best wings, great service! Casual and friendly. All you can eat is a great value. Lots of fun.

I used to love this place, would have given it at least a 4 but lately the quality of the food is ehhhh. I know it has become a very popular spot so you would think they would try be consistent with the wings they tout as South Jersey's best but the last 2 times we have ordered them they have been small and greasy. The seafood is OK but everything tastes like was fried in the same grease as the wings. Atmosphere is "cozy" and if you are on the other side of the bar you have to run a gauntlet to get to the ladies room. read more

Well after about 20-30 visits there we finally had a not so good experience. New menu with added items may be causing them issues. Hostess managed the wait well. We sat down as it was finally clearing out. Waitress was not attentive and cordial at all! French onion soup was a dud compared to before. Then after almost an hour we noticed the tables to our left and right that sat down we'll after us as we were having our soups and appetizers were done with their appetizers and almost done with their lunches. The waitress was no where in sight. We had not been served our lunches. They're known for wings. Guess what we ordered? Ya! Asked the bus boy to please find her for us then waited and went on to ask another waitress and watched this other waitress catch ours at the kitchen door and tell her and she kept walking in the opposite direction as the waitress obviously told her as this other waitress was pointing at us as she spoke to her. We waited longer then walked over to the hostess and asked her to please get us our check. Check came including the unserved lunches. I tried to tell our waitress we never got our lunches and she walked away! Manager came over and removed the unserved lunches from the check, apologized and took the cash I paid for the soups and beverages. We were quite surprised. A shame the 2 gals that usually attend us were not working as they are the best. Anyway, so much for trying the new menu. read more

Heard a lot of good things about this place and finally got around to trying it out. Everything we had was excellent!! Crab soup, onion soup, mild wings and garlic parmigiana wings. Wings were perfect. Best I have ever had. Staff was friendly, professional and attentive. Will definitely be heading back here. What a treat. read more

Wonderful environment and really friendly and caring owner. I love the wings and fried pickles. Good beer list. Is always packed but has a lot of space, but be prepared for a possible wait read more